Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have an argument about mil dressing my son girly?

219 replies

Aleeson · 03/10/2022 20:41

So me and my partner have a 2 yr old son and we are very blessed with grandparents on both ends who regularly spend time with our son, however there are some issues I’m having with my MIL.

Occasionally our son stays at grandparents house, we always pack a bag full of clothes and shoes to go with him for any occasion and there’s plenty of spares. My mil seems to ignore the bag of stuff we provide and constantly dresses him into her granddaughters clothes and SHOES or my sons clothes that were in her house and now are too small (I did request to donate them or give back to me so I can donate them)
What absolutely boiled my blood this time is that me and my partner were away for a few days because of work and we come back to our son dressed like a little girl and wore a jumper
2 sizes too small. Meanwhile she said to us she had a few of her friends come round and they had a good play in the garden (which is lovely) but
he was wearing a raincoat instead of a jacket we provided (it was quite cold in our area) and when we come home after a few hrs we realised our son has a fever of 39.4!!! And what annoys me is that because she does not dress him in weather appropriate or at least his clothes he gets sick and looks like his parents do not care about him at all! Or that we desperately wanted a girl and now trying to dress our son like one! I can’t imagine what her friends think of us, honestly it is quite embarrassing. My partner promised to sort it out with her as I’m tired of repeating the same thing about the clothes as she seems to totally ignore it! But he thinks I’m overreacting and he’s too little anyway to recognise he is wearing skirt over tights with flower pattern (I wish I was joking) but this gets me to the point that I feel like I would rather have my mum him when it’s needed all of the time because this is just humiliating both for my boy and me. AIBU to have an argument over that?

OP posts:
StridTheKiller · 04/10/2022 04:06

YABU. It's too late, he's already been gayed. You sound neurotic and DMIL sounds deranged. I'll bet family getherings are wonderful fun.

IvysMum12 · 04/10/2022 03:57

Get her a Barbie doll to dress up.

Smileeriley · 04/10/2022 02:07

She's batshit.

Don't let her mind him.

You wouldn't let anyone else get away with it so why should she.

Agapornis · 04/10/2022 02:04

Your MIL clearly has far bigger issues and the clothes thing is just a symptom. While your son is still quite young he probably won't understand her manipulative behaviour and language, but I'd fine alternative childcare asap. She isn't a safe adult, he deserves better.

Btw you don't need to use 'unalive' here, using the words kill and suicide won't get you banned.

Thistlelass · 04/10/2022 02:03

I think you have slipped up by using the word humiliated on here but you've said it now. I would not have liked that, or put up with it, for any of my 4 sons. That does include the youngest one who is gay! Don't think there is any way around it but to tell her straight. You just need to say you are sending him with all his own stuff and this is to be used, please. Maybe you could involve her in some discussion about future outfits you want to buy for him and why? Educate her about all the lovely things that are out there now for children. There was something to be said for the Mothercare catalogue we used to have back in the day. I don't think it is wrong to want your son to be treated in a way which is pretty much the 'norm' for 2022 UK.

Mamanyt · 04/10/2022 01:14

Likelookinginamirror · 04/10/2022 01:07

@Mamanyt - wasn't she being facetious saying that? Hope so!

I do, too, but (sadly) it bears repeating. I cannot tell you how many times I've heard, "That will make them gay!" You'd think people would learn by now.

Likelookinginamirror · 04/10/2022 01:07

@Mamanyt - wasn't she being facetious saying that? Hope so!

Mamanyt · 04/10/2022 01:06

"Gay" is not "caught," nor is it learned. That said, your MIL should respect your wishes, and dress him in the clothes that you have sent.

Goldencarp · 04/10/2022 00:59

I’d probably find alternative childcare. It would piss me off too. You provide clothes, she should use them. It’s very weird.

Likelookinginamirror · 04/10/2022 00:59

Maybe have a browse of personality disorders. Usually considered the result of childhood take, the threatening to end her life, feeling that no affection/ attention is ever enough, no ability to regulate her own emotions.. can be signs of Borderline for example.

Not so you can attack her with it, but so you and DH can get some advice/ideas on how to manage your relationship with her.

