Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you support a teaching strike?

264 replies

Strictly1 · 02/10/2022 18:00

Unions are currently talking to teachers regarding the proposed pay rise and government funding.
I do not want to strike but also know changes are needed for our children’s sake. With dwindling external support from agencies - schools are being expected to do more and more on limited resources that I predict will reduce due to squeezed budgets. The proposed pay rises are not funded. None of it is sustainable.

I honestly do not know what the realistic solution is.

YABU - you do not support teachers striking
YANBU - you do support teachers striking.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:46

Strictly1 · 02/10/2022 18:43

Support staff are fantastic, do a vital role in schools and should earn more. This should not mean that experienced teaching staff shouldn’t earn a decent wage after a degree and post grad qualification?
My support staff leave as the children do (quite rightly) but the teaching staff continue to work long after.
Let’s not make this a battle between support staff and teachers!

I completely agree. Did someone say they don't deserve decent pay?

JulesCobb · 02/10/2022 18:46

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 02/10/2022 18:32

Is the pay the main factor that causes teachers to leave, or the difficulties and stresses of the job itself?

I support the job being made more appealing to improve retention of good teachers. If pay is a significant issue then yes I'd support the strike.

I work in another public sector role, and whilst colleagues would like more pay the reason they are leaving is actually the job itself- trying to do the impossible with the resources you have, and worrying about being personally blamed for any poor outcomes resulting from that.

It is not enough money for the difficulties and stresses of the job.

There have been next to no pay increases for experienced teachers in a decade. All focus has been on recruitment. There is no progression for the vast majority of staff. Some staff will be paid SLT rates. Most will be main scale, UPS if the school pay it, taking on more and more work, larger roles and more stress for no extra money or time.

the govt is aiming for a £30k starting salary. So, after forty years in the job, there’s what? a £13k increase in wages?

BeeRogue · 02/10/2022 18:46

DH and I both have QTS. We're striking in the way many teachers are - leaving. I've left the profession and DH is leaving in the near future. So is my best friend. In fact, from my class of 73 for my PGCE, only 36 ever got QTS and now (just a few years later) only four are still teaching, we were discussing it just the other day in the group chat.

Whinge · 02/10/2022 18:46

noblegiraffe · 02/10/2022 18:44

Let’s not make this a battle between support staff and teachers!

I sincerely hope that support staff are gearing up for their own strike.

Join a union, folks.

THIS!!

The amount of staff in schools who aren't in a union is shocking.

Cocokitty · 02/10/2022 18:44

The situation for NQT here is dire though @LuluBlakey1. Dp qualified sept 2019, no job to start (NW england). Managed to get a mat leave cover Jan 2020. Covid hit, so guess what? Bye bye job. He completed term one of his NQT. He carried on applying and applying, but once again, he couldn't get a job. 60-100 applicants per job. He did well just getting some interviews. There was very little in the way of supply, and what there was was mostly TA cover for dreadful pay. It was Jan 21 before he finally got another job. Again it was another mat leave cover. He completed his NQT there. So finally Sept 21 he made it to m2. So that was 3 years after he left his job earning the same as an NQT at the time (24k). He has since managed to stay in work, going to another mat leave cover. He is finally in a fixed term job, with a view to permanent. He has always been well thought of, and all the schools have wanted to keep him on but not been able to (apart from one who could do it, but was 36 hours before he was due to leave and he had already committed to a new job). So I'm hopeful that this will finally lead to a perm job. Because we have taken such a massive financial hit to get this far. We are finally debt free (apart from all the student loans after!) after getting in to such difficulties with the job situation in his first 18 months. And now the cost of living once again threatens our stability.

He will one day earn a better wage, but right now it doesn't feel that way. And now is when we need more help than ever.

noblegiraffe · 02/10/2022 18:44

Let’s not make this a battle between support staff and teachers!

I sincerely hope that support staff are gearing up for their own strike.

Join a union, folks.

Strictly1 · 02/10/2022 18:43

Support staff are fantastic, do a vital role in schools and should earn more. This should not mean that experienced teaching staff shouldn’t earn a decent wage after a degree and post grad qualification?
My support staff leave as the children do (quite rightly) but the teaching staff continue to work long after.
Let’s not make this a battle between support staff and teachers!

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 02/10/2022 18:41

Tadpoll · 02/10/2022 18:29

If it’s just because of pay, nope.

I agree with @LuluBlakey1 , teachers are not underpaid.

We're not allowed to strike about the massive issue which is that the government isn't funding the pay rise that we have been offered. If we do get the (real terms pay cut) of 5%, that's got to come out of money schools had budgeted for other things - so cuts to education provision.

We're also not allowed to strike about how school funding has been cut to the absolute bone over the past 12 years and how we are now facing further funding cuts (what is there left to cut?) in order to fund tax cuts for the rich.

We're not allowed to strike about how the government has destroyed education provision, SEN provision, child mental health provision and the burden this has placed on schools.

We are not allowed to strike about them, but the anger this has created against the government by education professionals will certainly be in our minds when we fill out their ballot papers.

And a 5% pay rise is a pay cut. When energy costs, petrol costs, food cost, mortgage payments are increasing, teachers, along with other workers, will be worried about household finances. If there is money available to give the richest a pay rise so that they can increase their spending, then the govt can go fuck themselves telling everyone else that sadly there's no magic money tree, or that it 'might' fuel inflation. Had enough of it.

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:41

bettbburg · 02/10/2022 18:37

I'd support a teaching assistants strike as they get nothing compared to teachers.

It is very true that support staff like LSAs or classroom assistants, in schools are very poorly paid. They are often put-upon by schools too.

However, and I am being provocative I know, whilst they do a great job supporting vulnerable children, all the research shows they make little difference in improving achievement and are a very expensive way for a school to make tiny gains.

This makes them very vulnerable when schools have to lose staff.

Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 02/10/2022 18:40

Yes

Tadpoll · 02/10/2022 18:39

Sorry, but nearly £40k for a primary school teacher is pretty bloody good.

Lovescookies · 02/10/2022 18:37

Strictly1 · 02/10/2022 18:31

This is misleading. A UPS1 teacher in primary earns £38,690 and this is usually where they get stuck. There is no budget for TLRs but all are expected to lead a subject.
I earn £58000 as a HT of a larger than average primary school and 24 years experience and 8 of those in headship.

How many support staff earn anything close to £38,690?

bettbburg · 02/10/2022 18:37

I'd support a teaching assistants strike as they get nothing compared to teachers.

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:36

In the secondary school where I was Deputy Head we had 120 teachers. If they each had even a 1000 pay rise, plus the 22.5% on-costs that the school pays on staff salaries for every teacher, the school would have to find £122,500 (with no additional monies) to fund that pay rise. For small schools it is impossible. For large schools it might be possible but at the expense of people losing jobs- you don't save £122,500 by buying fewer stamps.

dandelionthistle · 02/10/2022 18:34

Thegreymethod · 02/10/2022 18:13

Yes I would support them, yes it would cause issues but that's the point isn't it, if it didn't strikes wouldn't work. If workers just rolled over and accepted being treated badly nothing would ever change for the better and we'd still be living in the days of no sick pay, no annual leave, no maternity pay. Good luck to them.

This.

Tadpoll · 02/10/2022 18:33

SweetSakura · 02/10/2022 18:32

I would support any striking workers at the moment

That’s a bit blanket isn’t it?

Neverfullycharged · 02/10/2022 18:32

I agree with @LuluBlakey1 too.

There are problems in education but IMO pay isn’t one of them.

But more generally I just don’t think teaching strikes are very successful. They only achieve alienating the people we need to support us, and there is still a feeling of resentment after covid.

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 02/10/2022 18:32

Is the pay the main factor that causes teachers to leave, or the difficulties and stresses of the job itself?

I support the job being made more appealing to improve retention of good teachers. If pay is a significant issue then yes I'd support the strike.

I work in another public sector role, and whilst colleagues would like more pay the reason they are leaving is actually the job itself- trying to do the impossible with the resources you have, and worrying about being personally blamed for any poor outcomes resulting from that.

SweetSakura · 02/10/2022 18:32

I would support any striking workers at the moment

Strictly1 · 02/10/2022 18:31

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:26

I don't think the pay if most teachers is low. It is low of new entrants to the profession but rises quite quickly now.
After 6 years when teachers can get additional points on the Upper Pay Scale for skill and experience- and they are not hard to get:
a classroom teacher can earn up to £43,685 with no additional responsibilites
a teacher who is, for example a Head of a core dept like English or Maths, can earn up to £58, 300
an additional SEN allowance is up to £4,700 on top of those numbers
Lead Practitioners- teachers who are excellent and help other teachers improve can earn up to £67.700
SLT earn between £44,300 in a tiny school up to £123,000 in a huge school as a Head.

You can add additional thousands to those for London and the Fringe.
13 weeks holidays.

I don't think many teachers are poorly paid. Those figure all go up to those points and not everyone reaches the top of every scale but they're not poorly paid.

DH is a Head in a secondary school and he is well-paid. I was well-paid as an Assistant and Deputy Head.

A newly qualified teacher starts on a minimum of 28,000 but within 4 years is on 32,000 and within 6 years of starting is on a minimum of £38,000 if they have not been promoted.

This is misleading. A UPS1 teacher in primary earns £38,690 and this is usually where they get stuck. There is no budget for TLRs but all are expected to lead a subject.
I earn £58000 as a HT of a larger than average primary school and 24 years experience and 8 of those in headship.

OP posts:
Tadpoll · 02/10/2022 18:31

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:29

But I do think teacher's pay rises should be funded by the government. If they aren't schools can not afford them without cutting back and the temptation is to attach lower allowances to promoted posts like Heads of Department, increase class sizes so they need fewer teachers or cut other resources or provision for children.

I agree with this too.

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:29

But I do think teacher's pay rises should be funded by the government. If they aren't schools can not afford them without cutting back and the temptation is to attach lower allowances to promoted posts like Heads of Department, increase class sizes so they need fewer teachers or cut other resources or provision for children.

Tadpoll · 02/10/2022 18:29

If it’s just because of pay, nope.

I agree with @LuluBlakey1 , teachers are not underpaid.

Cocokitty · 02/10/2022 18:26

Yes I'm supporting a teacher strike. DP is a teacher so it will hit us in the pocket. But the fully funded aspect is what makes me support it the most. School budgets can not fund a cost of living payrise! They can not. DPs current school couldn't even afford a desk for the teachers and pen pots for the table. Dp took our desk in. And we made pen pots in our own time at home.

Also, on a selfish note I'm a HCP and between us we can't afford the cost of living increases. Every penny counts in our pockets right now and we have had to accept we will be going cold this winter.

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:26

I don't think the pay if most teachers is low. It is low of new entrants to the profession but rises quite quickly now.
After 6 years when teachers can get additional points on the Upper Pay Scale for skill and experience- and they are not hard to get:
a classroom teacher can earn up to £43,685 with no additional responsibilites
a teacher who is, for example a Head of a core dept like English or Maths, can earn up to £58, 300
an additional SEN allowance is up to £4,700 on top of those numbers
Lead Practitioners- teachers who are excellent and help other teachers improve can earn up to £67.700
SLT earn between £44,300 in a tiny school up to £123,000 in a huge school as a Head.

You can add additional thousands to those for London and the Fringe.
13 weeks holidays.

I don't think many teachers are poorly paid. Those figure all go up to those points and not everyone reaches the top of every scale but they're not poorly paid.

DH is a Head in a secondary school and he is well-paid. I was well-paid as an Assistant and Deputy Head.

A newly qualified teacher starts on a minimum of 28,000 but within 4 years is on 32,000 and within 6 years of starting is on a minimum of £38,000 if they have not been promoted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread