Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to consider my grandma’s theory on why we’re all fatter?

267 replies

bagelbreath · 02/10/2022 14:20

My grandma swears up and down that although food and movement are obviously big factors to the massive weight gain of the country, heating is also very important.

While she lived in a cold house, wore stockings and dresses year round, and spent a lot of time outside, we all sit toasty in our well heated and insulated houses. Her theory is that it took lots of energy to stay warm then vs now.

Is it crazy? I kind of think it makes sense

OP posts:
JesusSufferingFuck22 · 02/10/2022 15:48

I think temperature does play a part. The theory for me is that being told “put your jacket on on you’ll catch a cold” is true. The energy your body uses to keep warm could be saved by putting a jacket on, then your body uses that energy to fight off the cold.

queenofarles · 02/10/2022 15:48

i believe it’s one of the reasons.

i love watching videos about food shopping in the past, never struck me that people ate healthier , the majority was canned food and very little fresh fruits and veg , there weren’t that much back then!

CaveMum · 02/10/2022 15:47

Sugar is the biggest culprit for the increase in obesity. Read this article, it’s long but informative: www.theguardian.com/society/2016/apr/07/the-sugar-conspiracy-robert-lustig-john-yudkin

As it states:

“Look at a graph of postwar obesity rates and it becomes clear that something changed after 1980. In the US, the line rises very gradually until, in the early 1980s, it takes off like an aeroplane. Just 12% of Americans were obese in 1950, 15% in 1980, 35% by 2000. In the UK, the line is flat for decades until the mid-1980s, at which point it also turns towards the sky. Only 6% of Britons were obese in 1980. In the next 20 years that figure more than trebled. Today, two thirds of Britons are either obese or overweight, making this the fattest country in the EU. Type 2 diabetes, closely related to obesity, has risen in tandem in both countries.
**
**
At best, we can conclude that the official guidelines did not achieve their objective; at worst, they led to a decades-long health catastrophe. Naturally, then, a search for culprits has ensued. Scientists are conventionally apolitical figures, but these days, nutrition researchers write editorials and books that resemble liberal activist tracts, fizzing with righteous denunciations of “big sugar” and fast food. Nobody could have predicted, it is said, how the food manufacturers would respond to the injunction against fat – selling us low-fat yoghurts bulked up with sugar, and cakes infused with liver-corroding transfats.”

Fleur405 · 02/10/2022 15:47

How does your gran account for the rise of obesity in countries like Brazil where it’s much hotter than here. I’ll tell you how I do - processed food, fizzy drinks, sugar….

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 02/10/2022 15:42

RueValens · 02/10/2022 14:29

I'm going to vote with not crazy! The reason being that when I had an eating disorder - anorexia - one thing I did all the time was wear summer clothing in the winter. My therapist said I may have been doing this subconsciously because my body would be using more energy to try and keep me warm.

Same here, drinking ice cold water so your body uses calories to warm it to body temperature as well.

floorida · 02/10/2022 15:41

Also the narrative that everyone was slim back in the day is weird. Now there were probably not morbidly obese people but plenty of middle aged adults had some timber.

CheezePleeze · 02/10/2022 15:41

madasawethen · 02/10/2022 15:40

I believe it has a small impact
It truly is all the food and snacking people do.
I remember growing up there were no overweight kids in school.
We never had snacks. Just our 3 meals a day.
There weren't any fast food places around so we seldom had it. We might go to a diner or a pizza place for a meal a few times a year.
I don't remember anyone sitting around much in the family. TV was only on after dinner.

Now people think they're going to starve if they don't constantly have food or snacks.

Yep 100%

Plus, as soon as it turns cold you'll see countless threads from Mumsnetters asking what their favouite 'Winter comfort foods' are.

BarmyArmy22 · 02/10/2022 15:41

@BarmyArmy22 and got a cleaner too, so I'm not burning any calories on housekeeping either. Lifestyle changes are definitely a massive factor.

madasawethen · 02/10/2022 15:40

I believe it has a small impact
It truly is all the food and snacking people do.
I remember growing up there were no overweight kids in school.
We never had snacks. Just our 3 meals a day.
There weren't any fast food places around so we seldom had it. We might go to a diner or a pizza place for a meal a few times a year.
I don't remember anyone sitting around much in the family. TV was only on after dinner.

