Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think when people say 'Should of' instead of 'Should HAVE' - it makes them look incredibly thick

204 replies

Vajizzle · 03/10/2022 11:08

Honestly I do not understand how people can continue making this mistake

I know people who are very clever and have professional jobs, that continue to do this

It makes me fkin scream inside

OP posts:
saraclara · 03/10/2022 14:40

The OP said 'it makes them LOOK thick', not that they are thick. And I agree.

I think it's an unfortunate error. I can see how it occurs and I can see that there are plenty of bright people who unwittingly make the error. But it does leap out.

I try not to be a snob, but I genuinely think that this is one of the errors that can really hold you back in life/your career. Because it LOOKS as though you're not intelligent, and makes prospective employers assume that you will make many other writing errors.

So yes, I'm not one for grammar policing, but if I was to make such a regular and obvious error, I'd want someone to tell me.

LetMeSpeak · 03/10/2022 14:38

He s “should’ve” sounds extremely similar to “should of”. How do you know they are saying which?

Also many people are have come from completely different backgrounds I think you should really take that into account when judging people on their grammar.

averageavocado · 03/10/2022 14:35

Really? does it really matter?

Makes you look like a twat to be so bothered about it

All language evolves - examples

Napron
Like many words having to do with cooking and kitchens (cuisine is a prime example), apron came to English from French. In this case, however, the sound of the word once it was used in English caused confusion. The word for a cloth covering in Middle French was naperon, which came from nape, meaning “tablecloth.” (In modern French, a tablecloth is called a nappe.) Naperon came into English in the 14th century, but referring to it in English as “a napron” led to some people spelling the term as “an apron” instead. The rest is messy history.

Ingot
An ingot is a bricklike solid mass of metal or the mold used to create such a casting. The shape is for ease of transport and regulating the size and weight of valuable metals, and this shape is also probably the reason for its name in its language of origin, French, lingot, derived from the Latin word for tongue, lingua (the same root as the English word language). Some English writers, knowing that le and la in French are abbreviated before vowels with an apostrophe as L’, chopped off the initial letter and ended up with ingot. These writers were too smart by half; they seemed to discount the fact that French also has words that just plain old start with the letter L. The original spelling lingot is preserved in dictionaries, but now it gets the label archaic.

Notch
The Middle French word oche meant “an incision made to keep a record,” but when the word migrated into English in the 16th century, the English indefinite article an got in the mix. “An oche” became respelled as “a notch,” used to mean “an indentation,” “a gap,” or “a degree.”

Nickname
The Middle English word eke meant “also” or “in addition,” and a secondary or unofficial name in the late Middle Ages was an ekename—literally, an “also-name.” Both words are labeled archaic in our dictionary today, because a newer word came on the scene that supplanted this compound noun: nickname. It would seem that nickname is also a compound noun, but nick is not a word that means “also,” or anything else for that matter: nickname was formed by the incorrect division of “an ekename” into “a nickname.”

Umpire
It’s ironic that the word for a person who literally calls balls and strikes is called by a name created by a linguistic foul. The original word in English was noumpere, which was a borrowing of the French term nompere. The -pere of nompere was the French word for “equal,” a descendant of the Latin word par (“equal”) that is the root of words like peer, pair, and, of course, par. Noumpere became the form used in English for “one without equal” or “peerless,” but frequent references to “a noumpere” ended up becoming references to “an oumpere,” which became the modern word umpire.

Orange
Nothing could seem more self-evident than an orange. It is, after all, a fruit that named its own color. And yet our name for it, orange, comes from an example of spoiled spelling. The original word in Arabic was nāranj, and it passed into French through the Romance language Old Occitan, which spelled the word auranja, which ultimately became orange in modern French. The n vanished because the indefinite articles in French un and une end with an \n\ sound, and the word was respelled accordingly, dropping the initial n. It’s notable that this respelling didn’t happen the same way in Spanish, which spells orange as naranja.

Aught
The noun aught means “zero,” or, when used in the plural as “the aughts,” a way of referring to the decade between 2000 and 2009. It originally meant “nothing,” and derives from another word that means “nothing”: naught. Naught comes from Old English and the false division created by the phonetic resemblance between “a naught” and “an aught” is to blame for the existence of two such otherwise similar words.

Newt
It may come as a surprise to learn that the name of the small amphibian known as the newt—short as it is—is too long. The creature was originally known as the ewt, a word that derived from a now-obsolete word meaning “lizard,” eft (which today refers to the terrestrial phase of a predominantly aquatic newt). But false division resulted in an extra letter being added, when “an ewt” over time became “a newt.”

Adder
Misdivisions of words that begin with the letter n are the most frequent because, in speech, it is difficult to distinguish between a sequence of the indefinite article “a” followed by a word beginning with an [n] (ex “a name”) and a sequence of the indefinite article “an” followed by a word beginning with a vowel (ex. “an aim”). This make the position of the n very easily confused.
Yet another example is the name of the venomous snake known as the adder. The Old English word for this viper was nǣdre, which became nadder in Middle English. Over time, a nadder became an adder. The Oxford English Dictionary records that by the mid-1400s, the word was being spelled both with and without the n, but since about 1500, the n-less spelling has prevailed.

www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/false-divisions-words-formed-by-mistake

Rolop · 03/10/2022 14:26

@sóh₂wl̥ interestint to see someone else in the same boat! I read a lot but still can't get my head around spellings and grammar when it comes to my own writing.

Hoppinggreen · 03/10/2022 14:23

LeFeu · 03/10/2022 14:21

Bit of an unnecessary reaction OP! Although my current grammatical pet peeve is people using “bare” instead of “bear” (such as “I can’t bare it”) which is really beginning to grate and also seems to making its way into generally accepted usage….

Bare with me makes me giggle as it suggests some sort of communal nudity

Hoppinggreen · 03/10/2022 14:23

Saying it is fine
Writing it is awful and does make people look like they don’t actually know that it should be HAVE rather than OF

LeFeu · 03/10/2022 14:21

Bit of an unnecessary reaction OP! Although my current grammatical pet peeve is people using “bare” instead of “bear” (such as “I can’t bare it”) which is really beginning to grate and also seems to making its way into generally accepted usage….

GreenManalishi · 03/10/2022 14:20

There are lots of reasons people veer from "correct" grammar, if you don't have any of them to deal with then try and let it slide, rather than letting it make you fkin scream inside.

We don't all have the same experience of education, and there are far worse things to grind your teeth over.

Minimalme · 03/10/2022 14:16

It doesn't bother me at all. Our language is ever-changing. In fact, the only consistent thing about it is change.

Can you explain why it bothers you so much op?

poweredbysteam · 03/10/2022 14:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Are you OP?

I haven't attacked anyone.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 03/10/2022 14:11

It makes me cringe.

I also agree that people who read even a tiny amount should be aware that that “would of” isn’t correct. Unless they just choose to ignore it and treat it like an accepted abbreviation.

Vajizzle · 03/10/2022 14:10

@PAFMO

The sky is blue.

OP posts:
shipwreckedonhighseas · 03/10/2022 14:10

It says something about their education. I'm not stupid or snobbish enough to think it says anything about their intelligence.

sóh₂wl̥ · 03/10/2022 14:06

It makes me think that perhaps they don't read very much. I think if you read books or newspapers (online or in print) you'll soon get the message that 'would of' isn't a thing.

Since I got passed initial reading problems - I've always read a lot. My teachers told my parents that spelling and grammar improve as a result. It didn't happen - in early 20s at University I was finally diagnosed with dyslexia.

I don't know if it is the dyslexia, or other conditions I have, but I've always worked best with explicit teaching.

I do think this was one reason grammar teaching wasn't done - as people who just pick up spelling and rules without much thought or practise assumed everyone was like them and it would just happen. Seen similar with our kids and spelling - never correct then surprise they never picked up it was wrong till we stepped in at home with comprehensive spelling program.

I think what's actually happened is entire generation - even well educated people like DH and I - post graduate qualifications - have educational gaps filled in ad hoc making it even harder to pass on correct grammar to next generation.

Ulrikakakaka · 03/10/2022 14:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PAFMO · 03/10/2022 14:04

Vajizzle · 03/10/2022 13:32

@PAFMO No unspoken rule.

Although repeating yourself can become a little tedious for those you are corresponding with.

My post was addressed to the poster who was supporting your POV. Not you. Unless, of course....

OoooohMatron · 03/10/2022 14:04

No because saying Should've, which is grammatically correct sounds like should of when spoken out loud doesn't it? Either way it's weird to get so annoyed with how other people speak.

rachelvbwho · 03/10/2022 14:03

Anyone who is so pedantic about language and grammar is a snob and has too much time on their hands IMO.

Language is there for us to communicate.... If you understand what the person is saying/writing then the communication has been successful and there is no need to comment further. Doing so belittles the individual and is completely unnecessary.

Not to mention the impact that commenting has on people with additional learning needs, disabilities and speech issues.

poweredbysteam · 03/10/2022 14:00

Ulrikakakaka · 03/10/2022 13:40

Oh god, the wolves are circling and turned it in to something else and a personal attack

I bet some of you are the same people who have 'be kind' plastered all over your facebook

It was OP who called people thick.

CulturePigeon · 03/10/2022 13:58

Ulrikakakaka · Today 13:40
Oh god, the wolves are circling and turned it in to something else and a personal attack
I bet some of you are the same people who have 'be kind' plastered all over your facebook

Yes - agree!

Is it as worse sin to be irritated by a grammatical error, or to be a spiteful keyboard bully?

Willing to bet lots of these people also have their irrational pet hates - but that's different, no doubt.

BuzzingFridge · 03/10/2022 13:44

Sorry to be unpopular but yes it makes me cringe for people who write 'Could of' in a work place environment so no YANBU

The only unreasonable thing I see is the way people are launching personal attacks

IcedPurple · 03/10/2022 13:41

I'm not a grammar snob but 'could of' makes my toes curl and puts me off reading anything else the writer has to say.

Ulrikakakaka · 03/10/2022 13:40

Oh god, the wolves are circling and turned it in to something else and a personal attack

I bet some of you are the same people who have 'be kind' plastered all over your facebook

Shortjanet · 03/10/2022 13:40

I can see that 've sounds like of which explains how it happens. What I don't get is why it only happens when preceded by could, should or would. In speech I'd be far more likely to say "I've got a new bike" than "I have got a new bike", yet I've never seen "I of" used in a similar way.

Totalityloss · 03/10/2022 13:39

AlwaysLatte · 03/10/2022 13:20

You should of put this in the Pedants section.

Yeah OP, it’s not THAT difficult to have got that right.

Just makes you look a bit thick to not be able to correctly use the site.

Grin
Swipe left for the next trending thread