Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Yr 1 school reading books shouldn't encourage playing at the local dump!

87 replies

luciemule · 25/01/2008 16:28

DD (6) just bought home a reading book called The Dump (Oxford Reading Tree), where on the 2nd page it says "The Dump was a safe place to play and it had everything we wanted".

Am I being too sensitive but I thought parents were supposed to actively discourage their children from playing at dumps!!!

OP posts:
edam · 27/01/2008 22:59

ah, unknown, I wonder what use I can make of my new psychic powers...

bookwormmum · 27/01/2008 20:51

I read Stig of the Dump when I was a child. In fact calling someone a Stig became a bit of an insult after that.

I don't think your BU as such but is there a 'moral' to the story such as someone gets hurt?

unknownrebelbang · 27/01/2008 20:32

Edam, you read my thoughts.

motherinferior · 27/01/2008 18:56

I am so glad the Inferiorettes' school appears not to stick to a reading scheme.

At least I think it doesn't. I am not what you'd call madly attentive to my children's academic prowess - tend to say 'oh yes we should read something shouldn't we' to DD2 while vaguely expecting her sister to read something at the same time. I do advocate this position, though, for the peace of mind it provides.

edam · 27/01/2008 18:54

Ooh, get you MI. Mr MI clearly has a lot to live up to!

I think children's fiction is exactly the right place to discuss dangerous things that they wouldn't necessarily be allowed to do IRL. Blimey, their lives are already so circumscribed these days now most parents don't allow children to play out. If we start censoring their reading matter there really will be nowhere left for them to explore.

I loved Stig of the Dump btw but can empathise with anyone who is fed up of the ORT reading scheme.

robinpud · 27/01/2008 18:47

Having had probably 1000 children read that book during my career, I don't think any of them felt moved to get on the bus and go to the local dump in order to play.
You are being very over sensitive. Perhaps 6 months into your GTP you will revisit this issue and see if your feelings are still the same.
My suspicion is that you will, by then, be quite grateful for the ORT which despite all its failings, makes the management of children's reading in the average primary school, a little easier to manage. I expect you will also have had the chance to see that there are plenty of children reading books which are far older or with other supposedly "dubious" story lines and actually blossoming because all that really matters is that they are in fact reading.

TheLadyEvenStar · 27/01/2008 18:44

Pointy, good books but because they may have had dad working and mum at home they are deemed politically incorrect and are not allowed in schools.

motherinferior · 27/01/2008 18:37

For various reasons, mainly the fact we'd moved abroad and didn't have many English language books in the house at the time, I read Jane Eyre when I was seven.

I bloody loved it, and wrote my MA thesis on it 16 years later.

pointydog · 27/01/2008 18:37

Do you mean throwing out good ones or rubbish ones?

TheLadyEvenStar · 27/01/2008 18:32

Pointy, I agree. My mum works in a primary school and the other yr we spent the majority of the 6 weeks holiday looking through books and throwing out certain ones....mind you I do know that most London schools did away with the oxford reading tree books.

pointydog · 27/01/2008 18:27

I don't think reading material is something that anyone should feel they have to 'play safe with', let alone schools. Heaven help us. Now, that is depressing

luciemule · 27/01/2008 16:26

I think I'll give up trying to explain how the line of the Dump made me feel but thank to everyone for their thoughts - it was really more about shools playing it safe with their reading material, in a world that is usually so up on health and safety etc.

OP posts:
NKF · 27/01/2008 16:21

I think the dump story could be quite funny. I think children like dirt and a bit of danger (in fantasy at any rate). John Burmingham has a story where a small boy gets his magic bed back from a dump.

TheLadyEvenStar · 27/01/2008 16:13

its just a book, and lets face it the majority of kids hear worse. I think the book is king arthur. they have been reading it in the school for a few yrs now. But i did buy ds1 a copy when he was 7 and he read it then

luciemule · 27/01/2008 16:03

OMG - no wonder they asked to have it removed. I'd have gone loopy.

OP posts:
TheLadyEvenStar · 27/01/2008 15:58

it says,

and he treated me like his bastard brother and bastard son...

luciemule · 27/01/2008 15:54

why can't you write the line on here TheLadyEvenStar? If it's that bad, surely DCs shouldn't be reading it?

OP posts:
TheLadyEvenStar · 26/01/2008 23:26

My ds1 is 9 and in yr5, he is currently reading a book in group read time that he has already read.....but many of the parents have complained as there is one line in the book they dont think their children should be reading....however i personally think that in the context it is i.e in a conversation between 2 adults it is fine....and i am sure many children do say worse.

i don't thinki would be allowed to put it on here though lol and ds1 read it when he was 7 for the first time.

ladymariner · 26/01/2008 20:09

It's only a story. Crikey, half of the books in the school library contain plots that most, probably all, of our dc will never come across!
And what about all the old stuff we read as kids, the famous 5 taking themselves off on bikes to remote places, rowing to deserted islands etc, armed with nothing more than a bottle of ginger beer and a scraggy dog!!!

cory · 26/01/2008 19:21

It is quite hard to judge what is age appropriate for a child. When my dd was 6, we were reading the Narnia stories, Just William and (her idea, not mine!) the Lord of the Rings. She has not shown any tendencies to go off with dwarves or save the world or even to aim at the headteacher's hat with a peashooter.
As for the stories of children skating on frozen ponds- where I grew up, that's what the grown-ups encouraged us to do! They sent us to skate on the lake and taught us how to judge the quality of the ice. So I would have serious issues with my dh if he tried to suggest reading about it was inappropriate.

ladette · 26/01/2008 17:07

i can see where Luciemule is coming from, but you just have to talk to your DD about why it could be dangerous. We had one about skating on a frozen pond, explained to whichever DC it was how dangerous that could be. I did complain about a reception reading book where the child let the old man (who they didn't appear to know!) in at the door, and then the child climbed out of the window. Wasn't happy with that. But if they are old enough to be reading, they are old enough to have a conversation about the dangers and that books are not the same as real life etc IMO.

Reallytired · 26/01/2008 16:33

My son is not likely to go and play at the local dump. He doesn't know where it is. I found the particular book very depressing. My son did not really enjoy reading it.

Prehaps rather than asking if a particular book is unacceptable, its better asking is 5/6 year old child likely to enjoy a particular book. Are they going to gain anything by reading it.

I think its completely reasonable to expect a teacher to give books to a child that they stand a chance of understanding as well as decoding. By the time a child is reading stage 6 of ORT they are quite good at barking at print, and comprehension becomes more important.

bozza · 26/01/2008 16:14

I think you are over-reacting as most others have said. When I was not much older than your DD I was reading Secret Seven, Famous Five etc and a lot of their exploits are not what you would encourage in your children today.

OTOH I do think there is an issue with children who are advanced readers and getting age appropriate reading material, but you say the book is only one year past your DD's age so not too far out of synch really.

TigerPants · 26/01/2008 15:39

It's a story.

Following your line of thinking, would you ban 'Wind in the Willows' because it takes place in and around deep water?
Or Paddington stories because he travels alone?

I know where you're coming from, but I think you are being too sensitive.

But please don't read 'Swallows and Amazons' - you'll pass out!

hercules1 · 26/01/2008 15:29

It was actually fascinating as full of huge mountains of junk like broken caravans, fridges etc. Our cats used to go there to have their kittens.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.