Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think two hours homework a night is not excessive for a year 10 pupil

438 replies

Challenger5 · 03/10/2022 20:49

DD 1 is adamant that two hours a night homework, is against her human rights. She has been stomping around, refusing to start her homework. DD 1 is being exceptionally rude to me swearing at me for sending her to a prison camp and claiming to be-having a nervous breakdown due to the schools expectations.

I am trying to calm her down and reason with her, that two hours a night is quite proportionate for a year 10 girl at a Grammar School. This especially as the school as stated her target grades are 7-9 in all ten GCSE subjects.

She has also informed me that her head of year as given her a after school detention, today for calling her English teacher a 'mean cow' for a poor homework mark. DD denies calling the teacher that, saying she was misheard when she pulled her face at the teacher.

DD is saying the detention is unfair and against her human rights because it is grossly an excessive punishment even if she had accidentally muttered 'mean cow' when the teacher spoke to her. DD argues that her face pulling was justified because someone has to stand up against the schools unrealistic and unreasonable levels of homework demanded.

OP posts:
pointythings · 04/10/2022 14:57

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 14:53

Aye! And we had O levels which were far harder exams than these dumbed down GCSEs that we could have sat at 11. And headmasters with canes to keep us in line with intermittent floggings to focus our minds.

And we were thankful!

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 14:53

SleeplessInEngland · 04/10/2022 14:41

2 hours is not much really, i'm sure i did much more, and my daughter and her friends do loads of extra curricular stuff (sport, drama, music, debating, MUN, volunteering) as well as just socialising on top.

You were lucky! In my day I had to do 17 hours of homework a night, then go to bed in a ditch!!

Aye! And we had O levels which were far harder exams than these dumbed down GCSEs that we could have sat at 11. And headmasters with canes to keep us in line with intermittent floggings to focus our minds.

SleeplessInEngland · 04/10/2022 14:41

2 hours is not much really, i'm sure i did much more, and my daughter and her friends do loads of extra curricular stuff (sport, drama, music, debating, MUN, volunteering) as well as just socialising on top.

You were lucky! In my day I had to do 17 hours of homework a night, then go to bed in a ditch!!

ihatesteve · 04/10/2022 14:34

It's not about getting all 9's anyhow. I wouldn't expect my child to get all 7's even without working really hard to be honest.

2 hours is not much really, i'm sure i did much more, and my daughter and her friends do loads of extra curricular stuff (sport, drama, music, debating, MUN, volunteering) as well as just socialising on top.

You are meant to be busy as a teen! Much better to be busy doing something productive than looking at bloody tiktoc (she does that too😬)

Mine is at an indi though so longer holidays - maybe that balances it out - more intensive spurts but lots of downtime too. Her friend has just changed schools and has actual school on a saturday mornjng now (not sport). That seems like a bit much.

catsonahottinroof · 04/10/2022 14:17

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 13:52

catsonahottinroof, surely that depends on the subject, possibly Maths and the sciences but it is not going to be possible to learn everything you need to know from a lesson in English Literature or the humanities. At GCSE you will be doing independent learning, that is part of the educational experience, it is simply not possible to not do homework that is often revision by year 11 and achieve the highest grades across the board for GCSEs however bright you are! Besides, the two are not mutually exclusive, a child who is very bright can and probably would read around other subjects or undertake other interests aswell as the homework.

Equally, it doesn't make you not bright if you have to complete homework for higher grades.

Thanks for replying, yes you're probably right about english literature and humanities - I think you would need to do some work at home for these to get the very top grades.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 04/10/2022 13:55

Sounds like she's not actually doing 2 hours a night - just complaining about it! Surely the 2 hours will be a guideline amount and the reality will be less?

I remember my school suggesting homework should be 1.5 hours in Y10. Occasionally it would take longer, but mostly it was no more than an hour. Plenty of time to do lots of extra curricular activities.

Your DD needs more than 4 weeks of Year 10 to be able to make an informed judgement about the actual amount of homework being set. Nobody is going to take her complaining seriously at this early stage in the year.

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 13:52

catsonahottinroof, surely that depends on the subject, possibly Maths and the sciences but it is not going to be possible to learn everything you need to know from a lesson in English Literature or the humanities. At GCSE you will be doing independent learning, that is part of the educational experience, it is simply not possible to not do homework that is often revision by year 11 and achieve the highest grades across the board for GCSEs however bright you are! Besides, the two are not mutually exclusive, a child who is very bright can and probably would read around other subjects or undertake other interests aswell as the homework.

Equally, it doesn't make you not bright if you have to complete homework for higher grades.

Coasterfan · 04/10/2022 13:39

I think it’s a lot, my DC gets about an hour a night and she is at a selective school with high expectations. Her friend’s parents make her get up at 5.30am every morning to revise for her GCSEs. In the first half term of year 10. To me that’s child abuse!!

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 13:36

Tranquiltortoise, I am educated to Masters level and don't understand how you didn't have to study for 2 hours a day at degree and post degree level. I studied English Literature and only had 7 hours a week in uni- there wasn't a notion of a 'day' at uni like work, you were very much expected to go away and think for yourself.

catsonahottinroof · 04/10/2022 13:35

"We need people that are interested in acquiring knowledge, not just doing the minimum to pass exams. If you have a child who seeks that intellectual stimulation and doesn't see it as a hardship then it should be supported IMO."
From Goldenbear: (sorry I don't know how to partially quote).

