Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

*trigger warning* Should we let pedophiles go?

112 replies

killthemall · 02/10/2022 16:08

I'm just thinking outloud here but I'd be interested in opinions.

I was groomed and taken advantage of by an older relative when I was a teenager. Didn't learn my lesson and was groomed again by his brother! (I wised up at the similarities though and nothing happened a second time)

Anyway the point is as I know them personally (and they are both still very much involved in the family, I was blamed as the evil temptress obviously) so I know all of their dirty little secrets. And theg have both gotten themselves into positions of power, given themselves access to vulnerable people. I don't know I'd anything has gone on but u wouldn't be surprised. What I do know is that they both preyed on vulnerable women for partners and abuse them now. I don't know the full extent but I know enough to know they haven't changed and are a source on society.
My children aren't allowed near them.

Now I was talking in a group about paedophiles, as you do when there is yet another case in the news or on the television, or on netflix.
Anyway, we were chatting and we got along the lines of whether it is an illness or not.
I don't believe so. Thinking the thoughts may be unpleasant but acting on them is another thing entirely.
Then it was said that if they aren't attracted to women then perhaps they wouldn't reproduced and if there was a peado gene maybe it would have died out.
And then we were saying that in the old days if you found out uncle Jim hurt your child like that then you would kill him and that be that. Because let's face it, you would if there was no law against it.

But what I've seen time and time again is creating, sharing and possessing indecent images of children isn't given a 15 year sentence. It's given a tap on the wrist 2 years 18 months with good behaviour.

I was watching a program about the police and there was a paedo and he had disgusting videos and images on his laptop, admitted to it, and was let out on bail on the same day waiting for his devices to be checked by whoever does that, Despite them already finding them!

Now I think if I was like that and I knew I'd get a couple years for possessing and sharing images like that then that's a minor deterent.

Or the ones who actually go through with it and hurt children. Oh god. I think they should be locked away indefinitely. I really don't feel safe knowing anyone could be one, but even ones who are caught are let go, ready to do it again. Loads of them do.

this was sparked by the should be bring back state murder thread and my first thought was 'not for murderers'' but then someone posted about paedophiles and I thought "oh yeah they can die" without a second thought.
I really think harsher sentences and they should be locked up. I mean that man who got caught and let out has surely just been shown that he can do it and he gets 24 hours in custody and then he's free basically (I know its on bail but they said he could be waiting 12-24 months to have his devices checked. imagine what he could do after being arrested and the videos were found and he confessed and then let go? Je is going to be exhilarated and possibly fearful of what's coming in a few years. he might go out and do what he can! he's just go away with it basically.

OP posts:
LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 19:04

We raise men to believe theyre superior. Some take it to its natural conclusion by abusing those with less power/who are 'inferior'.

Sorry, I forgot to say that I absolutely agree there's a big aspect in these bastards psychology/narrative that women and children are possessions.

And you can do what you like with your possessions, esp behind closed doors.

You have rights to their bodies, your rights and wants always come above theirs.

Lundy Bancroft's books on how abusers think touched on this well.

Scianel · 02/10/2022 18:54

Because, sadly, most abusers were themselves abused as children, I think?

They certainly know to give that as a reason in mitigation during their trials. Whether it's true or not, well, they're hardly the most honest of people.

jonesy1999 · 02/10/2022 18:53

Noteverybodylives · 02/10/2022 17:42

Quite a few of the men opted themselves for castration because they knew they couldn't change their sexual orientation.

I agree.

It’s painless, harmless, reversible and a lot cheaper than trying to house them all.

As women we put hormones into our bodies all of the time.

So I don’t understand the reason behind not forcing chemical castration on men convicted of sex offences.

They lost that part of their human rights when they took away someone else’s.

Yes, I agree with this.

It's ok for men to make abortion laws, but when it comes to mens bodies, this is off the table? It shouldn't be, this is an obvious solution and the reason it doesn't happen is that men and their bodies are deemed more important than womens.

That needs to change.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:51

Because, sadly, most abusers were themselves abused as children, I think?

There's a convincing school of thought that they all claim that when caught.

So sympathy and pop psychology can help them.

Funny how do many victims (the majority) of child sex abuse are female, yet so many of the offenders are male (in fact pretty much all, and if you see a case with a woman, it will almost always have a man influencing & procuring somewhere). Why aren't the majority female if that's the case?

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:48

*Lots of women always stick by the "bread winner

Pineappleflowers · 02/10/2022 18:48

Yep. With a lot of the child murders there was a pattern of escalating behaviour first thet should have been stopped earlier. Crime against children (and women) doesn’t get harsh enough penalties but defraud a bank and its ten years 🙄

jonesy1999 · 02/10/2022 18:46

I'm not sure it's an illness.

Because, sadly, most abusers were themselves abused as children, I think?

So I'm not too sure how it works. Some paedophiles I feel absolute hatred for....and then I hear about what does done to them as children. Obviously I don't forgive / excuse what they are done, but it is very sad.

But I agree completely that sentences need to be much, much harsher. And sentences for people with indecent images of children as well. Stop them before they hurt someone. As you say though OP, that's the dark side of the internet and much more needs to be done to police it.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:46

rumred · 02/10/2022 18:37

Agree with @LemonDrop22 on the whole.
Society is the problem. We raise men to believe theyre superior. Some take it to its natural conclusion by abusing those with less power/who are 'inferior'.

It's complicated. I've worked in child protection and saw vile men as opposed to mentally ill men

No idea how we sort this shitshow out

Yes but so many men being absolute fucking animals for sexual gratification (and that's an insult to animals) is the main problem.

They'd fuck anything that moves. They don't care if they shouldn't do it to prepubescent humans. They don't care as long as they're not caught (or have to pay any penalty). And let's face it, most of them (like ops abusers) don't.

Society, as you rightly point, makes sure they don't for all sorts of reasons. Lots of women always such by the "bread winner" and still do, even now they have welfare and child maintenance etc.
We have a rape apologist culture too, even when it comes to underage ..... Excuses are made, minimisation happens, if it can be said the victim is delusional or lying, it will be said.

Sausagenbacon · 02/10/2022 18:46

Does every society experience this?
Not in the rest of Europe. We have a very different take on sex offending on the UK.

ImaniMumsnet · 02/10/2022 18:44

Hi OP, we have received a number of reports about this thread so we have edited the title to include a trigger warning.

Best wishes.

SacredDeer · 02/10/2022 18:44

Considering a chunk of my life was taken from some vile offender, I would happily volunteer to dish out capital punishment on any sex offender. They need wiped off the face of the earth, too many lives are destroyed by these monsters. There's no deterrent for their crimes, they just reoffend and get away almost Scot free.

Throw them in 100ft acid pools I say or piranhas.

robertpaulson · 02/10/2022 18:42

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/10/2022 16:14

I hope you don’t live in Wiltshire , OP. Because the local police will visit you and give you a good talking to if you are ‘Untoward about pedophiles’. And try to get registered for a hate crime….

I still can't make that quote make grammatical sense. Let alone actual sense.

Jewel1968 · 02/10/2022 18:41

Don't you think our society has kinda normalised it. Watching a documentary about the making of Death in Venice and it is so obviously dodgy and yet it's heralded as a great work of art. And then there are the marriages that I remember from the 80s where an old very famous rock star married a very young 15 or 16 child.

I know psychologists that try to study this area struggle as no funding etc... I would rather they studied it and understood it so we can identify it earlier, prevent it happening. Harsh punishments would probably lead them to killing the witness.

Does every society experience this?

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:40

We should absolutely let them go and live on a small island somewhere. Drop food off regularly

Lepers through no fault of their own had this done to them.

Why not them.

Wouldn't be dropping food though, they could raise their own from initial stocks. Give them something to think about other than their cocks 24 hrs a day.

womaninatightspot · 02/10/2022 18:38

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:17

That's the first convincing argument I've heard against the death penalty.

(Aside from the 'to err is human" aspect).

It was a massive saving as well, nearly a half million dollars on average. Apparently every year you spend in prison reduces your life expectancy by 2 years in the US. Average age of death is 56 for a UK prisoner.

rumred · 02/10/2022 18:37

Agree with @LemonDrop22 on the whole.
Society is the problem. We raise men to believe theyre superior. Some take it to its natural conclusion by abusing those with less power/who are 'inferior'.

It's complicated. I've worked in child protection and saw vile men as opposed to mentally ill men

No idea how we sort this shitshow out

killthemall · 02/10/2022 18:37

Angelinflipflops · 02/10/2022 17:51

I'm.sorry to hear your story, is there nothing you can do to bring your abusers to justice

I managed to trick a grown man as a virgin child didn't you know? I was told off by everyone except my mum and my friends mum. They wanted me to go to the police but after hearing what everyone else said about me I chose not to.
I actually believed it was my fault and I'd given off the wrong signals. I was really ugly too.

I avoid him at family get togethers now but I didn't for a few years. when I started asking if he was going and it was obvious I was avoiding him, everyone brought up the fact that he should be avoiding me for tricking him into bed.

Before this though he used me to get close to other girls my age and that's part of the reason I felt so guilty for so many years.

oh well. at least i know enough to keep my children away from him. that's enough for me.

OP posts:
Cw112 · 02/10/2022 18:33

Firstly op it wasn't your lesson to learn- the blame for what happened to you solely lies with the two men involved so please don't blame yourself.

I have really mixed feelings on this. On one hand I've worked with kids who have been abused who then have gone on to abuse other children due to their unresolved trauma. I wouldn't class them as paedophiles because they're kids and victims themselves but as soon as they turn 18 they are classed in that bracket. So it's not always as straight forward an issue as people think.

I'm not one for the death penalty in any circumstance because I think it's a lot to say that certain people can never ever change or reintegrate safely into society. But I do think that some people regardless of their circumstances need to be kept away from society because they're maybe unable (for whatever reason) to make safe choices themselves. And for that reason I would absolutely support tougher sentencing.

I do however think there should be a mechanism where people experiencing those thoughts and urges can speak to someone and get support/ be removed from the public before they act on it. At the minute we don't have that and I think it makes it even more likely that someone will act on their feelings rather than having a safe place to go and look at why they are having those urges in the first place and get support to manage them in a way that keeps others safe. Wouldn't work for everyone- some people will always make that choice, but it might stop some from acting on it.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:31

but I think a differentiation must be made between actually abusing and merely accessing images that already exist.

Images would not be created without a market.

More would not created without the market.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:30

To cause such trauma to a child is horrendous

I saw a treatise online, later removed unsurprisingly, written by a paedophile (whether he was a true paedophile, I don't know- from what he wrote, it seemed so) from his point of view on why children should be allowed to make the decision on whether to enter into a relationship with him.

A large part of his argument was that he would a second or third guiding, supporting, wise, contributer to the child's education, development and welfare. The relationship would be a positive in so many ways for the child.

He was absolutely convinced of this.

The non typical child sex abuser probably doesn't think that, who knows, but convinces themselves they're not doing any real harm. Plenty convince themselves its mutual esp the older the child is.

One thing that I read that struck me was that a child sex abuser could talk for hours about the negative impact on his life of his crimes, but when asked what he thought the impact was on his victims life; was absolutely blank faced and could not come up with one thing.

pinheadlarry · 02/10/2022 18:29

I would like for them to get life in prison or death penalty but its unlikely to happen because i think alot of the lawmakers and judges are pedophiles and perverts themselves.

Pedophiles are very good at getting themselves into positions of power and close to children, very manipulative and calculated

KhaleesiDothraki · 02/10/2022 18:25

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - this has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sausagenbacon · 02/10/2022 18:21

So how come you know so much about paedophiles then, lemondrop. Are you a psychiatrist, or a social worker, or a JP?

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:20

Back on topic; true paedophiles (not the majority of child sex offenders) apparently do have observable brain differences. Parts of their brains are not developed as they should be.

That just illustratrs that they're dangerous (until we can replace faulty brain parts in the future) though.

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 18:17

womaninatightspot · 02/10/2022 17:42

I saw an interesting documentary detailing the cost of executions in the U.S. it was more than a million dollars per execution due to legal processes needing to be exhausted prior to execution. It was cheaper on average to keep them behind bars on a whole of life sentence.

That's the first convincing argument I've heard against the death penalty.

(Aside from the 'to err is human" aspect).