Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think two hours homework a night is not excessive for a year 10 pupil

438 replies

Challenger5 · 03/10/2022 20:49

DD 1 is adamant that two hours a night homework, is against her human rights. She has been stomping around, refusing to start her homework. DD 1 is being exceptionally rude to me swearing at me for sending her to a prison camp and claiming to be-having a nervous breakdown due to the schools expectations.

I am trying to calm her down and reason with her, that two hours a night is quite proportionate for a year 10 girl at a Grammar School. This especially as the school as stated her target grades are 7-9 in all ten GCSE subjects.

She has also informed me that her head of year as given her a after school detention, today for calling her English teacher a 'mean cow' for a poor homework mark. DD denies calling the teacher that, saying she was misheard when she pulled her face at the teacher.

DD is saying the detention is unfair and against her human rights because it is grossly an excessive punishment even if she had accidentally muttered 'mean cow' when the teacher spoke to her. DD argues that her face pulling was justified because someone has to stand up against the schools unrealistic and unreasonable levels of homework demanded.

OP posts:
PugInTheHouse · 04/10/2022 11:08

If your child needs to do 3-4 hrs work a night in Y10 and 11 then the school is clearly not very good, or your child is struggling and that amount of work is probably not good for them. GCSEs aren't hard enough to warrant that amount of work. It's absolutely crazy.

What is more crazy is forcing them to, how will they ever have any self motivation if parents force them do study for 4 hrs a night.

DS revised at the level he felt he needed to, he got mostly 7-9 grades but also got 2 x 6s instead of 7s by 1/2 marks on each. If he had studied for 2 hrs a night he probably would have got that however he is a musician and spends a lot of time rehearsing, writing music, performing and recording, even at 16 he makes good money from it already so whilst he is naturally academic it is more important IMO (and the schools opinion) for him to have a more rounded education. If he had been studying for 2 hrs a night then this would have been detrimental to his music.

No one will convince me we have brought him up to be lazy, he puts hours of work into music as well as working hard at school but it has been his decision to decide what level of effort goes into it. It's definitely paid off.

steppemum · 04/10/2022 11:06

for me the key is to let school respond, so for all mine, there is space and time to do it, if they choose not too, then they are accountable to school. If that measn after school detentions etc then that is fine, they must take the accountability.

I have occasionally written in for dd2, as she finds it impossible to speak up and say I can't do it, but mostly, I leave it between the child and the school.

That works well, as they are usually not willing to look poor in front of peers

steppemum · 04/10/2022 11:01

dds are at a girls grammar.
dd2 is year 10.
She doesn't get anywhere near that amount.
About an hour most nights, depending on how long it takes.
She rarely does anything on Fri and Sat, then mad rush Sunday night.
Lots of it is finishing off stuff.
She is predicted high grades,

dd1 is A level year and probably doesn't do that much. She had a clean sweep of grade 8s in her GCSE.

dd2 would not cope with 2 hours per night, as she is wiped out after school. (but she is probably autistic)

mountainsunsets · 04/10/2022 10:59

I also don't think the average child will get outstanding results with minimal effort.

Why do you assume I put in minimal effort?

There's a sensible middle ground in between working for two hours a night after school and doing the bare minimum.

SleeplessInEngland · 04/10/2022 10:54

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 10:53

Do you think that's the right time to rest knowledge? Surely that's far too late.

Mock exams and tests in class also exist.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 10:53

SleeplessInEngland · 04/10/2022 10:52

Most people would argue that's what exams are for.

Do you think that's the right time to rest knowledge? Surely that's far too late.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 10:52

Difference is, this is a 14 year old kid that you're comparing to an ADULT

So are other people "I don't do those hours now" type posts are comparing adults and children.

Children's minds are sponges. They have more energy and more free time that adults, as so they should. Its not unreasonable to use some of their free time, their energy, and their propensity to absorb things easier than adults to educate them well, in order to make sure they can pursue a career path they want.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 04/10/2022 10:52

Hawkins001 · 04/10/2022 09:45

I wonder how many of people here would handle 8-12+ hour days in the investment banking industry, etc

Well I am sure that those who wish to fulfil their lives in that way would manage just fine. Those who find fulfilment in other ways probably wouldn't like it much.

I won't be lying on my deathbed wishing I had spent my life working 12+ hour days in the investment banking industry. That I can assure you.

