Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to consider my grandma’s theory on why we’re all fatter?

267 replies

bagelbreath · 02/10/2022 14:20

My grandma swears up and down that although food and movement are obviously big factors to the massive weight gain of the country, heating is also very important.

While she lived in a cold house, wore stockings and dresses year round, and spent a lot of time outside, we all sit toasty in our well heated and insulated houses. Her theory is that it took lots of energy to stay warm then vs now.

Is it crazy? I kind of think it makes sense

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 04/10/2022 11:14

Housework used to burn calories, raking out a fire and bringing fresh coal in is hard work, busses were inaccessible if you had a child in a pram so you either walked with a pram or caught the bus carrying a child. Washing involved getting a washer out or using a tub with a wash board.

Also cleaning carpets and rugs used to involve hanging them on the line and beating them as opposed to running a hoover over them.

pigcon1 · 04/10/2022 11:00

Also about processed food and eating outside the house.

Solonge · 04/10/2022 10:57

FourTeaFallOut · 02/10/2022 14:32

Then it makes sense….colder climes…you shiver more thus using calories…

TheGoodFighter · 04/10/2022 10:42

FourTeaFallOut · 02/10/2022 14:32

That agrees with the OP's idea, it doesn't negate it!

sashh · 04/10/2022 10:40

Have a look at the footage of people watching the Apollo lift offs, they are all thin.

I don't think it's one thing.

More people had manual jobs, my dad worked for a grocer when he left school, there were no packets of sugar or butter, they got them in bulk and my dad had to learn to pack them up.

Children walked to school and back.

We had mass migration from the commonwealth and one of the benefits was we were introduced to loads of new food but we didn't start to eat dahl, no we learned to fry plantain and add chips to curry and rice.

Housework used to burn calories, raking out a fire and bringing fresh coal in is hard work, busses were inaccessible if you had a child in a pram so you either walked with a pram or caught the bus carrying a child. Washing involved getting a washer out or using a tub with a wash board.

Keeping warm does use more calories but it is only one of many things.

laurzf1 · 04/10/2022 10:11

Trying to keep your body warm would need energy but being too cold can lead to strokes and heart attacks in vulnerable people so I wouldn't recommend it.

KimberleyClark · 04/10/2022 10:07

RIPWalter · 04/10/2022 08:56

The thinest I've ever been was when I was windsuring regularly all through the Welsh winter, as that's when the wind and waves are most consistent. Mild hypothermia 2 or 3 times a week is a very effective diet!!!

The thinnest I’ve ever been was in my 20s during the 80s. Winters were a lot less mild then, I’d go to work with 4 layers on - t shirt, blouse, jumper or suit jacket, and an overcoat. Offices were not overheated and not full of machinery then. I retired three years ago, by then offices were so overheated you couldn’t wear winter clothes in winter!

fatchilli123 · 04/10/2022 09:57

In my grandma's days . Everybody walked wore thick clothes used brooms to do steps . Had manual jobs . We don't need the calories they did just to live

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 04/10/2022 09:08

Dh and I visited Prague over 20 years ago, where an American fellow tourist couldn’t believe how slim the people were despite the food being (as she called it) ‘unhealthy’. (A lot of meat, potatoes and dumplings, not much veg or salad at all.).
But as I pointed out, most people didn’t have cars, so walked a lot, and there was no fast food to speak of - people presumably mostly cooked from scratch.

At least 15 years previously we’d visited the US for the first time and been startled to see so many really grossly fat people - at the time you saw very few in the U.K. But there was fast food everywhere - and huge portions of it.

RIPWalter · 04/10/2022 08:56

ByeByeMissAmericanPie · 04/10/2022 08:37

I spent a month in sub arctic conditions in my 20s. Wore thermals but also ate 3 good meals a day, and a couple of mini mars bars. Lost a stone. I joke it was the best diet I’ve ever been on!

The thinest I've ever been was when I was windsuring regularly all through the Welsh winter, as that's when the wind and waves are most consistent. Mild hypothermia 2 or 3 times a week is a very effective diet!!!

Noviembre · 04/10/2022 08:46

People really gonna convince themselves it's their socks while chucking another 600cal muffin down their faces.

ByeByeMissAmericanPie · 04/10/2022 08:37

I spent a month in sub arctic conditions in my 20s. Wore thermals but also ate 3 good meals a day, and a couple of mini mars bars. Lost a stone. I joke it was the best diet I’ve ever been on!

Solonge · 04/10/2022 08:23

Scientifically the ball is in your grans corner. When we are cold we shiver....shivering uses calories. Being cold your body has to work harder to keep your core warm, so there is truth in her beliefs. The calorie load of course has to balance the exercise and movement, ie calories out, or we put on weight. Food was largely unprocessed previously....now, unless you are buying decent meat (ie not tampered with.....water injected or hormone fed) and fresh veg...... then its difficult to sometimes count calories.

Abra1t · 04/10/2022 08:01

There’s an article in today’s Times saying that cold temperatures increase brown fat, which burns more calories.

Cold at home? That could be good for you

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/a1971386-432d-11ed-abc9-d0d53e948d21?shareToken=4118509650047f05b34c638ec5ab5f72

pd339 · 04/10/2022 07:19

It's basic science, and obviously true.

Hagpie · 04/10/2022 03:24

I work at a place that is kept at 1-2°C and there are loads of larger people working there. Extra insulation is an advantage after all!

Eeksteek · 03/10/2022 22:12

I believe mammals use something insane like 90% of their calories to maintain body temperature. Which is why lizards etc can eat once a month. But humans modify their environment more than most mammals, even in Ye Olde Dayes. I think she has a point, but UPFs, snacking and general sedentary lifestyle has a lot to answer for, too.

I’ve always wondered if I could lose weight by being cold, but I hate being cold SO much, I’d rather be a bit plump than find out!

Lulibee · 03/10/2022 22:04

I think she is partially correct. There were less labour savings devices and more reliance upon walking and public transport. A lot less sitting around as everything took a lot longer to do as well as the need to keep warm. But I think it’s mainly down to far less reliance upon fast food - take-always and ready meals. Home made food was tasty but it didn’t have all the additives that drive us to eat too much.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 03/10/2022 21:41

It’s the snacking culture. People used to have 3 balanced meals a day. No snacks.
plus life was harder, carrying washing to the washouse, scrubbing floors and steps by hand, walking or cycling everywhere, kids played outside exercising all day when it was safe to do so. Food wasn’t processed.

ArtOfTheImpossible · 03/10/2022 20:17

If your grandmother is correct we'll have cured the obesity epidemic by next Easter OP.

Every cloud has a silver lining and all that...

Beautiful3 · 03/10/2022 20:04

I grew up without heating and had to wear dresses too. I was an over weight child. I wasn't allowed to play out, and ate sweets/crisps/chocolates. I honestly think too many kids aren't allowed to play out, or prefer to play on their consoles. Sedentary movement coupled with junk food/energy drinks are to blame for obesity.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 03/10/2022 19:56

I think your Gran was right, The house I grew up in had no heating or double glazing apart from a fire in the living room, using the emersion heater was a performance, but the first thing we did when we moved into a similar house was put in central heating, hot water and double glazing. When it broke down one February, the cold felt punishing but I'd been more than used to it growing up.

I also think its to do with being more time poor than people were in her day.

There's more things to do, both as leisure and as work and we have to all fit a lot more into the day, so we use more appliances, convenience food, one-stop supermarkets instead of frequent visits to six different shops on the high street and driving/transport rather than walking etc...

DahliasLove · 03/10/2022 19:50

clowerina · 02/10/2022 14:30

I also wonder if it is a generational thing. for example, my grandparents (war children) really pushed "treat" foods on us as children. They were deprived with rationing, poverty etc so they wanted to make sure we never went without. Without realising the true impact of this. E.g. crisps, chocolate etc to the max to "spoil" their children and grandchildren. The impact of this is people are more accustomed to junk food. Not to mention all the advertising, glorification of food in our society.

I have similar theories about generational impact on eating and food. My grandparents were young adults during the war, and my parents born just after. I was forced, and I mean I was literally not allowed to move from my seat until I finished every single thing on my plate. Probably because sometimes they wouldn’t know when they were next going to eat and how much.

But yeah, there goes my intuitive knowing of when I’m full.

LadyAstor · 03/10/2022 19:43

Junk food and the proliferation of it.

Massive weight gain started in the 1980s.

When junk food was made available to native Americans, they suddenly had a weight problem, whereas, prior to the introduction of junk food, they were a normal weight.

Sugar - white and deadly. There's a book about it.

antelopevalley · 03/10/2022 19:39

Smoking used to be very common.

Swipe left for the next trending thread