Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to leave my 10 YO old to watch her 7 YO for an hour

109 replies

carrotismyname · 03/10/2022 11:42

Posting here for traffic. I really can't remember how old I was when I was left with my older sibling. I'm a single parent and would love to do exercise classes around the corner from where I live but I am unsure what is legal, so would love some feedback.

10.5 YO daughter mature and smart and has been left alone for short times when i've nipped to the local shop. She has an ipad, which she calls off.

7.5 YO son who generally listens to sister, but I do worry if they fall out if I leave them alone.

I'm thinking maybe its another year or so off, but I am curious to what other parents do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
kimchifix · 24/12/2022 12:54

Depends on the kids - I let my 13 yo babysit the younger two (DD would have been 11 and other DS 6 but asleep in bed) a few times when we were close enough to get back home in ten minutes if needs be, and we would always get a calls "DS is bullying me", "DD is not behaving" etc etc because DS was "in charge" and they are both stubborn and won't be told what to do by the other one. It got better and youngest DS is very compliant about going to bed even now he's nearly 11 so it's no longer an issue, but I'd start by leaving them for ten minutes during the day, and work your way up from there...

Oblomov22 · 24/12/2022 12:37

Have none of you ever talked to your kids about what to do in an emergency? Be that .... in school, on the way home from school, getting lost / seperated from parent anywhere. What to do if home alone and x happens? I can't believe some of you don't have these basic conversations?

Oblomov22 · 24/12/2022 12:34

I agree. You will not leave them for an hour till aged 12? But they've started secondary and should be more than capable. Our primary encourages walking to school beginning of year 6, in preparation for secondary. All these kids not being left on their own for more than a few minutes because they can't cope? Mine at that age didn't move from their x box for hours? Wink Barely noticed when I was in the house. And cooked and made many main meals as part of DT cookery at school, yr 7, so this paranoia of they can't make toast isn't good for them.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 23/12/2022 23:25

Fink · 03/10/2022 13:46

I wouldn't leave a child without a proper adult for an hour until they're at least 12. 10 or 11 would be ok for 10 minutes. So two years until I'd leave your daughter alone, not minding her brother, 5 years until I'd leave him with anyone other than an adult.

I think 12 is fairly old. Children are off to high school at 11 and expected to travel etc. Would you really get a babysitter in to watch an 11yo for an hour?I actually have four 12, 10 and twin 7yo. I'd leave the eldest two in for an hour or two if they didn't want to tag along to something. Twins are not great at listening to older siblings so they get to come with me/ have childcare. Will reevaluate next year when they are 8 and eldest 13. I babysat at 13.

givethistokevin · 23/12/2022 23:15

Mellymoon · 23/12/2022 11:36

Reading these comments it’s no wonder we have the least capable children and teens on the planet.
too much responsibility for a ten year old? Give over!.

Interesting, I never left mine alone or to babysit at 10 but they grew into capable adults all the same.

oversized · 23/12/2022 23:13

In your scenario and ages of children, no, i wouldn't leave them for an hour - like you say, another year.

i have an 11 year old (at secondary school, 12 in Feb & has own house keys) and an 8 yo (9 in April) and i left them alone today for 1 hr exactly as they refused to get dressed and ready to go to town with me. Bit annoying as i only wanted one specific thing from one shop.

So off I went Wilko - i walked and took my phone. I gave them a safety/risk briefing, told them the time scale and make sure they were settled/occupied before i left.

I wouldn't leave them in the dark or evening or if they were arguing or not behaving sensibly towards one another.

I don't do it often but sometimes i do nip to the local shop, leaving them at home. - get there and back within 20 mins.

jannier · 23/12/2022 22:56

picklesandtea · 23/12/2022 18:54

Why is there so many ridiculous "what if" scenarios in these chats?! It's like the debate about leaving your sleeping child in the car while you pay for petrol.."what if the pump explodes?" "What if a someone steals the car?" A whole lot more likely that you and said child will get mowed down walking across the forecourt!!
10 and 7 are likely to be perfectly fine left alone - depending on the children of course!

Any nurse, doctor or paramedic can tell you accidents absolutely do happen and it's not just deliberate injury's. Have a look at accident statistics in the UK....everyone of these families never thought when they got up they would be at hospital before bedtime.....a small chance is still a chance.

picklesandtea · 23/12/2022 18:54

Why is there so many ridiculous "what if" scenarios in these chats?! It's like the debate about leaving your sleeping child in the car while you pay for petrol.."what if the pump explodes?" "What if a someone steals the car?" A whole lot more likely that you and said child will get mowed down walking across the forecourt!!
10 and 7 are likely to be perfectly fine left alone - depending on the children of course!

jannier · 23/12/2022 13:01

I always start with is your child old enough to cope in an accident like the younger one falling down the stairs do they know what to do and will they cope with feeling guilty even if it wasn't their fault. Because even an adult struggles with that but a 10 year old really would.

PortiasBiscuit · 23/12/2022 12:59

I might leave a 10yo home in daylight when I went to Tesco, but not with the 7yo, suppose they fight? Or if there is an accident, are you going to blame the 10yo. Too much responsibility.

Seeline · 23/12/2022 12:56

My concern in this situation is would the younger child be able to cope if something happened to the older child?

