Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to consider my grandma’s theory on why we’re all fatter?

267 replies

bagelbreath · 02/10/2022 14:20

My grandma swears up and down that although food and movement are obviously big factors to the massive weight gain of the country, heating is also very important.

While she lived in a cold house, wore stockings and dresses year round, and spent a lot of time outside, we all sit toasty in our well heated and insulated houses. Her theory is that it took lots of energy to stay warm then vs now.

Is it crazy? I kind of think it makes sense

OP posts:
sorrynotathome · 02/10/2022 17:08

YABU for saying “we’re all fatter”. I’m not. Late 50s, grew up without central heating etc etc. I weigh less now than before I had DC. And I put my heating on to a reasonable extent, as I really feel the cold.

AWOL66 · 02/10/2022 17:08

I think it makes sense and I've wondered this before too but I think driving is the biggest factor.
Since starting driving three years ago I've put on 2.5 stone and rising and struggle to get motivation to exercise when I wouldn't even notice my walking everywhere before.

If you were to eat just one Mars bar a day (240 cals) and not walk it off you'd put on half a pound a week so in a year you'd put on over 1.5 stone. In two years you'd have put on yet another 1.5 stone and so would be 3 stone overweight.

An hour of brisk walking would burn off the Mars bar and you'd maintain a steady weight.
I'd eat tons of biscuits and chocolate but walk miles if you looked back over the year- shopping, to the station, to work etc as I didn't drive so my weight always seemed to stay within a stone - I'm living proof of the detrimental effects of driving!

Darhon · 02/10/2022 17:06

Here is some info

Bbc article

Fancy150Years · 02/10/2022 17:05

@CheezePleeze

They've always been hot countries but they haven't always had an obesity problem. So I really don't think temperatures make a jot of difference.

It does tough when it's cold indoors and your behaviour is less sedentary as a result. Warm cosy home = lots of chilling, watching TV, gaming. Cold homes = keep moving to keep warm.

limitedperiodonly · 02/10/2022 17:04

It's not that crazy - keeping warm does indeed burn a lot of calories. But it's not a good life plan. It's miserable to be cold all the time and unhealthy too. Deaths shoot up in the winter and the main casualties are the elderly because when we get older our bodies get weaker and vulnerable to infections and we often don't realise it.

It is possible to live in a comfortable temperature and also watch your diet and barring disability, be physically active.

Your granny is still alive so I guess she's probably between 70 and 90 give or take. I'd be advising her to turn the heating on when it's cold if she can afford it for her best chance of reaching that telegram from the King.

We should respect the elderly - it's my ambition to be an old lady one day and I'll be trying to achieve it by turning the heating on when necessary and nodding and smiling when people say silly things.

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 17:02

kateandme · 02/10/2022 16:45

God we used to have lamb chops every week.how depressing they were once a cheap meat.and then sat there at the end of the meal all us kids with our plates tilted to get the fatty mince sauce gravy remains! Oh how shocking.😆

Lamb chops are quite a treat nowadays! YY to mint-sauced infused gravy and tilted plates!

Darhon · 02/10/2022 17:02

Definitely been shown that being colder burns fat. I’ll need to look it up unless someone already has. It’s one of the contributing factors including processed food, use of cars, use of tech reducing physical activity.

Lorrymum · 02/10/2022 17:00

Im 64 and remember the dreadful diet available during the 70s after the introduction of freezers to the masses. My Mum loved hers and we were fed a diet of frozen chips, burgers and ice creams in a multitude of colours. Sugar filled fruit squash didn't help. She was also a huge fan Harveys Duo cans, with slimy spaghetti one end and spaghetti sauce the other. Also Vesta packet meals, (I think they still exist) were big favourites.
My sister and I were skinny little waifs despite the calories. We walked everywhere and ice inside the windows every morning during winter was normal.

OrangePumpkinLobelia · 02/10/2022 16:54

LuluBlakey1 · 02/10/2022 14:57

Many people eat utter crap- watch the hordes get off planes at Newcastle airport at the end of holidays. In the middle of the night they walk out of the arrivals channel and 50% go straight into Greggs to buy carrier bags of hot , greasy crap at 3am.
This week I have been working in a secondary school and at the end of the day (3 days) have gone to the local Co-op at the request of the manager because he thinks the kids misbehave. I didn't think they were badly behaved but I was horrified to see what teenagers were buying at the end of the school day to eat on the way home- family packs of crisps, boxes of 10 flap jacks, 10 chocolate cornflake cakes, packets of 6 croissants, 6 muffins, big bottles of fizzy drinks. Not to share, each. I walked back with a group of boys one afternoon part of the way back to the school and they told me they buy something like that every day on the way home and eat it all before they get home. I was astonished.
I am 43. We NEVER had takeaways delivered when I was growing up. My dad went and collected fish and chips occasionally on Fridays for our tea but that was it. I never had a takeaway until I was at university. I have still never had a Macdonald's. People order delivered food all the time now.

I highly recommend getting yourself to a McDonalds! Big Mac and Big Tasty are truly food of the gods IMO.

It's not scientific but I lived for 2 years in a location that was insanely cold in winter. very limited heating as well and regular blackouts. I recall sitting in our kitchen because at 4 degrees it was warmer than the sitting room thanks to being able to turn on the hob. Walked to work which took circa 40 mins in the winter due to being careful on the icy footpaths.

I lost 3 stone the first winter I was there. despite not consciously dieting, loading up on gorgeous lovely nescafe 3 in 1 packets (coffee, dry milk and sugar in a packet) and eating loads of dumpling and meat (plus booze).

Anecdata I will admit but I recall it very well!

Trulyweird1 · 02/10/2022 16:52

I am in Scotland. We are fatter on average than the rest of the UK, and it’s cold.
🤷🏻‍♀️

Runmybathforme · 02/10/2022 16:52

When I think back to my childhood in the 60s, nobody snacked and we walked everywhere, not many people had cars. Children walked to school , I walked it four times a day as I went home for lunch.

BeyondMyWits · 02/10/2022 16:51

Choice helps make us fat. For instance, people will choose 4 a buffet with 5 or 6 things

erikbloodaxe · 02/10/2022 16:46

Aye the constant chest infections and bronchitis I suffered living in a cold house as a child certainly helped keep me underweight.

kateandme · 02/10/2022 16:45

Emotionalsupportviper · 02/10/2022 16:34

If you are a fan of Barbara Pym you will find people (of both sexes) in her novels dining on a small lamb chop, a single tomato and some lettuce, or one poached egg on toast for their main meal.

That's barely a starter in this house . . .

God we used to have lamb chops every week.how depressing they were once a cheap meat.and then sat there at the end of the meal all us kids with our plates tilted to get the fatty mince sauce gravy remains! Oh how shocking.😆

oakleaffy · 02/10/2022 16:42

Goatinthegarden · 02/10/2022 16:34

5000 calories seems a bit extreme. I just cycled 75km and it took just shy of four hours. My fitness tracker reckons that burned about 1500cals.

I walked 14km over the course of the day yesterday and that only burned 758 ‘active calories’.

I had a job as a cycle messenger {Teenager} one winter, and 50 miles was the average distance we did each day in all weathers..I was always starving, so much so I wondered if I had a tapeworm..Literally couldn't keep weight on.

ThomasinaGallico · 02/10/2022 16:42

If you’re active enough it all adds up. 758 calories (almost certainly an overestimate if you’re a small woman rather than the mythical average man these estimates are based on) is a generous sensible meal’s worth. Conversely once you get past a certain age, if you’re sedentary it becomes very difficult to keep your calories low enough not to gain weight but your micronutrients high enough to avoid deficiency.

Piglet89 · 02/10/2022 16:39

Ultra processed food. That’s why we are fat.

www.waterstones.com/book/why-we-eat-too-much/dr-andrew-jenkinson/9780241400531

Goatinthegarden · 02/10/2022 16:34

Brigante9 · 02/10/2022 16:06

I read something about everyone needing 5000 calories due to having to walk everywhere back in the day. There wasn’t the easy availability of sweets, kids played out in the street more-I was biking, climbing trees, walked a fair distance to school.

5000 calories seems a bit extreme. I just cycled 75km and it took just shy of four hours. My fitness tracker reckons that burned about 1500cals.

I walked 14km over the course of the day yesterday and that only burned 758 ‘active calories’.

Emotionalsupportviper · 02/10/2022 16:34

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 16:28

If you ever watch a film, documentary or book describing eating out in post war Britain you would be amazed at how small plates and portions were. (Even accounting for rationing)

A common starter used to be a glass of orange juice, or a slice of melon.

I was looking at the calories on the menu at a chain pub recently and was shocked to see some of the starters were over 1000 calories each!

If you are a fan of Barbara Pym you will find people (of both sexes) in her novels dining on a small lamb chop, a single tomato and some lettuce, or one poached egg on toast for their main meal.

That's barely a starter in this house . . .

RosesAndHellebores · 02/10/2022 16:34

All those saying they never saw their grandmother's sit down, whilst I agree with that, I leave the house at 8am and get home often after 8pm doing a mentally challenging role but admit I sit on my backside all day and have a parking space 50 years from my office! First thing I do when I get home isnto pour a glass of wine.

Grannie, however, drove a tractor, rode almost every day and mucked out stables. She did not however cook much but loved sweets, cake and chocolate. She was stout and short and had such a large bosom instead of using a bread board, she rested the loaf on her bosom and cut slices of bread onto the breadboard away from herself. I recall she always needed a size 16/18 and was barely 5'.

TheSimpleLife88 · 02/10/2022 16:34

It's definitely a factor biology wise. If you are cold your metabolism increases to generate more body heat. If you are sat in a warm room you don't lose as much body heat to the environment. However, there's also other factors like how you crave more energy dense foods in winter to balance out the fact you are burning more calories to keep warm. Whereas in summer your appetite decreases and you eat more salads etc because you don't need as many calories to keep warm.
Your body shape is also important. Tall skinny people have a bigger surface area to volume ratio which means they lose more body heat - good in summer, bad in the cold. Whereas in colder climates it's beneficial to be rounded with a smaller surface area:volume so you don't lose too much body heat.
It's a very complicated, multifaceted issue but ultimately if you don't burn enough calories through exercise (or keeping warm!) compared to what you eat then you will put on weight.

oakleaffy · 02/10/2022 16:34

HebeSunshine · 02/10/2022 14:31

I think she’s right, along with lack of movement. When I was a kid we never had a car and we walked miles and miles, nowadays it’s just too easy to get in the car to drive a couple of miles down the road.

We walked 1.5 miles to school and back each day. It was rare to get a lift.
Snacking was almost unheard of in 1970's..If there was a 'Snack', it was a slice of bread and butter with marmite, none of the sugary stuff or crisps. {At least not in our house} We were all whip thin.

PixellatedPixie · 02/10/2022 16:33

Even in very warm countries where no heating of any kind is ever required, people have still gotten fatter. I think Mexico has one of the highest obesity rates in the world.

CryingInTents · 02/10/2022 16:32

CheezePleeze · 02/10/2022 16:29

@CryingInTents they've always been the same so I doubt it.

I’m mystified now then, why have the numbers increased?!

Georgeskitchen · 02/10/2022 16:31

There is probably some truth in what your grandma says but the top and bottom of it is that people are overweight because they eat too much. Simple really!!