But if a child is very bright, then they won't need to spend hours doing homework and revision, as they will have already understood the concepts in the first place. And I agree they should be supported if they want intellectual stimulation, but wouldn't that be better spent independently researching subjects they are interested in, or learning new subjects from scratch etc, rather than spending hours doing homework on things they already know?

fdkc · 04/10/2022 13:34

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 13:14

The OP is talking about Year Ten students

Oooops thank you, that definitely makes more sense. I thought she said her child was aged 10 and gets 2 hours of homework a night.

Well if she's 14/15 then two hours is not too much, we definitely get that much if not even more here in Ireland.

Seeline · 04/10/2022 13:27

Both mine managed to do their music, dance, sport, guiding/scouting and have a social life with that level of home work. It's not difficult!

tranquiltortoise · 04/10/2022 13:26

I have been through the whole education system including grammar school up to Masters degree and did very well across the board.

It's very rare that I have ever had to study for 2 hours of an evening after having school/ college/ uni all day. The only times I would have done this is when I have an exam or assignment deadline coming up.

I certainly never had this much homework in secondary school, unless I was choosing to put extra work in (e.g. going overboard on an art project or something).

So yes I think it's excessive as a regular level of homework for year 10. When is she supposed to do The Rest of Her Life?!

Good on her for campaigning against it, it's good life experience to stand up against authority when you feel they are getting it wrong.

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 13:26

Education isn't a job though and that perception has ruined the desire for knowledge in this country.

My DS plays football at the park straight after school, he went to a house party on Saturday night, his social life is fine. Arguably, life isn't just about social life and having a good time.

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 13:21

University is very much an option in adulthood and not one available to you if your attainment at GCSE level is poor. If we are referring to highly competitive courses and jobs, then how do we achieve the levelling up if not via education. An educated society is always going to better than one that doesn't question or enquire, that is pretty self evident and no one is referring to extremes. We need people that are interested in acquiring knowledge, not just doing the minimum to pass exams. If you have a child who seeks that intellectual stimulation and doesn't see it as a hardship then it should be supported IMO.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 04/10/2022 13:19

I'm not a big supporter of more than minimal homework. Yes, home study skills are important to learn for those academically minded, but wouldn't you all be complaining if your job expected two hours of additional work every evening?
What about the evenings with sport commitments? What about HEAVEN FORBID a social life?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 13:14

fdkc · 04/10/2022 13:04

Ten year olds definitely still play with toys.

The OP is talking about Year Ten students

sheepdogdelight · 04/10/2022 13:10

ihatesteve · 04/10/2022 13:02

@sheepdogdelight you couldn't be more wrong for the very competitive courses. There is a big difference between all 7's and all 9's - particularly for children with the privilege of attending a grammar school. So many children get a full sweep of top grades now.

I'm a lawyer and was asked about my GCSE grades at an interview when 4 years qualified (after a levels, a degree, professional exams, post graduate study and 6 years working in role). I got the job.

What competitive courses are you talking about? I'm aware that GCSEs are important for things like medicine - but that's not something the majority of students are interested in.
And, if you meant university courses, then university is not really "options in adulthood" - yes I know students are adults, but the comment was made in reference to long term adult options, money earned etc.

I've never been asked about my GCSE grades once I was past my first job, and you have no idea whether they influenced the decision to employ you or not. And anecdotes don't prove anything anyway.

I'd be surprised if there are many people who think their path as an adult would have been significantly changed if they'd got "absolutely top GCSE grades" as opposed to just "very good GCSE grades"

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 13:06

Year 10 are 14/15 year olds.

fdkc · 04/10/2022 13:04

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 12:15

Do you know many secondary school kids that play with toys? That's the age we are talking about here.

Ten year olds definitely still play with toys.

ihatesteve · 04/10/2022 13:02

@sheepdogdelight you couldn't be more wrong for the very competitive courses. There is a big difference between all 7's and all 9's - particularly for children with the privilege of attending a grammar school. So many children get a full sweep of top grades now.

I'm a lawyer and was asked about my GCSE grades at an interview when 4 years qualified (after a levels, a degree, professional exams, post graduate study and 6 years working in role). I got the job.

Dammitthisisshit · 04/10/2022 13:00

@fdkc its year 10, so age 14/15

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 13:00

I agree with your DD.
One of my DDs had similar complaints as her teachers were assigning busy work which felt was useless as she already “got” the material and didn’t need to do 30 maths problems plus write essay after essay to prove it.

In fact she did her GCSE English speech with the title “Abolish All Homework” based on a study of the U.K. vs Finland Education systems.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-37716005
opinion.inquirer.net/154480/change-our-educational-system-to-the-finland-way

Dammitthisisshit · 04/10/2022 12:59

2 hours homework a week is too much. What about time to do sports? Music? Other interests?

calling any teacher a cow, however quietly, deserves detention and banging on about human rights would make me want to shoot her.

fdkc · 04/10/2022 12:58

Wow 2 hours of homework for a 10 year old, that's huge and way too much IMO. Here in Ireland a 10 year old child would still only be in 4th class so I'm confused when you talk about the start of the GCSE's already?

It's crazy the difference between the educational systems in the UK and Ireland when we are neighboring countries. I also don't have a clue what a grammar school is or how it's different from a normal school because we don't have them here.

Two hours of homework is alot of pressure for a little 10 year old child, they are supposed to be having fun, enjoying their childhood and doing extra curricular activities and playing sports!.