Competitive overworking isn't something to be proud of.

SleeplessInEngland · 04/10/2022 10:52

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 10:49

But how is understanding if a subject in a 45min window in class measured, during which some of the time is taken up actually teaching it? And the teacher is on hand to assist. Surely in order to make sure the topic is fully embedded, there needs to be additional checks done independently?

Most people would argue that's what exams are for.

SerenaTee · 04/10/2022 10:51

2 hours is the expectation in year 11 at our secondary school (not grammar but gets similar GCSE results). This is to cover homework and revision time, think it’s around 1.5 hours in year 10. My kids aimed for this around 4 times a week and then had 3 days (usually including both days at the weekend) to have a break from school/studying. That suited them and their learning styles/extra curricular commitments.

SleeplessInEngland · 04/10/2022 10:50

Hawkins001 · 04/10/2022 09:45

I wonder how many of people here would handle 8-12+ hour days in the investment banking industry, etc

Ah yes, investment banking, which has one of the highest burnout rates of any job in the world. Fantastic argument.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 10:49

But how is understanding if a subject in a 45min window in class measured, during which some of the time is taken up actually teaching it? And the teacher is on hand to assist. Surely in order to make sure the topic is fully embedded, there needs to be additional checks done independently?

sheepdogdelight · 04/10/2022 10:44

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 08:17

Is homework not just the best way to check understanding? A 45min lesson on trigonometry only passes the info one way. Setting some trig homework (30-45mins) then checks understanding as the work has to be completed without teacher assistance.

Then the French teacher does the same with verbs, 30 mins

Then the English teacher wants 3 chapters of The Woman in Black Read for tomorrow ready for critique, 45 mins.

There's your 2 hours.

Homework should have a purpose.
If the DC has understood the lesson on trigonometry (during which they will have worked on questions independently) then they may not need to do anything outside of class, or only 10 minutes worth just to finish a question sheet. Making them do tons of examples "just because" has no value. So homework should be set with a definite aim in mind, not just a timescale. Some people's DC on here are clearly getting work for the sake of giving homework.

Extending your work beyond what is required from class is more of an A Level skill. You don't get marks at GCSE for knowing stuff beyond the syllabus (although there is an educational value in this, of course). At GCSE students are not required to read 3 chapters of a book for tomorrow. They read at a very slow speed in class. Also, they probably only have 1 or 2 hours per subject per week. There's a limit to how much can be covered to need homework to reinforce.

Hawkins001 · 04/10/2022 10:38

postcardpuffin · 04/10/2022 10:07

Well, honestly, I have; and GCSE homework was a piece of piss in comparison, I can tell you.

People on here are acting like school is some kind of Gradgrindian factory! A bright year 10 kid who’s capable of getting 8s and 9s at GCSE is not going to be worn to the bone by a couple of hours writing a book report or drawing and labelling a diagram of the nitrogen cycle or whatever.

My own (university) students do far less work than ten years ago and boy do they whinge far more about what is actually a pretty light workload compared to a job! You would think it was toiling down the pit for ten hours a day with all the complaining about mental health, when actually they’re being asked to read an interesting book!

I’m all for resisting the imperatives of the capitalist grindstone but honestly, we need to get a bit of perspective here. School homework is not putting a presentation together for the board of directors at Citibank. It’s answering a few questions or writing a short exercise. Perfectly doable of an evening even with getting to watch a bit of television too.

Perfectly excellent perspectives

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 10:36

zingally · 04/10/2022 10:34

2 hours every night is excessive. Would YOU want to do 2 additional hours of work at home, after a busy day at work? No, you wouldn't.

That being said, the after-school detention is completely justified! She was obviously caught being really rude to the teacher (even if she denies it), so that's tough luck really. She's got an attitude, and needs to stop it.

Personally, I'd sit her down, tell her you're prepared to help her manage/reduce her workload, BUT she needs to do the detention in good grace, and fix the overall attitude.

I don't finish work until gone 6. So no. Although I have done when I've had exams. But if I finished at 3.30 then obviously it's not a problem.

zingally · 04/10/2022 10:35

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 10:17

They may be working more hours (just) but it's a different style of work to a paying job isn't it.

