Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think two hours homework a night is not excessive for a year 10 pupil

438 replies

Challenger5 · 03/10/2022 20:49

DD 1 is adamant that two hours a night homework, is against her human rights. She has been stomping around, refusing to start her homework. DD 1 is being exceptionally rude to me swearing at me for sending her to a prison camp and claiming to be-having a nervous breakdown due to the schools expectations.

I am trying to calm her down and reason with her, that two hours a night is quite proportionate for a year 10 girl at a Grammar School. This especially as the school as stated her target grades are 7-9 in all ten GCSE subjects.

She has also informed me that her head of year as given her a after school detention, today for calling her English teacher a 'mean cow' for a poor homework mark. DD denies calling the teacher that, saying she was misheard when she pulled her face at the teacher.

DD is saying the detention is unfair and against her human rights because it is grossly an excessive punishment even if she had accidentally muttered 'mean cow' when the teacher spoke to her. DD argues that her face pulling was justified because someone has to stand up against the schools unrealistic and unreasonable levels of homework demanded.

OP posts:
DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 20:39

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 20:32

But do they? Not being funny, but how much class time is spent on repetition and revision? Quite a lot from what my DC reported for the GCSE years. Which is odd too because we moved from one school that started them in yr9 to a school that started them in yr10. The school that only spent 2yrs on them got better results than the school that started them in yr9…so clearly any link between presenteeism and grades is tenuous at best.

Well it depends whether the days your children miss are days of new learning or days of revising things already learnt. How would you know. And it's very difficult for children to have gaps in their knowledge when the rest of the class has moved on to the next work.

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 20:36

Watapalava · 04/10/2022 20:23

It won’t mean much if it takes 2 hours to get them

a child who needs to revise that much to get an 8/9 isn’t clever enough to do the courses that require 8/9

they wouldn’t cope with such academic courses

you are not doing your kids any favours stretching them beyond their capabilities

2 hours per day 5 days a week works out to be about 33 hours per subject per year in private study. It's hardly excessive. Yet you think that's too much and kids that put this work in won't be able to cope with academic degree courses?

Give over. 🙄

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 20:32

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 19:40

If they missed 10 percent of the course work then it stands to reason that they are not going to be equipped with the knowledge for their exams, unless of course they use some of their own time to catch up.

But do they? Not being funny, but how much class time is spent on repetition and revision? Quite a lot from what my DC reported for the GCSE years. Which is odd too because we moved from one school that started them in yr9 to a school that started them in yr10. The school that only spent 2yrs on them got better results than the school that started them in yr9…so clearly any link between presenteeism and grades is tenuous at best.

Watapalava · 04/10/2022 20:23

It won’t mean much if it takes 2 hours to get them

a child who needs to revise that much to get an 8/9 isn’t clever enough to do the courses that require 8/9

they wouldn’t cope with such academic courses

you are not doing your kids any favours stretching them beyond their capabilities

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 20:14

Q2C4 · 04/10/2022 20:07

Those 8/9 grades will be with you forever and will help with UCAS applications. Worth 2 hrs per day for 2 years (excluding school holidays) surely if it means you get your pick of Unis / onto the course / onto the career ladder that you really want.

I agree. It clearly doesn't mean that much to a lot of people. It's quite sad really.

Q2C4 · 04/10/2022 20:07

Watapalava · 04/10/2022 19:42

I would not be wanting grades 8/9 if it takes 2 hours a night to get there

suggests to me most kids are not that bright and the schools pushing them unnecessarily to get the grades they should be teaching them to

schools fault here as asking kids to make up for their short fall

Those 8/9 grades will be with you forever and will help with UCAS applications. Worth 2 hrs per day for 2 years (excluding school holidays) surely if it means you get your pick of Unis / onto the course / onto the career ladder that you really want.

Watapalava · 04/10/2022 19:42

I would not be wanting grades 8/9 if it takes 2 hours a night to get there

suggests to me most kids are not that bright and the schools pushing them unnecessarily to get the grades they should be teaching them to

schools fault here as asking kids to make up for their short fall

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 19:40

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 18:33

Some posts on here are unreal, so the difference between 2 hrs or an hour means going from a high paid job to a crap boring one, seriously get a grip.

Id love to see an actual study showing this. It was preached alot to my DC along with charts showing things like 90% attendance = drop in GCSE grades. But no data to back this belief up.

If they missed 10 percent of the course work then it stands to reason that they are not going to be equipped with the knowledge for their exams, unless of course they use some of their own time to catch up.

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 19:36

Wonderwoman333 · 04/10/2022 18:45

I agree with your dd. 2 hours is way too much.

My 10 year old doesn't do homework as her school says it is optional. Most of my friend's dcs of that age don't do homework either. Kids are at school for 5 days a week, they don't get enough time to simply be kids as it is.

Year 10 is age 14/15. Not age 10.

mortgagescrewed · 04/10/2022 19:25

Way too much. There's no evidence that homework improves outcomes. I pity the poor teachers who are presumably having to waste time setting and looking at this stuff when they could be planning or doing another million other more worthwhile things.

She's at school all day then comes home to another two hours' work? No thanks. I don't blame her for digging her heels in.

I'm a teacher of a core subject in a secondary school and I'm dreading my DC coming home from school with crazy and pointless homework.

Wonderwoman333 · 04/10/2022 18:48

Sorry just seen it's for a Year 10 pupil! I still think it is too much. My Y11 dc doesn't do anywhere near that amount and is doing well at school with high predicted grades.

Wonderwoman333 · 04/10/2022 18:45

I agree with your dd. 2 hours is way too much.

