Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think one of each isn't that amazing?

116 replies

CarsonViolet · 03/10/2022 19:16

So I recently had my first child, a son, and DH and I are likely going to start trying to conceive our next when he's 1 as we'd like them to be close in age (also to just get the baby/toddlers years over with quicker). Our families and some close friends know this and have been quick to make the standard "let's hope for a girl" "bet you want a girl" comments.

Anyone else honestly prefer the idea of having same sex siblings to a mixture? Anecdotally, based on my own experiences with my siblings and from what I've seen from my friend's children, I just feel that my kids will get on better/ be closer if they're same sex (in my case two boys). Not to mention there's more opportunity to reuse clothes, toys etc They also probably be more likely to have shared interests so no arguments on what we're doing/where we're going for family days out and stuff

I'm aware this absolutely wont be the case for everyone but I've just never seen the appeal on one of each. I always knew I wanted two kids and I always had a preference for either two boys or two girls.

Anyone else feel this way?

OP posts:
namechangetheworld · 03/10/2022 23:43

I agree that having one of each is seen as a bizarre sort of Holy Grail. Once we had DD1 I was desperate for another DD (and thankfully got my wish) - not only to reuse all of the beautiful dresses and the VERY pink nursery, but because my friends with sisters all seem to have such lovely, close relationships that have lasted into adulthood. Close adult brother/sister relationships seem to be less common. DD1 and DD2 are currently the best of friends, as they tell us every day, and long may that continue.

EfficientDynamics · 03/10/2022 23:32

We have one DD. We were asked recently if we were going to try for a boy

How does one try for a boy?

Dreamingcats · 03/10/2022 23:22

Yes. If I could choose, I'd choose two of the same.

CaptainBarbosa · 03/10/2022 23:21

I'm one of each, me and my brother are just shy of 2 years apart in age, him being the eldest.

We are close, always have been. We shared similar interest, like sports but also had our individual tastes, I liked Barbie he like model aircrafts. Seemed to work out fine.

My cousins are two women, 18 months apart, they also get on ok, but not as close as me and my brother. Like even now as adults I see my brother twice a week, they only see eachother at family events and occasions, but they do WhatsApp a lot, they live no further apart than me and my brother do.

So I suppose it just comes down to their personalities more than their sex. But I suppose the financial bonus of having tow the same sex is easier on the purse strings!

RamsayEaster · 03/10/2022 23:12

Its nice to be able to raise a girl and a boy ❤️💙

Minniem2020 · 03/10/2022 23:07

I had a girl first but when I was pregnant with my 2nd I didn't think oh a boy would be nice so I have one of each. If anything I thought another girl would be easier as I knew what I was dealing with. I had a boy and he is amazing, as is my 3rd child, also a boy.
DP has 2 boys from a previous relationship and the day I told mil that I was expecting a boy her reply was oh dp wanted a girl! Erm no he didn't, he honestly had no preference at all. After me having our 2nd together that makes it 4 boys he has and he's delighted.

AloysiusBear · 03/10/2022 23:06

I put yabu because i was completely neutral about what i got both times

Dyra · 03/10/2022 22:54

I've got 4 younger siblings. Two of each. We all got on to varying degrees as children, but none of us are especially close as adults.

As for my own kids, I honestly didn't care what I had either time, as I believe that personality and age difference has a far bigger impact than sex on sibling relationships. So far, DC1 absolutely adores DC2. DC2 enjoys the attention. But then we're only 6 months in. Who knows what the future will bring.

JustDanceAddict · 03/10/2022 22:45

I have one of each with a small gap and they’ve always had similar interests and got on (as far as siblings do). I suppose I wanted two girls, but I’m actually pleased I didn’t in the end.

bakewellbride · 03/10/2022 22:43

I have one of each and whenever anyone tells me how it's 'the best' / superior to having 2 boys, I always point out I disagree and would've been equally as happy had dd have been a boy. It always dumbfounds people, it's so weird! Yes a boy and a girl is wonderful and amazing but then so are many other family set ups too.

Ultravox · 03/10/2022 22:32

I’m with you. I had 2 boys and was pregnant with a third child. The number of people who commented that we must be desperate for a girl was unreal! When DS3 was born I actually felt a sense of relief as I knew they could share bedrooms/toys/clothes etc. I would’ve been delighted if he had been a girl of course but it somehow made it feel easier that it was another boy. And no we’re not going to go for a 4th to try to get a girl.

supersop60 · 03/10/2022 22:30

I thought I wanted 2 DDs, but when DS was born I was delighted.
They are individuals, and now they are 21 and 18 they get on great!

thejadefish · 03/10/2022 22:23

I was secretly hoping to have 2 the same but had one of each in the end (love them both to bits of course, not disappointed) but I don't think that I've spoken to a single person who hasn't trotted out the "one of each that's really good!!!" line. Internally I rolled my eyes (particularly whilst I was expecting) but I think it's just small talk/something to say for most people 🤷🏻‍♀️

DramaAlpaca · 03/10/2022 22:22

I always wanted a family of boys. I never had any particular desire to have a daughter, though of course I'm sure I'd have been delighted if I'd had one. I have three boys and it's great. What I couldn't imagine having and tbh didn't want was a family of all girls, I think I'd have been desperate for a boy.

ZenNudist · 03/10/2022 22:22

I think any set up works well. I have 2 boys. Thats great. It has advantages and disadvantages. Same for 2 girls or one of each. I'd agree that 2 of the same is a bit easier but one of each gives you the chance to try parenting both boys and girls.

I do love my two boys and would have a third boy if i could.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/10/2022 22:18

PuttingDownRoots · 03/10/2022 19:20

DH has a brother who he hasn't talked to in several years.

I have a brother who is one of my best friends.

Its personality not sex.

Exactly

It’s just as odd for you to think two of the same will be easier, as for people to think one of each is somehow ideal.

CatSeany · 03/10/2022 22:16

We had the same comments, and I honestly didn't mind what we had. We had a girl, after having had a boy first time round. Then we got comments saying "well you don't need any more now that you've got one of each". We'd like another at some point we think. But it upsets me that if we'd had a boy as a second child, people would assume we were having a third just to try for a girl. My girl plays with cars more than she does anything else. My boy carries his teddies and pushes his pram everywhere 🤷‍♀️.

HelloBambinos · 03/10/2022 22:14

Elodie09 · 03/10/2022 19:42

It is the smug ones who get me, "I am so privileged to have one of each " like you have any say in it at all or you have done something super clever!
Sheer chance and we love 'em all .

Ahh yes I hated this attitude and the 'well I'm lucky as I have own of each' oh somehow are others beneath you then? We had two sons 2 years apart in age and we were ecstatic but the amount of people who tried to force gender disappointment on me was unreal..I got a lot of 'oh what a shame' 'i feel sorry for you' and a so called friend who had found out she was pregnant with the opposite gender of her first telling me days after I gave birth how 'its a different kind of love you wouldn't understand (even though she hadn't even given birth at that point) and how it's not your fault that you had two of the same gender I'm just lucky' needless to say that ended that friendship. DH has a sister 2 years apart who none of us have contact with and he always wanted a brother. I am one of two of the same gender also and we are close though I'm also close to my half brother. We were so happy as our boys are so close but I couldn't ever say gender doesn't matter without being accused of jealousy...6 months ago we had DD (she was a surprise and I didn't even find out until second trimester so definitely not trying) and I still feel the same regarding gender. I think it's ridiculous and rude...we would have been thrilled with another boy as well ..I'm slightly annoyed I have to buy more new clothes though as some things just can't be passed on from boy to girl ( think such things as outfits with 'little brother' & and 'little man with lots of giggles' on) so she's costing more clothes wise at the moment 🤣🤦‍♀️

TheBeautifulMoors · 03/10/2022 22:03

My siblings and I have the same sex. I’ve one of each. Their bond is nothing like the one I grew up in. We got along great but the relationship mine, has, is on a whole other level. I’ve seen that with many ‘one of each’ siblings. I’ve also seen some who are absolutely horrible to each other. I’ve seen sisters who hate each other.,

it doesn’t matter. What matters is the grounding and love you give them.

Elfrazzle · 03/10/2022 22:02

I (female) have 1 brother who I rarely speak to, so I was hoping for 2 of the same sex.

I did get 2 the same sex but they are both so different I feel I'm getting a one of each experience!

Oysterbabe · 03/10/2022 21:56

It just doesn't really matter. All combinations have strengths and weaknesses.
I have one of each and it's awesome, wouldn't change a thing.

Leakingroofagain · 03/10/2022 21:56

I have one of each. The only benefit to the later one being a different sex is that I can let him pee next to a tree if desparate without getting his shoes covered in wee.

inappropriateraspberry · 03/10/2022 21:54

To had o E if each and someone said to me "Aren't you clever?" Like I had any choice or influence!

NumberTheory · 03/10/2022 21:54

Before I had kids I had a vague idea that one of each would be nice because it makes it more likely you’d see a wider range parenting and family life. But I got same-sex twins and am relieved. I have quite a lot of twin mum friends and despite best efforts at not pushing gender conformity, society seems to do it’s thing from and early age and now I’m convinced it is, generally, quite a lot easier and more fun for them and the family as a whole having two of the same sex.

stuffnthings · 03/10/2022 21:53

*our