Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely despise job centre staff?

286 replies

backacge · 03/10/2022 15:23

I receive universal credit to top me up. I am a masters student in a vocational subject that will 100 percent result in a job, I work ten - twelve hours a week, sometimes more and am a single mum. I am trying my best. Over summer I work as often as I can also and make enough that the job centre aren't on my back as I'm earning enough.

Just received a notification that I must attend a work review on Thursday. Number 1 - I have uni that day. Number 2 - what more do they actually want me to do? I am in uni 3 days out the week then the other 2 I am studying. Saturday I work.

I am beyond frustrated. I always find the staff there to be rude and obnoxious and look down their nose at me, even though im probably more qualified than them.

OP posts:
backacge · 03/10/2022 17:29

Meadowbreeze · 03/10/2022 17:14

Hey OP, sorry you're having a hard time. You didn't come across great but I can see you're just frustrated. As someone who worked there in the last year I just wanted to clear up some misconceptions.

  1. It's not about the hours but pay. The 'hours' is based on NMW so if you manage to earn £1227, as it was when I was there, in 5 hrs, were not going to ask you to work more hours as the system will out you in the working enough category.
  2. There is no quota on sanctions, those are actually very hard to give and a massive pain paperwork wise. But it is a target based business model. They get the most funding out of any civil service and they are expected to show results. Most often this is targets on appointments. We would regularly be asked to drag claimants in that weren't in the group requiring appointments, just to fill diaries. Same when there is a visit and they need the job centre to look nice and full. It's the same as any business- whatever it takes to justify cost.
  3. Students were a massive pain because the system doesn't really recognise you. We had to do a manual adjustment every 3 months on students and if we forgot, the system would throw you into a group requiring appointments and would automatically give you an appointment. I used to get random pissed off students I'd never seen before turn up for appointments. It was annoying for us both. You rarely have enough time to check who's in your diary for that day and get through their whole history. Even if you do manage, you don't want to cancel the appointment on the day as they've likely moved stuff around to come. It just ends up an awkward waste of time as you can't really help and they can't change their situation.
  4. If you ever get an appointment you can't attend, send a journal message explaining. It's very hard/impossible to sanction someone who has done this, unless they've done this on 3 appointments running and the work coach has booked and noted the appointment according to sanction guidelines, every time. Make sure you include an alternative date and time. All job centres have Saturday appointments available.
  5. There are a lot of people there with much more qualifications than you. It is a soul destroying job. It is so so hard to make a meaningful difference. The rules you're working around are difficult and you're often working within policies you don't agree with. I actually believe you when you say they aren't nice. I had the mispleasure of working with people who treated claimants horribly. The ego trips are real. However, for every horrible work coach I saw 10 horrible claimants. That wears you down, even if you start the job determined to help. Me and my friends used to laugh that after a year you become allergic to empathy as the job just wears down any of that.

Don't allow people to guilt trip you for claiming, you are a tax payer and this is your right. Try to not get annoyed and send a journal message for any cancellations or queries. The phone line people are useless. I've left now so some things might be different, but I hope this is helpful.

Very useful, thank you 😊

OP posts:
OldFan · 03/10/2022 17:28

I found that most I've had anything to do with have been ok. Some are Socialist Workers. Grin

@backacge A machine probably sent out that letter, not a human. It's just 'If someone is earning X and doing Y hours then Z' and it generates a letter/appointment.

You could ask the staff what you need to do.

Andypandy799 · 03/10/2022 17:28

I am not saying everyone who gets pip or dla is a scrounger’s I get pip @FuzzyPuffling

HardLanding · 03/10/2022 17:28

FuzzyPuffling · 03/10/2022 17:25

This is probably the most disgusting post on this thread.
Scroungers who claim PIP or DLA?
Words fail me at the unpleasant, incorrect and hateful assumption here.

Agreed.

This’ll blow his mind - I get PIP for me and DLA for my child and guess what? I fucking work full time.

But even I didn’t, so fucking what? All these fully healthy people with fully healthy children need to check their fucking privilege.

Meadowbreeze · 03/10/2022 17:27

@Andypandy799 lol you think it was the job centre who decide the daily rate for UC pay? If anything, this experience should've shown you how little you get on benefits. You sound like a gem.

ColeensBoot · 03/10/2022 17:27

AuntSalli it's really not like that anymore. The staff have no leeway and horrendous targets to meet.

It is completely different nowadays.

Andypandy799 · 03/10/2022 17:27

Hoppinggreen · 03/10/2022 17:25

Are you one now?

What does it matter are you saying I shouldn’t get help either then? I can study FT at uni and not have to look for work and I get universal credit because I am not fit for work, so what do you make of that? @Hoppinggreen

onmywayamarillo · 03/10/2022 17:27

Aim one of those still on working tax credits.. dreading the day I have to talk to one of those advisors! But if I'm eligible for a top up I know I'll have to justify myself and it's probably worth doing whilst self employed and with young ish kids at home

Rocketclub · 03/10/2022 17:26

I can see where you are coming from but they are following a procedure - you are being supported by the tax payer - aka me and I’d rather they did do these reviews. As for all the studying - really an hour in the job centre interview is going to seriously effect your day?

FuzzyPuffling · 03/10/2022 17:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This is probably the most disgusting post on this thread.
Scroungers who claim PIP or DLA?
Words fail me at the unpleasant, incorrect and hateful assumption here.

Hoppinggreen · 03/10/2022 17:25

backacge · 03/10/2022 15:34

I've been a taxpayer for 25 years.

Are you one now?

Cam22 · 03/10/2022 17:24

Anyway, everyone does a “Master’s” in current, dumbing down times. It has lost its cachet.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 03/10/2022 17:23

They are very rigid, partly because people take the piss and jobcentre staff get jaded.

If you want the money you jump through the hoops, if the money isn't worth the hassle then don't bother, but personally I would suck it up.

backacge · 03/10/2022 17:23

RueValens · 03/10/2022 17:04

I know many who are in full time work and are doing masters.

Do you think all Masters have the same requirement? If she is doing say a Master's in nursing or occupational therapy or social work or any other Masters that gives you the qualification needed to become part of a regulated profession (because you can have an undergrad degree in psychology or something and then get the Masters to qualify you in the profession you want) then she won't be able to work FT alongside it. They are intensive courses full of placements.

Yep social work is what I am doing

OP posts:
Meadowbreeze · 03/10/2022 17:21

@FurryDandelionSeekingMissile There's no other courses we could send people on. The government assumes everyone who is on UC is an uneducated clamant. They also refuse to conduct any courses in house. Everything is outsourced. This means that if we send Jonny for a CV workshop, we have no idea what he's learning, who is teaching him and whether it's relevant. But the government requires us to put him on a course, won't give money for a course that'll help of course.
Some JC are better than others and have taken it upon themselves to set up Job clubs and other things.
This is a govt problem not a JC one. When labour was in power there was tons of things available.

butterfliedtwo · 03/10/2022 17:18

Whadda · 03/10/2022 15:35

Then stop claiming UC and you won’t have to lower yourself to dealing with them.

This, basically. You're not helping yourself thinking you're better than them. Not a good look.

Andypandy799 · 03/10/2022 17:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PanPacificBallroomChampion · 03/10/2022 17:15

The feeling is probably mutual.

Notbeinfunnehbut · 03/10/2022 17:15

Yeah sadly they are notoriously unhelpful

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 03/10/2022 17:15

I doubt you're more qualified than them to do their job though which is probably what matters.

Meadowbreeze · 03/10/2022 17:14

Hey OP, sorry you're having a hard time. You didn't come across great but I can see you're just frustrated. As someone who worked there in the last year I just wanted to clear up some misconceptions.

  1. It's not about the hours but pay. The 'hours' is based on NMW so if you manage to earn £1227, as it was when I was there, in 5 hrs, were not going to ask you to work more hours as the system will out you in the working enough category.
  2. There is no quota on sanctions, those are actually very hard to give and a massive pain paperwork wise. But it is a target based business model. They get the most funding out of any civil service and they are expected to show results. Most often this is targets on appointments. We would regularly be asked to drag claimants in that weren't in the group requiring appointments, just to fill diaries. Same when there is a visit and they need the job centre to look nice and full. It's the same as any business- whatever it takes to justify cost.
  3. Students were a massive pain because the system doesn't really recognise you. We had to do a manual adjustment every 3 months on students and if we forgot, the system would throw you into a group requiring appointments and would automatically give you an appointment. I used to get random pissed off students I'd never seen before turn up for appointments. It was annoying for us both. You rarely have enough time to check who's in your diary for that day and get through their whole history. Even if you do manage, you don't want to cancel the appointment on the day as they've likely moved stuff around to come. It just ends up an awkward waste of time as you can't really help and they can't change their situation.
  4. If you ever get an appointment you can't attend, send a journal message explaining. It's very hard/impossible to sanction someone who has done this, unless they've done this on 3 appointments running and the work coach has booked and noted the appointment according to sanction guidelines, every time. Make sure you include an alternative date and time. All job centres have Saturday appointments available.
  5. There are a lot of people there with much more qualifications than you. It is a soul destroying job. It is so so hard to make a meaningful difference. The rules you're working around are difficult and you're often working within policies you don't agree with. I actually believe you when you say they aren't nice. I had the mispleasure of working with people who treated claimants horribly. The ego trips are real. However, for every horrible work coach I saw 10 horrible claimants. That wears you down, even if you start the job determined to help. Me and my friends used to laugh that after a year you become allergic to empathy as the job just wears down any of that.

Don't allow people to guilt trip you for claiming, you are a tax payer and this is your right. Try to not get annoyed and send a journal message for any cancellations or queries. The phone line people are useless. I've left now so some things might be different, but I hope this is helpful.

okytdvhuoo · 03/10/2022 17:14

bodie1890 · 03/10/2022 17:07

Well quite, but also just to point out it is actually irrelevent whether or not OP is/ was a taxpayer.

She would still be (rightly) entitled to the same thing under our benefits system.

V true. I think the original post was in response to all the posters offended about OP ‘using taxpayers’ money’ – as if the taxpayers are somewhere else and that’s not the whole point of the system.

PlutoCritter · 03/10/2022 17:14

stop claiming uc then and fund your master yourself

exactly.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 03/10/2022 17:13

hamdden12 · 03/10/2022 15:45

If you walk in there with that"I'm probably more qualified than them" attitude I feel sorry for them. Be grateful we have a system where you can get benefits to support you and your family whilst you study.

The number of people who walk into the Jobcentre for the first time with an "I'm more qualified than them" attitude is probably smaller than the number who walk out of there after x number of visits — where JC staff have spoken to them rudely and condescendingly, assumed they're barely literate with no qualifications and asked them to attend very basic courses aimed at that level, acted as if they have no other obligations so can and must attend JC appointments at any random time, and generally adopted a superior and dismissive attitude — and who then, in a defensive way that's entirely understandable if you know anything about human beings, might choose to lash out in an anonymous forum at the patronising way they've been treated and the assumptions made about them and their intelligence and qualifications, with something like "I'm probably more qualified than them".

My personal experience with the Jobcentre has been limited but fine, but people I know well and trust have had the kind of treatment I'm talking about.

We're not hearing from the OP posting before her first trip to the Jobcentre, assuming it's run by thickies and that this really is all beneath her. We're hearing from someone who's been through the bureaucracy mill, and personally I'm willing to give a little leeway for defensive lashing-out. She shouldn't have added that part but it's an understandable reaction to being treated like shit on someone's shoe.

Blinky21 · 03/10/2022 17:13

I went into the job centre once and they asked me what qualifications I had. I told them I had just graduated with a 2.1. The woman then said, "yes but have you got any GCSEs?" I found the whole process ridiculous and prohibitive, never bothered going back!