Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mental health issues. Am I being unsympathetic?

170 replies

PurpleSky300 · 02/10/2022 13:51

I feel afraid to say how I’m feeling ‘’in real life’ so I thought I would put it here.
Essentially, there are three young men in my family (aged 25-32) who have long-standing problems with depression. They are skilled, talented people but they have struggled with keeping jobs, have drifted from their friends, rarely leave the house. They are well supported by their parents.

What I struggle with is that somewhere along the line, this has become ‘normal.’ In the sense that nobody expects it to change, it’s the status quo, it has gone on for years and if you ask any of them about things like hobbies / applying for jobs / plans to leave home / friendships or anything that might help them move on, they get angry and you get attacked for not ‘understanding’.

I’ve never had severe depression so maybe they’re right, I don’t fully understand. And whenever I try, it seems I’m always saying the wrong thing or verging away from what’s expected. The truth is what I see from the ‘outside’ is just… complacency, loss of hope, a whole bunch of adults so frightened of saying the wrong thing that they’ve accepted a ‘new normal’ that couldn’t be further from normal.

We are a very plain-speaking Northern family and I don’t understand how supporting someone with MH issues came to mean – tiptoeing around them / never challenging them / never speaking your mind for fear of what they might do. It’s a strange claustrophobic situation and I don’t know what to do for the best. Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
BBBBMushroom · 03/10/2022 01:47

Sorry @PurpleSky300 I missed the post about therapy and medication so they must have a diagnosis. It could be the incorrect diagnosis mine was.

BBBBMushroom · 03/10/2022 01:43

I have serious MH issues diagnosed and have been in a treatment programme for years now. I actually agree with you about enabling. My DH forced me in to the treatment programme as I didn’t want to go. I would be dead by now or enduring the living death like state I was in still.

Have they been formally diagnosed at any point? Because if they haven’t then there are assumptions being made. There does seem to be a rising number of young people mainly males that just do nothing and their parents are petrified of upsetting them in any way. They can also have a life online. I used to know someone whose son did just what those lads in your family are doing. There was nothing wrong with him he was just lazy but she was so scared of upsetting him because he had threatened her and there was a lot of guilt about various situations.

Do they game a lot by any chance all night and then sleep in the day?

LonelyPlanett · 03/10/2022 00:06

OP, if you were my family member, I'd appreciate your input and any ideas. It's a very lonely place to be. I do understand the defensiveness of the parents as you feel like you have failed.

LonelyPlanett · 03/10/2022 00:01

I'm in this boat. DD is 23 and has autism and severe mental health issues. She is mostly at home. I've tried honestly everything. She takes medication which does help, but otherwise we fight a daily battle with OCD and anxiety. She wants very much to go out and live her life but somehow can't. Almost every possible local organisation/Adult Mental Health team has tried to help. More referrals are currently going in to various places. I just keep on trying. It's very very worrying.

PurpleSky300 · 03/10/2022 00:01

BatshitBanshee · 02/10/2022 23:02

Because you asked - you asked for opinions and I've given an opinion to you, if you don't like it then that's a you-problem.

Why on earth would my OP have given anybody 'chills', I'm not a serial killer.

You can't see why your POV about people with mental illness could be chilling reading for other people with mental illness? Chilling is another person's opinion and their feelings. The fact that your so dismissive of that and even tossing it aside because you're "not a serial killer" demonstrates that you have your measure of things and you're unwilling to see it from anyone else's side.

You call me 'dismissive' and yet you have no problem telling me what is and isn't my business, to butt out etc

Because your language to PPs who disagree is dismissive. Anyone who has disagreed with you here has been met with boxed-cat like reactions when you have asked for opinions. Were you hoping to create a merry band of mental illness bashers or asking for genuine opinions?

when you have no idea of my relationship to these men

Because you haven't furnished anyone with that information because, I suspect, you'd be told to butt out further.

Take your own advice, hypocrite.

I didn't ask for my advice, I didn't ask for your advice - you came to a public forum and asked for opinions. If you didn't get entirely what you were looking for and you don't quite understand why, I suggest you familiarise yourself with the landscape of internet advice forums.

There are posters here who have disagreed with my OP or asked questions in a reasonable way, and I do value their input. Others have immediately 'gone on the attack', made a ton of assumptions and been utterly rude. I wasn't bashing my family, I was looking for advice to help people I love - which for a few people here seems to boil down to "don't bother, butt out and f* off". Fair enough, but it's a strange thing to hear from people who claim to have compassion for others.

OP posts:
pattihews · 02/10/2022 23:39

OP, for a few years when I was young I lived in a flat above a lovely women who turned out to have bi-polar disorder and who had several manic cycles in the three or four years I knew her. She did and said terrible things to me and others when she was manic, including phoning up at night and saying she was at our doors with a knife and was going to break in and kill us. (That was usually the point at which the police intervened and she was sectioned). When she was stable again afterwards she'd apologise profusely and give us flowers and tell us that mental health issues didn't give her the right to behave like a c**t. It's a lesson that some others have still to learn.

There are people on this thread who've experienced poor mental health and understand what you're saying and acknowledge the strain within a family when one person's mental health problems affect everyone around them, including those on the periphery watching the drama unfold. They're the ones to heed.

Abcdefgh1234 · 02/10/2022 23:30

You and i in the same condition op. My step sister is teenager with depression and bipolar. I’m so annoyed with her and everything i said its just wrong to her. maybe she is right i never have any depression so i dont understand but i feel sometimes she doesn’t even try.

At one point i just so fed up with her and now i just not talking to here often anymore. I just give up now

hamstersarse · 02/10/2022 23:20

yanbu op

its obvious you are correct

that hurts people’s feelings but the truth can hurt

Things have gone very wrong when so many physically healthy young adults are living like this. It’s surely obvious to anyone

BatshitBanshee · 02/10/2022 23:02

PurpleSky300 · 02/10/2022 22:09

Why on earth would my OP have given anybody 'chills', I'm not a serial killer. You call me 'dismissive' and yet you have no problem telling me what is and isn't my business, to butt out etc - when you have no idea of my relationship to these men. Take your own advice, hypocrite.

Because you asked - you asked for opinions and I've given an opinion to you, if you don't like it then that's a you-problem.

Why on earth would my OP have given anybody 'chills', I'm not a serial killer.

You can't see why your POV about people with mental illness could be chilling reading for other people with mental illness? Chilling is another person's opinion and their feelings. The fact that your so dismissive of that and even tossing it aside because you're "not a serial killer" demonstrates that you have your measure of things and you're unwilling to see it from anyone else's side.

You call me 'dismissive' and yet you have no problem telling me what is and isn't my business, to butt out etc

Because your language to PPs who disagree is dismissive. Anyone who has disagreed with you here has been met with boxed-cat like reactions when you have asked for opinions. Were you hoping to create a merry band of mental illness bashers or asking for genuine opinions?

when you have no idea of my relationship to these men

Because you haven't furnished anyone with that information because, I suspect, you'd be told to butt out further.

Take your own advice, hypocrite.

I didn't ask for my advice, I didn't ask for your advice - you came to a public forum and asked for opinions. If you didn't get entirely what you were looking for and you don't quite understand why, I suggest you familiarise yourself with the landscape of internet advice forums.

PurpleSky300 · 02/10/2022 22:09

BatshitBanshee · 02/10/2022 21:36

"Chills"? Nonsense.

This response to a PP @PurpleSky300 tells me everything I need to know about how you view other people's mindframes and feelings, you're dismissive. YABU and quite frankly, it's none of your business to be frustrated with these men or challenging anyone. Butt out. You have no understanding and quite obviously, you don't want to have any understanding.

Why on earth would my OP have given anybody 'chills', I'm not a serial killer. You call me 'dismissive' and yet you have no problem telling me what is and isn't my business, to butt out etc - when you have no idea of my relationship to these men. Take your own advice, hypocrite.

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 02/10/2022 21:50

Regular people are scared and worried and not trained to deal with depression, so they just want to make life easier for a family member whose struggling.

Yes, @KILM, we have this situation in DH’s family. One person is supported and buoyed up by other family members, but the underlying issues aren’t really addressed, because no one knows what to do. Adults can choose whether to engage with medical services, and if they don’t, their family just don’t know what to do.

BatshitBanshee · 02/10/2022 21:36

"Chills"? Nonsense.

This response to a PP @PurpleSky300 tells me everything I need to know about how you view other people's mindframes and feelings, you're dismissive. YABU and quite frankly, it's none of your business to be frustrated with these men or challenging anyone. Butt out. You have no understanding and quite obviously, you don't want to have any understanding.

