Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Yr 1 school reading books shouldn't encourage playing at the local dump!

87 replies

luciemule · 25/01/2008 16:28

DD (6) just bought home a reading book called The Dump (Oxford Reading Tree), where on the 2nd page it says "The Dump was a safe place to play and it had everything we wanted".

Am I being too sensitive but I thought parents were supposed to actively discourage their children from playing at dumps!!!

OP posts:
hercules1 · 26/01/2008 15:28

I lived next door to a scrap yard when I was a small child and used to play there often. Very dangerous actually but we all survived.

luciemule · 26/01/2008 15:23

ok - I understand everbody's point but the point that I was trying to make (backed up by what Reallytired was saying) was that it was a really strange book to give a 5/6 year old to read - although I suppose that DD is reading yr 2 books so perhaps that's why it seemed a little old for her.

I also see what you're all saying about the fiction thing but I still believe that school reading books should not be promoting playing in deserted, potentially dangerous areas of waste land at the age of 5/6 (using boys who aren't 5/6 and are more like 10/11 to illustrate the fact).

And I didn't imagine for a second my DD would take herself off to play in that sort of place, but merely meant that she'd have set the thought in her mind that it's ok to do that when she's older.

As Really Tired said, there are some really dodgy story lines in the Reading Tree books -would you really want a 5 yr to read about witches being burned alive on stakes?

And yes, I realise teachers don't have that much time as to be sifting through out of date books.

OP posts:
cazzybabs · 26/01/2008 11:31

Regardless of wether the story is morally correct or not I susepct the school has not the resources to replace all slightly dodgy story line boks or the time to think which ones may or may not offfend parents. You wait till your a primary school teacher - trsut me your dad will be filled with questions like how am I susposed to hear Jonnie read and teach the rest of the class rather than ohh I am not sure about his book I think I may go and look for a better one!

Reallytired · 26/01/2008 11:22

luciemule,

I don't think you are mad. My son had a book that is in the same series as the dump called "Rotten Apples" its about a horse that gets drunk. The book was hilerous for an adult to read, but totally lost on a five year old child.

Age appriopate reading books for children who are ahead with their reading is much of a problem as age appriopiate books for children with special needs.

Your son is doing really well to be reading difficult books like the dump. A bright five year old doesn't stand a chance of understanding a book with a mature story line. It just becomes an exercise in barking at print. Our children need developmentally appriopiate story lines to develop comprehension.

glitterfairy · 26/01/2008 09:27

I think many of us did play on waste ground as kids and we are still here .

I think we can all get a little over protective and places we used to play in woods, tree houses, etc are only ok if they are fenced in, part of an adventure park or built by craftsmen.

The fun was always using our imagination and materials we had never used before, creating havens which were ours and were far away from adult eyes.

I think it is sad that books for kids should fit our adult world view. It is precisely because most children disobey adults in books that they have such great adventures. Children's fiction is full of examples where the main characters break rules, fight them and disobey adults.

Blandmum · 26/01/2008 09:27

And you dont think that as an adult, with the ability to discus fantasy and reality with your child you could overcome the 'damage' that this book could do?

And would your six year old be able to get to a place with needle strewn matresses alone?

I realise that you didn't mean to semm overprotective, but I'm sorry, I think that you are being somewhat ott.

Once you start teaching you will see that for many children , playing in a dump could be considerably safer than playing in their own houses

pointydog · 26/01/2008 09:17

To op, I don't think you really understand what a book is meant to do.

Marne · 26/01/2008 09:03

Going to the dump was the best day out when i was a kid, now kids are adviced to stay in the car , we are going to the dump todat and dd1 is looking forward to it

twelveyeargap · 26/01/2008 09:02

It's make believe.

yetanothername · 26/01/2008 09:01

"Am I being too sensitive but I thought parents were supposed to actively discourage their children from playing at dumps!!!"

Your argument is flawed. Is the book your child's parent?!

You know you can actually have a dialogue with your child about the book!

