Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely despise job centre staff?

286 replies

backacge · 03/10/2022 15:23

I receive universal credit to top me up. I am a masters student in a vocational subject that will 100 percent result in a job, I work ten - twelve hours a week, sometimes more and am a single mum. I am trying my best. Over summer I work as often as I can also and make enough that the job centre aren't on my back as I'm earning enough.

Just received a notification that I must attend a work review on Thursday. Number 1 - I have uni that day. Number 2 - what more do they actually want me to do? I am in uni 3 days out the week then the other 2 I am studying. Saturday I work.

I am beyond frustrated. I always find the staff there to be rude and obnoxious and look down their nose at me, even though im probably more qualified than them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pearlearringgirl · 04/01/2023 02:56

Had a few dealings with job centre staff myself after finishing my education and before my first job. Nowhere would employ me as I didn’t have ‘experience’ how exactly you’re meant to get that experience when no one is willing to give you a chance is beyond me? 🤷🏼‍♀️

Anyway my confidence was already on shaky ground having rejection after rejection applying for all kinds of random jobs and every-time I went to the job centre I had someone talking down to me and generally treating me like some shit they found on their shoe. At one point I was actually suicidal I was so depressed. I hope there’s a special place in hell for job centre staff who take enjoyment in being judgmental assholes to the people they are supposed to be helping…

Anyway I eventually accepted a care job that I was over qualified for and at the time didn’t actually want to do. (Btw Care homes are full of staff who actually don’t want to be doing that job).

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 00:26

XenoBitch · 04/01/2023 00:19

How come you were offered the car park job? Did you attend an interview? Surely if you did not want the job, you could have sabotaged your application for it?
I have a relative who has a cleaning company, and she receives awful applications from people who were clearly only applying because they were forced to. She would not dream of even inviting them for interview, let alone offering them a job.

'Accepted' was the wrong choice of words. They wanted me to go to an interview which by all accounts sounded like a 99% chance of getting it. It was for a big ongoing event which required loads of staff and he'd already placed quite a few people there in the past week, all of whom had been accepted.

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 00:21

AuntSalli · 03/10/2022 15:33

Years ago I sat down with one of them and said look I am only gonna be on your books for six months we can both put ourselves through the trouble of completing all this paperwork or I can just sign on this dotted line you can press the button and we can both move on with our days and concentrate our efforts where they will be more rewarded. And she did.
I would imagine that level of autonomy has completely disappeared and these poor souls now are micromanaged to within an inch of their lives the best way to look at them really is with pure pity

Six months! They'd be on your back in less than six weeks these days unless it's all changed in the last few years.

XenoBitch · 04/01/2023 00:19

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 00:16

I remember the one and only time I was on JSA after being made redundant. I wasn't even going to bother as was confident I'd find another job within a month but my mate persuaded me that as a taxpayer I should absolutely do it.

Fucked it off after the second meeting I think it was following a low key argument with a snotty prick in sandals (no joke) who looked a bit like Jesus.

I'd already been to a fair few interviews before signing up for JSA and was due to hear back early the following week about second interviews, which would take place later the same week. The job centre wanted me to accept a job as a car parking attendant and threatened to cut my JSA if I declined.

I said I was happy to do any job if it came to it but was fairly confident I'd have a job in next week or so as some of the companies I was applying to knew me and had previously sent me notifications of available positions.

They wouldn't budge so I said OK but if I need to go to a 2nd/3rd interview at short notice I'll be prioritising that. They said if I didn't turn up to the car parking job then they'd probs cut my benefits for that.

It was an utter joke, like they expected me to spend all my time on the totally inappropriate jobs they were offering me which would have barely paid my rent. I literally walked out and had a job offer for another decent bid management job in less than a week.

How come you were offered the car park job? Did you attend an interview? Surely if you did not want the job, you could have sabotaged your application for it?
I have a relative who has a cleaning company, and she receives awful applications from people who were clearly only applying because they were forced to. She would not dream of even inviting them for interview, let alone offering them a job.

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 00:16

I remember the one and only time I was on JSA after being made redundant. I wasn't even going to bother as was confident I'd find another job within a month but my mate persuaded me that as a taxpayer I should absolutely do it.

Fucked it off after the second meeting I think it was following a low key argument with a snotty prick in sandals (no joke) who looked a bit like Jesus.

I'd already been to a fair few interviews before signing up for JSA and was due to hear back early the following week about second interviews, which would take place later the same week. The job centre wanted me to accept a job as a car parking attendant and threatened to cut my JSA if I declined.

I said I was happy to do any job if it came to it but was fairly confident I'd have a job in next week or so as some of the companies I was applying to knew me and had previously sent me notifications of available positions.

They wouldn't budge so I said OK but if I need to go to a 2nd/3rd interview at short notice I'll be prioritising that. They said if I didn't turn up to the car parking job then they'd probs cut my benefits for that.

It was an utter joke, like they expected me to spend all my time on the totally inappropriate jobs they were offering me which would have barely paid my rent. I literally walked out and had a job offer for another decent bid management job in less than a week.

Fluffy2023 · 04/01/2023 00:13

Suck it up...yes it conflicts with class but unfortunately it needs to take priority as its your means to attend university. Hopefully it's only temporary for you.

As for the staff looking down their nose at you...for the hour or two your there I really don't think you should worry. They are doing their job and probably don't care to be perfectly honest as they deal with claimants in and out of education and work everyday.

If you have the view your more qualified than them then maybe its you that gives them bad vibes with your persona when you attend?

ThinWomansBrain · 04/01/2023 00:10

any reason for disabling voting? - like you realise most people would think your being unreasonable?
If you think attending JC interviews is beneath you, stop claiming benefits and get a student grant.

JudgeRudy · 03/01/2023 23:58

YABU
You sound both judgemental and entitled. Whilst getting your Masters might be a strategic move long term you can't really expect the state to pay you to do this. You've chosen to invest in your career like many other students. Yes it's harder for you with kids to care for but it's your choice....and your responsibility.
You've said 'the staff'rather than one specific person you've clashed with. Have you considered maybe thats its YOU that is the problem?

JudgeRudy · 03/01/2023 23:51

How long ago was that? If you're claiming benefits and able to work you sign to say you will take work for a minimum number of hours per week.

Welfarerightsworker · 03/01/2023 23:46

Keyansier · 03/10/2022 15:27
It's not a case of earning enough... it's the number of hours you work. Anything less than 16 per week and they will call you to attend these types of meetings.

This is not correct.

Work related requirements are withdrawn once you earn more than your 'individual threshold', which is the amount that you would earn doing your 'expected hours of work' at minimum wage.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 03/01/2023 23:25

Any reason to bring up an old thread to pontificate on @Cbhyc ?

Cbhyc · 03/01/2023 23:12

I hate most of the responses to this post, the benefits system, that we all pay lots of money into should be designed to support people into getting higher paying jobs, that in turn generate more tax, that in turn support more people into higher paying jobs. Most of the posts in here are mean and seem driven by jealousy. If someone has studied, raised a kid is getting a masters and has a viable career path in plan they should be supported. Trying ti make the poor poorer stinks. Equally people that’s bar some and are qualified for higher paying jobs shouldn’t be forced into minimum wage jobs because it’s counterproductive and lowers the tax base all round, meaning that those that need the benefits don’t have as big a pot to eat from. Use your brains rather than your prejudice.

hearditthroughthegravevine · 08/10/2022 23:53

Needsomeadvice33 · 08/10/2022 22:35

I'm doing a healthcare related MSc and working far more hours than you are. So therefore I don't need UC.

The issue is your working 10 -12 hours per week. What's that all about.

So you do 35 hour a week placements, then work on top of that enough that you don't need a UC top up? You're also single and have children? When is the OP meant to see her children? Study? Sleep? Eat? God forbid relax for a minute.

Needsomeadvice33 · 08/10/2022 22:35

I'm doing a healthcare related MSc and working far more hours than you are. So therefore I don't need UC.

The issue is your working 10 -12 hours per week. What's that all about.

MatronicO6 · 08/10/2022 13:28

I had this with Job Centre staff, when I was training and working part time. Think it depends on the individual rather than 'all job centre' staff. It's also not exactly the happiest of workplaces.

But yeah some of them definitely did speak to me as if I was some kind of leech on the taxpayer. A view clearly shared by some mumsnetters, considering the posts here. Though I will say, I think your "more qualified than them" comment is indicative of a bit of judgement on your part.

But I wouldn't pay any heed to it, it's only temporary. Be pleasant as I am sure they get a lot of grumpy people in!

mycatisannoying · 08/10/2022 13:18

Dumbo? I really didn't think anyone bright or progressive still used words like that these days. Bless.

hearditthroughthegravevine · 08/10/2022 13:03

mycatisannoying · 08/10/2022 09:45

You only work one day a week? No wonder they're on your back.

Dumbo, she can't work due to placements. Her placements are 5 days a week 9 - 5. She works at night when she can fit it in! She also had a daughter. Is she not meant to see her?

mycatisannoying · 08/10/2022 09:45

You only work one day a week? No wonder they're on your back.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 08/10/2022 09:33

Didn't see if op did actually answer one of the first questions, but did you actually try to change the appointment? Read your replies and doesn't seem like you even tried that.

Also many people do hate social workers. I know there are some good ones, I know of a few, but some are dreadful. A very horrible one lives near me, breaks many rules in her job and judging on her parenting skills with her own child, she is slowly producing a paedophile or rapist by letting him get away with crimes as a teenager. Some are shit I'm afraid, like every profession. Might as well face the facts on that.

Aprilx · 08/10/2022 09:19

HardLanding · 04/10/2022 15:22

I was in my second year when this poster was in her first and I sure as shit couldn’t have done what they’re claiming to do.

I suggest you read my post, because I didn’t claim to do anything with a £10k loan. I made a simple comment that my life was easier as a full time student than as a full time worker, in that yes I could get up later and some days didn’t need to go in at all etc. I am really feeling very baffled at the hostility.

Aprilx · 08/10/2022 09:03

HardLanding · 04/10/2022 14:29

You paid you rent, bills, food, childcare and Uni expenses with the £10,000 loan?

Cool story bro.

I don’t have rent or childcare bills, I am 52 and mortgage free. My comment was not about money at all. I was firstly commenting that I did find being a full time student easier than full time working (in response to another post) and I was then commenting on my experience with the job centre staff which the thread is about.

I am not sure why I would make up a cool story about it, it doesn’t even seem particularly cool to me, I would have made up something more interesting if I were inclined to make up anything at all, which I am not.

Andypandy799 · 07/10/2022 20:04

HardLanding · 03/10/2022 18:05

Like you, wanting millions of pounds a year from the tax payer from the age of 31 till death because you owned a successful business? I’ve heard it all now.

@Meadowbreeze just came back as wanted my real name removed from thread. In what post did I say I expected millions back?

I worked my arse off from a young age after leaving comprehensive school and after 11 years of working 100hrs a week my dad and son died and I was just 31 and had a break down.

I got unwell and lost it all. However to then ask me to live on what I get is a joke and I can’t even afford to eat. I now have a life long debilitating illness and not eating makes the condition worse so it’s a vicious cycle. I can’t get well to work but need to work to keep alive.

Obviously I am going to not like the system but hey think of all the people my taxes have helped, I suppose I should be grateful?

FFS for 6 months I got £280 a month! You try living off that

VoiceaFromUranus · 04/10/2022 16:04

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request

Lachimolala · 04/10/2022 15:59

Your working commitments should only be turned on during holidays, especially when on a full time course with placements.

Have you queried this with them?

I must say I do find it a little pointless during the holidays where it’s 1 week etc. I don’t understand how you’re supposed to find a job, interview for it, go through the application stages then induction/training in one week?

When I did my degree I found most of the staff nice and just a select few quite rude and patronising. I just nodded my head and got on with it, soon you’ll be graduated and you’ll hopefully find a job quickly and not be bothered by them too much.

okytdvhuoo · 04/10/2022 15:56

FreddyHG · 04/10/2022 15:21

Here here. Where is the personal responsibility?

Ok well people are entitled to do that – have not done so myself but am glad that people have this option while pursuing further education. The opportunity is available to you too, so there is no issue of unfairness here. I suppose you also do not take advantage of other state-provided services such as the NHS – only private healthcare, etc. funded by your own savings. Good for you – although btw, no-one cares.