Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think two hours homework a night is not excessive for a year 10 pupil

438 replies

Challenger5 · 03/10/2022 20:49

DD 1 is adamant that two hours a night homework, is against her human rights. She has been stomping around, refusing to start her homework. DD 1 is being exceptionally rude to me swearing at me for sending her to a prison camp and claiming to be-having a nervous breakdown due to the schools expectations.

I am trying to calm her down and reason with her, that two hours a night is quite proportionate for a year 10 girl at a Grammar School. This especially as the school as stated her target grades are 7-9 in all ten GCSE subjects.

She has also informed me that her head of year as given her a after school detention, today for calling her English teacher a 'mean cow' for a poor homework mark. DD denies calling the teacher that, saying she was misheard when she pulled her face at the teacher.

DD is saying the detention is unfair and against her human rights because it is grossly an excessive punishment even if she had accidentally muttered 'mean cow' when the teacher spoke to her. DD argues that her face pulling was justified because someone has to stand up against the schools unrealistic and unreasonable levels of homework demanded.

OP posts:
TreeLine6 · 04/10/2022 22:25

@Delatron

Personally I think a year 10 student who is having tantrums and kicking off about doing 2 hours homework because they’d rather spend time on tiktok is being lazy.

2 hours a night isn’t even a lot. A DC could easily have more than 4 hours to chill/do whatever they want after doing their 2 hours.

DS1 is in year 11 and has a physics test coming up. He has done 3.5 hours revision last night and 4 hours tonight because he wants to do well and knows he needs to work hard to so and has had this ingrained in him.

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 22:24

Well that is simply not true and if you look at how the top private schools achieve higher grades it is down to a formula that works across the board and not only for the incredibly bright! I don't think this is what an 'education' is but I equally don't agree with the other extreme that suggests home learning and independent learning has no benefit or impact on a child's education. Yes, of course social factors come in to play but that aside it is more likely to create the conditions for success which may look like 5 GCSEs at grade 5 rather than nothing at all. Although we don't live in a meritocracy it is loads better than it was. It is a fact that to escape a cycle of poverty education is a key part of that.

homarrrerr · 04/10/2022 22:18

2 hours a night sounds insane.

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 04/10/2022 22:13

Against her human rights??? That's ridiculous

At our local secondary It's 30 mins per subject (x3) years 7,8,9
then 45 mins per subject (x3) years 10, 11

6th form 1 hour per subject per night

If you want good results you have to put the effort in!

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 21:58

Florenz · 04/10/2022 21:42

We don't live in a meritocracy but if you take 2 children in similar circumstances, one of whom works hard, one of whom is lazy, the hard worker will do better in life probably 99% of the time.

Depends how you define success. Right? Trump (hate him), he worked hard on setting up business after business (casinos, fake universities, property developments, hotels, golf courses etc) and through his sheer idiocy lost most of his billions in inheritance money. When you look at the trail of failures behind the man, you have to admit, yes he worked hard to lose billions. It was calculated that if he’d simply left his billions in a mutual fund or two, and did nothing but sit around a pool and sip margaritas all day he’d be ten times richer than he is now. So in his case, lazy would have been the better course if you measure success in £££. That’s a sobering thought really, that the Uber rich have to work hard to lose their money and being lazy is how to hold on to wealth. But it’s true. Do you think the Duke of Westminster works hard to keep owning half of London?

and hard work vs lazy is such extreme language! We are talking about doing 7hrs/day vs 9hrs/day…there is no lazy when doing 7hrs instead of 9hrs?

how is success measured? For GCSEs it is in the grade you get on an exam. There’s no set rule that 2hrs day homework gets you a higher grade than if you hadn’t done 2hrs/day…in fact it’s more likely the 7hrs of teaching you’re supposed to get each day have a much greater impact on your GCSE grades than the hours of homework you do. After all, that’s the bulk of learning time with a supposed expert!, so why are we telling children it is all on them and on how hard/long they work? When it’s a small factor really (imho)

Delatron · 04/10/2022 21:52

It’s not a choice between being lazy and doing 2 hours every night though is it? There’s lots of middle ground which allow for a more balanced, less pressurised life whilst still doing just as well (if not better judging by some of the breakdowns I have seen at the local grammar school)..

