Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely despise job centre staff?

286 replies

backacge · 03/10/2022 15:23

I receive universal credit to top me up. I am a masters student in a vocational subject that will 100 percent result in a job, I work ten - twelve hours a week, sometimes more and am a single mum. I am trying my best. Over summer I work as often as I can also and make enough that the job centre aren't on my back as I'm earning enough.

Just received a notification that I must attend a work review on Thursday. Number 1 - I have uni that day. Number 2 - what more do they actually want me to do? I am in uni 3 days out the week then the other 2 I am studying. Saturday I work.

I am beyond frustrated. I always find the staff there to be rude and obnoxious and look down their nose at me, even though im probably more qualified than them.

OP posts:
coffeeandpoetry · 04/10/2022 15:31

FreddyHG · 04/10/2022 15:21

Here here. Where is the personal responsibility?

@FreddyHG
How do you expect people to take "personal responsibility" when their courses are full time and it's only possible for them to work a shift at the weekend? The OP has explained this already.

Being forced to claim benefits because a course doesn't allow you to continue your full time work is not a "luxury" or lacking "personal responsibility." What an ignorant comment.

HardLanding · 04/10/2022 15:22

AuntSalli · 04/10/2022 14:43

This mythical £10K is like the Mumsnet chicken that feeds the 5000…. Even if it actually happened a few years ago certainly not gonna happen now is it? @Aprilx

I was in my second year when this poster was in her first and I sure as shit couldn’t have done what they’re claiming to do.

FreddyHG · 04/10/2022 15:21

maddiemookins16mum · 04/10/2022 07:23

Someone who decides/chooses not to work full time (I don’t give a shite that you’re studying) should not be able to claim benefits anyway imho. Choosing to study and not earn a wage is a luxury.

Here here. Where is the personal responsibility?

AuntSalli · 04/10/2022 14:43

HardLanding · 04/10/2022 14:29

You paid you rent, bills, food, childcare and Uni expenses with the £10,000 loan?

Cool story bro.

This mythical £10K is like the Mumsnet chicken that feeds the 5000…. Even if it actually happened a few years ago certainly not gonna happen now is it? @Aprilx

HardLanding · 04/10/2022 14:30

@Aprilx and SOME students, like me, are up at 6am, out the door at 7:30am and not home until 6pm, 5 days a week, with extra studying to do on top. My job at Asda was far easier than the 4 years I spent doing that.

HardLanding · 04/10/2022 14:29

Aprilx · 04/10/2022 14:10

I went back to university full time in 2018 as a mature student. I funded myself didn’t claim benefits and to be honest I saw this a a bit of a luxury even though it was geared towards a specific occupation. But if I hadn’t been able to afford it, I wouldn’t have done it and frankly compared to my working life, my life as a student was very easy and sometimes involved getting up late.

Fast forward and earlier in 2022, employment had not worked out as well as I had hoped and I found myself deciding to claim Jobseeker’s Allowance. It is entirely possible I am more “qualified” than the person who dealt with me, I have a degree, a masters and a prestigious professional qualification as well. I was still unemployed. My issue was that I was looking for much more junior roles than I had previously had and my tactics had not worked, she directed me in a particular location and I walked in and within a week I had some work, to suit the hours I wanted to work. I feel like she did her job.

You paid you rent, bills, food, childcare and Uni expenses with the £10,000 loan?

Cool story bro.

backacge · 04/10/2022 14:12

@Aprilx you don't have kids then eh?

OP posts:
Aprilx · 04/10/2022 14:10

backacge · 03/10/2022 16:24

You sound equally delightful 🤣 yes I'm a student, so that must mean I sleep until mid day and stay in my pjs.

I went back to university full time in 2018 as a mature student. I funded myself didn’t claim benefits and to be honest I saw this a a bit of a luxury even though it was geared towards a specific occupation. But if I hadn’t been able to afford it, I wouldn’t have done it and frankly compared to my working life, my life as a student was very easy and sometimes involved getting up late.

Fast forward and earlier in 2022, employment had not worked out as well as I had hoped and I found myself deciding to claim Jobseeker’s Allowance. It is entirely possible I am more “qualified” than the person who dealt with me, I have a degree, a masters and a prestigious professional qualification as well. I was still unemployed. My issue was that I was looking for much more junior roles than I had previously had and my tactics had not worked, she directed me in a particular location and I walked in and within a week I had some work, to suit the hours I wanted to work. I feel like she did her job.

HardLanding · 04/10/2022 13:58

maddiemookins16mum · 04/10/2022 07:23

Someone who decides/chooses not to work full time (I don’t give a shite that you’re studying) should not be able to claim benefits anyway imho. Choosing to study and not earn a wage is a luxury.

Aye, next time you’re pissing and moaning about how long it takes any form of test results from the NHS to come through or the next Pandemic, or anything at all related to Public Health/Microbiology/Biomedical Science, or in fact in anything STEM related, remember these words.

Because there’s a huge shortage of Scientists, particularly women, and allowing single parents to claim UC whilst they study is one of the small mercies that is seeing these numbers slowly go up.

But who needs them, right? Not like we drive improvements in all aspects of human life. I should have stuck to NMW on a shop till despite the fact I have the ability to help others.

jewishmum · 04/10/2022 12:34

maddiemookins16mum · 04/10/2022 07:23

Someone who decides/chooses not to work full time (I don’t give a shite that you’re studying) should not be able to claim benefits anyway imho. Choosing to study and not earn a wage is a luxury.

Quite. Only the well-off should be able to become qualified enough to fill the jobs that the UK so desperately need filled.

antelopevalley · 04/10/2022 12:26

Typical Mumsnet bullying on this thread.

LightHousePanda · 04/10/2022 12:16

What a horrible thread. I agree the OP didn't do herself a favour in some of the wording but posters have gone over the top in assessing that she'll be a rubbish social worker and all other ridiculous charges.

NuNameNuMe · 04/10/2022 08:08

The ability to withstand and navigate bureaucratic, inconsistent and frankly baffling systems will stand you in very good stead for any organisation, and especially social care which straddles two such systems in councils and NHS.

Attend, and think of it as on the job training.

maddiemookins16mum · 04/10/2022 07:23

Someone who decides/chooses not to work full time (I don’t give a shite that you’re studying) should not be able to claim benefits anyway imho. Choosing to study and not earn a wage is a luxury.

Oldsu · 04/10/2022 02:45

okytdvhuoo · 03/10/2022 22:17

What a load of nonsense. Old Su literally says:

“paying tax is not or ever should be seen as money for us to draw on when they need it […] only entitled people see it as that”

S/he doesn’t make the distinction you suggest s/he does at all. And indeed there is no meaningful distinction between:

a common resource to be used as and when, by whomever needs it

And a ‘personal piggybank’.

The latter is just an insulting way of saying the former.

Are your comprehension skills so poor? etc. (No, not in fact my own attitude - just mirroring your words back)

Actually @okytdvhuoo that is exactly the distinction I am making, if you read my initial reply you would have read that I have paid tax for 52 years (thus far) paying tax for so long does not nor should it entitle me to income based benefits, in fact I will never be entitled to income based benefits, but if I did it would be my personal circumstances that would entitle me to them NOT the fact that I have and am still paying tax , the same with my state pension I am lucky I paid into SERPS while I was working age so get a higher pension then some but the fact remains its working age people who are paying my pension just as I paid for other people's pension when I was paying NI, people who insist that they are 'owed' something just because they once or are still paying in (and I count a lot of pensioners in this) do have an entitled attitude.

Trez1510 · 04/10/2022 00:06

okytdvhuoo · 03/10/2022 22:17

What a load of nonsense. Old Su literally says:

“paying tax is not or ever should be seen as money for us to draw on when they need it […] only entitled people see it as that”

S/he doesn’t make the distinction you suggest s/he does at all. And indeed there is no meaningful distinction between:

a common resource to be used as and when, by whomever needs it

And a ‘personal piggybank’.

The latter is just an insulting way of saying the former.