Now people think they're going to starve if they don't constantly have food or snacks.

BarmyArmy22 · 02/10/2022 15:40

HebeSunshine · 02/10/2022 14:31

I think she’s right, along with lack of movement. When I was a kid we never had a car and we walked miles and miles, nowadays it’s just too easy to get in the car to drive a couple of miles down the road.

This is definitely a factor. I didn't learn to drive until I was 40 so had no choice but to walk most places and was always trim/thin. Middle age spread may have happened anyway by mid 40s but now I have the option to drive plus more home-working have definitely had an impact!

HilaryThorpe · 02/10/2022 15:37

We did have quite a lot of sugar though. Home-made jam, stewed apple, cakes, sweets like butterscotch etc. I think one difference was that we ate at mealtimes and not in between. It was common for people to become stout in middle-age but not obese. I live in rural France and see the same shaped people now and many of the same eating habits too, sit down meals and no grazing.
Not sure why people think food was awful though. Home made pies and cakes, fresh fruit and vegetables from the garden, fresh eggs, lots of butter and cream. It isn't necessarily how we cook now, but there was lots to enjoy, especially at weekends when my mother wasn't at work.

floorida · 02/10/2022 15:36

when i moved into my first home it was freezing & I put on weight as I didn't do much else except sit on the sofa watching tv & comfort eating.

I think it's the shift from manual labour & less walking.

lightisnotwhite · 02/10/2022 15:35

clowerina · 02/10/2022 14:30

I also wonder if it is a generational thing. for example, my grandparents (war children) really pushed "treat" foods on us as children. They were deprived with rationing, poverty etc so they wanted to make sure we never went without. Without realising the true impact of this. E.g. crisps, chocolate etc to the max to "spoil" their children and grandchildren. The impact of this is people are more accustomed to junk food. Not to mention all the advertising, glorification of food in our society.

But treats 30 years ago was just that. Coke was for Christmas and birthdays or maybe the weekend if you had a pop man.. If you got some from Granny all good. Now it’s part of fast food and meal deal, sold in every shop and petrol station.
Same with crisps and sweets.

Nothing was open on Sundays, half day closing or after 6pm in most lcds except big cities.
We have treat food much more cheaply and readily available especially fast processed food which is 24/7

ShandaLear · 02/10/2022 15:35

Lots of factors - no cars, fewer treats, no gadgets - vacuum cleaners, washing machines, tumble dryers, etc. so everything was done manually. Fewer fridges/freezers so people walked to the shops every other day and only brought back what they could carry, food relatively bland so not as enticing as todays food, only one person in a household worked usually so less money for treats, agree with the heat one, but also kids would be out ALL the time. At weekends and holidays we’d be out of the house running or cycling over roads and fields, and we’d only materialise for lunch and dinner (and we didn’t bring water bottles or anything with us!). My kids do much less of that so they move less apart from organised activities. Food was much less available - we were relatively affluent but I don’t remember us going out for many meals. We’d very occasionally get fish and chips as a takeaway but there was no pizza, Chinese or Indian takeaway. You considered it a treat if you got potatoes, peas and a Findus Crispy Pancake!

SneakAttackDamage · 02/10/2022 15:34

Eating little and often is also appalling for weight gain.

Fat is stored when insulin is detected in the blood, which happens after eating anything with sugar (or carbohydrates which break down into sugar).

In my parents and grandparents generation, people would have 2 or 3 large meals across the day. The current trend of grazing, having maybe 6 - 8 small meals across the day, doubles or even triples the amount of time the body is being instructed to store fat. And with people generally moving less this means increased weight gain.

kateandme · 02/10/2022 15:33

Moonatics · 02/10/2022 15:28

Ha, same. Whilst going through my anorexia I wore thin clothing, all the time. I think I knew instinctively that being cold burned more calories.
Just googled and shivering for an hour uses 400 calories.
If you times that by the entire winter period and the fact that food was simple and plain and not vast amounts of meat, then yes it had some effect.
So did walking everywhere, using peggy tubs? Those washing machines that you more or less did most of the work.
Carting your shopping home a few times a week. I'm pretty sure my mum went three times a week shopping and refused to use an old lady trolley (that I see are almost fashion statements now)

I do remember every big meal we had were with bread and butter (real butter) or masses of potatoes presumably to fill us up. Most lunchtimes if we had one was sandwiches with sliced cheese or meat, no sauces, no extras, only one sandwich.
I'm not that old but I remember most of my childhood feeling hungry.

Sadly this was just another lie your Ed told you

APlanetFarFarAway · 02/10/2022 15:32

No, there's no silver lining to not being able to heat your home this winter Hmm

We're fatter because of all the processed food and our over reliance on wheat. We're stressed and don't have time to make 3 decent meals a day.

MeanderingGently · 02/10/2022 15:32

Your grandmother is correct about the cold, although it's only one factor. I have lived in some very cold places (Nordic countries, above the arctic circle) where most of the year it was between -7 and -25. Yes, you wrap up warmly when going out and have heating on indoors, but your whole lifestyle includes dealing with the cold. You burn up masses of calories just living, you eat more but the weight drops off. Believe me, it does....

However, in the UK we no longer do 'cold living' and we certainly don't tend to stay outdoors very long in minus temperatures anymore, unlike in the 50s and 60s when children would be outside all day, playing in freezing weather and snow. And we do keep our houses/shops/offices too warm, preferring to keep wearing our blouses and T-shirts rather than thick pullovers indoors in winter.

But it's only one factor. We're also fatter because of processed food, larger portions, different types of food, snacking, less manual labour, not as active.... All sorts of other reasons too.

KangarooKenny · 02/10/2022 15:29

People used to walk a lot more.

Moonatics · 02/10/2022 15:28

RueValens · 02/10/2022 14:29

I'm going to vote with not crazy! The reason being that when I had an eating disorder - anorexia - one thing I did all the time was wear summer clothing in the winter. My therapist said I may have been doing this subconsciously because my body would be using more energy to try and keep me warm.

Ha, same. Whilst going through my anorexia I wore thin clothing, all the time. I think I knew instinctively that being cold burned more calories.
Just googled and shivering for an hour uses 400 calories.
If you times that by the entire winter period and the fact that food was simple and plain and not vast amounts of meat, then yes it had some effect.
So did walking everywhere, using peggy tubs? Those washing machines that you more or less did most of the work.
Carting your shopping home a few times a week. I'm pretty sure my mum went three times a week shopping and refused to use an old lady trolley (that I see are almost fashion statements now)

I do remember every big meal we had were with bread and butter (real butter) or masses of potatoes presumably to fill us up. Most lunchtimes if we had one was sandwiches with sliced cheese or meat, no sauces, no extras, only one sandwich.
I'm not that old but I remember most of my childhood feeling hungry.

CornishGem1975 · 02/10/2022 15:26

I knew two of my great-grandmothers growing up and they were big ladies, always were from the photos I've seen, born 1900. Not sure everyone was slender, they had fat and thin just as we do now. People who eat too much and move too little are going to be bigger.

CheezePleeze · 02/10/2022 15:25

Haha no!

Seriously, it's too much food and lack of exercise that's making people fat.

If they keep up what they're doing now, they could move to an igloo and it's really not going to make much difference.

MarianneOnAMotorcycle · 02/10/2022 15:24

I believe it's been scientifically proven to make a small difference, but it's not going to solve the obesity problem if we all shiver through the winter. Same as drinking ice cold water.

antelopevalley · 02/10/2022 15:23

Fancy150Years · 02/10/2022 15:22

we all sit toasty in our well heated and insulated houses.

Absolutely. We haven't got the heating on yet and it's getting chilly. Therefore I am running around the house, fixing, tidying, sorting or going for walks, anything active as sitting around on the sofa mumsnetting relaxing is just not fun when it's cold.

YANBU.

The cold always makes me lethargic. Our house is cold.

Fancy150Years · 02/10/2022 15:22

we all sit toasty in our well heated and insulated houses.

Absolutely. We haven't got the heating on yet and it's getting chilly. Therefore I am running around the house, fixing, tidying, sorting or going for walks, anything active as sitting around on the sofa mumsnetting relaxing is just not fun when it's cold.

YANBU.

Swipe left for the next trending thread