AegeanBlue · 02/10/2022 21:23

I can’t quite believe I’m saying this but in this situation I think it might be worth looking at Jordan Peterson. He has strong messaging for young men as to how to get out of depressive holes. Perhaps have a look at some of his videos on YouTube and see whether it might resonate with any of them?

ddl1 · 02/10/2022 21:04

While I can't speak for individuals, I think it very unlikely that most people with serious life restrictions caused by illness, mental or physical, think it's 'normal'. Even if they are so isolated that they are not much exposed to their real-life contemporaries, they will usually be exposed to others' lives through TV, the internet and social media, and will realize that others have more varied lives than they do. Being unable to change, or to change as much as others, or even themselves, would think desirable, does not mean that they think that their lives are normal.

Teenyliving · 02/10/2022 20:48

Are all three children in the house not working and living a reduced life OP? Are there other children? Do the parents work?

PurpleSky300 · 02/10/2022 20:19

AmInormallk · 02/10/2022 18:19

Trust me - they do NOT like living like this. This post is giving me chills, tbh

OP you say this - I don’t understand how supporting someone with MH issues came to mean – tiptoeing around them / never challenging them
What you mean by challenging them? That word 'challenging' borders on very dangerous ground and I feel concerned - What exactly are you challenging them about?

When you say they are 'well supported' by their family, - what exactly does this mean?

You sound frustrated with the whole situation - on a daily basis - how does their condition affect your life - are you providing care and support, yourself?

"Chills"? Nonsense.

They are well-supported in that they have loving parents, who have helped them to get therapy and medication and given them anything that might help them. One parent gave up their job to look after their DS. They have bent over backwards to do the right thing.

If I sound frustrated, perhaps because part of that is because I do hear a lot from the parents about their own situation and the impact on them and am somewhere 'in the middle' of the parents and the sons - a situation where everyone seems tired, stressed, worn out and complaining but can't work up the nerve to say it to each other, so it goes on and on.

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 02/10/2022 19:34

@LadybirdsAreNeverHappy, a question for you. How would you cope as the ageing parent of three children who spend their days at home in their rooms, playing video games and expecting three meals a day in their 20s and 30s and doing nothing to get help? What about the lives of their parents? Why do you have so little sympathy for the rest of the family?

totally agree with this @LadybirdsAreNeverHappy

its not just the young people’s health and wellness that matters

Overthinker2022 · 02/10/2022 19:12

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 02/10/2022 15:46

So what exactly is it you are saying here, do you think the parents are making their sons illnesses worse by supporting them in the wrong way?
Do you know what diagnoses they have and what treatment they have had/ are receiving?
They are all adults, how much do you actually know about their personal lives?
You clearly have no understanding about depression and yet you’re the expert on what they’re capable of and how their parents should handle the situation?
Why is it that you feel you have to go around “challenging” them about their personal situation?
What do you think you can do here? Just keep on at them about how you know better than they do what they should be doing with their lives? What will that accomplish?
YABU. It doesn’t sound like anyone has asked for your help or opinion. The thing to do would be to leave them alone.

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy you say YABU to OP but I feel YABU with your passive-aggressive questioning and, quite frankly, rude and confrontational tone to your post.

The irony here is that this abrupt and rude tone to take could very well contribute to a human being's declining MH, be it IRL or on the Internet.

Badlydrawnhuman · 02/10/2022 19:12

Even if you could get them to go anywhere, they wouldn't enjoy it. I was like this. I made a huge effort and got myself a part time job. One horrible colleague asked me one day "why on earth did someone like you apply for a job? " so I obviously wasn't coming across as normal. I was good at my job, it was data entry, but I couldn't make chit chat. In the toilets one day, I heard someone say, "is the weirdo in? She's a loner isn't she? Billy no mates". Imagine how that made me feel? It made me worse. You can't just suddenly "act normal".

KILM · 02/10/2022 19:11

Yourstory · 02/10/2022 18:04

I can see both sides. I have a lot of empathy for those with mental health issues.

Saying that, I think SOMETIMES the issue is that because they are men with mental health issues that being helpless is enabled. This in the long run makes the situation worse. If they were women who were single primary caregivers the chances are no matter how bad they felt they would have no other choice to get ok with it, and so they would. If not their children would end up in care and the majority of mothers would turn the universe upside down before that happened.

Of course there are other issues such as undiagnosed autism ect. But I think this is a big one.