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 23/12/2022 12:46

I'm leaving my 11 yo and 8 yo today to go food shopping. They'll have a phone and my mum only lives round the corner

JazbayGrapes · 23/12/2022 12:45

Both children at that age should be capable of behaving for an hour.

Zanatdy · 23/12/2022 12:08

No too young by a couple of years I’d say

richlydetailed · 23/12/2022 12:07

My almost 12 yo is left one day a week for a few hours when he gets back from school. We have occasionally left him and 9yo ds for about 40 mins max with clear instructions as what to do in some of the scenarios outlined above.

I do find that NSPCC advice a bit strange- it refers to 12 year olds as primary aged and says they shouldn't be left to make their own way to school. Most primary schools near me allow y5 and y6 students to make their own way in and home if they have parental permission.

Mellymoon · 23/12/2022 11:36

Reading these comments it’s no wonder we have the least capable children and teens on the planet.
too much responsibility for a ten year old? Give over!.

mountainsunsets · 05/10/2022 20:14

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 05/10/2022 20:08

Not a chance aren't they meant to be 14 to supervise a younger child by law??

No.

There's no law, only guidance.

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 05/10/2022 20:08

carrotismyname · 03/10/2022 11:42

Posting here for traffic. I really can't remember how old I was when I was left with my older sibling. I'm a single parent and would love to do exercise classes around the corner from where I live but I am unsure what is legal, so would love some feedback.

10.5 YO daughter mature and smart and has been left alone for short times when i've nipped to the local shop. She has an ipad, which she calls off.

7.5 YO son who generally listens to sister, but I do worry if they fall out if I leave them alone.

I'm thinking maybe its another year or so off, but I am curious to what other parents do.

Not a chance aren't they meant to be 14 to supervise a younger child by law??

Oblomov22 · 05/10/2022 05:41

Probably not. Maybe, depends on the children. Probably not for an exercise class. I'm struggling to remember what ds2 was like at 8. Actually I've scrolled back through my photos and looking at that time ds1 was very mature, as was ds2. They were so young, so cute. Both would happily sit and watch tv, later x box for hours, so I could easily leave them and they wouldn't even move. But both were perfectly happy if I popped out.

But that needs building up gradually. Dh and I would often do gardening, or go to the seperate garage for over an hour, never bothered them, they never even noticed. And I'd pop out for 5 minutes, then 10, then built up. Both of mine were thrilled to be eventually left at home for 1/2 a day when I worked. They loved it. Even though I kept it low key they couldn't understand why it was a big deal.

alanabennett · 05/10/2022 03:32

I've re-read my post and it is unnecessarily snarky - apologies.

alanabennett · 05/10/2022 03:25

Dferg386 · 05/10/2022 01:46

I cannot believe that this is even a debate. No way should a 10 year old be left babysitting a 7 year old. So many things could happen that a 10 yr old would not have the maturity to handle. Also a 10 yr old should just be a child and not have that type of responsibility. Find a good work out routine to do at home instead of putting your children in danger. You don't have to leave home to exercise. My daughter is 13 and only on rare occasions do I leave her alone just to drive to the store one block away. In most places it's illegal to leave a child under the age of 12 to baby sit.

With respect, unless you live in southside Chicago, that's insane. Your (presumably neurotypical) 13 year old is rarely left for an hour? Fuck me, my just turned 14 year old is babysitting other kids! How is your child going to master independence if she never tastes any freedom?

alanabennett · 05/10/2022 03:22

I leave my 11 and 8 year olds together for an hour or so. They've been fine and I am always within 10 minutes of home.

While I understand the reticence of leaving the younger child, I do question the wisdom of not allowing almost secondary school aged kids the freedom of time home alone. By the time I was that age I was getting two buses across a busy northern town. I'm in my 40s so it wasn't that long ago! Kids seem to be infantilised in a way they never were. (Then again, I was once of the few voices on a recent thread wondering why a high schooler sat alone at a bus stop for 3 hours rather than speak to a bus driver, so I may be in minority.)

InvincibleInvisibility · 05/10/2022 02:22

Ive left mine at that age for around 45 minutes but only when

A) they were both watching TV and
B) my mum was watching over them through skype on the computer, angled so she could see them both

We live abroad and skype babysitting was a godsend several times.

My mum would text me regularly to tell me how they were and they could ring me on the landline if needed or go see a neighbour (block of flats).

I did leave my 10 year old for 90 minutes once (his brother's appointment overran). My mum said he did not stop talking to her about dinosaurs for 1 second 🤣🤣🤣

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 05/10/2022 01:53

No a 10 year is not old enough to look after anyone, I am surprised you even needed to ask.

Dferg386 · 05/10/2022 01:46

I cannot believe that this is even a debate. No way should a 10 year old be left babysitting a 7 year old. So many things could happen that a 10 yr old would not have the maturity to handle. Also a 10 yr old should just be a child and not have that type of responsibility. Find a good work out routine to do at home instead of putting your children in danger. You don't have to leave home to exercise. My daughter is 13 and only on rare occasions do I leave her alone just to drive to the store one block away. In most places it's illegal to leave a child under the age of 12 to baby sit.