Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Yr 1 school reading books shouldn't encourage playing at the local dump!

87 replies

luciemule · 25/01/2008 16:28

DD (6) just bought home a reading book called The Dump (Oxford Reading Tree), where on the 2nd page it says "The Dump was a safe place to play and it had everything we wanted".

Am I being too sensitive but I thought parents were supposed to actively discourage their children from playing at dumps!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HereComeTheGrannies · 10/11/2022 19:57

@mnhq why are you not banning this “pbp” instead just pointlessly deleting their posts? It’s fucking ridiculous

Dogsogdog · 10/11/2022 19:57

Child is now 20 !

slowquickstep · 10/11/2022 19:55

We used to play on the railway line and in the river, i was only 5.

Softplayhooray · 10/11/2022 19:51

Don't care it's a zombie thread, this book will still be doing the rounds in schools somewhere! It's a depressing weird classic!

sanityisamyth · 10/11/2022 19:51

This thread is 14 years old 🙈🙈🙈

Softplayhooray · 10/11/2022 19:50

luciemule · 25/01/2008 16:28

DD (6) just bought home a reading book called The Dump (Oxford Reading Tree), where on the 2nd page it says "The Dump was a safe place to play and it had everything we wanted".

Am I being too sensitive but I thought parents were supposed to actively discourage their children from playing at dumps!!!

Omg please post a photo. This book went down in actual history in our family as being the most ridiculously depressing kids book of all time. We had a mixture of horror and laughing in the house the night my eldest bought that disaster home.

JeniferAllisonPhillipaSue · 10/11/2022 19:49

@Kanaloa I think she is now old enough to have left school a couple of years ago.

ZOMBIE

Yellowdahlia12 · 10/11/2022 19:49

I wouldn't know where to find a rubbish dump. The local tip, yes, but no children play there, it's very well staffed.
It's a story in any case, it's not encouraging children to do anything, except read.

Kanaloa · 10/11/2022 19:46

Realistically, I think by the time your dd is old enough to play out alone and unsupervised, she’ll be sensible enough to understand that she shouldn’t play in a rubbish dump even though a book she read when she was 5 said kids play in the rubbish dump. At that stage she’ll be old enough/sensible enough to make better judgements.

ofwarren · 10/11/2022 19:44

ZOMBIE THREAD

Clackyheels · 10/11/2022 19:43

My daughter read that one. A week later I found her running around with wild dogs at the local dump. Be warned.

Definitely go and speak to the teacher about it tomorrow. They'll appreciate an educated perspective.

MissEnolaHolmes · 10/11/2022 19:43

Have you read it until the end?

do you discuss the characters?
do you discuss the plot?
do you discuss what a dump is? Why the characters might say that

woodhill · 10/11/2022 19:42

It's from a bygone age

Don't really understand why you would worry about it

AnApparitionQuipped · 10/11/2022 19:41

I have fond memories of the book 'Stig of the Dump'.

RememberWhen07 · 10/11/2022 19:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

pointydog · 28/01/2008 22:41

lol boco

who thinks up stories? They must have... imaginations or something

duchesse · 28/01/2008 13:24

Loving parents have much wanted baby. Baby is beautiful. Sadly loving mother dies. Dad remarries, get new wife who HATES little girl. Sends her to be killed in forest by henchman. Little girl saves herself by going to live with seven short men, returns when seduced by passing prince to see stepmother cruelly and painfully punished.

Loving couple want baby but can't have one. Eventually agree to hand over their first born to local witch who promises them a good infertility treatment. when baby comes, change mind, but have to go through with it anyway. Witch locks baby up in tower for 16 years. Girl grows hair v v long. Local lad climbs up hair, seduces her, and they outwit and kill the witch.

Two little kids have poor parents who can't keep them. Parents decide to lose kids in forest. Older one saves them first time, but fails second time. They fall into clutches of an evil cannibal woman with poor eyesight. Eventually manage to get away by pushing evil witch into big oven where she dies horribly.

None of these are suitable reading material for a 6 yr old.

Unless you have a peculiarly suggestible 6 yr old, stories like the one you describe are an excellent opportunity to discuss the rights and wrongs of certain things, imo.

Boco · 28/01/2008 13:18

So, in conclusion, ORT books are mostly deranged.

Boco · 28/01/2008 13:18

My 5 year old just read a book where for no apparent reason kip and Chiffer and Bop and Flippy and Gran were all magicked to a castle where there were three witches, and gran went up behind one and threw her on the floor! I thought that was a little aggressive. And could encourage grandmothers to needlessly attack. It turned out that the witches were quite bad, so gran turned them all into frogs. I don't know what happened then, there's no way of knowing.

wannaBe · 28/01/2008 13:13

when I was 6 I was reading the famous 5/the secret 7/various other enid blyton adventure stories.

When I was 7/8 I read the hobbit.

While I would have loved to have gone camping on my own in the holidays, catching criminals as i went, and wished I had a dog which went with me everywhere, and a ring that made me invisible, it just wasn't going to happen was it? because most of what's written in books is just fantacy, written about someone else, not the reader.

And I sincerely doubt whether children are that heavily influenced by what's written in their reading book which they will take to school next week and swap for something else.

luciemule · 28/01/2008 12:59

The Dump doesn't really have a moral. I imagined that it would in that a child would get hurt etc, like you said.

Actually what happens is the land gets houses put on it and the builders then build another purpose built, with scaffolding to climb on , an old lorry to play in etc for the kids.

The kids say play parks are for toddlers and the whole feel of the book is more, I think, aimed at young teenagers.

Oh well, DD read it last night and we chatted about the dangers of playing on waste ground (as I had always planned to chat to her about it) and she said she understood.

OP posts:
TheLadyEvenStar · 28/01/2008 01:36

Rosa, i don't see a problem with it, especially as it is a book he already owns and read 2 yrs ago. But it is amazing how many parents are up in arms over it.

fishpie · 27/01/2008 23:36

DD who was 6 at the time bought home a book that was about a Chinese boy that was so unhappy that he threw himself into a river (so he could drown) I was gob smacked and stopped DD reading it. Wrote a rather snotty to the point note about the book, DD teacher was amazed that no one else had picked it up as it had been in the box since the word dot! Also agreed with me that it was not reading material for a 6 yr old!

Have discovered (especially as I work in the school) no matter how hard they try to Water Shed every book, there always seems to be at least one that gets away! That is what happened with DD, Teachers had read the first story, seemed ok, bypassed the rest and thought ok! just goes to show no one is perfect!

Plus I trust the schools reading scheme!

RosaLuxOnTheBrightSideOfLife · 27/01/2008 23:27

If the book is Arthur, I rather assume that bastard is being used in the context of illegitimate, rather than as a swear word, in other words it is being used to elucidate the socio-familial relationship structure involved. So not necessarily a problem for year five IMO.

unknownrebelbang · 27/01/2008 23:06

Well it rhymes with E.

pml.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.