Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

*trigger warning* Should we let pedophiles go?

112 replies

killthemall · 02/10/2022 16:08

I'm just thinking outloud here but I'd be interested in opinions.

I was groomed and taken advantage of by an older relative when I was a teenager. Didn't learn my lesson and was groomed again by his brother! (I wised up at the similarities though and nothing happened a second time)

Anyway the point is as I know them personally (and they are both still very much involved in the family, I was blamed as the evil temptress obviously) so I know all of their dirty little secrets. And theg have both gotten themselves into positions of power, given themselves access to vulnerable people. I don't know I'd anything has gone on but u wouldn't be surprised. What I do know is that they both preyed on vulnerable women for partners and abuse them now. I don't know the full extent but I know enough to know they haven't changed and are a source on society.
My children aren't allowed near them.

Now I was talking in a group about paedophiles, as you do when there is yet another case in the news or on the television, or on netflix.
Anyway, we were chatting and we got along the lines of whether it is an illness or not.
I don't believe so. Thinking the thoughts may be unpleasant but acting on them is another thing entirely.
Then it was said that if they aren't attracted to women then perhaps they wouldn't reproduced and if there was a peado gene maybe it would have died out.
And then we were saying that in the old days if you found out uncle Jim hurt your child like that then you would kill him and that be that. Because let's face it, you would if there was no law against it.

But what I've seen time and time again is creating, sharing and possessing indecent images of children isn't given a 15 year sentence. It's given a tap on the wrist 2 years 18 months with good behaviour.

I was watching a program about the police and there was a paedo and he had disgusting videos and images on his laptop, admitted to it, and was let out on bail on the same day waiting for his devices to be checked by whoever does that, Despite them already finding them!

Now I think if I was like that and I knew I'd get a couple years for possessing and sharing images like that then that's a minor deterent.

Or the ones who actually go through with it and hurt children. Oh god. I think they should be locked away indefinitely. I really don't feel safe knowing anyone could be one, but even ones who are caught are let go, ready to do it again. Loads of them do.

this was sparked by the should be bring back state murder thread and my first thought was 'not for murderers'' but then someone posted about paedophiles and I thought "oh yeah they can die" without a second thought.
I really think harsher sentences and they should be locked up. I mean that man who got caught and let out has surely just been shown that he can do it and he gets 24 hours in custody and then he's free basically (I know its on bail but they said he could be waiting 12-24 months to have his devices checked. imagine what he could do after being arrested and the videos were found and he confessed and then let go? Je is going to be exhilarated and possibly fearful of what's coming in a few years. he might go out and do what he can! he's just go away with it basically.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 02/10/2022 16:29

Paedophilia is a sexual orientation (imo) and thus cannot be rehabilitated. Therefore anyone who holds images or carries out actions that would labelled paedophilia in a court of law should be removed from society and locked up for life.

Notanotherwindow · 02/10/2022 16:29

I keep thinking this about Jon Venables. Why for the love of God do we keep releasing him with 6000 new identities when he keeps reoffending and outing himself. Either lock him up permanently or let him live under his own name and risk someone killing him. God knows he deserves it. He isn't going to stop reoffending, he's said as much himself. He doesn't see anything wrong with what he's done.

Thurst · 02/10/2022 16:27

We should have very harsh sentences for people who access images of children being abused and contact offenders should never be let out. I don’t even care about punishing them. Just send them to a little farm somewhere they can have job and some recreational activities. They can interact with each other and crack on with their lives but kept completely away from the rest of the world. They don’t change and the risk is too high.

Ouchh · 02/10/2022 16:27

They should exile sex offenders who can't be rehabilitated. They can form their own self sustaining colony on an island somewhere whilst the rest of us stay safe

Isaidnoalready · 02/10/2022 16:22

Paedophiles are practically a protected characteristic these days but even back fifteen years ago they didn't sentence them

Friends husband used his daughter as bait to get to her friends charged and given a two year suspended sentence with restrictions broke his restrictions another two years SUSPENDED broke them again same deal he was also granted access to his daughter the first time second time children services said file in court and he didn't show up

Paedophiles with a specific interest in pre school and primary school children housed in flats to left of the flats is a park to the right a primary school

Paedophile with an interest in teenagers housed by the shops next to a church where teenagers hang out because they run clubs for them

It's like they are giving them access on a plate

killthemall · 02/10/2022 16:18

I couldn't even type child in front of that word. evil basterds deserve nothing. We are supposed to hate them.

OP posts:
killthemall · 02/10/2022 16:17

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen get off, is that true because I'll have to start supporting the vigilantte groups if the police end up being rape supporters.

OP posts:
killthemall · 02/10/2022 16:15

To he fair I'd rather have burglars and drug dealers on the streets if that meant there were more prison space for peadphiles

and I completely agree that I don't care if it is an illness or not. I suppose there must be people who feel that way and hate it and don't act on it.

I wonder if the Internet, giving access to... ways to see it... helps people move along. So they have access and then they feel more emboldened to act, they can talk to others like them and feel more accepted?
it's a very big downside to the Internet.

OP posts:
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/10/2022 16:14

I hope you don’t live in Wiltshire , OP. Because the local police will visit you and give you a good talking to if you are ‘Untoward about pedophiles’. And try to get registered for a hate crime….

Keyansier · 02/10/2022 16:12

^^ That was general sentencing, btw, not just for paedophilia.

Keyansier · 02/10/2022 16:11

I have no interest in whether it's a legitimate illness or not. It's illegal, it's disgusting, and yes, it carries a far too light sentence than it deserves.

I'm not calling for an illogical USA-style 280 years sentence, but the sentencing laws in this country need a complete and harsher overhaul.

killthemall · 02/10/2022 16:10

So in short,
should we ever let them go even if it is on bail.

Yabu they should be let go after arrested and evidence

Yanbu they should be sent somewhere to keep the public safe after arrested and evidence

OP posts: