Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think one of each isn't that amazing?

116 replies

CarsonViolet · 03/10/2022 19:16

So I recently had my first child, a son, and DH and I are likely going to start trying to conceive our next when he's 1 as we'd like them to be close in age (also to just get the baby/toddlers years over with quicker). Our families and some close friends know this and have been quick to make the standard "let's hope for a girl" "bet you want a girl" comments.

Anyone else honestly prefer the idea of having same sex siblings to a mixture? Anecdotally, based on my own experiences with my siblings and from what I've seen from my friend's children, I just feel that my kids will get on better/ be closer if they're same sex (in my case two boys). Not to mention there's more opportunity to reuse clothes, toys etc They also probably be more likely to have shared interests so no arguments on what we're doing/where we're going for family days out and stuff

I'm aware this absolutely wont be the case for everyone but I've just never seen the appeal on one of each. I always knew I wanted two kids and I always had a preference for either two boys or two girls.

Anyone else feel this way?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
xogossipgirlxo · 04/10/2022 12:45

Each to their own, so YANBU. If I had a choice, I'd want two boys or boy and a girl. I have a sister and I think it's not that great or maybe it's just us 🙄

Kaleidoscope2 · 04/10/2022 12:45

I'm from a family of only sisters, and husband is only brothers. I have a DD and would prefer another girl - more possibility to reuse (although we didnt find gender out first time so up until she was one she wore mainly in unisex clothes), similar interests (this might be a gendered stereotype but based on my DH and I's childhoods we had very different play habits). My family has a lot a girls so its my comfort zone as well. I know first time round I really did want a little girl but next time I think I will be more relaxed about the gender either way. Also dont think same gender are the only basis for closeness, dynamics, geographic location (as adults), personality types have a much greater bearing in my view.

Blocked · 04/10/2022 12:42

Calmdown14 · 03/10/2022 20:50

I have a boy and a girl and a four year age gap. Like you I thought two boys would get on better and didn't have a strong preference either way.

Despite the gap being bigger than intended and having opposite sexes, they are the absolute best of friends. My son loved her from the day we got home, adored her as a baby and is now totally wrapped around her little finger! But I think it's down to him being a totally softy. In return she is his little comfort blanket as he's very shy. If they'd been born the other way round not sure how it would have worked!

I have a boy and a girl with the same age gap. Same experience as you - he's been besotted with her since day 1. I was worried he would be jealous but they're so lovely together. Does my heart good to see how much they love each other Smile

TheGoodFighter · 04/10/2022 12:42

I would have thought that whatever you actually have is what is amazing.

If you won't be happy with whatever you get,you shouldn;t have one.

vivainsomnia · 04/10/2022 12:39

I thought exactly like you and so wanted number 2 to be the sane sex, especially as there were to be 3 years apart.

Number turned out to be the opposite sex, and I came around the idea. As it is, they were the closest siblings growing up amongst all their friends and my friends kids! Ironically, not so much so now they are adults!

We can never predict how our children are going to be like. We have to go with the flow and just adjust accordingly.

chesterelly1 · 04/10/2022 12:36

Just wait until you have a boy and a girl and people assume your 3rd is a "happy accident " because why would you possibly want to change the balance. Loved putting mil right on that score after she'd told nearly everyone she knew

SallyWD · 04/10/2022 07:35

I just feel it's irrelevant really. They are so much more than "a boy" or "a girl". You could have 2 boys or 2 girls with wildly different personalities. I have 2 brothers and we've always been very close and have (in my opinion) almost identical personalities and mannerisms. Who knows, if I had a sister we might have been polar opposites. I think personality is more important than genitals and you never know what you're going to get in terms of personality! It's like a big a lottery.

mrsanflowerpot · 04/10/2022 07:19

We have quite a big gap (4.5 years) between DD and DS. I worried about the gap and then about the gender difference as I worried they wouldn't be close. DD is now nearly 14, they are best of friends (mostly!) and DD calls DS her shadow.

All about personality and them as individuals - they both bring joy (and challenge!) in different ways.

HappyKoala56 · 04/10/2022 07:13

I was the same, when pregnant with my second I hoped for another boy for my son's sake. Was very happy still when we found out we were having a girl.
Mine are very different which makes it hard for days out, but I don't think either fall into complete stereotypical boy/girl interests. Even if you had 2 boys they may not be into the same things.
My 13yo boy loves museums, theatre shows, castles and theme parks. My 11yo daughter hates all of these and wants to do active things like rock climbing, paddle boarding or roller skating.

Copasetic · 04/10/2022 06:36

I've got 2 girls then a boy with 8 years between each one. When I had my first girl all I wanted was girls and used to say that if I had six children I'd still want them to be girls, although I knew having a boy would also be good and had it's benefits. My son is now 11 and I think I might like boys best on the whole as I find other peoples girls a bit bratty. I have no time for the falling out that girls tend to do. In short I think I like best the current sex that I'm mostly dealing with!

Yousee · 04/10/2022 05:43

My third DS is 5 weeks old and I've already had a few people asking if I'll "try again" for a girl.
Considering DS2 was stillborn* and I nearly died, I'm immensely grateful that DS3 and I are both here and healthy and not of a mind to chance my luck again for one thing.
For another thing, I resent so much the idea that my hat trick of beautiful boys is somehow less than because they don't have a vagina between them.
Even my darling mother in law said if I had another it would probably "just" be another boy. There is nothing "just" about any of my sons thank you very much.

*Also comments when I was pregnant with DS3 about how I must hope it's a girl this time as "it's nice to have one of each" as if a) I didn't already have 2 sons so the "one of each" ship had sailed and b) as if a woman whose last child was born dead would be even vaguely concerned about whether the next was a boy or girl

JackMummy12 · 04/10/2022 05:33

I’ve got one of each and always hated it when people told me how lucky I am. I am lucky, but not because of their genders but the great kids they are.

I will be honest, I had a girl first and wanted another girl. I think particularly because of the relationship I have with my sister and the lack of one my husband has with his.

Hearthnhome · 04/10/2022 05:28

I do find the ‘one of each is ideal’ a weird things but.

I know many women in my mums generation who had more kids than they planned to have a child of a different sex. My aunt had 4, in pursuit to get a girl and openly admits she would have stopped at 2 if her second had been a girl and would have had a 5th if the 4th had been a boy.

My dads sister was openly nasty to my parents for getting one of each. She had 3 girls. Mum and Dad just had me and my brother. 4 years apart. We are and always have been close.

I had dd first then 6 years later got pregnant again, I was having a boy. Honestly, I didn’t care either way. I saw advantages to both. A woman at work, was openly hostile to me when I told my colleagues that I was having a boy. Constant ‘it could be wrong it could be a girl’ with a look of distain on her face. I picked a name and it was ‘so what happens when it’s born a girl’ and wasn’t happy with my response of ‘well that name has a well known female version so it will be that’ . It got to the point that someone else told her to shut up.

So I do believe that ‘one of each’ seems to be some peoples ideal.

I do think it’s weird to think that will be close based on sex though. I know loads of people with mixed sex kids and same sex kids. The sex of the kids doesn’t show a pattern.

My Sister in law has 2 girls, 2 years apart who have never got on since the youngest was about 2. My brother has a big and a girl that are 15 month part that really don’t get on. My kids are one of each almost 7 years apart and are super close. Dd just moved away to Uni, ds misses her more than I do. She is contact with him more. She comes home to see him, takes him out for the day and treats him to lunch. She messages him at least once a day to see how school was or how his weekend has been. Her closest friends include him in things they are all doing, where they can.

That’s how me and dbro grew up. His friends became mine and Vice versa. When mum died last year, all dbros long term friends and their partners. got in touch with me personally. Came to see me not just dbro. They are all men. So I don’t find ‘well they are more likely to friends with the same sex so won’t be in the same groups’ doesn’t work either. Dbro married one of my friends.

Dbro is 4 years older than me and his friends grew up with us both. One knew dbro before I was born so known me my whole life. The rest have known me since I was 7. They were at our house a lot when we were young so I think that influenced it.

My dp is the only boy in a family of 5. He is the only one that speaks to all his 4 sisters. All the sisters don’t speak to at least one of the other sisters and it’s always been like that.

Its personality. Upbringing can influence it as well. So I don’t think one of each is ideal, I don’t think multiples of the same sex gives a chance of a better relationship, on its own, either.

CuriousMama · 04/10/2022 05:26

I always wanted 3 boys. Got 2 DSS. I have a dsd and she has 3 boys. I have 5 boys now 🙂. My sons are close but very different personalities. Dsgss are very close. Baby dgs is adored by his brothers.
Someone I know, after having her 3rd son, got a card saying better luck next time!

Quirrelsotherface · 04/10/2022 05:16

All situations are different and of course there will be exceptions but in general I think it's nice for the parents to have one of each but for the kids to be the same sex.

I have all one sex and though there's arguments they have a bond and a real understanding of each other. You can see now that there will be an easy friendship when they're older and I think they are so lucky. I had a brother and although close to him, wish I'd had a sister!

Mumandcarer · 04/10/2022 05:13

I’ve got one of each thank goodness. Both have autism I’m not sure I could have managed a double dose of either of them tbh. Saying that they were both runners when they were little. My so was the worse though.

Musti · 04/10/2022 05:08

I don’t think it really matters. I have two of each. I’ve always thought I wanted a sister as I have only brothers but my girls who are close in age fight like cat and mouse. Hopefully it will change.

TheMightyThor · 04/10/2022 05:02

I have one of each. It makes me a bit sad to pass DDs lovely party dresses and school pinafores onto her friend instead of her sibling 😁but otherwise it really hasn't made much difference so far.

Apollonia1 · 04/10/2022 04:58

I have boy/girl twins. I found out at 10 weeks that one twin was a boy, but had to wait till 20 weeks to find out the sex of the second baby.
Secretly I hoped Twin2 would be a girl, but I thought it might be better for Twin1 to have a brother (so they would be closer as adults).
They're now toddlers and get on well. It's nice to hear previous posters' stories of boy/girl siblings being close as adults.

It's funny that everyone congratulates me on having one of each. I'd never heard the phrase "Gentleman's family", but apparently that means having two kids, one of each.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 04/10/2022 00:16

Siblings either get on or don’t. There were times my dd’s were constantly at each other and were at times damn right nasty to each other or to their older brother.

Toys can be handed down, having both they played with everything. Jeans, trousers, T-shirts can be worn by both sexes.

😂 shared interests. My older son and youngest daughter have more interests they share than they do with their other brother and sister. Afterall they are all individual people.

CarsonViolet · 04/10/2022 00:04

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/10/2022 22:18

Exactly

It’s just as odd for you to think two of the same will be easier, as for people to think one of each is somehow ideal.

Honestly I disagree. I think, generally speaking, same sex siblings tend to get on better for the same reason that most men will have majority males friends and most women will choose to surrounds themselves with majority female friends. People do on the whole relate to and get on with people of the same sex better than the opposite.

Obviously there are exceptions, as this thread has showcased, but I think it's accurate of me to believe that my children will likely be closer if both are male as opposed to male/female.

OP posts:
Mamai90 · 04/10/2022 00:00

I agree. There was just me and my sister growing up, we are so close, always were. She has two boys. I have one girl and I'd prefer baby number two to be a girl. I'd still be happy with a boy but if I could choose it would be another girl.

pogostickplastique · 03/10/2022 23:57

I wanted two boys from the off and got two boys. Thankfully haha

amc8583 · 03/10/2022 23:56

I have 2 DDs and was happy that they in the future may have the sisterly bond my sister and I have.

Interestingly, my SIL is pregnant and doesn't want a girl. She wants a boy as she already has a boy and wants them to have a brotherly bond. My BIL also really doesn't want a girl.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/10/2022 23:54

I just think that the sex of a child - or adult come to that - is rarely the main thing about them.

I think people often fixate on a baby’s sex as there’s little you can say about a baby - you don’t know their personality yet. However, we all know that human beings are rounded and complex, and as they get older, there should be much more to talk about than if they’re a boy or girl.