2sugarsagain · 26/01/2008 09:00

luciemule, no, but it does imply it's perfectly OK to pick up dog poo with a bit of bog roll and chuck it down the loo. At least it did to my dds when they were 3!

mrsruffallo · 26/01/2008 08:54

Dumps were the original recycling centres weren't they?
I am sorry, I don't see the problem here at all

mrsruffallo · 26/01/2008 08:54

My mum always tells me the best place to play when she was a kid were the bombsites

luciemule · 26/01/2008 08:52

Firstly, it's not based at a recycling centre, it's a piece of waste ground being used as a dump (1988, book was written) so tipping was still prevalent.

Secondly, my DD knows that little girls with red cloaks don't meet wolves for a chat in the woods and that bears don't eat porridge etc. Plus, sleeping beaty pricking her finger illustrates how you shouldn't play with needles.

I wasn't meaning to be overdramatic/overprotective and of course I realise about fiction (I am soon to start a GTP course and become a primary teacher!).

In the book, the waste ground became a building site and the kids still wanted to play there, with lorries, cement mixers, concrete pipes everywhere etc.

At the beginning they said how it was a safe place to play. Old mattresses could have needles in them, pipes could fall/roll, ground is unstable etc.

All I'm saying is the theme of the book (not the reading ability) was aimed at a much higher age group (9/10/11) and said they didn't want to play at the playpark where there was a slide, swings, see-saw etc (all the things my DD loves playing on).

It said it was ok and safe to play on waste ground being used as a tip.

OP posts:
MaryAnnSingleton · 26/01/2008 08:41

Alice drinking strange things from bottles

Blandmum · 26/01/2008 08:36

Little Red Riding Hood....walking through the woods on her own and playing with a wolf

The three little pigs....the dangers of poor building standards

Hansel and Gretal, the woods again, and climbing into ovens

Snow White, taking fruit from stange old crones

Sleeping beauty, playing with sharp objects

and so on , and so on.

You'r going to spend a long time getting wound up

MaryAnnSingleton · 26/01/2008 08:33

ds had a fact book about rubbish,recyling and dumps which he loved and Stig of the Dump too.

mrsruffallo · 26/01/2008 08:26

YABU. Its a story fgs. I have fond memories if Stig Of The Dump too.
Sounds like this book is encouraging recycling by suggesting you can get everything you need from a dump, wouldn't you agree?

luciemule · 26/01/2008 08:19

Yes, but Come Outside doesn't say it's safe to play on a building site/sewage farm/factory/rubbish dump etc.

OP posts:
2sugarsagain · 26/01/2008 06:18

Did your dcs ever watch Come Outside when they were younger, with Auntie Mabel and Pippin the dog? Now that did worry me. Mine were captivated by the poo one, and I have visions of them scouring the dog bit of the garden for poo, picking it up with toilet paper and flushing it down the loo ......

TheLadyEvenStar · 26/01/2008 02:07

Oh i dunno am sure there are worse books. My ds1 has read aesops fables when he was in yr1 and enjoyed them. Didn't pose any terribly hard questions....now in yr5 he is reading a set of books called his dark materials

luciemule · 25/01/2008 22:38

Well, I wasn't joking but maybe I'll now pretend I was so as I don't look quite so silly!

I just thought it seemed, as Reallytired said, that it was not age appropriate for a 6 yr old and the book was very out of date.

OP posts:
scottishmummy · 25/01/2008 17:45

luciemule dont be so silly. so i guess goldilocks is a moral tale don't trespass, dont eat the porridge? fiction is the suspension of reality eg it is not intended to be real or literally interpreted

i do hope you are joking

berolina · 25/01/2008 17:39

We've got a book called 'Under the Ground' in which two children dig their way to the other side of the world. Whenever we look at it with ds1, dh gets indignant and says it encourages children to do dangerous digging. I always respond that in my world no child young enough to be encouraged by a book like that would be left unsupervised in a position to do it. Think the issue is the same here.

Reallytired · 25/01/2008 17:39

I agree with you. My son read that book recently and he is in year 1.

I think that book is unsuitable for year 1 children because the story line is quite grown up. Its good for junior school or lower secondary school children though.

My son also could not understand why the children in the book did not like the kiddie's playground. After self respecting six year olds like swings and slides.

From what I can remember about the book, most the adults were unemployed and my son said to me "why don't they just get jobs like you and Daddy?"

I think reading books should state age appriopateness of the theme as well the reading age.

My son is a magic key fan.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.