Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What can we as parents do to stop our sons turning into the men we read about on mumsnet daily?

205 replies

Watermelon46 · 02/10/2022 09:39

…….or to teach our daughters not to put up with any of this.

It seems (from posts on here) that so many children are living in toxic environments, with fathers who are man children who are used to their own way and throw their toys out of the pram if they don’t get it, and mothers who appear trapped in this environment.

I see and hear elements of this behaviour from grown men regularly with my friends and my own family, including ourselves, so know it’s not just made up on here.

What can we do to break this cycle?

OP posts:
GarlandsinGreece · 02/10/2022 13:42

I am lucky enough to have had a father who did more than half of the domestic chores. His father, back in the dark ages, told my father that you never know when your spouse will die (cheery, I know) so you need to be able to cook and clean and look after yourself. My father did all the cooking when I was growing up.

My husband does a huge amount of the cooking, and takes his kids places at the weekend, rarely ducks out to play golf for twelve hours or whatever. I work very part-time.

I just don’t recognize the imprint of man often discussed on here, where two people work full-time and the man in the relationship barely lifts a finger. It’s despicable.

alwaysmovingforwards · 02/10/2022 13:41

FiveShelties · 02/10/2022 09:44

The men I know bear no resemblance to posts on here. The women I know would not put up with the behaviour that I read about on here. To be honest I think most of it us made up.

Very much agree.

Often seems like this is a place is a weird parallel universe.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/10/2022 13:40

I know this is tangenital but above all else please ingrain in your daughters particularly the need for them to be financially independent at almost all costs. The road to hell is paved with a nice man who'll 'provide' for his family.

TamzinTotally · 02/10/2022 13:40

Flyingagain · 02/10/2022 12:58

I think feminism has shot itself in the foot by years of denigrating men.

The problem with the "toxic masculinity" narrative is that it gives boys nowhere to go and there is a depressing/derogatory view of masculinity.

It's important to talk positively about maleness, give boys responsibility and teach them they are stronger and need to exercise self control and respect women.

It is a privilege being a man but it also comes with great responsibility.

@Flyingagain

Agree with this. We can call out bad beahviour but I really don’t think it’s our place to try to define masculinity to men/boys anymore than they should be teaching boys about what “healthy” and “toxic” femininity is. I think it’s creating a backlash in the younger generation of males that is going to come out more and more as they get older.

Ive yet to see a boy have a positive reaction or become more respectful of women because of anything “toxic masculinity” or feminism related. In general they get this “screw you you don’t know me” attitude over it.

Watermelon46 · 02/10/2022 13:38

Things that have happened this week which prompted me to write this post:

  1. My female friend (mother of 2 older teenage sons) basically accepts her sons talking to her like dirt. One spoke to her in public in a very derogatory way and I felt sorry for her. Everyone else just went quiet. She seems to accept this behaviour as part and parcel of having sons and has assumed a role of a lesser person.
  2. Another female friend has a son about to start uni. She said “oh he has no idea how to cook, I’m hoping he will find a nice girl to cook for him at uni”😡 And it wasn’t a joke, she was serious.
  3. I went to watch my ds (9) play football yesterday. Some of the dads on the touch line were a disgrace, basically yelling at the kids, getting so angry if their kid miss kicked a ball etc. At one point I had to remind my dh that he was watching the u9 match not the premier league. Lots of talk of “man up” etc. Tried to discuss the effect of this pack type male behaviour on ds and his friends with dh when we got home but it fell on deaf ears as I was apparently over-reacting.
  4. General chat with my friends about the amount of life admin and mental load we take on compared to our dhs and the message this sends to our dc.
OP posts:
DismantledKing · 02/10/2022 13:36

We also owe it to our daughters to teach them not to become the people pleasers that often post on here, having got themselves into a right mess because they can’t ever say ‘no’ to others.

Angelinflipflops · 02/10/2022 13:36

Tamsin, although it is a running theme in my friendship groups, most of my female friends do most of the housework, not all, I don't think it's just mumsnet

APlanetFarFarAway · 02/10/2022 13:35

Teach them to be decent human beings.
To pitch in with chores, to work hard at school, to support or volunteer for charities.
Develop their sense of empathy and accept them for who they are.

TamzinTotally · 02/10/2022 13:34

RoseBucket · 02/10/2022 12:50

Get rid of sayings such as “it’s a boy thing” or “boys will be boys” to justify shit behaviour. Small but important start.

@RoseBucket

Does anyone really say “boys will be boys”? Especially about obviously bad behaviour?

I see people saying that it shouldn’t be said a lot - I’ve never actually heard it said (like ever in my 36 years)

TamzinTotally · 02/10/2022 13:31

Stop reading Mumsnet daily?

But seriously if you read endless complaints on Mumsnet daily your going to come away with a false impression of men and the relationships of men and women. Heck for every woman complaining here that her husband doesn’t pull his weight there’s probably three whose husbands act the exact same way who aren’t bothered by it.
My husband and I don’t do equal housework but then again we don’t do equal paid work either - so to me it ends up equal.

I think ultimately men are going to do what they want to do, because the reality is they have the power to and always will. If we want things to be better for women (in some ways) then we can only improve (some) mens behaviour (not talking criminal stuff here) by showing them how it benefits them. I do worry that some women have become so focused on trying to control men and tell them how to be men that their may be a big backlash if ever men just decide they’ve had enough of being lectured too.

I have 4 sons and 2 daughters and I want all of them to be happy in their skin without being told how to be a boy or girl by either conservative types or by more new age types.

Hawkins001 · 02/10/2022 13:16

Sometimes
I'd guess
It's people's perspectives
It's human psychological perspectives and emotions, e.g. What they think should be
Then their other influences e.g. Tv, films, internet other friends

Basically a cauldron of different types

FluffySocksAndHotChocolate · 02/10/2022 13:03

It not just men though, women can be just as bad! Let's not be sexist.

Zilla1 · 02/10/2022 13:02

Suspect a parent never really knows what their DSs are like, perhaps unless they have a chat with honest ex's of their DS.

SwordToFlamethrower · 02/10/2022 13:02

I've raised a son. He is 18 and living with his girlfriend. Their plan is for him to work and support her while she does university.

I raised him to consider others, look at situations from all angles, speak his mind and value justice and fairness.

I think he is naturally quite empathic so that helped.

I read posts out to DH sometimes and his reaction is to claw at his face and shudder in horror. He grew up with just his mother as his father was an addict and pretty useless. He us a self confessed misandrist and views most men he meets with suspicion. Thinks the world would be a brilliant place if it were run as a matriarchy.

I was once verbally abused in the street by a massive man who was accompanied by his partner/wife and 8 year old son. I said "you should be ashamed of yourself talking like that in front of your child" and his son responded by calling me a cunt who would like to also kick my head in... the woman just looked speechless and a bit terrified to be honest.
I had parked outside my own house and the man in the car behind me wasn't happy he had to indicate and pull out around me.

MintJulia · 02/10/2022 13:02

And I'd just like to point out that despite being a single mum, working full time, with no support from ex, I do not let my son run wild or sit on his XBox all day.

Talk about ignorant generalisations!

Flyingagain · 02/10/2022 12:58

I think feminism has shot itself in the foot by years of denigrating men.

The problem with the "toxic masculinity" narrative is that it gives boys nowhere to go and there is a depressing/derogatory view of masculinity.

It's important to talk positively about maleness, give boys responsibility and teach them they are stronger and need to exercise self control and respect women.

It is a privilege being a man but it also comes with great responsibility.

MintJulia · 02/10/2022 12:58

DS is 14. I require him to tidy his room, sort his own washing, and plan, shop & cook once a week (normally Saturday). Also to say please and thank you, to choose and buy birthday presents and cards for other people himself, and to help me carry food shopping..

Extra tasks for 2023 will be doing his own washing, and cleaning the bath after he uses it.

He already has a little job for a couple of hours on Sunday mornings. He's saving for his school ski trip.

But he's fundamentally kind, which is a good place to start.

Knackeredandstressed · 02/10/2022 12:56

Model the behaviour you'd like your DC to emulate. Encourage but dont "fix" everything for them - offer support but let them work out and discuss their own solutions. Point out unkind or bad behaviour and let them understand repercussions.
I have 2 nephews brought up by supportive hardworking parents, and 2 nephews and a niece whose helicopter parents did everything for them.
2 boys had basic chores from a young age, went to Uni, work, and have a flatshare with friends. Theyve learnt to shop and cook, do their laundry, clean up after themselves, pay bills. The other 3 helicoptered DC (21, 23, 25) can't cook a basic meal, not self reliant, don't hold down any job very long due to apathy and poor timekeeping, no relationships as equal partners. They think the world (or rather bank of mum and dad) owe them a living, and are always on the scrounge for money. When I suggested I'd pay one to do some light gardening work for me he rolled his eyes! Would rather lie in bed all day playinv computer games or our their phone to their mayes. They never learnt or were taught adulting. My DB is pulling his hair out with them but it's the way he and SIL brought up their kids that created the helpless child-like adults. And it's not going to make them attractive to any potential partner!

Raidtheice · 02/10/2022 12:51

Pineappleflowers · 02/10/2022 12:41

Yep. The boys I see in our village who will ‘go bad’ tend to have absent fathers and mothers who’ve had difficult lives, many of whom drink a lot, and they don’t have energy left to bring up their sons properly. It’s easier just to let the boys run riot or sit on Xbox killing things all day. 😭

The Xbox is only 22 years old. There have been problems with ASB and men treating women like shit since the dawn of time.

But yes of course it is the Xbox........

RoseBucket · 02/10/2022 12:50

Get rid of sayings such as “it’s a boy thing” or “boys will be boys” to justify shit behaviour. Small but important start.

sst1234 · 02/10/2022 12:49

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 02/10/2022 12:45

FFS, I've heard it all now! Hmm

Is the truth not progressive enough for you?

Katapolts · 02/10/2022 12:49

Number 1 thing is for them to have a decent dad.

This isn't a problem women can solve.

Men who have dads who are clean, tidy, respectful, hands-on parents grow up thinking this is how to be a man.

UWhatNow · 02/10/2022 12:48

You and your partner must model it. Even if you live apart.

Raidtheice · 02/10/2022 12:47

Agree with leading by example.

My 7YO told us that apparently he is the only child in his class who's dad cooks. 🙄

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 02/10/2022 12:45

Pineappleflowers · 02/10/2022 12:41

Yep. The boys I see in our village who will ‘go bad’ tend to have absent fathers and mothers who’ve had difficult lives, many of whom drink a lot, and they don’t have energy left to bring up their sons properly. It’s easier just to let the boys run riot or sit on Xbox killing things all day. 😭

FFS, I've heard it all now! Hmm