Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH refused dinner over a carrot, 3 hour+ sulk

158 replies

Eliza667 · 03/10/2022 20:51

DH has been unwell for a few weeks. His stomach won’t take rich foods but he agreed a roast dinner would be ok as it’s just meat, vegetables and gravy really.

I haven’t made one all summer and was stressing trying to remember the timings. Near the end I asked if he could help, but he said he wasn’t feeling well, I said don’t worry and went to do it myself (I’d asked if he could cut the meat and finish the gravy). He then started talking to me from the other room, extractor fan going so I had to keep walking back to the other room to hear him, whilst trying not to let stuff burn. He said he’d come in and help in a minute, so I thought great, he’s well enough to help a bit.

When he comes in he’s making the gravy and I ask how long till it’s ready, he’s just giving awkward answers like “I don’t know” rather than having a best guess. I need to get in the oven as the roasted carrots are burning, and he starts telling me I should have put tin foil on them before they got to that stage and saying to me that I was doing everything weird. At that point I admit I got fed up and asked if he wanted to cook instead. I’d been trying really hard to get everything right but I was months out of practice and felt attacked so snapped a bit.

He threw the utensil he was holding across the room and stormed off swearing, saying to throw his in the bin, that was 3 hours ago and he’s still in bed. I finished cooking, put his out and went upstairs to tell him it was ready and he just said he wasn’t hungry. It’s still on the plate.

AIBU that this is a severe over reaction (ill or not) and is also massively disrespectful to not even eat the food I’d spent effort on? I’ve cleaned up in the kitchen, emptied the dishwasher, sorted the pets, been to the shop to buy food for his lunch, and he’s still in bed and hasn’t said a word to me. Am I in the wrong that much for snapping about the carrots and the tin foil? I’m starting to think there’s something else going on with him to react in this way.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StridTheKiller · 18/12/2022 18:51

I wonder how many divorces occur as a result of Roast Dinner Wars?

Nofucksleft · 14/10/2022 14:36

I'd be pissed too if I felt miserable dh was cooking dinner and kept looking for help..if its not usual behaviour I'd let it slide he's feeling rotten

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 08/10/2022 14:07

Eliza667 · 05/10/2022 08:20

We chatted it through. He came downstairs and didn’t talk so I started the conversation. At first he refused to apologise so thank you to whoever suggested saying that the throwing things was unacceptable as he did eventually apologise after I explained that was what had upset me (not the carrots, I really couldn’t care about burning the carrots, it’s the way he reacted).

He continues to insist there’s nothing else wrong or anything going on. I don’t think this is anything sinister and he’s not on weird meds, just an illness picked up overseas that’s carrying on a bit.

I explained the extra pressure I felt and feeling unappreciated for my effort. I think he felt a bit bad as yesterday he did some other jobs around the house.

I’m really surprised so many people think it’s over dramatic to be upset about someone throwing things and feel for those people saying this, I’m not sure how bad your home lives must be to consider this an overreaction. It certainly made me realise we must have it really good most of the time..

To those analysing my cooking ability, I had 7 things on the go at once, none of it was aunt Bessie’s, and to the person who asked, yes there were Yorkshires! :) Someone said this is hardly a bake off, I’ve actually won a baking competition before so it just goes to show different people find different things harder or easier.

Glad its sorted but what a pathetic amount of drama from both of you.

Eliza667 · 08/10/2022 13:17

@OldFan No, that’s what was so strange about it as it’s unusual for him and wasn’t a particularly significant thing to get that worked up over. Things seem fine again now so I’m putting it down to a blip!

OP posts:
OldFan · 05/10/2022 22:53

I hadn't quite spotted the throwing something thing earlier @Eliza667 . That's really not ok. Has he thrown stuff before?

CharlotteCollinsneeLucas · 05/10/2022 22:26

AutumnCrow · 05/10/2022 10:00

Personally I find it’s toast, but hey you do you.

Oh yeah! I was going to say pasta and pesto. Or pizza. But toast - can't get easier than toast.

Glad he apologised, OP, although shame he had to be prompted.

ILoveMeSteakIDo · 05/10/2022 21:26

He still sounds like a twat. You had to drag an apology out of him. He did a bit of housework to placate you and that's that. He can move on. Until next time.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/10/2022 14:49

TygerTyger · 05/10/2022 09:49

I’m glad he apologised. Throwing stuff and door slamming really stress me out too. Hope you have a better day. Roast dinner timings are tricky, only ever attempt it at the weekend round here.

Glad you've had a chance to sort things between you.

A roast dinner isn't technically difficult, but keeping an eye on umpteen different things, and managing timings so that everything is ready at the same time can be a faff.

Hopefully now the two of you have cleared the air and he sees how unpleasant and unreasonable his behaviour was it won't happen again.

NannaKaren · 05/10/2022 14:11

What a twat he needs to grow up - mean idiot ! 😕

Ffsmakeitstop · 05/10/2022 12:58

My DH can be a bit petulant. Occasionally he gets arsey on a Sunday and won't have tea I used to try and jolly him along and make suggestions. I don't do that any more I just get something for me and leave him to it.

Buttonjugs · 05/10/2022 12:51

justasking111 · 03/10/2022 22:13

Gave up counting how many times in this post you've used the words .

I - IM - ME. Think about it

She’s also used him and he a lot. What’s your point?

billy1966 · 05/10/2022 12:51

Throwing things is most certainly not normal.

