Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to consider my grandma’s theory on why we’re all fatter?

267 replies

bagelbreath · 02/10/2022 14:20

My grandma swears up and down that although food and movement are obviously big factors to the massive weight gain of the country, heating is also very important.

While she lived in a cold house, wore stockings and dresses year round, and spent a lot of time outside, we all sit toasty in our well heated and insulated houses. Her theory is that it took lots of energy to stay warm then vs now.

Is it crazy? I kind of think it makes sense

OP posts:
Dimsumbun · 02/10/2022 15:21

Any idea what your ancestors did as jobs? one if DH ancestors was a laundress about 150 years ago. Imagine the huge physical effort that job would require. How many people do you know that have to move a lot when working? the majority of my friends are sat at desks.

People walked miles almost no one had a car when your Grandma was young. Even 50 years ago we all walked to primary school. From age 9 I had a 4 mile round trip walk every day.

People eat huge amounts of food, I have some of DH Grandmother's 1970’s dinner plates, they are tiny compare to my actual dinner set.

kateandme · 02/10/2022 15:21

antelopevalley · 02/10/2022 15:15

These posts seem to be trying to persuade us all that it is good we can not afford to put the heating on.

Because life will be all right when we lose weight and are thin after all.😣

antelopevalley · 02/10/2022 15:20

My gran was slim. She worked as a factory cleaner and then came home and cleaned the house, washed the families clothes by hand and took care of her children, all without any practical help from anyone.

kateandme · 02/10/2022 15:19

No because they were also eating foods we demonise now.proper butter.sugary cakes.lard and fats.full fat dairy and as much meat as they could.bread.carbs!they didn’t prescribe to shorty diet culture so much.they are more intuitively because of this.societal pressure for the thin ideal wasn’t so rampant.and the lie that thin always equal health wasn’t so pushed. Generally more active just because of how life was jot just forced exercise.
can’t wait to see where this thread goes.
weight,fat,food discussion on man here we go…

nicknamehelp · 02/10/2022 15:17

I read my grandma's diary from 100 years ago as no TV etc at home would spend evenings out at library, cinema etc which due to not having a car meant walking so they naturally where more active. Food also wasn't as easy/convenient as it is today and often was either home grown or carried home from the shops so again more exercise.

antelopevalley · 02/10/2022 15:15

These posts seem to be trying to persuade us all that it is good we can not afford to put the heating on.

sunshineandsuddenshowers · 02/10/2022 15:13

Well I eat more in the winter, and more still on v cold days. And there’s nothing like winter swimming to put a hunger on you. So in the absence of easy high calorie snacks I am sure colder equals thinner.

Gwenhwyfar · 02/10/2022 15:13

clowerina · 02/10/2022 14:30

I also wonder if it is a generational thing. for example, my grandparents (war children) really pushed "treat" foods on us as children. They were deprived with rationing, poverty etc so they wanted to make sure we never went without. Without realising the true impact of this. E.g. crisps, chocolate etc to the max to "spoil" their children and grandchildren. The impact of this is people are more accustomed to junk food. Not to mention all the advertising, glorification of food in our society.

Yes, but the reason for this is the overabundance of cheap food since the war. So yes, our grandparents and parents gave us too much food, but that was because they could.

Getoff · 02/10/2022 15:13

I would guess it's the putting of sugar into processed foods that's the real underly cause of the obesity epidemic. People aren't suddenly getting fat now because sugar has suddenly become more attractive or affordable. They're getting fat because their diet is changing towards processed foods, which contain sugar.

Getoff · 02/10/2022 15:11

Apparently it's sugar that is responsible for the worldwide obesity epidemic, and not because of the calories in it.

See videos by Dr Robert Lustig on Youtube.

My summary: all common sugars are roughly 50% fructose. The only organ in your body that knows what to do with fructose is your liver, which turns it into fat. Consequently, your insulin levels go up. Extra insulin suppresses the effect of the hormone leptin which controls your appetite.

So, if I've understood correctly, and am not unintentionally exaggerating, the consequence of eating one extra teaspoon of sugar today is that your appetite and therefore calorie intake will be higher for the rest of your life.

(The other half of sugar, typically glucose, is relatively benign, the only harm is the actual calories. Most of it doesn't reach the liver, because all you organs know how to use it for energy. Even when some does reach the liver, it is converted into glycogen, a starch energy store, rather than generating new fat, the way fructose does.)

Freedomfromguilt · 02/10/2022 15:08

Portion sizes. My MIL's dinner plate which date from her 1966 wedding are the same size as my side plates.

Matrons · 02/10/2022 15:07

Difference between eating to live back then and now living to eat.

Thinkingblonde · 02/10/2022 15:03
  • Moved more and ate less.
Cyw2018 · 02/10/2022 15:02

I think your Grandma's correct but that it is more complex than that. If you look at what food is available locally and naturally during winter, we are designed to have scarcity of food one season a year. Even Chickens barely lay in the winter, let alone the lack of fresh produce.