Agree with this.
Regular people are scared and worried and not trained to deal with depression, so they just want to make life easier for a family member whose struggling. Its so hard to try and seek help when you are depressed, and its an awful disease that can make you appear lazy and selfish and manipulative. But we dont do ANYONE any good by pretending gender doesnt factor in here. By not looking closer at the root of the issue we could be missing ways to help these people, missing another way society lets men and women down through deeply entrenched patriarchy and shit mental health support. Enabling behaviours are a thing. Its a thing with families of addicts. Its a thing with families of binge eaters. Its a thing with diabetics who eat crap and end up affecting their sugars. Its people who arent trained professionals doing their best with what they know for a loved one. And that loved one is coping how they know how. Both parties need support. Proper support and advice. And the general public are not professionals and most people will be hurt if you point out that their son is out 7 nights a week partying but threatens to kill himself if you ask him to enter the dishwasher and them saying 'okay il do it' then nothing else happening to follow that up isnt helping, they will understandably be upset. But its true. Its not helping. But we need proper funding, understanding, education and support which sadly will not happen right now in this country.

namechange3394 · 02/10/2022 19:07

RedHelenB · 02/10/2022 19:00

But a person with a broken keg would do physiotherapy, would use crutches to get out and about etc. Yes depression is crippling but it doesn't have to be a life sentence, there is support and medication out there.

Well yes exactly, hence why I said they probably need medication or counselling?

I'm not saying they should be doing nothing but OP wondering why they don't just get a job or make some new friends is rather naïve I think - and expecting them to run before they can walk.

ddl1 · 02/10/2022 19:05

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 02/10/2022 17:34

I know quite a lot of young adults (mostly male) in this situation and it is heartbreaking to see the misery of their lives and their parent's distress. I wonder what these young people would have done in the past, when most people were very poor and all family members had to work. I think they would have found a way to contribute.

What I think, is that most of them would have died young. Life was very uncertain even for the totally physically and mentally healthy; for the less healthy, long survival was unlikely. Even nowadays, people with serious mental health problems have lower life expectancies than those who don't.

There may be some people who would have done better in those days, NOT because if life was made tough enough, they would be forced out of their problems, but because there are some people who have a particular problem with the stress of decision-making, and might have coped better with the life of, for example, outdoor servants, whose lives were hard physically but who were deprived/relieved of much responsibility for making choices. But most would just not have survived.

And of course, in relatively recent times. most people with severe mental illnesses would have been placed in institutions.

BruceHellerAlmighty · 02/10/2022 19:04

ddl1 · 02/10/2022 18:52

If their brain problems make them unable to function, then they're physically unable to do so, just as much as someone with damage to their arms or legs or spine. Some people with diseases such as Alzheimers still have the motor ability to carry out many tasks, but lack the cognitive ability. People with Parkinsons may be able to make certain movements automatically, that they can't intentionally. Anything that affects the brain's function is a physical problem at some level. In any case, withdrawing support or trying to force depressed people to function like non-depressed people is not going to cure them!

I'm sorry but no. They aren't as physically unable to do things. They're mentally unable due to their thought processes. But that is not a physical change, not in the same way that Alzheimer's and dementia are.

Hakunamatata91 · 02/10/2022 19:00

Its a tricky one. I've had severe mental health issues, and when I was really depressed, leaving the house was incredibly hard. I would try force myself out for very short walks and spend those wanting to just sit on the pavement and cry. And believe it or not I'm not a dramatic person- thats just how bad I was feeling. If someone had been asking me about how much I'm going out, or asked questions that highlighted all the areas I was struggling with, that would have made me hate myself even more. I was really lucky in the support I had from friends - they were there for me and supported me without making me feel judged. Eg one got me a gift of a one tray easy cookbook which helped prompt doing some actual cooking. They will know its not normal, pointing it out to them, explicitly or by questioning them, will not in any way help. Equally pretending its normal won't help. I would just try keep any opinions to yourself about the negatives, and encourage any positives you can see.

RedHelenB · 02/10/2022 19:00

namechange3394 · 02/10/2022 18:42

But you're not being very helpful are you? You're suggesting they just go and get a job to "help them move on", when what they probably need is medication and/or counselling.

What you're doing is the equivalent of asking someone with a broken leg why they haven't bothered to go back to the gym yet.

But a person with a broken keg would do physiotherapy, would use crutches to get out and about etc. Yes depression is crippling but it doesn't have to be a life sentence, there is support and medication out there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread