Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to consider my grandma’s theory on why we’re all fatter?

267 replies

bagelbreath · 02/10/2022 14:20

My grandma swears up and down that although food and movement are obviously big factors to the massive weight gain of the country, heating is also very important.

While she lived in a cold house, wore stockings and dresses year round, and spent a lot of time outside, we all sit toasty in our well heated and insulated houses. Her theory is that it took lots of energy to stay warm then vs now.

Is it crazy? I kind of think it makes sense

OP posts:
LaDamaDeElche · 03/10/2022 19:35

I was a child in the 80's and a teen in the 90's and there were loads of overweight people around, especially in the 80's. People look younger than they did then (especially when we're talking the 80's) and people in their 40's, 50's and 60's often look much fitter and more sporty than they ever did. Maybe there are more obese people now, but there seemed to be more overweight people/people who didn't take care of themselves back then.

Grrrrdarling · 03/10/2022 19:32

bagelbreath · 02/10/2022 14:20

My grandma swears up and down that although food and movement are obviously big factors to the massive weight gain of the country, heating is also very important.

While she lived in a cold house, wore stockings and dresses year round, and spent a lot of time outside, we all sit toasty in our well heated and insulated houses. Her theory is that it took lots of energy to stay warm then vs now.

Is it crazy? I kind of think it makes sense

Your grandma is not wrong.
The colder you are the more energy you calories/energy you expend keeping warm/alive.
Google how many calories arctic & Antarctic explorers need to consume. It is insane if not obscene.
A big problem arrises when people can’t consume enough calories/energy, through food to fuel their bodies to compensate for the extra calorie/energy usage & many are struggling to feed themselves right now too.
If you can’t properly fuel your body it will go into starvation mode & critical systems will start to suffer. Yes you’ll initially use up fat reserves to keep your body going but when those reserves run out you are heading down a slippery slope to organ/body damage then starvation.

cavalier · 03/10/2022 19:29

I think lack of labour saving devices got them all moving 👍

Funkyblues101 · 03/10/2022 18:57

And when giving ideas on how to keep warm, no one ever just says, "do ten star jumps," they only ever give ideas on how to keep warm whilst sat on their arses.

RockyReef · 03/10/2022 18:51

Perhaps this is the Tory parties long term plan. Make everyone freeze, those that don't die off will get thinner from.keepong themselves warm thus reducing the pressure on the underfunded NHS from obesity related diseases!

RosesAndHellebores · 03/10/2022 18:20

Good point Toria

Also the shops used to shut at 5pm or 5.30pm and on Sundays.

To the person who said there weren't huge chocolate aisles, no, but there were far more little sweet shops.

When I moved to Putney in 1981 there was one 7-11 on the high street. Sainsbury's opened late on Fridays only. Except for a couple of Indian restaurants there was one restaurant at the bottom of the hill, called La Forchetta and nowhere to get a cup of tea or coffee except for an old fashioned bakers. I used to meet friends at Juliana's in Notting Hill for tea.

Bpdqueen · 03/10/2022 18:15

I blame uber eats and technology

Skodacool · 03/10/2022 18:12

clowerina · 02/10/2022 14:27

I find when I'm cold I eat a lot more comfort food, junk food, high fat food etc to try to stay warm, so I'm not sure that theory rings true.

Back then there simply wasn’t an unlimited supply of food on offer. We ate at mealtimes, very little snacking. There really was very little junk food.

Toria33 · 03/10/2022 18:08

Our frames are much bigger we are not simply fatter. My grandmother was 4ft 11 and I am 5ft 7. My lean body mass is 65kg and I am meant to weigh 65-75kg. My husband has such large lungs, he has to have two taken and blows over a900 peak flow. We are using an out dated system in bodies that are simply more advanced and bigger. Fatter is the wrong term.

BadgeronaMoped · 03/10/2022 18:06

Chocolate "share" bags. They were not about back in the days of no heating, nor were massive aisles of CHOCOLATE.

As dozens of posters have already said Wink

PlntLady · 03/10/2022 18:04

To be fair there is probably something in this. I lived in Canada for a while. I arrived in the summer and noticed ppl were much slimmer there. I thought nothing of it until the -45°C winter hit which lasted from November untill February. I lost A LOT of weight that summer and hadn't adjusted my eating habits at all.

Chuck2015 · 03/10/2022 18:02

I don’t think it’s the main factor but she has a point, imagine going outside to the toilet in the winter with no heating (that’s what my Mum and Dad had to do). We didn’t have full heating until I was about 6 and I feel the cold a lot less than most people and hate being too hot,
keeping warm does take more energy. I never have heating on in the bedroom and wake up starving!

Jojojojojowhat · 03/10/2022 17:58

Think it’s a combination of things. Coldness would have burned more energy, but it’s so much easier to consume excessive calories when processed crap is so widely available.

user1466167893 · 03/10/2022 17:56

I live on a very old house with single glazing. The inside temperature is pretty much the outside temperature. I've only put on weight since living here. So, no, I don't think she's right otherwise I'd be able to fit into my jeans 😂😂

Lunar270 · 03/10/2022 07:36

I think you literally need to be shivering in order burn significant calories so don't think granny's theory holds up, even if a large proportion of food intake goes into keeping the body at an even temperature.

Most likely processed foods. I think it's been debunked that we are less active now than in the past and exercise doesn't burn that much anyway.

Weight is all lost in the kitchen (medical conditions aside) so is most likely down to our diets. Too many ready meals and processed crap that's full of fillers/sugar to make them cheap. Sadly it hits the poor disproportionately, hence the larger numbers of obese.

EbbyEbs · 03/10/2022 07:32

There are a lot of factors. For one thing they would never have popped out for a McDonald’s in those days, they wouldn’t have ordered a takeaway on a Saturday night. They wouldn’t have stopped off at Starbucks whilst doing their grocery shopping like folk do these days.

On top of this, they walked everywhere. There was no 5 minute drive to the local coop - it would have been a half hour walk.

Id say this stuff is a bigger contributing factor than the heating

Totalityloss · 03/10/2022 07:18

Freedomfromguilt · 02/10/2022 15:08

Portion sizes. My MIL's dinner plate which date from her 1966 wedding are the same size as my side plates.

I think this is one of the factors. Crisp packets are those massive ‘grab bags’ now. A cake is a massive muffin, not a little fairy cake.

And lack of movement. People drive everywhere. And being busy. Before I had kids I was a smug arse who walked or cycled everywhere. Now I am a working parent I drive as time is my most precious commodity. I just don’t have the time to walk or cycle. Those are now leisure pursuits, not my mode of travel.

Goatinthegarden · 03/10/2022 03:08

antelopevalley · 03/10/2022 03:00

Read about history of slaves. People did used to need 5000 calories a day but they were working extremely long hours doing heavy physical work like cutting cane sugar. It would be like permanently being in a spin class.

Being a slave is a bit different to granny walking to the market and mopping the floor every day, but yes, I can believe someone doing forced hard labour every day might need more calories.

antelopevalley · 03/10/2022 03:00

Read about history of slaves. People did used to need 5000 calories a day but they were working extremely long hours doing heavy physical work like cutting cane sugar. It would be like permanently being in a spin class.

Goatinthegarden · 03/10/2022 02:48

ThomasinaGallico · 02/10/2022 16:42

If you’re active enough it all adds up. 758 calories (almost certainly an overestimate if you’re a small woman rather than the mythical average man these estimates are based on) is a generous sensible meal’s worth. Conversely once you get past a certain age, if you’re sedentary it becomes very difficult to keep your calories low enough not to gain weight but your micronutrients high enough to avoid deficiency.

758 was the burn for the whole day, not the actual walking. I took a fast paced walk into and around town, totalling 14km and am pointing out that if a a person of yore was regularly walking those distances daily, they wouldn’t burn anywhere near enough to be able to eat 5000calories a day.

My point was that people overestimate how much they can eat after a little bit of exercise. A walk like that is very much only a little bit of sedate exercise, but it is considered exceptional by many people now.

Sleeplessinthesouth71 · 03/10/2022 01:20

For me I think the biggest driver is stress.

antelopevalley · 03/10/2022 00:55

I agree. It is easy to consume a huge amount of calories from snacks every day even healthy ones.

MangyInseam · 03/10/2022 00:48

I do think snacking, and it's from tiny kids who seem to be stuffed constantly, is huge.

I'm sure a factor with that was the pushing of the idea that it was better to snack and graze all day, which was popular when I was around 10 or so.

In a lot of countries no one snacks much, if there are snacks they are social and planned regular ones where there is a gap between meals. Kids stop snacking a lot younger too.

CheezePleeze · 03/10/2022 00:09

Even eating cheap crap won't make you fat as long as you don't eat too much of it, stop the constant snacking and take plenty of exercise.

Almost every single overweight person I know eats an awful lot of food but they probably don't think they do, if they're comparing it to the people around them who eat even more.

GooglyEyeballs · 03/10/2022 00:04

I think a big contributing factor is that everyone is so burnt out they don't have time to keep fit and learn how to cook healthily and so many people are depressed, motivating ourselves is harder! But lots of factors come in to play and those are only two.