Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU help or not.

155 replies

Cantthinkstraught · 02/10/2022 17:31

We are in a diocese house (vicarage)with two adults, one child. The house has four bedrooms and we use two. We have been asked to house someone who is fleeing domestic violence. Its a woman.
There are other people who could do this nearby without kids but they have declined to.
We both work full time but the pressure is on as the higher ups in our parish feel its our duty. I want to help, husband wants to help but I don't feel I have it in me to live with someone who is a complete stranger for an unspecified period someone who will understandably be emotionally scarred and need support as well as everything else. We are told its our Christian duty and as we have free rooms we should but surely there are other ways to help. What would everyone else do...please don't shoot me down.

OP posts:
errnerrcallnernnernnern · 03/10/2022 10:10

Naunet · 03/10/2022 09:32

I think you’re missing the point. She’s not saying OP has to step in, she’s saying all this Christian preaching is a load of hypocritical bullshit.

Except she did say OP should step in:

Or she really does urgently need somewhere to stay or she’s at risk of imminent harm. In which case you take her. Meet her. Lay down the rules - she can’t be in contact with her abuser, she can’t let anyone know your address or it will put your child at risk.

CollyWibbleWobbles · 03/10/2022 10:08

Well said @Whakarongamai !

Whakarongamai · 03/10/2022 09:53

Clergy here, nope no way. This request crosses huge boundaries in far too many ways. It's ok to ask that someone helps to accommodate this lady, but it's equally ok for you and your family to say no to the request.

Those who are pressuring you are being unreasonable. It's your husband who is ordained not you, as the vicars wife you are entitled to your own life and opinions. Too many congregations see the vicars wife as an unpaid parish worker which is wrong in so many ways.

Help her out in other ways by all means with support groups who probably have far more experience supporting people in similar situations.

saraclara · 03/10/2022 09:45

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 08:56

@errnerrcallnernnernnern yes I have read the posts and stand by my belief - the OP isn’t just any random person, she lives the life of a vicar’s wife and for her DH certainly that comes with certain obligations. Not picking and choosing who you help.

OP had offered to help in many useful ways. She has the professional contacts to find this woman the help she needs from various specialist organisations and to help her with all the form filling etc.

What she is, rightly, reluctant to do, is take her in for an undefined period, when it had been made clear that it is unsafe to do so.

There is more than one kind of help that any of us can give, and OP is already being generous with her time and experience. But she has a vulnerable child in the house.

Naunet · 03/10/2022 09:42

snumsmet · 03/10/2022 09:38

@Naunet
I'm not missing the point. The OP isn't a preacher. Her husband is, but isn't responsible for the hypocrisies of the whole church. They sound like a thoroughly Christlike couple to me, from my comfy secular vantage point.

Hence why she mentioned the 5 vicars.
You're right though, it’s thoroughly Christlike, which is why I can’t stand religion.

saraclara · 03/10/2022 09:39

Mamansparkles · 03/10/2022 09:19

For any new to the thread who might be distracted by a PPs constant sniping, to summarise the OP:

  • is married to a vicar. She is not employed by the church but works in a caring profession so they think she should so this.
  • does not get a 'free' house. Her DHs stipend is tiny because they get accommodation.
  • is happy to take people in and help and has done before (parish, Ukrainian refugees)
  • has an adopted son from a background of violence
  • does lots extra in the parish that she doesn't need to eg shopping, supporting vulnerable with form filling. On top of her actual job.
  • has offered to help this lady in multiple practical ways that would actually be useful.

She sounds like a bloody saint! And absolutely should not be putting her son in a position where a violent drug dealer turns up at their house looking for his wife, who has a history of revealing her location, and whose own family have refused to take her in because it is too dangerous.

Perfectly and clearly put.

The sanctimoniousness on this thread is beyond belief.

snumsmet · 03/10/2022 09:38

@Naunet
I'm not missing the point. The OP isn't a preacher. Her husband is, but isn't responsible for the hypocrisies of the whole church. They sound like a thoroughly Christlike couple to me, from my comfy secular vantage point.

MichelleScarn · 03/10/2022 09:33

So op agrees to let this woman move in then next week the parish says, now this other person needs help, move them in too? And op then has a never ending stream of people in her home?

Naunet · 03/10/2022 09:32

snumsmet · 03/10/2022 07:46

#Onyellow have you missed that the OP's child is adopted from a background of violence and has only just regained childhood 'innocence' - which may be fragile because of its history?

Your hectoring tone to a woman who works professionally to support vulnerable people and to subsidise her husband's doing similar, who volunteers in the community and who needs to protect her child even more than most mothers do - is really unpleasant.

I think you’re missing the point. She’s not saying OP has to step in, she’s saying all this Christian preaching is a load of hypocritical bullshit.

Onyellow · 03/10/2022 09:32

@Cantthinkstraught I don’t think you are at fault (it is your husband’s job, not yours anyway), but I think it’s a sad reflection of the modern Church of England and a sign of how far they’ve strayed from Christian values. Five men of the church passing the buck because no one wants to help this woman. Against diocese policy to help.

Anyone who actually wanted to follow Jesus’ teachings would be far better able to do it from outside the church. This woman has made a sorry mistake turning to the church for help.

Naunet · 03/10/2022 09:28

Azandme · 02/10/2022 18:20

FIVE vicars, all in rent free housing provided by the church, have all said no to helping a person in need?

Well that confirms my thoughts on organised religion.

"Would you walk by on the other side, when someone called for aid?"

Yep, we would. All of us.

You'd think at least one of you, enjoying the benefits of the free housing, would practice what you preach.

So many people welcoming in refugees - and not one vicar in FIVE will help an abused woman?

Says it all.

Agree completely.

YumYummy · 03/10/2022 09:23

If you can’t find her anywhere else to go then I think she should move in with you,. Could you negotiate a time scale for how long she stays?

Mamansparkles · 03/10/2022 09:19

For any new to the thread who might be distracted by a PPs constant sniping, to summarise the OP:

  • is married to a vicar. She is not employed by the church but works in a caring profession so they think she should so this.
  • does not get a 'free' house. Her DHs stipend is tiny because they get accommodation.
  • is happy to take people in and help and has done before (parish, Ukrainian refugees)
  • has an adopted son from a background of violence
  • does lots extra in the parish that she doesn't need to eg shopping, supporting vulnerable with form filling. On top of her actual job.
  • has offered to help this lady in multiple practical ways that would actually be useful.

She sounds like a bloody saint! And absolutely should not be putting her son in a position where a violent drug dealer turns up at their house looking for his wife, who has a history of revealing her location, and whose own family have refused to take her in because it is too dangerous.

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 03/10/2022 09:05

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 09:00

There’s always a risk when you take on this helpful lifestyle but there’s no guarantee there will definitely be harm - they aren’t housing a violent person they’re housing a victim FFS.

My colleague is married to our local vicar and they have done similar and even had men coming out of prison stay with them and their children and have risk assessed to ensure the risk is minimised - they’ve never had a bad experience yet. OP could do this with support from local authority and diocese

OP’s child was subject to violence before s/he came to her and she has had to work hard to help them regain their innocence. Telling her ‘there’s no guarantee there will definitely be harm’ is just not bloody good enough.

You would never want this for your child so stop with the virtue signalling.

Cantthinkstraught · 03/10/2022 09:04

I have offered our space to any of he vicarsvthat care to use it but no takers!

OP posts:
Mamansparkles · 03/10/2022 09:01

This is a terrible idea. OP get straight onto the diocesan safeguarding officer this morning and get them to intervene. This must be being suggested by completely naive people with no understanding of domestic violence. This will not help her longterm and it will put your family in danger, including an already vulnerable from abuse child. No, no and no.
It isn't about 'not following Christian moral duty', they aren't turning her away with no help. It's about giving appropriate and safe help that actually, you know, helps, rather than just puts more people (including a child from an abusive background) in danger. Also they have latched onto OP as being the appropriate person to help due to her profession (although she will be out at her profession..). OP does not work for the church.
If her husband is a local drug runner and she has a history of going back to him, best thing would be to get her into a women's aid hostel - your local women's aid will get her into a hostel far enough away to be safe from him.
If she stays with you for more than a night or two, she will be 'out' the system and it will be harder to access the benefits and support she needs to escape permanently.
I would, however, say to the diocesan safeguarding officer that although due to your son you can't risk having her with you, and she needs to get into a refuge so it isnt in her interests to stay more than a night or two, you are more than happy for one of the single vicars to come stay with you so she can have their house (although they are much better positioned to have her stay with them anyway!). And obviously help her access women's aid, council support etc but it sounds like you will do all that.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 09:00

There’s always a risk when you take on this helpful lifestyle but there’s no guarantee there will definitely be harm - they aren’t housing a violent person they’re housing a victim FFS.

My colleague is married to our local vicar and they have done similar and even had men coming out of prison stay with them and their children and have risk assessed to ensure the risk is minimised - they’ve never had a bad experience yet. OP could do this with support from local authority and diocese

snumsmet · 03/10/2022 09:00

I am staggered by the sanctimony here.

The op lives in a big house for cheap so we get to offload all our societal responsibility to fund shelter for vulnerable women onto her. Super.

(The house isn't even cheap: they pay with long hours of caring work, but let's enjoy letting our jealousies rampage, what fun!)

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 03/10/2022 08:59

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 08:56

@errnerrcallnernnernnern yes I have read the posts and stand by my belief - the OP isn’t just any random person, she lives the life of a vicar’s wife and for her DH certainly that comes with certain obligations. Not picking and choosing who you help.

You keep saying OP has been given free housing and has a house that is supposed to help but this is wrong.

She has explained her DH works very long hours for very little pay and that he does the job because it is fulfilling.

When you take that into account, you should seen that the housing isn’t really free at all, it’s just factored into his small stipend.

LicoricePizza · 03/10/2022 08:58

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 08:56

@errnerrcallnernnernnern yes I have read the posts and stand by my belief - the OP isn’t just any random person, she lives the life of a vicar’s wife and for her DH certainly that comes with certain obligations. Not picking and choosing who you help.

Even if it means putting herself & child in harm’s way? How exactly is that helping?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 08:56

@errnerrcallnernnernnern yes I have read the posts and stand by my belief - the OP isn’t just any random person, she lives the life of a vicar’s wife and for her DH certainly that comes with certain obligations. Not picking and choosing who you help.

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 03/10/2022 08:54

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 08:53

@saraclara a vicar’s wife marries into the lifestyle of helping those in need. women fleeing violence are exceptionally vulnerable, it’s massively hypocritical to be in a home that is supposed to help but pick and choose who you do help

Except she’s not supposed to house people.

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 03/10/2022 08:53

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 08:02

TBH I agree it’s your Christian duty - you’re happy to reap benefits of free housing etc from the diocese but not happy to give back when they ask you to help someone in need?

Have you bothered to read OP’s post at all before your Monday morning sermonizing?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 08:53

@saraclara a vicar’s wife marries into the lifestyle of helping those in need. women fleeing violence are exceptionally vulnerable, it’s massively hypocritical to be in a home that is supposed to help but pick and choose who you do help

Cantthinkstraught · 03/10/2022 08:52

@Onyellow and @OriginalUsername3 and @LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet

It is our duty to help but there are ways in which his can be done by a professional organisation, like the ones I work with. As I said I am more than happy to help with her finding a safe place but I really don't think the safest option for any of us is to have her live here for a non defined period. Just to confirm that she has been prevented from working by her abuser so has no money currently. I've offered to help fill out the forms etc.
I am sure social workers would be knocking on my door if anything happened to my son due to this. I found out that she has an adult daughter who lives locally who has refused to have her because of the risk that he brings to her young family.
As is often the pattern she has been back too him several times and revealing her location to him how do I know that this time would be different.
My husband, he has suggested he will drive her to wherever she needs to go etc but I feel I can do that as I wouldn't want her to feel any more frightened than she is.
I want to help but she is mistustful of men how could that be a livable situation for any of us?
At what point do you draw a line, we would never be able to go anywhere or have any life if we had a constant train of people in volatile situations living with us. I so this all day in my secular job do I have to live like this with absolutely no separation between home and work?
It's different taking people from a war zone (which we did) from Ukraine where there are no services, to taking someone who is locally connected with all the wrong people.
Please read previous posts my son is adopted from this background so I know how it works and I am employed by a regular employer no the diocese.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread