Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help me decide what to do - moving house

36 replies

SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 17:25

We have sold our place and are renting while waiting for our purchase to complete. This means we have 200k in the bank ready for our move.

In May 2021 we offered on a house and it was accepted at 400k. Barclays bank then sat on our mortgage application for a number of months despite much chasing, and eventually the purchase collapsed at Christmas.

We waited for the market to get going again in the spring and in May 2022 we found a house at 465k. Now with a national building society, we are in groundhog day. It has been with the underwriters for so long the vendors have given us a two week deadline to get an offer. (We did have a DIP)

We are seriously losing hope and losing this sale would realistically mean waiting until the spring again as the market and particularly rhe mortgage market have changed.

Today we had a mad thought and looked at some auction properties. There's one that needs to be renovated, roof is sound, but it's still in the 1970s inside. Opening bid is 200k. We are wondering if we could do it up as a project to reduce the amount of mortgage we need.

What would you do? We have no idea if this mortgage will come through, and no idea of we would even win the bids.

We do have some experience of fixing up.
Yanbu- auction
Yabu - wait for spring and carry on original plan

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SecretWorrier · 06/10/2022 10:28

So to update, our mortgage finally came through, thank you so much for your advice and opinions everyone, good food for thought for the future.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 02/10/2022 22:10

SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 17:37

We wouldn't need a mortgage with the auction one.

? You said you have 200K cash, and the auction starting price is 200K.

In auctions, the price goes UP with each bid (not down).

MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 21:41

I think what I'm wondering is, if a property is 200, but with a potential renovated value of 300, would it go for 300? Surely there'd be space for a profit for the person doing the works, there has to be, doesn't there? Anyone been in this situation?

No it wouldn’t sell for 300 as that would leave no profit as you say. That’s why it’s really important to know your market and have a sound understanding of realistic renovation costs.

If it seems there is ‘too much profit’ to be made at auction then it’s possible that there are issues (structural, legal for example) that means it’s priced lower than you would expect.

SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 21:33

Sorry, was dealing with vomit.

Yes, L&C.

I think what I'm wondering is, if a property is 200, but with a potential renovated value of 300, would it go for 300? Surely there'd be space for a profit for the person doing the works, there has to be, doesn't there? Anyone been in this situation?

OP posts:
Summersdreaming · 02/10/2022 20:08

Do you already have a broker? I would recommend getting a good one and have them hunt for a mortgage for you. Ours managed to get us one in less than 7 days earlier this year. Good luck.

MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 20:04

Ok, so cash closer to 300K is probably very doable on a 200k starting price. What do other actions tend to go for price wise in your area? Do they go much over the starting bid? How’s this house priced compared to market value if fully renovated? If there is a 100K profit to be made, it’s either priced low and will go massively over 200K at action or there is an issue with it - structural/legal for example.

Have you checked how much auction fee is?

Is the 30K realistic price wise for renovation for what you want? Have you actually gone to price things like kitchen/bathroom? Got quotes from tradespeople? Not saying it isn’t, just so many people underestimate renovation cost without even running into anything unexpected.

MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 19:58

That's an idea ! I'll have a look on rightmove though I did think the pressure of cash only might reduce the market for the auction.

The majority of auctions are cash only. You can get some amazing deals. Although it will be mainly experienced property developers who are bidding.
It sounds though with your budget you’d need to be looking at auctions starting around 100K though.

If you want to go for auction, get yourself a really, really good solicitor and make sure you are completely clued up about the process. You need to be absolutely on the ball.
Also, unless you are very experienced in looking at houses that need renovating, take someone with you who 100% knows what they are looking for.

Fully understand your market before bidding, research sale and purchase prices, what sells quickly in that area, what types of properties don’t sell as fast, what percentage a driveway/big garden adds for example.

Make sure you know renovation costs and what could potentially go wrong/incur further costs with that particular renovation.

Make sure you have people who can actually do the work in the time frame you need. There is no point knowing electrical work will cost 3K for example but you can’t find an electrician who can start the work for you, then that puts all your other work out.

RedHelenB · 02/10/2022 19:57

SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 17:37

We wouldn't need a mortgage with the auction one.

If you watch homes under the hammer, just make sure you read the legal pack. I'd go to the auction, have a top limit and stick to it.

SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 19:47

The full figures are, cash 289, house we were buying, 465, mortgage 200 exactly. So it was a pretty low LTV.
No idea what the auction property would finish at but I'd say we'd need 30 for renovations, it's not structural, and 5-8 for fees and legals, and 10 for a buffer (autocorrect trying to give me a 10k buffet there) so perhaps we could bid as high as 240.

I don't know what to do. Struggling to face yet another Christmas in our tiny flat. We are overcrowded.

OP posts:
SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 19:44

MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 19:42

You could always buy cash, it doesn’t necessarily have to be auction. Cash puts you in a really good position for making offers and you can still buy one to do up.

That's an idea ! I'll have a look on rightmove though I did think the pressure of cash only might reduce the market for the auction.

OP posts:
MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 19:42

You could always buy cash, it doesn’t necessarily have to be auction. Cash puts you in a really good position for making offers and you can still buy one to do up.

MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 19:40

SE - you can still get a mortgage, it’s just often harder. You may need to reduce the amount you want to borrow or look for a smaller bank that lends on circumstances rather than ‘computer says no’.
Has your lender actually declined you?

MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 19:38

In terms of going for the auction, how are you funding renovation, paying fees if your capital is not much over the auction starting bid?

DoingJustFine · 02/10/2022 19:29

Worst case - you just wait 2-3 years and it will no longer be an issue. Some mortgage companies only need 2 years of accounts, the others need 3.

Have you used a broker? Mine was fantastic.

DoingJustFine · 02/10/2022 19:27

Yep. We did. No idea at the time that it would be a problem.

Same! I even paid mine back when I found out it would affect future mortgage applications, but it's still on my file. I need to see if HMRC will remove it from my records.

Have the mortgage companies mentioned it being a problem?

SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 19:14

DoingJustFine · 02/10/2022 19:11

I'm self employed and used a mortgage broker to do my mortgage. (They're free as the mortgage companies pay them.)

I needed 3 years of SA302 (if I remember right) forms from HMRC. Do you have those? And loads of bank statements.

I know the 4th SEISS grant has stopped lots of people getting a mortgage. Did you get that?

Yep. We did. No idea at the time that it would be a problem.

OP posts:
FruitPastilleNut · 02/10/2022 19:12

If the auction property goes for the opening price - or anywhere close to it - there's something very wrong with it. Opening prices are usually set very low ime and it's not unusual for a house to go for 50% more.

DoingJustFine · 02/10/2022 19:11

I'm self employed and used a mortgage broker to do my mortgage. (They're free as the mortgage companies pay them.)

I needed 3 years of SA302 (if I remember right) forms from HMRC. Do you have those? And loads of bank statements.

I know the 4th SEISS grant has stopped lots of people getting a mortgage. Did you get that?

SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 19:00

Thank you for replies. It seems the voters think I should go to auction but the commenters do not.

What would you do in terms of not be able to get a mortgage? I asked a friend who is also self employed how she'd gotten a mortgage - it was a rhetorical question really - and she said she had worked her butt off to get a deposit. Well we have a 50% deposit and we are still struggling. No personal debt, impeccable credit scores and over 5 years books.

OP posts:
DoingJustFine · 02/10/2022 18:43

I love the idea, and your resilience! But it'll never sell for just £200k if it has potential.

Have you read the information pack? You'd want a survey done before you bought it, which will be £££, and possibly wasted if you get outbid.

What money are you expecting to use for the renovation? Are you thinking you'd mortgage the house after you bought it?

CollyWibbleWobbles · 02/10/2022 18:30

I agree with @MilkToastHoney , be very careful

MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 18:21

Thank you. I expect we would go with a solicitor recommended by the auctioneer. The one we used for our sale was dreadful.

Yes, some can be awful.
I don’t want to sound negative but I’d be incredibly wary of using a solicitor for auction you’ve no personal experience of.
Estate agents, auction houses very often recommend solicitors who are rubbish!
You are risking thousands if solicitor turns out to be like your other one.

Realistically, you also need to be very familiar with the conveyancing process.
It can take a lot of work and chasing on your part to push through for the auction time frame. 4 weeks isn’t long at all and you have to be completely on the ball to chase solicitor, estate agents, auction house, make sure you get the correct paperwork completed and back in time, no errors on your part that can delay things (then solicitor blames you), proof of funds all spot on.

SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 18:01

MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 17:57

Well we are self employed, which I don't think they like very much. It's the only explanation I have.
**
We have the cash in the bank for the auction property. It's a bit over 200 that we have. We would be able to complete on it, without a mortgage, in time.

Yes, they hate self employed-it can be a nightmare!

If auction is starting at 200K though, it’s likely to go a fair bit over. Plus the action fees, solicitors fees, renovation costs. I’d say you’d need over 300K cash for an auction with a starting bid of 200K. That’s assuming it doesn’t go massively over the starting bid.

Have you got experience with your solicitor? The difference between individual solicitors can be huge and I’d only trust one I’d used several times to guarantee completion for an auction.

Thank you. I expect we would go with a solicitor recommended by the auctioneer. The one we used for our sale was dreadful.

OP posts:
SecretWorrier · 02/10/2022 17:59

Aprilx · 02/10/2022 17:53

But you don’t know the price of the auction one.

I would stick with the one you have, the vendors will soon realise the market is turning and growing less favourable for them.

Thank you, however we don't have one. We've been trying to move for a number of years and it's looking like we cannot get a mortgage to be able to get a house that doesn't need work.

OP posts:
MilkToastHoney · 02/10/2022 17:57

Well we are self employed, which I don't think they like very much. It's the only explanation I have.
**
We have the cash in the bank for the auction property. It's a bit over 200 that we have. We would be able to complete on it, without a mortgage, in time.

Yes, they hate self employed-it can be a nightmare!

If auction is starting at 200K though, it’s likely to go a fair bit over. Plus the action fees, solicitors fees, renovation costs. I’d say you’d need over 300K cash for an auction with a starting bid of 200K. That’s assuming it doesn’t go massively over the starting bid.

Have you got experience with your solicitor? The difference between individual solicitors can be huge and I’d only trust one I’d used several times to guarantee completion for an auction.