Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

*trigger warning* Should we let pedophiles go?

112 replies

killthemall · 02/10/2022 16:08

I'm just thinking outloud here but I'd be interested in opinions.

I was groomed and taken advantage of by an older relative when I was a teenager. Didn't learn my lesson and was groomed again by his brother! (I wised up at the similarities though and nothing happened a second time)

Anyway the point is as I know them personally (and they are both still very much involved in the family, I was blamed as the evil temptress obviously) so I know all of their dirty little secrets. And theg have both gotten themselves into positions of power, given themselves access to vulnerable people. I don't know I'd anything has gone on but u wouldn't be surprised. What I do know is that they both preyed on vulnerable women for partners and abuse them now. I don't know the full extent but I know enough to know they haven't changed and are a source on society.
My children aren't allowed near them.

Now I was talking in a group about paedophiles, as you do when there is yet another case in the news or on the television, or on netflix.
Anyway, we were chatting and we got along the lines of whether it is an illness or not.
I don't believe so. Thinking the thoughts may be unpleasant but acting on them is another thing entirely.
Then it was said that if they aren't attracted to women then perhaps they wouldn't reproduced and if there was a peado gene maybe it would have died out.
And then we were saying that in the old days if you found out uncle Jim hurt your child like that then you would kill him and that be that. Because let's face it, you would if there was no law against it.

But what I've seen time and time again is creating, sharing and possessing indecent images of children isn't given a 15 year sentence. It's given a tap on the wrist 2 years 18 months with good behaviour.

I was watching a program about the police and there was a paedo and he had disgusting videos and images on his laptop, admitted to it, and was let out on bail on the same day waiting for his devices to be checked by whoever does that, Despite them already finding them!

Now I think if I was like that and I knew I'd get a couple years for possessing and sharing images like that then that's a minor deterent.

Or the ones who actually go through with it and hurt children. Oh god. I think they should be locked away indefinitely. I really don't feel safe knowing anyone could be one, but even ones who are caught are let go, ready to do it again. Loads of them do.

this was sparked by the should be bring back state murder thread and my first thought was 'not for murderers'' but then someone posted about paedophiles and I thought "oh yeah they can die" without a second thought.
I really think harsher sentences and they should be locked up. I mean that man who got caught and let out has surely just been shown that he can do it and he gets 24 hours in custody and then he's free basically (I know its on bail but they said he could be waiting 12-24 months to have his devices checked. imagine what he could do after being arrested and the videos were found and he confessed and then let go? Je is going to be exhilarated and possibly fearful of what's coming in a few years. he might go out and do what he can! he's just go away with it basically.

OP posts:
Daisychainsx · 02/10/2022 17:41

Its a crime that can NEVER be justified. I'm not a professional in that area... but I'm not sure that they'll ever not be into what they're into. They might receive help not to act on it, but I'm sure the temptation would remain.

For that reason I think a life long sentence would be best. Or at least a life long ban from participating in society where children may be present... and I'm not sure how you do that without locking someone up or restricting their movements in some way.

The child will have to live with the scars of what they've been through forever... so why should the abuser walk free? World's gone mad.

Also, I think anyone who is willing to commit these crimes is ill, and therefore the 'not guilty due to insanity' verdict should be binned and 'guilty and insane' (or something to that affect) should replace it.

Noteverybodylives · 02/10/2022 17:40

It doesn't matter if it's 'the easy way out' for them if it means that children are protected.

That is true.

They wouldn’t suffer as much as I’d like but then other children wouldn’t suffer at their hands again either, which is more important.

Oliverfunyuns · 02/10/2022 17:38

I know it's not a popular opinion, but I'd dole out death sentences to rapists and murderers, regardless of the age of their victims. Tbh, I don't care whether these criminals have a mental illness or not.

Eeiliethya · 02/10/2022 17:38

J0y · 02/10/2022 17:02

I don't think it'sban illness. I think it's prioritising their sexual gratification over the well being and mental health of an innocent child. A disgustingly selfish choice.

If there is no room in prisons they should be tagged and given chemical castration drugs.

I agree with castration, chemical or otherwise.

I watched a Louis Theroux doc on a prison in USA once that housed peadophiles and they tried putting them through mental treatment but they could also opt for castration. Quite a few of the men opted themselves for castration because they knew they couldn't change their sexual orientation.

I think we should castrate them because we can't put them down unfortunately.

womaninatightspot · 02/10/2022 17:37

We should absolutely let them go and live on a small island somewhere. Drop food off regularly.

seriously though I think the Californians have the right idea. They have a centre where paedophiles get sent to, it’s not prison, you’re being rehabilitated but your odds of being released ever are minute.

girlmom21 · 02/10/2022 17:33

Noteverybodylives · 02/10/2022 17:27

The only reason I don’t believe in the death penalty is that it’s the easy way out.

I’ve heard of many child killers/ abusers who’ve been sentenced to a long life sentence like Ian Brady who have begged to be put to death.

I’d rather they suffer every day in prison.

But the issue is that most of them are allowed back out.

The problem is if they're in prison they're being paid for when, IMO, there's no chance of rehabilitation.

Paedophiles are the one group of people I'd happily reinstate the death penalty for, and I'd happily execute them myself.

It doesn't matter if it's 'the easy way out' for them if it means that children are protected.

Itsnotallblackandwhite · 02/10/2022 17:29

There should be no place in society for anyone who harms a child. I'm okay with child abusers forfeiting their right to live among us.

killthemall · 02/10/2022 17:28

that's what I'm on about. back in the day, before we were 'civilized' we would have a group of men with pitchforks.

I think its because there are no consequences.
if be behind a murderer who killed these filthy men. I really would.

they don't deserve a new identity. are they mad? why waste time and resources protected those who are big and strong enough to rape a person. a minor. a baby.

A slash on the wrist is more fitting than a slap.

OP posts:
Noteverybodylives · 02/10/2022 17:27

The only reason I don’t believe in the death penalty is that it’s the easy way out.

I’ve heard of many child killers/ abusers who’ve been sentenced to a long life sentence like Ian Brady who have begged to be put to death.

I’d rather they suffer every day in prison.

But the issue is that most of them are allowed back out.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 02/10/2022 17:26

The fact that you are saying they should have "died out" suggests you think there is a genetic link which I really don't think there is.

We seem to be getting more Liberal, granting men in women's clothing the opportunity to enter spaces that ought to be reserved for women and girls, we allow them access to corrupt young minds by doing Drag Storytime etc.

I don't suggest that everyone who does the above is a paedophile, but these actions are lowering the barriers to entry for closer relationships with children and in turn, this will create contact where it wasn't before for those willing to try.

mycatisannoying · 02/10/2022 17:24

Really, it's best if we just put them out of their misery. They have no place in society.
Imagine your sole purpose in this life is to cause damage to others. What is the actual point in you being here?

Noteverybodylives · 02/10/2022 17:22

It’s of course a mental illness like with psychopaths, either caused by something wrong in their brains or because they’ve been brought up with abuse and conditioned to it.

But that doesn’t mean it’s acceptable and there’s a massive difference between having these thoughts and acting on them.

Although I did read about a psychopath who was almost schizophrenic where he’d try everything to stop himself from killing someone but the other side of him would take over and he’d do it and then feel bad afterwards - of course that could just be what he told the courts afterwards so they felt sorry for him.

But even if they can’t help it - surely that’s even more reason to keep them off the streets.

I think the reason that peados get such short sentences is because, like racism, it is ingrained into our legal system and society.

Men come above women and children.

I bet a man going around abusing other men would get a much harsher sentence than if they had abused children or women.

I think the simplest, effective solution for any sort of sex offender is to be chemically castrated (as well as jail time), especially if they are claiming they can’t help it.

Getting a slap on the wrist does not help and in some cases may even make it worse if they get off on the fact that it’s forbidden.

killthemall · 02/10/2022 17:19

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 02/10/2022 16:40

Also I seen pedophiles being referred to as MAPS ( minor attracted persons) and people actually believing that its OK. It is never OK and if that ever becomes widely OK then ordinary people will need to intervene!

what about that sicko who made basically Essex dolls but minors. Their argument was that each ine is saving a child but actually this kind of thing escalates so a person with a doll is MORE likely to offend in real life than not.

OP posts:
killthemall · 02/10/2022 17:16

Notanotherwindow · 02/10/2022 16:29

I keep thinking this about Jon Venables. Why for the love of God do we keep releasing him with 6000 new identities when he keeps reoffending and outing himself. Either lock him up permanently or let him live under his own name and risk someone killing him. God knows he deserves it. He isn't going to stop reoffending, he's said as much himself. He doesn't see anything wrong with what he's done.

This is what I was on about. They should have died out because it seems like a basic instinct to at least beat them.
When you read about a crime and its rape or murder of an adult it feels bad, right?
But when the victim is a child the reaction is of intense disgust. They are othered. communities won't accept them, we want them out. and in some cases in jail, prisoners who don't even know the affexted child will gang up on them and the officers look the other way. Vigilante groups are applauded and people watch videos of them being caught and scared.
Most people will say they want them dead or put away but nothing ever happens. you can get 14 years for drug dealing. I can't believe a pp said a reoffender was let off!

I bet if there was a political party who would go hard on them they would win hands down.
but instead the law is so lenient on them.
Then again, almost every man I ever walked past once I reached the age of twelve and grew to an A cup I was suddenly asking for it for existing (even though I existed a good few years after that with no make up, no skirts, no shaving. I was a very late developer but a plethora of men said or did inappropriate things to me. Strangers and relatives alike. same story with every woman I've ever spoken to about this)

OP posts:
OrlaCarmichael · 02/10/2022 17:04

I think a lot of child sex abusers are just abusers, abusing power. Certainly many that abuse within the family.

Not an expert, but have some experience. Something seems off to me about this being an ‘orientation’ or a widespread thing.

And I certainly don’t want the crime of a pedophile being treated more leniently because of their ‘condition’ 🤮

How is it diagnosed? How stringent is the procedure for diagnosis?

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 02/10/2022 17:04

OriginalUsername3 · 02/10/2022 16:50

I don't think law should be able to kill people. I don't think police should have the power to kill people. I don't think judges should have the power to sentence people to death. At the same time. I would kill somebody who hurt my child. I would hurt them beyond what I think is acceptable to do to a person. But the law is susceptible to corruption and shouldn't have the power over life.

I do think paedophilia is an illness. Like schizophrenia. I think we should be investing in treatments. But I also think the person maintains their sanity and CHOOSES to act on those thoughts. And that is abhorrent. All rapist deserve so much more jail time and so much more intensive rehabilitation than they get. No rapist or child abuser should ever leave prison until they are as likely to rape/abuse as any other decent man.

I think we should make an exception for pedophiles in terms of the death sentence.

J0y · 02/10/2022 17:02

I don't think it'sban illness. I think it's prioritising their sexual gratification over the well being and mental health of an innocent child. A disgustingly selfish choice.

If there is no room in prisons they should be tagged and given chemical castration drugs.

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 02/10/2022 16:57

I think there is an unjustifiable lack of respect and care for children and their childhood in society.
Yes it applies to women and their safety too but you asked about paedophiles.
The sentencing is a joke. The prevention is a joke. The porn industry and child sex abuse images is beyond a joke because no one is really even trying.
I think rape should be sentenced the same as murder, with no statute of limitations.
I think viewing/possessing images of child rape should be treated the same as rape. There should be an obligation to report these images if found accidentally and if not you are liable.
Child rape - I couldn't give a fuck what happens to the offender. As long as they are not in society.

OriginalUsername3 · 02/10/2022 16:50

I don't think law should be able to kill people. I don't think police should have the power to kill people. I don't think judges should have the power to sentence people to death. At the same time. I would kill somebody who hurt my child. I would hurt them beyond what I think is acceptable to do to a person. But the law is susceptible to corruption and shouldn't have the power over life.

I do think paedophilia is an illness. Like schizophrenia. I think we should be investing in treatments. But I also think the person maintains their sanity and CHOOSES to act on those thoughts. And that is abhorrent. All rapist deserve so much more jail time and so much more intensive rehabilitation than they get. No rapist or child abuser should ever leave prison until they are as likely to rape/abuse as any other decent man.

Isaidnoalready · 02/10/2022 16:42

00100001 · 02/10/2022 16:38

Was the father given unsupervised access?

The first time? He had supervised but they discussed unsupervised because he never touched her just her friends mum refused to consider it got support in pushing back but they were clear eventually he might get unsupervised access then he broke his restrictions and as he was a repeat offender they said no to all contact

Tealpoppy · 02/10/2022 16:41

trigger warning

My dd was abused by a family friend
he’d used her as his ‘warm up’ until his own dd was ‘of the right age’ (9-11)
thankfully he was found guilty and got 7 years,did 3 and a half,was let out under the conditions he didn't step foot in our home town for 5 years (3 and a half years where spent in prison) and then he’s a free man to do what he likes-although he’s not allowed any contact with under 16’s (god knows how they police him-there is nothing to stop him lingering around schools or parks)

my friend was raped analy aged 7 (in a park toilet)
he got away with it with her,but was found guilty over the years with other children
hed do his time,get out,the council would re-home him,he’d do it again and back to prison he went
last time I saw her,she knew he was living 500 yards away from my dcs school and when people complained they’d just shrug and say they had no other options as he kept getting hounded out of his home when people found out

weve both been warned that we can’t say or do anything towards these men-they are protected
so if I was to see dds abuser in the street,I have to walk the others way-I can’t warn anyone or do anything or I’m at risk of being arrested and charged

the help we got after was almost zero-i feel we where hung out to dry-he got all the help and support he wanted and I know he’s not changed-he doesn’t see he did anything wrong

i don’t know the answer to what should happen but 3 and a half years served of a 7 year sentence is a fucking joke

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 02/10/2022 16:40

Also I seen pedophiles being referred to as MAPS ( minor attracted persons) and people actually believing that its OK. It is never OK and if that ever becomes widely OK then ordinary people will need to intervene!

00100001 · 02/10/2022 16:38

Isaidnoalready · 02/10/2022 16:22

Paedophiles are practically a protected characteristic these days but even back fifteen years ago they didn't sentence them

Friends husband used his daughter as bait to get to her friends charged and given a two year suspended sentence with restrictions broke his restrictions another two years SUSPENDED broke them again same deal he was also granted access to his daughter the first time second time children services said file in court and he didn't show up

Paedophiles with a specific interest in pre school and primary school children housed in flats to left of the flats is a park to the right a primary school

Paedophile with an interest in teenagers housed by the shops next to a church where teenagers hang out because they run clubs for them

It's like they are giving them access on a plate

Was the father given unsupervised access?

Crimeismymiddlename · 02/10/2022 16:33

I have been thinking along the same lines as you since Adnan Syed was released. He was 17 at the time of the murder and has been in prison ever since. He was so young and has had his best years taken. I feel it’s enough. It is also easier to rehabilitate a murderer, while the reoffending rates for child abusers and rapists are sky high I would rather they stay in prison.

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 02/10/2022 16:33

I think it's unforgivable, if anyone did this to my children I would murder them myself. I think death sentence is most appropriate, I really don't believe they can be rehabilitated so it's a waste of time keeping them in prison and a waste of money and if you kill them at least you know they can't do anything like thar again. I'm very sorry for what you went through OP