Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

*trigger warning* Should we let pedophiles go?

112 replies

killthemall · 02/10/2022 16:08

I'm just thinking outloud here but I'd be interested in opinions.

I was groomed and taken advantage of by an older relative when I was a teenager. Didn't learn my lesson and was groomed again by his brother! (I wised up at the similarities though and nothing happened a second time)

Anyway the point is as I know them personally (and they are both still very much involved in the family, I was blamed as the evil temptress obviously) so I know all of their dirty little secrets. And theg have both gotten themselves into positions of power, given themselves access to vulnerable people. I don't know I'd anything has gone on but u wouldn't be surprised. What I do know is that they both preyed on vulnerable women for partners and abuse them now. I don't know the full extent but I know enough to know they haven't changed and are a source on society.
My children aren't allowed near them.

Now I was talking in a group about paedophiles, as you do when there is yet another case in the news or on the television, or on netflix.
Anyway, we were chatting and we got along the lines of whether it is an illness or not.
I don't believe so. Thinking the thoughts may be unpleasant but acting on them is another thing entirely.
Then it was said that if they aren't attracted to women then perhaps they wouldn't reproduced and if there was a peado gene maybe it would have died out.
And then we were saying that in the old days if you found out uncle Jim hurt your child like that then you would kill him and that be that. Because let's face it, you would if there was no law against it.

But what I've seen time and time again is creating, sharing and possessing indecent images of children isn't given a 15 year sentence. It's given a tap on the wrist 2 years 18 months with good behaviour.

I was watching a program about the police and there was a paedo and he had disgusting videos and images on his laptop, admitted to it, and was let out on bail on the same day waiting for his devices to be checked by whoever does that, Despite them already finding them!

Now I think if I was like that and I knew I'd get a couple years for possessing and sharing images like that then that's a minor deterent.

Or the ones who actually go through with it and hurt children. Oh god. I think they should be locked away indefinitely. I really don't feel safe knowing anyone could be one, but even ones who are caught are let go, ready to do it again. Loads of them do.

this was sparked by the should be bring back state murder thread and my first thought was 'not for murderers'' but then someone posted about paedophiles and I thought "oh yeah they can die" without a second thought.
I really think harsher sentences and they should be locked up. I mean that man who got caught and let out has surely just been shown that he can do it and he gets 24 hours in custody and then he's free basically (I know its on bail but they said he could be waiting 12-24 months to have his devices checked. imagine what he could do after being arrested and the videos were found and he confessed and then let go? Je is going to be exhilarated and possibly fearful of what's coming in a few years. he might go out and do what he can! he's just go away with it basically.

OP posts:
LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:15

*They are often generally prone to immoral behaviour all round (cheating on partners, using sex workers, stealing in some form, financially abusing partners, fraud etc etc ; you'll see lots of other examples of it in their lives if you know they're a child sex abuser.

My Grandmother went on a cruise on which a man murdered his ex wife.

He had transferred pretty much all his assets into her name (on civil terms 🙄and the murder was related to the finances.

It transpired, but should be no surprise, that the resin he'd transferred his assets out of his accounts (in the US) was because he'd been caught having sex with underage girls and was vulnerable to compensatikn payments to them. All round sociopath/psychopath.

bloodyplanes · 02/10/2022 18:15

mycatisannoying · 02/10/2022 17:24

Really, it's best if we just put them out of their misery. They have no place in society.
Imagine your sole purpose in this life is to cause damage to others. What is the actual point in you being here?

Exactly this

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:10

I think I just can't quite wrap my head around how someone could get sexual gratification from anything involving a child

You probably feel exactly the same about animals, or unconsious people, or people with severe disabilities, or corpses (sorry to go there) yet men have been caught penetrating all of them.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:09

Miajk · 02/10/2022 18:06

That's a very valid point and an important distinction.

I think I just can't quite wrap my head around how someone could get sexual gratification from anything involving a child unless they truly are mentally ill.

They are predators with low/integrity.

Whether that constitutes a mental illness, I don't know.

They are often generally prone to immoral behaviour all round (cheating on partners, using sex workers, stealing in some form, financially abusing partners, fraud etc etc ; you'll see lots of other examples of it in their lives if you know they're a child sex abuser.

AmInormallk · 02/10/2022 18:07

NO WE SHOULD NOT LET THEM GO
THIS THREAD IS STUPID

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:06

It must be some mental illness as we know it's not normal to view children this way.

I have to break it to you but a portion of the male population just sees any human, including a child, as a collection of holes to fuck & ejaculate into .... And the advantage of kids is that they often can't say no, or can be made not to tell, and may not know it's wrong etc etc. Their sexual abuse is always accompanied by grooming Inc threats to make sure they don't realise it's wrong or don't tell.

Miajk · 02/10/2022 18:06

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:02

It must be some mental illness as we know it's not normal to view children this way.

True paedophilia is a type of mental illness.

But the vast majority of child sex abusers are not true paedophiles. They are opportunistic, exploitative, no integrity, predators.

That's a very valid point and an important distinction.

I think I just can't quite wrap my head around how someone could get sexual gratification from anything involving a child unless they truly are mentally ill.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:02

It must be some mental illness as we know it's not normal to view children this way.

True paedophilia is a type of mental illness.

But the vast majority of child sex abusers are not true paedophiles. They are opportunistic, exploitative, no integrity, predators.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:00

And further on paedophilia..... A minority of paedophiles are true peadophiles; they are exclusively emotionally and sexually attracted to children. They generally do not form relationships with adults.

Most child sex offenders are not true paedophiles. They do not exclusively form emotional and sexual relationships with kids (or try to, I suppose). That are not exclusively attached to kids emotionally and sexually.

Most child sex offenders are a combination of character traits that often line up with personality disorders ie highly exploitative, highly selfish, immoral, low integrity, sociopathic, predatory etc.

They simply predate on and exploit children because they see them as easily exploitable - for many reasons that are pretty obvious.

They are vulnerable, they have always been. This type of character seeks out and exploits vulnerability.

The same sort of person will be the type of Jen who will have sex with people who have learning disabilities, people who are unconscious, at the extreme end .. corpses, animals etc.

They are united by being self serving, exploitative, having no boundaries, no personal responsibility etc. They just see and take an opportunity for sexual gratification - where a decent human would not.

Sausagenbacon · 02/10/2022 17:58

I think you all sound deranged. Except miajk who I agree with.

Scianel · 02/10/2022 17:56

I don't really care whether it's an illness, an orientation or whatever. But I think that attempting to treat or rehabilitate a paedophile or other sex-offender is the worst kind of woolly-headed wishful thinking. They're like that for life. Releasing them guarantees more victims.

LuckyLil · 02/10/2022 17:56

Thefaceofboe · 02/10/2022 17:42

Did anyone watch that programme of the pedophile who openly admitted he was attracted to children? He had never acted on it and even moved into the middle of nowhere so he wasn’t around children. I never thought I’d feel the way I did but I really felt sorry for him. He tried all sorts of things to ‘make the feel go away’ but it just didn’t. He hated himself

To those saying it’s sexual orientation, I agree, but if being involved with men was not allowed the same way pedophilia isn’t, I would simply never touch a man again. To cause such trauma to a child is horrendous, and you have to be sick in the head to act on those feelings.

But that's because you're trying to rationalize it. They don't think what they are doing is wrong. To them it's normal behaviour.

Thatboymum · 02/10/2022 17:54

Let them go where ? Death penalty and straight to hell absolutely, Let them go free Absolutely not. It’s not a sickness they are just vile dirty beasts

Miajk · 02/10/2022 17:54

I think my view on this will be very unpopular, but here we go.

First of all, I think the way society treats pedophiles is wrong. It must be some mental illness as we know it's not normal to view children this way.

There will be a high proportion of pedophiles who will very much know something is wrong with them, and the way they feel. They don't want to act on it. They need some kind of help. But what do they do? The way society treats them and speaks about them means they cannot admit to anyone anywhere these urges or get help.

Don't get me wrong, if someone acts on this, then they shouldn't be let out. This should be addressed through either prison or mental health facilities, but if there's a risk of reoffending they should never be let out.

But I think we could as a society do much better at prevention if we tried to understand why and how we can help troubled individuals like this, instead of right away say they should die and they're scum. I think this just makes it worse because it makes people hide a mental illness out of fear.

LuckyLil · 02/10/2022 17:53

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 02/10/2022 16:29

Paedophilia is a sexual orientation (imo) and thus cannot be rehabilitated. Therefore anyone who holds images or carries out actions that would labelled paedophilia in a court of law should be removed from society and locked up for life.

I've heard people who have been in prison with paedophiles say that it's a sexual preference which can't be cured or rehabilitated. They don't fancy women or men.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 17:53

Paedophilia is not a sexual orientation.

Orientation implies potential consent between partners etc.

Paedophilia is a paraphilia.

Bestcatmum · 02/10/2022 17:51

Thet should be physically castrated. I worked with them for years and they do not ever reform.

Angelinflipflops · 02/10/2022 17:51

I'm.sorry to hear your story, is there nothing you can do to bring your abusers to justice

girlmom21 · 02/10/2022 17:50

saw an interesting documentary detailing the cost of executions in the U.S. it was more than a million dollars per execution due to legal processes needing to be exhausted prior to execution

They stay on death row for decades as well, don't they, and they get options of how they want to be killed.

Maybe once they've been convicted they should be put in prison in solitary confinement and just given the tools to end it themselves when they're ready.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 02/10/2022 17:47

I know it's not a popular opinion, but I'd dole out death sentences to rapists and murderers, regardless of the age of their victims. Tbh, I don't care whether these criminals have a mental illness or not.
You're wrong - it appears to be a very popular opinion; every post on this thread seems to hold exactly the same view

Rowthe · 02/10/2022 17:44

They should be castrated after the first offence.

If they reoffend they should be given the rope. It saves the tax burden.

aModernClassic · 02/10/2022 17:43

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 02/10/2022 16:40

Also I seen pedophiles being referred to as MAPS ( minor attracted persons) and people actually believing that its OK. It is never OK and if that ever becomes widely OK then ordinary people will need to intervene!

These MAPS, now hide under the LGBTQ+ umbrella. Hiding in plain sight for all to see and admire, as they're all so stunning and brave #sickf*ckers.

Noteverybodylives · 02/10/2022 17:42

Quite a few of the men opted themselves for castration because they knew they couldn't change their sexual orientation.

I agree.

It’s painless, harmless, reversible and a lot cheaper than trying to house them all.

As women we put hormones into our bodies all of the time.

So I don’t understand the reason behind not forcing chemical castration on men convicted of sex offences.

They lost that part of their human rights when they took away someone else’s.

Thefaceofboe · 02/10/2022 17:42

Did anyone watch that programme of the pedophile who openly admitted he was attracted to children? He had never acted on it and even moved into the middle of nowhere so he wasn’t around children. I never thought I’d feel the way I did but I really felt sorry for him. He tried all sorts of things to ‘make the feel go away’ but it just didn’t. He hated himself

To those saying it’s sexual orientation, I agree, but if being involved with men was not allowed the same way pedophilia isn’t, I would simply never touch a man again. To cause such trauma to a child is horrendous, and you have to be sick in the head to act on those feelings.

womaninatightspot · 02/10/2022 17:42

girlmom21 · 02/10/2022 17:33

The problem is if they're in prison they're being paid for when, IMO, there's no chance of rehabilitation.

Paedophiles are the one group of people I'd happily reinstate the death penalty for, and I'd happily execute them myself.

It doesn't matter if it's 'the easy way out' for them if it means that children are protected.

I saw an interesting documentary detailing the cost of executions in the U.S. it was more than a million dollars per execution due to legal processes needing to be exhausted prior to execution. It was cheaper on average to keep them behind bars on a whole of life sentence.