Are your comprehension skills so poor? etc. (No, not in fact my own attitude - just mirroring your words back)

Nothing wrong with my comprehension skills, dear.

OldFan · 03/10/2022 23:17

TLDR all I was trying to say was the JC do not in general treat you with dignity and we have bouncers at ours

@Andypandy799 They probably do that in case people turn nasty.

Little Hitlers lol.

Half the time they're helping people claim stuff they're entitled to.

Iamchurchill · 03/10/2022 22:38

They’re doing their job, you sound like a snob.
don’t claim UC or claim it and have the inconvenience of having someone check that you are eligible

okytdvhuoo · 03/10/2022 22:17

Trez1510 · 03/10/2022 21:53

Good grief! Are your comprehension skills so poor as to not understand @oldsu was saying only entitled people view the taxes they paid as a personal piggy-bank, rather than accepting the reality they are a common resource to be used as and when, by whomever needs it.

Or are you bristling because quite a few pp's have considered you to be 'entitled'?

In any event, neither are traits/attitudes that will assist you when you are serving the most vulnerable in our society.

What a load of nonsense. Old Su literally says:

“paying tax is not or ever should be seen as money for us to draw on when they need it […] only entitled people see it as that”

S/he doesn’t make the distinction you suggest s/he does at all. And indeed there is no meaningful distinction between:

a common resource to be used as and when, by whomever needs it

And a ‘personal piggybank’.

The latter is just an insulting way of saying the former.

Are your comprehension skills so poor? etc. (No, not in fact my own attitude - just mirroring your words back)

bathsh3ba · 03/10/2022 22:14

I received a UC top up when I did my Masters and PhD full time. I didn't have any work requirements but I still had to go in once a year to 'renew my claimant commitment'. It sounds like this is what that is? I never had an issue with the job centre staff though, some I dealt with didn't really know what they were doing bit they were all polite.

MargeSampson · 03/10/2022 22:14

Stop claiming UC and support yourself and your life choices. Interesting how you're rude about JC staff and seem to find it beneath yourself to have to be accountable to them, yet you're happy to let the state support you.

girlfriend44 · 03/10/2022 22:07

Bestcatmum · 03/10/2022 15:37

Unfortunately it really isn't their fault. They are told how to do their jobs and they HAVE to follow the rules.
The rules are shit and they realise this but they themselves would get the sack if they follow the rules.
They must get abuse every day of the week. I had a friend who did this job and she said at first she cried every night when she got home and the only way she could cope was to harden herself and not get involved.
I couldn't do it.

Me neither. Little Hitlers lol.
Could never sanction anyone either. I wouldn't want to be responsible for taking away someone's money to live on. I couldn't punish them and try and starve them.

Cw112 · 03/10/2022 22:02

You're being unreasonable. Firstly (and ironically) you're looking down your nose at them "I'm probably more qualified" and secondly they're on reduced appointments and most things now are done through UC portal so if you've been asked to come in there is clearly a reason for it so you should be able to come in a little later to uni if you email your tutor. It's unfair to hate them all for doing their job and asking you to come to an appointment that confirms your entitlement to tax payers money. I would never begrudge anyone the right to receive uc if they need it but to throw the head up over being asked to attend an appointment is a bit much. If you do varying hours then the review is likely to confirm that you are working less than 16hrs and are on the right rate of uc. As you're in education you should be able to provide a letter stating this which will be taken into account.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 03/10/2022 22:00

I agree, I was made redundant and claimed job seekers allowance and found my 'work coach' patronising and the process really awful. I was looking for a new job but they made me feel pretty awful. I found a new job fairly quickly but they made it harder not easier.

Trez1510 · 03/10/2022 21:53

backacge · 03/10/2022 21:05

@Oldsu so only entitled people claim benefits?

Good grief! Are your comprehension skills so poor as to not understand @oldsu was saying only entitled people view the taxes they paid as a personal piggy-bank, rather than accepting the reality they are a common resource to be used as and when, by whomever needs it.

Or are you bristling because quite a few pp's have considered you to be 'entitled'?

In any event, neither are traits/attitudes that will assist you when you are serving the most vulnerable in our society.