I call that violent behaviour exhibiting a lack of control.

I appreciate people can become frustrated but it is not normal behaviour to be dismissing.

AutumnCrow · 05/10/2022 10:00

threatmatrix · 04/10/2022 21:56

I think a roast is the easiest thing ever to cook.

Personally I find it’s toast, but hey you do you.

TygerTyger · 05/10/2022 09:49

I’m glad he apologised. Throwing stuff and door slamming really stress me out too. Hope you have a better day. Roast dinner timings are tricky, only ever attempt it at the weekend round here.

Eliza667 · 05/10/2022 08:20

We chatted it through. He came downstairs and didn’t talk so I started the conversation. At first he refused to apologise so thank you to whoever suggested saying that the throwing things was unacceptable as he did eventually apologise after I explained that was what had upset me (not the carrots, I really couldn’t care about burning the carrots, it’s the way he reacted).

He continues to insist there’s nothing else wrong or anything going on. I don’t think this is anything sinister and he’s not on weird meds, just an illness picked up overseas that’s carrying on a bit.

I explained the extra pressure I felt and feeling unappreciated for my effort. I think he felt a bit bad as yesterday he did some other jobs around the house.

I’m really surprised so many people think it’s over dramatic to be upset about someone throwing things and feel for those people saying this, I’m not sure how bad your home lives must be to consider this an overreaction. It certainly made me realise we must have it really good most of the time..

To those analysing my cooking ability, I had 7 things on the go at once, none of it was aunt Bessie’s, and to the person who asked, yes there were Yorkshires! :) Someone said this is hardly a bake off, I’ve actually won a baking competition before so it just goes to show different people find different things harder or easier.

OP posts:
mandolinwind · 05/10/2022 08:07

I have often felt rather low a few days after starting on amoxicillin; DP was on one type of antibiotic that made him feel irrational towards the end of the course.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 05/10/2022 07:42

Good morning op.

I hope you managed to get some sleep and this morning is better.

Just wondering if he apologised or expected you to cook breakfast today?

Sheenqueen · 05/10/2022 05:15

threatmatrix · 04/10/2022 21:56

I think a roast is the easiest thing ever to cook.

I thought it was just me. I have been surprised by the number of people saying it’s a big and complex undertaking. One of the easiest and most straightforward meals.

Unless the OP was giving it a twist by fusing it with another type of cuisine.

Anyway all sounds like way too much drama.

Alison20 · 05/10/2022 04:40

lf it’s not typical it is worth considering if medication or illness is having an impact. Both can different for different people. Eg codeine in our family makes us really angry in an irrational way. A heart condition made my dad tearful and emotional and other illness has made other people in the family snappy and bad tempered at particular points. It doesn’t excuse but it can be an understandable reason. It may be good to step back and really get to the underlying issues especially if this is not typical.

AndYouCanBuggerOffAsWell · 04/10/2022 23:44

Get a Toby Carvery delivered next time
Job done

TygerTyger · 04/10/2022 23:40

Carrots. Burnt carrots. That is not the hill that I would choose to plant my flag. Both of you are upset. Let it be, talk tomorrow. Ease off. If it is something catastrophic you’re going to need to use all your energy efficiently. I wouldn’t be preparing 3 meals for him, it might even make him more scared that you think he can’t even manage to feed himself. Let him stand up for himself, DH tipped the pasta in the pan, he’s cooked a meal, he feels he’s contributed, most people want to feel useful, and one day that’s going to be almost impossible, in the meantime, just muddle. You shouldn’t be doing all that, it’s not good for either of you. Tired and resentful and scared (both of you) are a recipe for falling out. Sleep well.

oxfordjrr · 04/10/2022 23:23

He owes you an apology. You've been thoughtfully cooking his meals and wanted a bit of help with this meal and he has the gall to throw a tantrum and sulk in bed on his phone. You said you took laundry up, so did he ignore you when you entered the room? You also mentioned you work full time yourself yet you went out and bought his lunch for work while he's got the hump upstairs. Its not your fault he's ill. It's unbelievably childish and silent treatment can be very abusive.

dustofneptune · 04/10/2022 23:04

Two things I know are true in my household:

  1. The kitchen is where frustrations come out
  2. My dude is super cranky when he has any ongoing health issue

I think that's what is happening here in your case, honestly. You were tired, he's anxious about health and feeling shit.

Pent up frustration goes somewhere. I throw things sometimes when my frustration boils over. Never at anyone, but it happens. I'm generally a calm person. You say your husband is too.

Holding things down while your partner is unwell is really rough. They are dealing with their private fears of youth ending / catastrophe happening / what if I can't provide? / / what if this is something big?, and your'e dealing with having to take on more than you normally do, juggling so much, and then on top of that dealing with what feels like total lack of gratitude and lack of care for everything you're doing.

Truly, I'd go talk it out, hug, have a laugh about it, forgive, forget, and move on from it.

Isinglass20 · 04/10/2022 22:54

YABU. DHs behaviour out of character. Clearly stressed over his illness and feels ill and you banging on about cooking the carrots!! You should cook him a nice meal without pestering him and show sympathy and care. You might be ill in the future and expect to be cared for and shown sympathy and given support.

Rollergirl999 · 04/10/2022 22:54

Why the drama over a roast dinner? I haven’t cooked one for ages but wouldn’t have a problem cooking one without help. It’s not difficult.