Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you support a teaching strike?

264 replies

Strictly1 · 02/10/2022 18:00

Unions are currently talking to teachers regarding the proposed pay rise and government funding.
I do not want to strike but also know changes are needed for our children’s sake. With dwindling external support from agencies - schools are being expected to do more and more on limited resources that I predict will reduce due to squeezed budgets. The proposed pay rises are not funded. None of it is sustainable.

I honestly do not know what the realistic solution is.

YABU - you do not support teachers striking
YANBU - you do support teachers striking.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Piggywaspushed · 26/01/2023 06:54

jenny, I'm not sure you are right about this. Maybe look back to the previous year as well.

But why are we allowing public sector to fight against public sector? We are all in this together.

noblegiraffe · 25/01/2023 22:37

Anyone who says teachers don't need a pay rise are supporting the further deterioration of the education sector which is already in crisis.

Hope you don't have kids in state education.

Mum2jenny · 25/01/2023 22:30

As teachers got a 5% pay rise this year, much higher than other public sectors, no they do not need a pay rise as much as ambulance workers, nurses etc

Ballymaloo · 31/12/2022 16:45

Workyticket · 10/10/2022 20:17

We're on day 6 of 10 strike days in FE. Stay strong, know your worth 💪

In FE the problem isn’t low salaries. It’s colleges getting rid of full time permanent staff in order to hire hourly paid staff through an agency. This relieves the college of all responsibility for holiday pay, maternity, sick pay and pension. It also means they are only paying for time actually spent in the classroom, and staff are forced to do prep and marking unpaid.

These staff usually aren’t Union members. They can’t afford the fees because they get paid so little. They also can’t afford to strike and lose wages. So the issue that needs fixing is not low pay. It’s zero hour contracts and insecure jobs with no benefits.

GracieLouFreeebush · 31/12/2022 16:21

I’ve not had my ballot paper. They’ve sent 3 and none have turned up. I’ve asked if I can go pick one up now.

Benjispruce4 · 30/12/2022 23:11

Absolutely support the strikes. I’m a HLTA in primary school and our school is so overwhelmed with SEN and so inadequately supported in every way.

alphabetsoup1980 · 30/12/2022 20:39

100% support the strikes!!

Workyticket · 10/10/2022 20:17

We're on day 6 of 10 strike days in FE. Stay strong, know your worth 💪

user1499128287 · 10/10/2022 20:11

MrsHamlet · 03/10/2022 19:36

Today we had a taste of the future. Due to staff absence, most of our students who have TAs were unsupported.
There were tears, runners and not a great deal of learning going on. And that's what will happen more and more thanks to unfunded pay rises.

That's a normal day in my school - high need and no support. We all just have to work so much harder and pull rabbits out our asses to make it though :(

noblegiraffe · 04/10/2022 14:14

Jonathan Gullis, schools minister has said that he will do anything to avoid strikes but also said the govt won’t budge on the 5% pay rise.

I’m wondering if they will actually give schools funding for it.

Guess he’d better hope there aren’t any teachers out there with mortgages up for renewal on the new Tory fuck-up interest rates.

GuyFawkesDay · 04/10/2022 13:32

Last real terms pay rise teachers got was when Tony Blair was PM.

It was that long ago. We've effectively had over 20% pay cut since then.

It's unsustainable. There's just so few people out there. If I check TES (and loads of schools don't advertise on there any more!) there's 12 jobs in my subject within 20 miles. Bear in mind I am semi rural. I have never, ever seen this before. Not in October! March maybe as teachers move schools for September but before October half term means massive recruitment and retention issues.

We have hardly anyone coming for SCITT this year too.

Why on earth would you? Get underpaid by other masters level job standards to be abused daily, do a 12 hour working day, be responsible for results but have absolutely no agency over how you do your job, get pilloried by the media for what? Is the (not so good) pension worth reducing your lifespan over?

Because you sure as hell don't have time to fit in an hour's exercise, look after your own family and do your job.

I genuinely would far rather we went to 8-4:30 working hours with nothing past that time, and work the holidays doing admin/other things whilst kids are off and get paid for the extra 8 weeks of work I might do and to have my evenings and weekends back.

noblegiraffe · 04/10/2022 11:46

Tadpoll · 04/10/2022 08:56

My point is, are you saying that everyone should get a pay rise in line with or above inflation every year? How would that work?

Teachers have had real terms pay cuts since 2010. Wages have decreased significantly, compared to the private sector, to the point where we are critically short of teachers.

Would you prefer that was not addressed, and teachers awarded yet another pay cut? Have you got kids in state education, in which case you should be very worried, not just about the teacher market, but also that the pay rise offered will be coming out of education provision for your kids.

If you’re going to say ‘oh but there isn’t any money to give teachers a decent pay rise’, we’ve heard it every year for over a decade. And it’s clearly a lie. When this government wants money for something in its interests, it finds it.

Pottedpalm · 04/10/2022 09:10

treesandweeds · 03/10/2022 19:09

I don't think teachers are underpaid. And I see all the salaries in my workplace. Support staff on the other hand are ridiculously underpaid. Office staff work harder than teachers in a very stressful role and no one appreciates what they do.

You really think office staff work
harder than teachers?

Tadpoll · 04/10/2022 08:56

MrsHamlet · 04/10/2022 06:58

I didn't say it was Bob's fault. Neither is it mine.

My point is, are you saying that everyone should get a pay rise in line with or above inflation every year? How would that work?

MrsHamlet · 04/10/2022 06:58

Tadpoll · 03/10/2022 22:58

But it’s not Bob’s fault the cost of living has gone up, yet he’s the one who’ll suffer.

It’s gone up for all of us. The vast majority in the private sector aren’t getting any kind of pay rise, let alone one in line with inflation.

Are you expecting everyone to get a pay rise every time the price of milk goes up? That’s not how it works.

I didn't say it was Bob's fault. Neither is it mine.

user1499128287 · 03/10/2022 23:47

VBF · 03/10/2022 08:11

I don't want to be difficult but I think your schools may be the minority here. Whilst I do agree pay is better than it used to be (starting pay in particular), it is no where near the levels you suggest in my area at least. I have been a teacher for 8 years across 3 schools and still do not reach £40k mark, even with UPS 1. At one point even with UPS1 and a responsibility I was still not on (in fact a few thousand away before tax) from that mark.
It may just be East Anglia has low pay brackets, but this is the same pay across most of the schools I have seen here. We have a lot of academies and they can set their own boundaries which doesn't help...

Back to OP's question. I am in the same boat. I hate striking and think with all the time parents and children have already missed of work/school it is a horrid thing to do. Equally, teaching as it is is unsustainable.

I honestly think that poster must be a journalist or troll quoting those fantasy figures, VBF. Or working for the DFE to try to spread utter misinformation about what teachers are actually paid in the real world.

user1499128287 · 03/10/2022 23:42

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 18:26

I don't think the pay if most teachers is low. It is low of new entrants to the profession but rises quite quickly now.
After 6 years when teachers can get additional points on the Upper Pay Scale for skill and experience- and they are not hard to get:
a classroom teacher can earn up to £43,685 with no additional responsibilites
a teacher who is, for example a Head of a core dept like English or Maths, can earn up to £58, 300
an additional SEN allowance is up to £4,700 on top of those numbers
Lead Practitioners- teachers who are excellent and help other teachers improve can earn up to £67.700
SLT earn between £44,300 in a tiny school up to £123,000 in a huge school as a Head.

You can add additional thousands to those for London and the Fringe.
13 weeks holidays.

I don't think many teachers are poorly paid. Those figure all go up to those points and not everyone reaches the top of every scale but they're not poorly paid.

DH is a Head in a secondary school and he is well-paid. I was well-paid as an Assistant and Deputy Head.

A newly qualified teacher starts on a minimum of 28,000 but within 4 years is on 32,000 and within 6 years of starting is on a minimum of £38,000 if they have not been promoted.

Are you for real? Do you know what you have to do to get UPS these days and progress beyond £37,000 a year? I work a 50 hour week and still can't get through this, despite teaching since the 90s, even though I got through it once before under the old criteria.
You're just quoting random numbers without really knowing the details.

basilmint · 03/10/2022 23:20

Tadpoll · 03/10/2022 22:54

How does that work? Are you implying that the teachers who are in the profession now aren’t very good because they’re not earning enough?

How does giving them a pay rise help that? They’ll suddenly start trying?

There aren't enough teachers in the profession so not all of them will be suitably qualified, no. Your DC may be taught their Physics GCSE by someone without a physics background. Sometimes the teachers aren't of the highest standard because schools have to recruit literally anyone who will be able to stand in front of the class.

DH is tutoring some A-level business students who haven't had a teacher since the first term of their course because one can't be recruited. They are "taught" by a series of cover teachers who read out a PowerPoint.

We won't get sufficient teachers unless pay and conditions improve.

Sherrystrull · 03/10/2022 23:10

@Tadpoll

Of course not. All my colleagues are brilliant teachers.

However, they are already leaving. The pay is rubbish. I've worked 12 hours today and that's normal.

Also, what makes an amazing maths graduate want to be a teacher? If the pay isn't competitive they will choose a different career.

Good pay and conditions retain and invite excellent teachers.

Crap pay and conditions means no teachers.

noblegiraffe · 03/10/2022 23:08

Are you implying that the teachers who are in the profession now aren’t very good because they’re not earning enough?

Because the pay and conditions in teaching are such that the government has missed its recruitment targets for years (except in 2020, due to pandemic panic, and those trainees didn't generally stay) and teachers do not generally last long in the profession, the quality of teacher trainees has gone down. Some trainees I've seen you've wondered how they managed to get through the interview. And yet they are generally dragged through training with every attempt made to get them to pass.

Due to a critical shortage of teachers, when schools advertise they can often not afford to be choosy about who they hire, because the alternative is no one.

In addition, schools are also making use of unqualified staff to cover or even teach classes, so the person at the front of the room may not have a teaching qualification. They may not even have the qualification they are teaching.

So yes, because pay and conditions are poor, the quality of teaching staff in schools is not always what you would hope it to be. But schools can't send kids home every time there isn't someone suitable to teach the class (that would probably be a more effective signal to parents about the shit state of education than going on strike, tbh).

Crazyducklady · 03/10/2022 23:04

I’m an ex teacher for a reason.

Yes I support teacher strikes. Teachers don’t strike for the shit and giggles of it. They care about children’s education as much as interested, concerned parents and much, much more than parents who don’t give a damn. We need to look after and keep our teachers.

Tadpoll · 03/10/2022 22:58

MrsHamlet · 03/10/2022 20:23

Of course I have an obligation to my students. But my primary obligation is to myself. If I can't pay my bills, Bob in year 8 isn't going to bail me out.

But it’s not Bob’s fault the cost of living has gone up, yet he’s the one who’ll suffer.

It’s gone up for all of us. The vast majority in the private sector aren’t getting any kind of pay rise, let alone one in line with inflation.

Are you expecting everyone to get a pay rise every time the price of milk goes up? That’s not how it works.

Tadpoll · 03/10/2022 22:54

Sherrystrull · 03/10/2022 19:52

Can you see the irony in your post?

Better pay and conditions = better teachers

How does that work? Are you implying that the teachers who are in the profession now aren’t very good because they’re not earning enough?

How does giving them a pay rise help that? They’ll suddenly start trying?

mycatisannoying · 03/10/2022 21:59

MrsHamlet · 03/10/2022 19:36

Today we had a taste of the future. Due to staff absence, most of our students who have TAs were unsupported.
There were tears, runners and not a great deal of learning going on. And that's what will happen more and more thanks to unfunded pay rises.

This

noblegiraffe · 03/10/2022 20:33

And have seen little to no effort from the school to help get kids caught up from covid/school closures.

Remember when the government appointed a covid catch-up tsar and he recommended a £15bn package of measures to support kids and help them recover from the pandemic? The government rejected his recommendation and he resigned in disgust. The government then decided that the way to help kids catch-up was tutoring. They put the contract out, bizarrely awarded it to the lowest bidder which was a Dutch HR company with no experience. The National Tutoring Programme was a farce, kids and schools couldn't access it and what they could access was often poor quality. The govt ended up cancelling the contract.

So yeah, when you talk about no effort being made to catch kids up, blame that one on the government too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread