Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you support a teaching strike?

264 replies

Strictly1 · 02/10/2022 18:00

Unions are currently talking to teachers regarding the proposed pay rise and government funding.
I do not want to strike but also know changes are needed for our children’s sake. With dwindling external support from agencies - schools are being expected to do more and more on limited resources that I predict will reduce due to squeezed budgets. The proposed pay rises are not funded. None of it is sustainable.

I honestly do not know what the realistic solution is.

YABU - you do not support teachers striking
YANBU - you do support teachers striking.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Iamnotthe1 · 03/10/2022 20:31

Teachers striking IS them showing their obligation and care for their students.

Teachers are leaving at an unsustainable rate. Education isn't being sufficiently funded. Support is being cut left, right and centre. Some of the people who would be perfect for teaching are never even considering it as a profession because they can earn double or triple in a job that doesn't require the same number of weekly hours. Schools are being expected to do more than ever before but with so much less than they need to do it.

This is the education system our children are experiencing. If you actually care about children, why wouldn't you want more for them?

MrsHamlet · 03/10/2022 20:23

Of course I have an obligation to my students. But my primary obligation is to myself. If I can't pay my bills, Bob in year 8 isn't going to bail me out.

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 20:17

But maybe the REASON kids aren't caught up after covid is BECAUSE there isn't enough money or STAFF to do so.

Fucks sake it's not rocket science.

And teachers only have an obligation to their students as long as they stay teachers. And many aren't staying teachers because the responsibility and high expectations are not matched by pay and conditions.

Iamnotthe1 · 03/10/2022 20:07

Jackienory · 03/10/2022 19:51

No, I would not support a teacher on strike. I think education in this country is sub par when compared to that offered in Europe. I can see this with my youngest daughter and my education. The standard of teaching in her school is really quite poor. It worries me greatly.

Data doesn't support this. Based on the last set of comparative testing, the United Kingdom ranks 6th in Reading, 5th in Science and 9th in Maths. Only two countries rank higher than the UK in all three areas: Finland and Estonia.

There are issues in the UK education system but the work ethic and skillset of the majority of teachers is not one of them.

Annoyingkidsmusic · 03/10/2022 20:02

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:26

I don't think the pay if most teachers is low. It is low of new entrants to the profession but rises quite quickly now.
After 6 years when teachers can get additional points on the Upper Pay Scale for skill and experience- and they are not hard to get:
a classroom teacher can earn up to £43,685 with no additional responsibilites
a teacher who is, for example a Head of a core dept like English or Maths, can earn up to £58, 300
an additional SEN allowance is up to £4,700 on top of those numbers
Lead Practitioners- teachers who are excellent and help other teachers improve can earn up to £67.700
SLT earn between £44,300 in a tiny school up to £123,000 in a huge school as a Head.

You can add additional thousands to those for London and the Fringe.
13 weeks holidays.

I don't think many teachers are poorly paid. Those figure all go up to those points and not everyone reaches the top of every scale but they're not poorly paid.

DH is a Head in a secondary school and he is well-paid. I was well-paid as an Assistant and Deputy Head.

A newly qualified teacher starts on a minimum of 28,000 but within 4 years is on 32,000 and within 6 years of starting is on a minimum of £38,000 if they have not been promoted.

Yes, I agree with this. Teaching is a well paid profession where I live. Also getting increasingly pissed off with the many adhoc teacher training days our school puts in at short notice, and half days becoming more frequent at end of term/start of term. My 10 yr old had a 3 hour morning “back to school” day- ridiculous. And have seen little to no effort from the school to help get kids caught up from covid/school closures. So no, I would not support a strike.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 03/10/2022 19:55

@treesandweeds Office staff work harder than teachers

What proof can you offer for this statement? On the whole, my experience of office staff in schools is that they can largely close the door and get on with their work. They certainly don't have to deal with the behaviour issues that teachers do, or rarely.

@Jackienory I think education in this country is sub par - I suspect you'll find it varies substantially between schools, actually.

Sherrystrull · 03/10/2022 19:52

Jackienory · 03/10/2022 19:51

No, I would not support a teacher on strike. I think education in this country is sub par when compared to that offered in Europe. I can see this with my youngest daughter and my education. The standard of teaching in her school is really quite poor. It worries me greatly.

Can you see the irony in your post?

Better pay and conditions = better teachers

Jackienory · 03/10/2022 19:51

No, I would not support a teacher on strike. I think education in this country is sub par when compared to that offered in Europe. I can see this with my youngest daughter and my education. The standard of teaching in her school is really quite poor. It worries me greatly.

Tadpoll · 03/10/2022 19:43

Proud2care99 · 03/10/2022 06:58

Come work in a care home or as a home carer.
Minimum wage, not a penny extra for bank Holidays, Xmas day, no sick pay...
There's no way we can strike over conditions because we have people to look after.
Sorry, but teachers have an obligation to their students.
It would also be concerning for people who need to work who are already on the breadline who would have to take time off during these strikes to look after their children.

This.

MrsHamlet · 03/10/2022 19:36

Today we had a taste of the future. Due to staff absence, most of our students who have TAs were unsupported.
There were tears, runners and not a great deal of learning going on. And that's what will happen more and more thanks to unfunded pay rises.

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 19:27

It'll be really interesting to see whether all those who were against the schools closing to due to covid (but also against vaccinations and masks that might keep them open) will be also against the schools closing - and they will close - because the government has starved them of cash for so long.

I just don't see how they'll stay open this winter. Because there are staffing vacancies (and maybe redundancies if school budgets have to pay for teacher pay rises) when staff get sick, there still won't be enough supply and it will quickly be a situation where the staff / student ratio isn't safe.

noblegiraffe · 03/10/2022 19:26

Nothing else seems to work, so striking is the only option really.

And what is useful are the discussions potential strike action is prompting about school funding. We've been wanting these conversations for years.

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 19:23

spanieleyes · 03/10/2022 18:53

We are a "Good" school in a historically low earning area- lots of retail/food producing/ manufacturing and distribution employment. But we can't currently employ staff, teachers but especially Teaching assistants because we can't pay enough. Yet we have children who have been waiting months and months for places in specialist provision who rely on the TAs we do employ to keep them in school, we have children who have been waiting 2 years for CAHMS support who are only in school because of the emotional support teachers and TAs provide, we have children who don't meet the criteria for social service involvement who we are supporting with food and clothes because no one else will or can. The role of school staff has widened exponentially as other services have been cut, but we are now down to the bare bones of staffing- we don't replace any support staff who leave and, if we have to fully fund the recent pay awards, we will be cutting the ones we do have. That is the position we are finding ourselves in and it will only get worse.

Great post, true in my children's schools too.

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 19:21

According to free market economics (which the Tories are supposed to believe in) it's all about supply and demand. So given that it's difficult to recruit teachers or even get supply teachers then salaries should go up. Same is true for the 40,000 nursing vacancies. We wouldn't have 40,000 nursing vacancies if they were paid 60k+.

Somehow the Tories are in favour of free market economics when it's shareholders making massively ridiculous profits because of soaring energy bills (i.e profit for nothing off the backs of people being pushed into poverty) but not when it comes to paying nurses and teachers according to supply and demand

Sherrystrull · 03/10/2022 19:18

spanieleyes · 03/10/2022 18:53

We are a "Good" school in a historically low earning area- lots of retail/food producing/ manufacturing and distribution employment. But we can't currently employ staff, teachers but especially Teaching assistants because we can't pay enough. Yet we have children who have been waiting months and months for places in specialist provision who rely on the TAs we do employ to keep them in school, we have children who have been waiting 2 years for CAHMS support who are only in school because of the emotional support teachers and TAs provide, we have children who don't meet the criteria for social service involvement who we are supporting with food and clothes because no one else will or can. The role of school staff has widened exponentially as other services have been cut, but we are now down to the bare bones of staffing- we don't replace any support staff who leave and, if we have to fully fund the recent pay awards, we will be cutting the ones we do have. That is the position we are finding ourselves in and it will only get worse.

Great post.

This is exactly the situation in my school.

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 19:17

I think most teachers I know will be striking mostly because they see that children are being let down by the lack of funding in schools and because they know they are getting to a point that - no matter how brilliant and self sacrificing they are - they simply cannot fulfil their responsibilities to these children with the current lack of funding and cuts.

Nothing else seems to work, so striking is the only option really. I seriously doubt most of them will be striking about their pay alone.

noblegiraffe · 03/10/2022 19:16

I don't think teachers are underpaid.

It doesn't matter what you think when we cannot recruit or retain teachers for the money being offered.

Unless you think not having anywhere near enough teachers isn't a problem? Maybe you don't have any children in school.

Piggywaspushed · 03/10/2022 19:14

Can you quantify in what ways office staff work harder than teachers?

Are you office staff by any chance?

You realise pay across all sectors is related to level of qualifications obtained? Teaching is a postgraduate profession.

Disclaimer : not suggesting office staff don't work hard.

treesandweeds · 03/10/2022 19:09

I don't think teachers are underpaid. And I see all the salaries in my workplace. Support staff on the other hand are ridiculously underpaid. Office staff work harder than teachers in a very stressful role and no one appreciates what they do.

noblegiraffe · 03/10/2022 19:00

we have to fully fund the recent pay awards, we will be cutting the ones we do have

And that is an awful position to be putting teachers in too. Knowing that the crappy pay rise we have been awarded is potentially at the cost of colleagues' jobs. But what can teachers do? Everyone has higher bills to pay.

spanieleyes · 03/10/2022 18:53

We are a "Good" school in a historically low earning area- lots of retail/food producing/ manufacturing and distribution employment. But we can't currently employ staff, teachers but especially Teaching assistants because we can't pay enough. Yet we have children who have been waiting months and months for places in specialist provision who rely on the TAs we do employ to keep them in school, we have children who have been waiting 2 years for CAHMS support who are only in school because of the emotional support teachers and TAs provide, we have children who don't meet the criteria for social service involvement who we are supporting with food and clothes because no one else will or can. The role of school staff has widened exponentially as other services have been cut, but we are now down to the bare bones of staffing- we don't replace any support staff who leave and, if we have to fully fund the recent pay awards, we will be cutting the ones we do have. That is the position we are finding ourselves in and it will only get worse.

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 18:44

noblegiraffe is as usual right about TA recruitment too. TA recruitment relies heavily on people who are invested in local communities and who love the job doing it and the enjoyment and sense of achievement helping children, ease and convenience outweighing the supremely crap pay. The reasons for doing the job will stack up less and less as the cost of living increases and people can earn more elsewhere.

Ultimately whatever solution anyone tries to come up with there simply isn't enough money being put into state education.

I have considered teaching but I wouldn't train without a bursary (I've got my own kids to feed) and I wouldn't touch teaching with a barge pole right now because I think the way things are going teachers and school staff are increasingly going to be put in a position of enormous responsibility without the resources to discharge that responsibility effectively - and yes, I think that includes safeguarding. I'm not surprised so many are leaving.

noblegiraffe · 03/10/2022 18:30

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 18:25

I mean I suppose the other option would be not to give a pay rise and to accept we won't have any teachers in 5-10 years and it'll be unqualified TAs providing childcare.

Problem there is that we can't recruit TAs either. They can get more money working for Aldi.

These people saying 'I don't think teachers are poorly paid' need to understand that their opinion is irrelevant as we don't have enough teachers for the money we're offering.

The lowest paid teachers are being offered an 8.9% pay increase but this isn't anything to do with inflation, this was a manifesto promise to increase new teacher pay to £30k (this will raise it to £28k). This was deemed necessary in order to improve the recruitment of new staff. That pay rise would now be completely eaten by inflation so what impact that would have on recruitment is probably lessened.

The usual argument is that recessions are good for teacher recruitment, but now people can't afford to train as teachers because the govt cut the bursaries. They'll need increasing next year.

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 18:25

I mean I suppose the other option would be not to give a pay rise and to accept we won't have any teachers in 5-10 years and it'll be unqualified TAs providing childcare.

Governorfedupwithitall · 03/10/2022 18:23

mycatisannoying · 02/10/2022 23:25

I understand what you're saying SmileBut the modern day classroom absolutely could not function without support staff. There would be some children who'd run riot. Some are flight risks and a safety issue. 20 years ago, sure, a teacher flying solo could work. These days it's an impossibility for the majority of schools.

You're right - the classroom won't function without them but there is literally no other choice. There is no room in the budget for anything else. Schools are already failing to function in many ways because of cuts that have already happened.

There's no other option.

This is literally the only option.

If we don't give a pay rise to teachers we'll lose our teachers. We are already several staff down and unable to recruit. Any good teachers can walk into a job wherever they want, we know several other schools who are also advertising with no luck.

Our state schools are going to deteriorate more and more unless money is put in. Already those who can (even if it's tough and they have to scrimp and save) are jumping ship to private.

Swipe left for the next trending thread