My 10 year old doesn't do homework as her school says it is optional. Most of my friend's dcs of that age don't do homework either. Kids are at school for 5 days a week, they don't get enough time to simply be kids as it is.

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 18:33

Some posts on here are unreal, so the difference between 2 hrs or an hour means going from a high paid job to a crap boring one, seriously get a grip.

Id love to see an actual study showing this. It was preached alot to my DC along with charts showing things like 90% attendance = drop in GCSE grades. But no data to back this belief up.

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 18:27

pointythings · 04/10/2022 14:57

And we were thankful!

Young people these days…

HopelesslyOptimistic · 04/10/2022 17:23

Let her choose what she does. Let her deal with the grade drop. Let her deal with the consequences. Don't let her be a rude cow. Don't let her change your home rules. Don't let her off with home tasks. Sit back and let us all know how this plays out.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 04/10/2022 17:21

Tbf I don't think you worded your title quite accurately for the voting. I voted YABU at first as 2 hours per night is excessive. But then when you say 10 hours per week and she's not doing anything at weekends therein lies the issue - a Sunday afternoon would break the back of it, thats when I used to do most of mine depending on the deadlines.

NotLactoseFree · 04/10/2022 17:18

She's being a bit ridiculous but quite frankly, this is why I think I will be unlikely to send DD to a grammar school, even though she is very likely to be able to get a place. It's an excessive amount of homework.

balalake · 04/10/2022 17:15

Find the documentary about life for women in Saudi Arabia (cannot remember the title) and sit her down. Then ask her what human rights infringement is.

Challenger5 · 04/10/2022 17:14

DD1's school starts at 8.40 am finishes at 3.35pm and she is always home for 4pm, . I agree with posters who suggest that grade 8 and 9s are not everything and need to be taken in to account with mental stress and ability. I also know some Grammar schools are more pushy than others regarding homework and perhaps less compatible for children with other issues.

This is why DD 2 who is a year 9 goes to a different Grammar school mainly because it is less pushy and far more accommodating to DD2s EHCP. This was given to her for her Autism and being a looked after child (she has been with me since she was 4 and now is 13). DD2 was overjoyed when she passed the 11+ despite significant hurdles . In understanding achievement I know that DDs 2 likely target grades of 5-7 are equal if not greater than all the 8 and 9s DD1 might achieve.

The school offers alongside traditional A levels Dance, Photography and some more vocational offerings in Sixth Form . The school also only requires a 5 for Math's and a average of 5.5 over six subjects.

This is a perfect environment for DD2 who unlike DD1 is not gearing up for a RG University.

OP posts:
PugInTheHouse · 04/10/2022 17:12

Some posts on here are unreal, so the difference between 2 hrs or an hour means going from a high paid job to a crap boring one, seriously get a grip.

I agree with Twilight, revising and set homework are 2 very different things. I am glad DS didn't have set homework, he was able to recognise which areas he needed to revise and those he didn't, it worked well for him. Tonight he has stayed at college as a group of them have decided to spend a couple of hours doing some extra work using the facilities there, they have a good work ethic and are making good decisions clearly so somehow he's learnt to put the effort in without me forcing him!

Twilight7777 · 04/10/2022 17:05

Christ 2 hours a night?! If it was revising and by choice I could understand it, but not just homework! I didn’t do 2 hours a night in uni ffs 🤣

Q2C4 · 04/10/2022 16:25

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 03/10/2022 21:17

2 hours is way too much. 5 hours of lessons a day and then another 2 hours at home. No wonder she's pissed off.

Imagine if you came home from work and had to do another 2 hours of work every single evening.

Many people do, only work doesn't finish at 3pm!

Q2C4 · 04/10/2022 16:20

2hrs is not excessive, especially if school hours are only 9-3pm. She could do two hours of homework plus an after school club and still have time to relax in the evenings.

What would she like to do post GCSEs? Has she expressed any interests in a particular career path? Just wondering if it would help her to link the effort she needs to put in now with the career outcome she'd like.

Hawkins001 · 04/10/2022 16:10

SleeplessInEngland · 04/10/2022 10:50

Ah yes, investment banking, which has one of the highest burnout rates of any job in the world. Fantastic argument.

Well it would be, if the workers had the attitude of the ops, dd.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 04/10/2022 15:05

sheepdogdelight · 04/10/2022 12:53

On the other hand if you want to maximise your options in adulthood (not least with regards finding well paid enjoyable work) then working your backside off to get the best grades possible really helps.

There's a balance though? OP's DD is at a grammar so presumably pretty bright.
If she worked her backside off maybe she would get all Grade 9s.
If she worked at a more relaxed level she would probably still get all Grade 7s and above.

Really the difference in options in adulthood resulting from either of these sets of results is not going to be that much.
If she was doing nothing and not working in class either to the point she was on the verge of failing her GCSEs or just scraping passes, it would be different. But that's really not the scenario here.

My DD has just finished GCSES. She was at a bog standard comp that didn't set that much homework. She worked at a level that she thought was appropriate to enable her to get good grades (which in some weeks meant very little; just before tests meant a lot more; and when she had to submit her art and drama portfolios she pretty much only stopped to eat and sleep).

Fair point, but then again it is not what you know it is who, and getting into Oxbridge might be the difference between doing OK and being wealthy.

And obviously it depends what she wants to do - for some things any old uni is probably fine, for others it might really help to be at the right one. Unless she is CERTAIN that her life path does not require the right uni then it would be prudent to assume the worst and work her backside off.

Obviously she is too young to make a reasoned adult decision as to whether she will benefit from hard work or whether he can get away with doing less.

Swipe left for the next trending thread