I'd love to have an hour or so built into my paid day at work to play rounders with the team and paint and bake some cookies. Which is once a week for most secondary schools if not twice. Sit and read a play and talk about it? Great! Easier than most tasks I do now.

No customers, no pointless training sessions, no meetings where everyone starts at you til you make a decision, no risk of losing your home from the company going into administration, no potential patients dying while your in charge.

Difference is, this is a 14 year old kid that you're comparing to an ADULT.

zingally · 04/10/2022 10:34

2 hours every night is excessive. Would YOU want to do 2 additional hours of work at home, after a busy day at work? No, you wouldn't.

That being said, the after-school detention is completely justified! She was obviously caught being really rude to the teacher (even if she denies it), so that's tough luck really. She's got an attitude, and needs to stop it.

Personally, I'd sit her down, tell her you're prepared to help her manage/reduce her workload, BUT she needs to do the detention in good grace, and fix the overall attitude.

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 10:32

fUNNYfACE36 · 04/10/2022 10:09

Well no, it's not a choice is it , if the school requires it? Are you talking about self imposed work?

Both.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 10:17

They may be working more hours (just) but it's a different style of work to a paying job isn't it.

I'd love to have an hour or so built into my paid day at work to play rounders with the team and paint and bake some cookies. Which is once a week for most secondary schools if not twice. Sit and read a play and talk about it? Great! Easier than most tasks I do now.

No customers, no pointless training sessions, no meetings where everyone starts at you til you make a decision, no risk of losing your home from the company going into administration, no potential patients dying while your in charge.

VickyEadieofThigh · 04/10/2022 10:13

Doesn't matter what you all think - this is the homework she's being set (although how long it takes tends to vary per person, surely?) and the choice is either do it, not do it and be in continual trouble, remove her and find a school which isn't bothered about homework (let us know if you find one).

fUNNYfACE36 · 04/10/2022 10:09

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 08:28

My daughter does more than that in her her lowly academy school. Her choice. She wants to do well. It is the GCSE years.

Well no, it's not a choice is it , if the school requires it? Are you talking about self imposed work?

postcardpuffin · 04/10/2022 10:07

Hawkins001 · 04/10/2022 09:45

I wonder how many of people here would handle 8-12+ hour days in the investment banking industry, etc

Well, honestly, I have; and GCSE homework was a piece of piss in comparison, I can tell you.

People on here are acting like school is some kind of Gradgrindian factory! A bright year 10 kid who’s capable of getting 8s and 9s at GCSE is not going to be worn to the bone by a couple of hours writing a book report or drawing and labelling a diagram of the nitrogen cycle or whatever.

My own (university) students do far less work than ten years ago and boy do they whinge far more about what is actually a pretty light workload compared to a job! You would think it was toiling down the pit for ten hours a day with all the complaining about mental health, when actually they’re being asked to read an interesting book!

I’m all for resisting the imperatives of the capitalist grindstone but honestly, we need to get a bit of perspective here. School homework is not putting a presentation together for the board of directors at Citibank. It’s answering a few questions or writing a short exercise. Perfectly doable of an evening even with getting to watch a bit of television too.

WireSkills · 04/10/2022 09:52

It's been a long time since I was at school. Part of me was thinking that as schools don't start massively early compared to a "usual" office, but finish earlier that 2 hours of homework a day is equivalent to a working week.

However, I've just checked one of our local schools who has an 8.30am start and a 3.40pm finish, so just over 7 hours in school each day. Yes, there's breaks, etc (85 mins in the day), but a normal office would only expect 8 or 8.5 hours a day in the office. Given that these are children, while there is an element of preparing them for their future working lives, making them work more than someone that works full time seems rather unfair.

(I do agree that you DD is going in to full on drama queen mode about it though!)

Hawkins001 · 04/10/2022 09:45

I wonder how many of people here would handle 8-12+ hour days in the investment banking industry, etc

SamanthaVimes · 04/10/2022 09:43

2 hours every night is ridiculous. 30 mins to 1 hour should be sufficient.
I didn’t do homework every day at secondary, certainly nothing like 10 hours a week! I got all A’s apart from 1 B at GCSE.

Could she do some of the homework at lunch time / on the bus (if she gets one) that way it wouldn’t feel like it’s eating into her time as much?

She’s not wrong to complain about the volume but she is wrong to be rude to the teacher and deserves that detention.

Swipe left for the next trending thread