So in winter we should be calorie deprived as well as struggling to keep warm. Now we eat an abundance at Christmas (let alone all the other dark cold evenings), live in centrally heated homes, and have cars to drive so we can go almost door to door without barely venturing into the weather if we wish (having a dog obviously prevents this!).

TokyoTen · 02/10/2022 15:02

I don't think it's one factor, but many. So it may include living in colder homes, smoking which suppresses appetite, more of us have cars which means less walking/cycling, ready availability of junk food etc. I think the biggest factor is sugary food - because sugar sets up a craving for more sugar when you're on the down from it.

strawberrysea · 02/10/2022 15:01

I don't think so, but I'm absolutely not a scientist so just my take.

Processed food, sitting at desks all day and overindulgence are the main factors.

5128gap · 02/10/2022 15:01

I've seen pictures of my grandma and her friends and neighbours and they don't look very thin to me. Mostly fairly well upholstered apple shaped women by the time they hit mid life.
They didn't spend their whole lives cold either. My grandad was a miner and so coal fires were free. The middle room where the range was was absolutely boiling.
While there wasn't processed food, there was always tins of cake, a slice of which would come in at around the calories of a small meal.
They walked more and housework was heavier, which helped.
The men, who I'd agree seem much smaller and thinner, had to do a lot more manually. Children weren't fat either.
Being cold burns more calories, but overall I'd think it was negligible amongst other factors.

WeepingSomnambulist · 02/10/2022 15:01

It's everything. Processed, calorific foods, sedentary lifestyles, warmth. Even easier housework; vacuums etc. And most people do less housework than 1950s women did.

Thinkingblonde · 02/10/2022 15:01

They moved more and are less. Hard physical Labour, long working hours, walking more, walking to work was more common. Or walking to catch public transport.
In the home there was less household appliances, washday was just that, a day devoted to washing. The day my mother got her first washer, after either doing it by hand or using the local wash-house was like all her dreams came true. It was a single tub with an electric wringer. Fill it with water, let the water heat up add detergent, clothes then let the paddle thing in the middle go to work, drain the water out, fill back up with cold, rinse, rinse again and the each garment through the wringer one at a time. If you put too thick an item through it, the pressure thing would disengage, fly up and hit you in the face. Or it took your hand through if you weren’t quick enough to move them out of the way.
Everything was line dried.
Today there’s more food choice, outlets, fast food, more office based work.

CherryGenoa · 02/10/2022 14:59

Intuitively it feels as though it would be a factor. Also my granny cooked a lot of meals that were meat or fish with two or three veg. And fruit for pudding. Relatively healthy if you look at the nutritional breakdown, and no processed snacks.

Abra1t · 02/10/2022 14:58

CheezePleeze · 02/10/2022 14:44

Oh come on.

More channels on the TV than you can count.

The internet.

People driving because they think a 40 minute walk is too long, or they're going to dissolve in the rain.

Huge portions of food at mealtimes and constant snacking in between.

Junk food outlets cramming up every town centre, everywhere you look.

Said junk food outlets delivering to our doors so we don't even have to get off our arses.

Those examples are just a tiny part of why we're all fatter, but if your gran thinks it's down to better heating, let her crack on 😁

You might want to do more research!

www.businessinsider.com/cold-temperatures-could-lead-to-weight-loss-2018-3?amp

time.com/5025694/does-being-cold-burn-calories/?amp=true

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 14:57

Many people eat utter crap- watch the hordes get off planes at Newcastle airport at the end of holidays. In the middle of the night they walk out of the arrivals channel and 50% go straight into Greggs to buy carrier bags of hot , greasy crap at 3am.
This week I have been working in a secondary school and at the end of the day (3 days) have gone to the local Co-op at the request of the manager because he thinks the kids misbehave. I didn't think they were badly behaved but I was horrified to see what teenagers were buying at the end of the school day to eat on the way home- family packs of crisps, boxes of 10 flap jacks, 10 chocolate cornflake cakes, packets of 6 croissants, 6 muffins, big bottles of fizzy drinks. Not to share, each. I walked back with a group of boys one afternoon part of the way back to the school and they told me they buy something like that every day on the way home and eat it all before they get home. I was astonished.
I am 43. We NEVER had takeaways delivered when I was growing up. My dad went and collected fish and chips occasionally on Fridays for our tea but that was it. I never had a takeaway until I was at university. I have still never had a Macdonald's. People order delivered food all the time now.

Galarunner · 02/10/2022 14:55

I am sure I have read somewhere that the average man or woman actually eat less calories than they did in 1940, activity levels were much higher especially in traditional manual jobs.

Totalityloss · 02/10/2022 14:55

Yes it’s true. It’s one of the reasons children in fuel poor households are smaller in height.

Lentil63 · 02/10/2022 14:55

It’s multi factorial and your Nan is right. There is much more…

Swipe left for the next trending thread