Florenz · 04/10/2022 21:50

What does "simply be kids" even mean? They aren't kids when they're at school? Or when they're doing homework?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/10/2022 21:48

Wonderwoman333 · 04/10/2022 18:45

I agree with your dd. 2 hours is way too much.

My 10 year old doesn't do homework as her school says it is optional. Most of my friend's dcs of that age don't do homework either. Kids are at school for 5 days a week, they don't get enough time to simply be kids as it is.

Your 10 yo is at Primary right? So not the same situation.

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 21:47

Florenz · 04/10/2022 21:42

We don't live in a meritocracy but if you take 2 children in similar circumstances, one of whom works hard, one of whom is lazy, the hard worker will do better in life probably 99% of the time.

This.

Florenz · 04/10/2022 21:42

We don't live in a meritocracy but if you take 2 children in similar circumstances, one of whom works hard, one of whom is lazy, the hard worker will do better in life probably 99% of the time.

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 21:39

Florenz · 04/10/2022 21:03

Hard work is by far the best way to become successful. If parents and schools are telling children they don't need to work hard because the best jobs will always go to children with rich parents, they are not doing a very good job themselves.

It’s one way to increase your chances of becoming successful, and I prefer work smart, not hard as there is a limit. Tons of people I know are very hard workers. Are they successful? No. A few have been, but they are the exception not the norm and it’s been working smart + good luck.

I think it’s important to be realistic to kids especially my working class DC that even if you do work hard, it is no guarantee of success because privilege is a thing and has more impact on your life chances than anything else in this world. This is an inescapable fact. Class privilege, wealth privilege, and for my DDs male privilege.

Just like the other facts of bad things happen to good people and good things happen to bad people.

We don’t live in a meritocracy and I’m tired of the pretence that we do.

MichaelAndEagle · 04/10/2022 21:37

pointythings · 04/10/2022 14:57

And we were thankful!

And walked to school, in all weathers, uphill both ways!

Mydogatemypurse · 04/10/2022 21:35

Its excessive

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 21:29

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 20:58

Sorry but what a load of waffle, a) it is not common in state schools for many children to get all 9s so the idea that those committing to 2hrs revision to attain 8s/9s is not exactly mind-blowing! You won't get far at A level stage or degree level on the back of high intellect alone, you will need to put some effort in.

Plus, there are loads of studies on attainment and attendance, look at the studies showing attendance and gaps between rich and poor.

the idea that those committing to 2hrs revision to attain 8s/9s is not exactly mind-blowing!

No, it’s false advertising imho. Saying it’s time spent rather than quality of work done or any other factor for that matter. There’s no proof that if a student spends 2hrs/day homework then they will get 8/9s. None.

there are loads of studies on attainment and attendance, look at the studies showing attendance and gaps between rich and poor.

I’ve looked at them and they don’t account for confounding factors like home life, quality of teaching, quality of educational resources, etc. You can’t be saying rich kids are naturally smarter and harder working than poor kids? Can you? Please say Ive got wrong end of the stick here. They over simplify a correlation into primary causation as if showing up to a school even an Inadequate special measures school where students throw each other throw plate glass windows is all that is required to “attain” good grades…

You won't get far at A level stage or degree level on the back of high intellect alone, you will need to put some effort in.

True, on some effort, but why specifically 2hrs a day? What makes it superior to 1hr a day? Besides, I found that work smarter not harder was key to succeeding at degree level. In addition, you don’t have as much time in a classroom compared to GCSE because the ratio of teacher-student learning vs independent learning shifts more and more to independent learning.

Challenger5 · 04/10/2022 21:26

I have just checked DD2s school homework expectations for Year10 next year and it says 14 hours per fortnight so is considerably less than DD1 is required to complete.

DD1 has told me that because she is in top sets for English/Maths and Chemistry though officially the school does not set in Chemistry. The three teachers concerned are notorious for supposedly setting more homework than the other teachers. So maybe the school are putting their higher attaining pupils under more pressure with a higher workload.

I do think though that DD1 who is at the top end of her Grammar school cohort should be expected to produce consistent academic work. This should be of higher standard than DD2 who is nearer the bottom of her school's cohort.

However, as stated previously, I think DD2s achievements will be equal if not greater than DDs1, when you throw in all the obstacles placed in her way.

OP posts:
Delatron · 04/10/2022 21:20

I think that’s the point though. A child manages their learning and naturally this would ramp up towards exams. You would expect to spend more hours revising for exams than on homework.

2 hours seems completely arbitrary- what is this based on? People insisting unless these children do precisely 2 hours per night they won’t get good grades. Rubbish.

FishAndChipsForDinner · 04/10/2022 21:16

Im on the fence. My dc did basically none at this stage of the year, but 2 hrs or more during exam season. Came out with 6 9s, 3 8s and a 7. Revision before exam season was making anke flashcards. Was at a bog standard state comp. now at a top ten 6th form and manages to get all study done during frees, plus working two evening and one weekend day.

Verytirednow · 04/10/2022 21:12

Have just asked my son who was at Grammar School and he said 2 hrs homework never happened. My other son and daughter who also went to Grammar school never had more than an hour max and did their homework at school!
All high achieving Uni graduates now .

ElspethTascioni · 04/10/2022 21:12

Wow! I’m surprised by the responses. It seems a normal amount to me. My year 11 son does similar, and I certainly did when I was at school- and I was never a particular hard worker…

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 21:07

It is certainly not going to equate to guaranteed high grades but this thread isn't about that, if you need to revise to achieve more average grades or even low grades rather than none at all then how is revision not beneficial. Qualifications opens doors for people, an education is a way to level up, it's about having options in life.

DuckBilledFattypus · 04/10/2022 21:06

Florenz · 04/10/2022 21:03

Hard work is by far the best way to become successful. If parents and schools are telling children they don't need to work hard because the best jobs will always go to children with rich parents, they are not doing a very good job themselves.

I agree with this. It's a real shame for those children.

Fairislefandango · 04/10/2022 21:05

suggests to me most kids are not that bright and the schools pushing them unnecessarily to get the grades they should be teaching them to

Most kids are average. As you'd expect.

schools fault here as asking kids to make up for their short fall

What does that mean? What 'shortfall'? Do you not think it's schools' responsibility to help students achieve their potential?

Florenz · 04/10/2022 21:03

Hard work is by far the best way to become successful. If parents and schools are telling children they don't need to work hard because the best jobs will always go to children with rich parents, they are not doing a very good job themselves.

Goldenbear · 04/10/2022 20:58

Sorry but what a load of waffle, a) it is not common in state schools for many children to get all 9s so the idea that those committing to 2hrs revision to attain 8s/9s is not exactly mind-blowing! You won't get far at A level stage or degree level on the back of high intellect alone, you will need to put some effort in.

Plus, there are loads of studies on attainment and attendance, look at the studies showing attendance and gaps between rich and poor.

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 20:46

Q2C4 · 04/10/2022 20:07

Those 8/9 grades will be with you forever and will help with UCAS applications. Worth 2 hrs per day for 2 years (excluding school holidays) surely if it means you get your pick of Unis / onto the course / onto the career ladder that you really want.

I’m not convinced that 2hrs homework/day = 8/9 grades. Yes some time spent on homework is beneficial say practicing maths equations, but I think there’s a point where not only do you get diminishing returns but additional hours of work can actually lower grades. How many times does one need to read The Inspector Calls? Or draw a self portrait? Homework should be tactical and skills based, not busy work that stresses and drains enthusiasm for learning.

I think it’s wrong to tell children too that if you dont do 2hrs a day, you won’t get high grades and will end up in a boring low paid job. There’s no evidence this is a magic one size fits all recipe for success.

I think too, it is in part the application of the Tory myth that the high paid rich folk are there because they worked harder compared to the low paid poor folk who didn’t work hard (lazy sods)- only it’s being applied to schoolchildren as a microcosm of society and taught to them like a religious belief.

Academic success has tons of factors and hard work is one which is a double edged sword and so should be more carefully considered rather than touted as the primary factor behind success.