Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to 'Think the unthinkable' TW child death and organ transplant

34 replies

SunsetandCupcakes · 02/10/2022 16:33

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-63080520

Please read this, I had already had the conversation when my son unexpectedly ended up in ITU which made the decision much easier.
If my loss could save another child and another parent then I knew it was something I wanted to do.

Despite this I didn't know that this was a decision that brave parents made after the death of their child in labour or as neonates, I appreciate this whole topic doesn't bear thinking about but if we can, I think we should.

Comfort can be gained in the darkest of spaces, for me my pain was going to be with me forever, I drew comfort from the thought another family could avoid it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ihatethenewlook · 03/10/2022 09:17

broodyat39 · 02/10/2022 17:10

Aren't we all automatically on the donor list now and we have to opt out instead of opting in?

Yes. I was on the register to donate everything except my corneas until they brought this new law in. I disagreed with it so strongly that I deregistered myself for everything.

KitchiHuritAngeni · 03/10/2022 09:11

Thank you Emerald and May in the past I've been made to feel bad because I was focused on my loss rather than someone else's gain, and I've never been able to flip that feeling around and be grateful someone else's baby was alive because mine died.

May I completely understand what you're saying. Everything we see about donation makes it seem like a great thing, that donors families should be proud, and that recipients need to be delighted.

I truly hope that you never get to the point where you're in the position of needing one, I cant imagine what that would be like Flowers

MayThe4th · 03/10/2022 05:51

KitchiHuritAngeni · I am so sorry for your losses.

I do think that all too often the grief is brushed aside when talking about the wonderful thing someone has done and how many lives have been saved etc. Please don’t ever feel that you owe it to anyone to feel any kind of sense of anything but your own grief.

I need a heart transplant and that is one thing I have struggled with immensely. I am not quite on the list yet but whenever I think of having to have a transplant the idea of waiting for a call to tell me that a heart has become available has a very mixed view. Because while I will hope that it is the right heart for me, the idea that I will be waiting for the right person to die just doesn’t sit right. I’ve seen the organ donation couriers leave the hospital I’m under and my first thought is always that someone in there has suffered a tremendous loss.

I believe in organ donation and I bang the drum regularly on my own social media. But I will never feel able to be one of those people who stands up and campaigns for others to donate their organs so that I can be given a chance at life.

In fact in my heart of hearts (excuse the pun), I am hoping that I will always remain healthy enough that that ends up being a bridge I don’t have to cross.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 03/10/2022 00:21

@KitchiHuritAngeni I'm so sorry about your Daughter and your Son.
I imagine nothing could make you feel better when the worst possible thing has happened and nothing can change the outcome. 🌹

KitchiHuritAngeni · 02/10/2022 23:12

I have had two of my children die.

I was able to donate my sons organs, I wasn't able to donate my daughters due to how she died.

My experience of donating was quite a few years ago now, but I don't think I have the usual sense of pride in myself because I made that choice. I just feel a bit empty tbh.

I didn't feel this sense of greater good after I decided to donate his organs.

In fact, as awful as it sounds, I would have 100% chose my sons life over the 7 people who benefitted from his organs.

I got a letter from the hospital giving basic details of who received his organs (age, sex and which organ) and I honestly felt nothing. It was almost like a sense of duty, I could do that and other people won't have to go through this shit if I decide to do this, so I will, but it wouldn't make my son less dead.

At his funeral I wasn't proud that people were out there living better lives due to his death, I was just sad.

Some years later when my daughter died, I didn't feel any different about her death than I did my sons, if that makes sense. People who know often talk about my sons death as more 'worthy' but I just don't feel it. All I can feel is my loss.

When I see videos of all these touching moments of brides at weddings listening to her fathers heart in another man's chest, or a child running up to a bereaved mother after they were donated her child's lungs it strikes fear into my heart because I NEVER want that to happen. I sort of feel a bit resentful actually that other kids are alive and my baby boy isn't (again, I know that makes me sound like a cunt).