Likelookinginamirror · 04/10/2022 00:53

@Aleeson - ah, hadn't seen this - see, I'm right! You've got a bigger problem than flowery tights, I reckon.

Likelookinginamirror · 04/10/2022 00:52

I think you inadvertently hit the spot when you mention that she buys him Disney Princess card stuff because SHE likes it.

This has NOTHING to do with your son. It's entirely about her. What she wants, what she does, what makes her happy.

Your mistake was putting "girly" in the subject line Grin

Your MIL has absolutely no interest in what is best for your son, or whether something is or isn't appropriate, so those of you slating the OP should cop on to yourselves. Yes, she feels weird having her child dressed as a girl, but the thing that makes her uncomfortable is probably the MIL's treating her child as a doll, and not a separate, sentient human being.

Also, yelling at her about the catching the cold thing. Just because she's wrong about that (although yes, if you're coming down with a cold, getting cold is a bad idea), doesn't mean she's wrong about MIL.

TropicalShakedown · 04/10/2022 00:51

@Puffalicious it's what the youngsters seem to call suicide now, mainly because the word is flagged on some social media sites

Aleeson · 04/10/2022 00:31

ScrollingLeaves · 04/10/2022 00:12

I know other posters are trying to stress the point that really there are no ‘girls’ clothes or ‘boys’ clothes except in adults’ minds and a small child won’t care.

But in practice many of us dress in clothes roughly designed according to our cultural ideas of what each sex wears (except for Christening robes)

I think it is very odd of this grandmother to specifically opt to dress him in another, girl child’s clothes when he has had his own provided. Does your husband know why she is doing this?

On the other hand, if he has a happy time with her that is the main thing and the clothes don’t really matter at all. He is so young he won’t be comparing his clothes with other children’s;.and friends will just know it is your mother in law’s funny ways.

She did say that she does it because she likes how pretty girls clothes are and there’s still plenty of life in them, which is true, but why not to give to a little girl who will likely enjoy it more? Or charity?

or is that she finds our sons clothes ugly maybe? I don’t know, but he likes his clothes, especially his cartoons merch and is always super excited when he find his favourite characters in shops

at this point I’m just finding this whole girl dress up situation a bit creepy, as she always wanted daughters (never had one) then she had 1 granddaughter of her own and another step-granddaughter so technically she has 2! It’s not like she never got to buy a pretty dress for child or dress them up all cute

OP posts:
Blueink · 04/10/2022 00:25

*Meaning 1 (or 2 days per week) with DGM

Blueink · 04/10/2022 00:23

@Bobbysgirls sorry to hear your struggles with long Covid and glad you are getting back on your feet. That is a tough situation, great for the support you’ve had when it was needed, but can understand why you want to build up your own confidence again as a Mum. Would you benefit from some emotional support, like counselling or parenting classes to help you build your confidence and own boundaries?
I also felt very secure with my DGM as it was a very calm and routine based environment. Yes, DC generally test the boundaries of their DP. Now your health is improving, though there is no reason you can’t look after him for most if not all of the time. 1 or (max) 2 days per week is plenty to provide some continuity and for you to establish new routines at home. Parenting isn’t about being perfect and some of the things you are stressing about don’t matter as much as you think they do, but understandably you feel under scrutiny and pressure to perform. Your style may well be different and that’s ok.

Aleeson · 04/10/2022 00:22

Another things to add, my partners family has beed very much struggling financially when he was growing up, and the MIL still like to hoard things ( I think I comes from having absolutely no money when she was young) which could be the reason for the clothes worn until they absolutely do not fit in, but we are not in this situation and neither is she now , so there is no need for that
I’ve been “told off” by her for giving a lot of stuff away (both baby stuff we no longer need and my personal stuff) as it isn’t practical , which is something I struggle to understand. If my child has grown out of it/ doesn’t play with it I am not going to keep it in the attic in hopes IF we decide to have a second child to use it, and every time I asked for his outgrown clothes that I left in her house, or asked her to pass it on to charity or give to someone she would never do it, instead she puts it on my child even though he clearly grown out of it

OP posts:
ScrollingLeaves · 04/10/2022 00:12

I know other posters are trying to stress the point that really there are no ‘girls’ clothes or ‘boys’ clothes except in adults’ minds and a small child won’t care.

But in practice many of us dress in clothes roughly designed according to our cultural ideas of what each sex wears (except for Christening robes)

I think it is very odd of this grandmother to specifically opt to dress him in another, girl child’s clothes when he has had his own provided. Does your husband know why she is doing this?

On the other hand, if he has a happy time with her that is the main thing and the clothes don’t really matter at all. He is so young he won’t be comparing his clothes with other children’s;.and friends will just know it is your mother in law’s funny ways.

Puffalicious · 04/10/2022 00:08

Unalive herself?

Aleeson · 04/10/2022 00:08

Aleeson · 04/10/2022 00:07

No we allowed grandparents to see our baby literary same week he was born, in fact, both of the grandparents were always welcome to come see him at our house as soon as the cocos restrictions were lifted ,
so we definitely never hid our child from family

*COVID

OP posts:
Aleeson · 04/10/2022 00:07

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 04/10/2022 00:02

Where did OP suggest her MIL not seeing their baby for 6 weeks after birth? I haven't seen that mentioned???

No we allowed grandparents to see our baby literary same week he was born, in fact, both of the grandparents were always welcome to come see him at our house as soon as the cocos restrictions were lifted ,
so we definitely never hid our child from family

OP posts:
ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 04/10/2022 00:02

Blueink · 03/10/2022 23:51

Hmm I agree to a point, but you are over egging it a bit. It’s not about anyone’s preference other than yours, as he’s practically a baby. Too tight items, especially shoes and inappropriate clothing for the weather is totally unacceptable, but I can’t get excited about flowery leggings or whatever, sorry. This seems a bit of a hang up from your DP (I don’t agree with MIL not seeing DC for first 6 weeks either FWIW).
I would take proactive action to collect DS’s old ill fitting clothes and preferably leave a change of his current clothes at MIL. There might be some other narrative she has about not wanting to unpack the bag, mess up his new stuff in the garden or create extra washing for you, who knows.

Where did OP suggest her MIL not seeing their baby for 6 weeks after birth? I haven't seen that mentioned???

Aleeson · 03/10/2022 23:59

If I walked in to my MIL house and saw my little boy in flowery tights and a skirt I would look aghast and point blank say ‘why in gods name have you dressed him as a girl? Surely you’ve not taken him out like that? He better not have been like that when so and so popped round was he? Then I’d pick up my son and address him and say ‘what’s granny doing to you? Granny wants another little girl I think! Ahh let’s get you in your nice, normal clothes! Hey, Jackie, pass me his bag and I’ll get him dressed.’

Yes, I definitely should have done it this way. But the thing with her, if you tell her you don’t like somethings she’s doing she starts bawling her eyes out and I see it a way of manipulation and often have a cold reaction to this, yet my partner thinks we should be soft with her as she is so sensitive

**TW
I know her for 6 years and it is always ends with “I’m so bad, nobody likes me, poor me, brb gotta call the mental breakdown helpline, feel on edge” kind of thing

the woman even went so far to dread us and her other kids that she is going to unalive herself because nobody loves, this happened many times and is also quite triggering for my partner

OP posts:
Itsbritneybitch22 · 03/10/2022 23:55

Aleeson · 03/10/2022 23:50

And to add, in his 2 years of life there were other situations like his cards/present bags from her are almost always pink / Disney princess stuff because she likes it (that’s what she told to my partner when he questioned her on that)
also on many occasions I suggested that my son goes to my parents all of the time as my mum works from home and only 2 days a week and my parents have a lot more active lifestyle and in general it would be easier for them to look after a hyperactive 2 year old…. but then I was thrown with a lot of arguments that I keep my son from seeing his grandma from dad’s side etc and she has thrown a crying scene when I didn’t let her have him for a sleepover when he was only a few weeks old :/

@Aleeson

Let her cry and cause a scene she’s a weirdo, keep your son away.

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 03/10/2022 23:53

Toottooot · 03/10/2022 21:01

So why do constantly keep putting him there - dinna like fit she dis - dinna pit him there 🤷🏻‍♀️

In English? Dinna? Fit? Wtf?!?