Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU help or not.

155 replies

Cantthinkstraught · 02/10/2022 17:31

We are in a diocese house (vicarage)with two adults, one child. The house has four bedrooms and we use two. We have been asked to house someone who is fleeing domestic violence. Its a woman.
There are other people who could do this nearby without kids but they have declined to.
We both work full time but the pressure is on as the higher ups in our parish feel its our duty. I want to help, husband wants to help but I don't feel I have it in me to live with someone who is a complete stranger for an unspecified period someone who will understandably be emotionally scarred and need support as well as everything else. We are told its our Christian duty and as we have free rooms we should but surely there are other ways to help. What would everyone else do...please don't shoot me down.

OP posts:
Vecnussy · 02/10/2022 23:15

@Onyellow why don't you offer to take this woman into your home if you feel this passionately about it?

Onyellow · 02/10/2022 23:10

Taking in the needy is against diocese policy - oh that really is brilliant.

And a priest sacked for housing people in need.

If your husband meets Jesus at the pearly gates, he can tell him he didn’t house the needy because it didn’t pass the risk assessment.

He could probably help more people if he quit his job and worked in a private capacity tbh.

Keroppi · 02/10/2022 23:07

I think the religion is not central to this issue - the other vicars aren't taking her in. I am Christian but have Muslim background - my family's local mosque works with shelter to become a homeless centre of sorts in winter, providing beds and meals, but it is in collaboration with a huge charity and the local council. It all has to check out, risk assessments, dbs etc, a dedicated lead in the council housing team to move rough sleepers onto sheltered accom. I appreciate different with DV but I imagine similar - working closely with local women's shelter, arranging lifts there, providing food and bedding. Not being housed directly, at least in my experience only.

EspressoPatronumm · 02/10/2022 23:04

Friend of mine got sacked as a priest because she housed people who were in need of help. You need to speak to the Diocese

Onyellow · 02/10/2022 23:02

Also re: putting your child “at risk”. Thousands of people in this country have invited refugees into their homes, people who they don’t know, even when they have children in the house. Some people with strong moral convictions let homeless people etc say in the house with their children. Whereas others would say “no way”. I expect those people who do that sort of thing rationalise it by thinking of the example of human kindness they are setting their child, despite the risk.

If you were a Christian and that way inclined, it might be a good opportunity to explain to your child about helping others in need - people really in need, at inconvenience to yourself, not just Paul and Brenda from down the road because their house sale fell through.

Your husband is the vicar - he should be saying yes (what does he have to say about it?). You must know he’s a hypocrite for saying no, and so are all these other church officials who said no as well.

Pansypotter123 · 02/10/2022 23:00

It's not fair to put you and your husband in this position at all and your PCC needs a plan / policy for if a similar situation occurs (and should already have one under the church safeguarding policy)

I agree completely with this. Please enlist the support of your Area Dean etc in formulating this plan and ensure your church wardens and PCC are informed of the reasons for any decision made about the present situation.

Keroppi · 02/10/2022 22:58

No, it is dangerous. It could bring damage and stop her accessing benefits - it wouldn't be in her best interests. Perhaps your DH can come at it from that angle too? Seems a bit sexist to use your profession as evidence you will cope, well, yes, you cope as you have boundaries ans this would blur them, impacting on your physical and mental health and your parenting/work abilities.

You work in a caring profession and need home to be a place to relax, prep etc. Perhaps offer temporary sanctuary, for example 3 days, whilst you, dh and others higher up can take her to housing office/job centre/police/womens aid etc whatever to get her housed safely and free from her abuser. Need some sort of interdisciplinary meeting to get her safe and able to rebuild her life free from abuse ASAP

CactusFlowers · 02/10/2022 22:57

If her ex is likely to try and find her then it would be a terrible idea to house her locally where her ex can locate her. For her own safety she needs support to find a refuge place outside of the local area.

Tilllly · 02/10/2022 22:53

Wearing both my work and volunteer hats -

Your Diocesan safeguarding officer would tell you not to take this person in - it's actually a case study in the domestic abuse training in the C of E.

If she is fleeing DA, the police safeguarding team will find her a place of safety

Your husband's role here is to provide pastoral support, that's all.

It's not fair to put you and your husband in this position at all and your PCC needs a plan / policy for if a similar situation occurs (and should already have one under the church safeguarding policy)

Ask yourself, would this woman pass a DBS check? No - then she should not be with your son.
There are agencies out there whose job it is to help this woman, practically and emotionally

LivingMyBestLie · 02/10/2022 22:51

Do you live in the vicarage at a subsidised/free rate?

If so, then you absolutely should help. If not you, who? They allow you to live there at a discount because of your faith. Christianity is based on helping those less fortunate. Practice what you preach.

If you pay market value for your house, then I think there's less obligation, although yes, you should help, albeit with firm boundaries given a child also lives in the property.

I would probably stay with the child at night at least initially to make sure it's safe. Ideally I'd want a DBS check or equivalent on the woman to make sure there's no convictions you should be aware of.

Onyellow · 02/10/2022 22:49

@Cantthinkstraught Well either she doesn’t really need to be urgently housed, she could easily get to an appropriate shelter, but the church officials are all pushing for someone in the church to take her anyway, in which case they are doing empty virtue signalling (oh it’s our duty in to house her - but not me.)

Or she really does urgently need somewhere to stay or she’s at risk of imminent harm. In which case you take her. Meet her. Lay down the rules - she can’t be in contact with her abuser, she can’t let anyone know your address or it will put your child at risk. If she seems like an entirely untrustworthy person then your husband can find her a shelter and drive her there the next morning. But does she not at least deserve a chance?

Most women it will take many attempts to leave before they actually make it out for good. Maybe this is her “for good”. I can only imagine how she feels if she’s turned for the church for help and is met with ‘no’s.

hotdiggetydog · 02/10/2022 22:46

You are motally and contractually obligated to help.

startfresh · 02/10/2022 22:45

I think you're right. Unfortunately for the woman, your child and his safety must come first. This could invite a whole heap of trouble. Not that it's her fault, but it's not your risk to take.

Funny how people are happy to offer up someone else's home without a thought of the cons side of things.

Cantthinkstraught · 02/10/2022 22:38

@Onyellow What would you have me do then?. I hadn't made up my mind just needed to straighten my thoughts. As I said it's not my " job" to do this or even care at all but I do so I will. We are advised by the diocese not to take people we don't know in as we aren't qualified to help and people have been accused of all sorts. Would you be happy placing your child at risk? It's other people in the Parish that are pushing this responsibility on me. I do not get paid by the church, I have a totally separate job.
We are dealing with more complex issues these days than 20 years ago. Please do suggest what you would do in my position?

OP posts:
Onyellow · 02/10/2022 22:30

Is market rent for a four bedroom house really so very low? In my area that component alone would be more than the UK average salary.

You’ve clearly made your mind up so why even post the thread.

So you’ll let people in need stay in your spare bedrooms, but only if they’re already people you know from the parish, and - in your own words - no additional issues or risk.

Nothing about the modern Church of England is remotely Christian is it.

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 02/10/2022 22:22

Thanks, so not really free housing at all. Your home is your own, I would say no with zero guilt.

allboysherebutme · 02/10/2022 22:22

I would not do it with children in the house, what if he found out were she was living. No way. X

Cantthinkstraught · 02/10/2022 22:20

@errnerrcallnernnernnern it is very low and he works very long hour six days a week but feels really fulfilled with it. So although we get housing he gets very little for the hours.

OP posts:
ehb102 · 02/10/2022 22:12

No no no no no! Jesus said an awful lot about not being a doormat. Your child comes first.

Love thy neighbor as thyself also means treat yourself with as much support and respect as your neighbor.
Amazing how good Christian folk are so keen to get someone else to make the sacrifice.

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 02/10/2022 22:10

You'd think at least one of you, enjoying the benefits of the free housing, would practice what you preach.

Is it really free housing? Or is his stipend small to reflect the free housing?

billy1966 · 02/10/2022 22:02

Typical, shove it onto the nearest woman to sort out.

Stand your ground.

I wouldn't be putting my home or child at risk and I would push back hard at anyone who asked me to.

This is your husbands career, not yours.

Onyellow · 02/10/2022 22:01

It’s not “love thy neighbour as yourself unless it’s difficult and inconvenient.”

And charity isn’t really charity if it comes with zero self-sacrifice. But I’m sure you know that.

I don’t think pointing her towards resources from your gratis four-bedroom house is the kind of personal sacrifice Jesus had in mind.

Maybe point her towards the nearest Sikh gurdwara as they would help her.

SheilaSazs · 02/10/2022 21:57

Shouldn't this be dealt with by professionals in supporting those who have experienced domestic abuse? There's a reason they are trained. I think it's important we recognise when someone else is better suited to help.

rcat74 · 02/10/2022 21:50

Absolutely don’t do it. Seek legal advice if needs be. You can’t expose your family to the danger. It’s not fair on any of you. It’s not walking by on the other side. It’s being wise. There must be a better solution. Are there any alms houses nearby owned by the church? The C of E owns a lot of property.

SavingsThreads · 02/10/2022 21:44

Well, what would Jesus do?

Swipe left for the next trending thread