The process itself wasn't as traumatic for me as I thought it would be. The nurses and team listened to me, and they fulfilled all my requests. Often people say that it was horrific not being there for their loved ones last breath, but I had known for a little while that he had taken his last breath already, any more were made by machines. As stoic as I was after knowing that the little body laid there was no longer my baby, I did ask for someone to hold his little hand all the way through, the lovely nurse who did said she sang to him too, the songs that I sang to him at his bedside (she learned them especially).

I received a little backlash afterward, in my culture its not usual to donate organs so some words were had but it was fine eventually, and I also had some religious extremists harass me about it because I decided to donate his organs and cremate him (which is usual in my culture) they told me he was going to be tortured in eternal limbo because of me, which was lovely to hear when you're a teenager and have just had your baby die.

Overall I'm not proud or happy about it. I feel a bit of a fraud if I feel any sense of pride or happiness about it because I would take it back in a second if I could have just one more cuddle with my son.

If the very worst happened I would definitely do it again though.

I guess I'm just trying to say that it's normal to feel nothing really, or have conflicting feelings. It doesn't always come with a huge sense of pride.

That said, when other parents do that and it takes even a tiny bit of their pain away I'm so happy they get that relief, even for a second. This path is dark, so any bit if light shining on it for anyone is special.

EdithGrantham · 02/10/2022 21:50

FarmerRefuted · 02/10/2022 20:32

There is a good FAQ here that includes information on what happens after, its written in a factual but sensitive way. Your loved one is returned to you afterwards, any wounds will have been closed and dressed and cosmetic damage repaired. The transplant coordinator will be able to arrange for you to have time with them, in the case of a young child or infant this can include use of a cold cot/cold bed to enable the family to have more time.

www.aftermathsupport.org.uk/get-support/organ-donation/

Thank you, that is exactly the kind of info I was wondering about.

pointythings · 02/10/2022 21:32

We started talking to our DDs about organ donation when they were still young (under 10), showed them our donor cards and obtained their verbal consent to donate their organs if the worst should ever happen. They got their own donor cards and signed up for the bone marrow register as soon as they were old enough to do so. It's a difficult subject, but so important.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 02/10/2022 21:16

Thank you OP. 💓

EmeraldShamrock1 · 02/10/2022 21:15

It's the worst possible situation.

My deepest condolences to pp's who've had to suffer their DC dying.

I'd like to believe that it would be one of the easier decisions to say yes in the face of a horrendous situation, if it was possible.

DorritLittle · 02/10/2022 21:14

My best friend had an extra 20 years thanks to a transplant. Thank you OP. 💐

MayThe4th · 02/10/2022 21:10

For anyone who feels their family may override their decision, I would recommend you take out an advance directive in order to ensure your wishes are carried out.

On some level I agree that relatives should not be allowed to override the decision of the deceased, but it’s difficult, because a family is faced with the generally sudden death of a loved one, and then to be told that they will be taken and their organs donated in line with their wishes which the family may not have been aware of, is far more likely to increase any trauma.

That is why the family have to make the final decision. Because it is the family who have to live with it, and the family who have to say goodbye without the ability to be there while the life support is withdrawn.

PurpleSproutingSomething · 02/10/2022 21:04

My ex husband and son's father has had 6 extra years so far due to him receiving an organ transplant.

It's been the best gift any of us could ever have asked for.

Flowers OP

Toddlerteaplease · 02/10/2022 20:47

I also think that if you have given consent by being on the register. Relatives should not be able to override that decision.

Toddlerteaplease · 02/10/2022 20:46

I always thought that one of the most tragic things about a recent high profile death. Was that his organs could possibly have been donated. His parents may have found comfort from that in the future. I know several people who had to make that decision and they all find comfort from it.

FarmerRefuted · 02/10/2022 20:32

There is a good FAQ here that includes information on what happens after, its written in a factual but sensitive way. Your loved one is returned to you afterwards, any wounds will have been closed and dressed and cosmetic damage repaired. The transplant coordinator will be able to arrange for you to have time with them, in the case of a young child or infant this can include use of a cold cot/cold bed to enable the family to have more time.

www.aftermathsupport.org.uk/get-support/organ-donation/

HayleyBay · 02/10/2022 20:29

When my son died we weren't able to donate his organs (SUDI so there had to be a post mortem and police investigation).

I wish our tragedy could have helped another family, I think it would have given us some comfort.

AuntSalli · 02/10/2022 20:22

I can’t imagine burying or burning organs that might be of used to any other human being on this planet. It ought not to be allowed.

OrlandointheWilderness · 02/10/2022 20:21

Absolutely no hesitation here. If any bit of me can help someone else then they can have what they want - certain bits are buggered but you are welcome anyway! 😂 I'm very pragmatic about death - the alternative is perfectly usable bits that could save or change someone's life will rot in the ground or be turned to ash. Same goes for my DD. To be able to do that for someone else is a wonderful thing.

EdithGrantham · 02/10/2022 20:07

I absolutely agree with all the points made as to why you would donate, I guess I am imagining a scenario where if DD were to die in my arms, I don't know in all honesty if I could physically hand her over immediately which I suppose is what would be required?

Hbh17 · 02/10/2022 17:51

If a death is somehow troubling or traumatic, then surely it would at least be a consolation to know that another person has benefited from a transplant? There is no good reason to refuse. As an adult, if I thought anybody close to me might refuse to donate my organs after my death I would be very, very angry - it is not their decision to make, given that I have already said it's what I want.

endofthelinefinally · 02/10/2022 17:44

My DC all signed up for bone marrow donation as soon as they were old enough to do it. They are mixed race and they responded to an appeal related to a particular need.
My late son was on the organ donor register (as are we all) and even if he had not been, I would have consented to whatever the doctors thought would be appropriate. He was a kind and generous young man and I know he would have approved. Unfortunately it was not possible, due to the circumstances of his death.
IMO we should address this question when all is well and we have time to have sensible conversations about it.
I have a family member who is a recipient and every day I am thankful that in the midst of their tragedy, a family gave their consent to save another life.

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 02/10/2022 17:42

Thank you for your gift of life, OP.

My dsis was an organ recipient. That gift of life gave her 9 extra, precious years. In that time she got her dream job, won a place in the GB Paralympic squad, and got to know my 3 eldest dc. I will be forever grateful to the donor family.

Soubriquet · 02/10/2022 17:35

I’m on the list but if I go before dh does, I know he won’t honour that.

He has already told me. He can’t bear the thought of someone else having my heart or other organs.

We had a big argument about it but he still refused.

It would be the same with the kids I think. I would agree and he wouldn’t.

I tried the whole “if you would accept one, you should donate too” but no.

ElizabethBest · 02/10/2022 17:21

I had it on my birth plan that DS’s organs could be used in the event something went wrong in labour.

I would still allow it now he’s older, absolutely. But he has heart defects so may not be a viable donor.

I love him with every fibre of my being. If a little part of him could live on, and spare another family grief, then I want that for him.

MayThe4th · 02/10/2022 17:17

EdithGrantham · 02/10/2022 17:12

I saw this article this morning and will be discussing with DH at some point. I'm on the donor register myself and would like to think I could allow my DDs organs to be used if, god forbid, that situation ever arose.

But then I started thinking about it more and the thought of having her taken from my arms, which presumably would have to be very soon after she died, nearly made me weep. Then it occured to me if I got to hold her again after would she be noticeably lighter? I know that's a very selfish reason not to do it but it's the question that popped into my head.

If your daughter needed an organ, would you accept one?

We are far more likely to need a transplant than to be in a position to donate our organs. But receiving that transplant is reliant on someone else deciding to donate a loved one’s organs.

It’s a personal decision of course, but the fact is anyone could be told they need a transplant at a moment’s notice. And in order for that transplant to happen we have to rely on the selflessness of someone who is facing bereavement.