Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What can we as parents do to stop our sons turning into the men we read about on mumsnet daily?

205 replies

Watermelon46 · 02/10/2022 09:39

…….or to teach our daughters not to put up with any of this.

It seems (from posts on here) that so many children are living in toxic environments, with fathers who are man children who are used to their own way and throw their toys out of the pram if they don’t get it, and mothers who appear trapped in this environment.

I see and hear elements of this behaviour from grown men regularly with my friends and my own family, including ourselves, so know it’s not just made up on here.

What can we do to break this cycle?

OP posts:
Softplayhooray · 03/10/2022 21:13

Great question OP! Just from a personal perspective I think trying to talk to girls as much as possible about boundaries, red flags, etc is so valuable. Sounds obvious but my parents never bothered, and tbh while self esteem wasn't an issue, I ended up with guys being able to take advantage simply because I had to work out red flags and various shades of grey for myself via experience.

For boys, with mine I just try to help them with empathy for girls their age (e.g., they know all about periods, how it must feel for a girl if they have an accident at school and so on), we talk a lot about standing up for others and being am advocate (for anyone, not just girls), about how girls can feel unsafe in a way a boy wouldn't in certain situations, and why, and so on. No idea if we are doing the best thing but we are trying and they do often get praise for their helpful and kind behaviour at school.

PollyEsther · 03/10/2022 21:06

Don't have children with men like this.

My ex has substantial influence on DS1 and it undermines absolutely everything that DH and I attempt to teach him. DH is fantastic, the best role model our DC could wish for, and DS1 just wants to emulate his father. Unfortunately, his father is a narcissistic abuser. I was groomed by him and abused by him and somewhat controlled by him for years after we split. DS continues to suffer.

The DC I have with DH are completely different in their attitude. All have been brought up together since DH and I got together when DS1 was tiny (a toddler, he knows no different). Much of this is, I believe, genetic.

So, yeah. Model appropriate behaviour, but also don't procreate with cunts.

Rocketclub · 03/10/2022 21:04

Katapolts · 02/10/2022 12:49

Number 1 thing is for them to have a decent dad.

This isn't a problem women can solve.

Men who have dads who are clean, tidy, respectful, hands-on parents grow up thinking this is how to be a man.

Ok both of mine are buggered then.

I teach both of mine boundaries
saying no
NOT over riding their boundaries to be nice

calling out abusive to us friendships etc

and lots of love and cuddles and animals

no playing on any Xboxes etc lots of board games

IndiGlowie · 03/10/2022 20:58

Cyw2018 · 03/10/2022 16:41

Just back from DD (4) swimming lesson.

Signs throughout the changing room saying not to leave bags/clothes in the cubicle, a lot of people ignore the signs, so you then I have to use them with other peoples stuff in anyway, obviously with no way of knowing if the stuff belongs to someone from the same session or the next session.

So, this evening I chose wrong! As I'm changing DD a women (A Grandmother I presume) starts banging on the door, I ask/tell her she'll need to wait. Next thing I know the 2 boys in her care (Age about 6-7) are lay on the floor looking under the cubicle door and sticking their hands under, no attempt from her to stop them, for all I know she might have been encouraging them. I had to tell them to stop and that their behaviour was not okay.

What hope is their for the safety of women and girls using unisex changing/toilet facilities if this kind of behaviour isn't put in check at an early age by parents and guardians.

So teach your boys acceptable boundaries early please.

I'm amazed the Grandmother didn't tell them off !

Cyw2018 · 03/10/2022 16:41

Just back from DD (4) swimming lesson.

Signs throughout the changing room saying not to leave bags/clothes in the cubicle, a lot of people ignore the signs, so you then I have to use them with other peoples stuff in anyway, obviously with no way of knowing if the stuff belongs to someone from the same session or the next session.

So, this evening I chose wrong! As I'm changing DD a women (A Grandmother I presume) starts banging on the door, I ask/tell her she'll need to wait. Next thing I know the 2 boys in her care (Age about 6-7) are lay on the floor looking under the cubicle door and sticking their hands under, no attempt from her to stop them, for all I know she might have been encouraging them. I had to tell them to stop and that their behaviour was not okay.

What hope is their for the safety of women and girls using unisex changing/toilet facilities if this kind of behaviour isn't put in check at an early age by parents and guardians.

So teach your boys acceptable boundaries early please.

IndiGlowie · 02/10/2022 22:52

Dads gave a part to play too . He warned me about boys and men and their manipulative tricks and about not letting them have their way easily. He said a man will tell a women anything he thinks she wants to hear to get his way sexually. He told me to place a value in myself and never to put up with abuse metal and physical and the front door to the family home would always be open .

JamSandle · 02/10/2022 20:44

The onus isn't on the parents. Its on the individual. Be the best parent you can be. Dont blame yourself for the adult your child may or may not become.

Girls...encourage them to be financially independent and build strong friendships and connections with other women. Build their self-esteem young.

HeadAboveTheParapet · 02/10/2022 20:43

I have teen girls.
When we watch films or movies I bring up poor behaviour and point it out.
Is that really romantic or is it pushing boundaries when the guys won't take no for an answer. I've done this since they were little and they call it out themselves now.
We've watched love island to do the same, so they can see how manipulation works outside the film world.

My family is full of strong gender non confirming women so we model behaviour.
I always say they don't have to be kind or nice to people who push their boundaries.
Trust their instinct and not ignore it to appease social niceties. Instinct is there for a reason.

For boys it's important the are taught the same. If they are into sports talking about the good behaviour of sports stars. Not enabling the hero worship of vile man children because they are good at a Particular sport. Yes Rinaldo might be a great footballer but he admitted to raping a woman and paying her off I'd not let a child of mine idolise him.

Every parent needs to understand that pack mentality is hard to go against in teens. Look at how any group of teens over 2 in size completely forgets how to cross a road safely!

APlanetFarFarAway · 02/10/2022 20:42

Lookingforbargains · 02/10/2022 20:24

@Caroffee
I agree - it’s an appalling comment. Not sure you’d get very far reporting it though 🤷‍♀️

It’s so, so obvious that men (as a group) get more out of heterosexual relationships than women it just beggars belief that people (women, no less!) can’t see it. No, it’s not everyone- but it’s a noticeable percentage.

I don't think most men see it either. There's such a lack of appreciation for a good solid relationships. It's almost like it's old fashioned, there are better, cooler, more able potential partners out there so why put any effort into the current relationship?
( not everyone of course)

reluctantbrit · 02/10/2022 20:42

Stop with single sex schools. It's ridiculous to keep teens in single sex and don't teach them how to deal with the opposite one.

Especially boys schools are a toxic envrionment and I hate the idea of DD (now 15) dealing with overgrown babies not knowing how to be a normal man and how to treat a female.

Obviously make sure you and your partner lead by examplel, DD sees DH doing housework and dealing with her like I do.
Seeing it in friend's or relative families. Ensuring your daughter is confident and has self-values.

If only single sex schools are possible, clubs like Scouts are great for learning to interact. DD is an Explorer and most of the teen boys are whipped in shape by a no-nonsense female leader and the male co-leader is always showing respect to the girls and shows the boys how to behave. At one camp DD and two other girls experienced some body shaming behaviour from a boy and when we spoke to the leader she called up all the boys and was horrified by the lack of the understanding what verbal body shaming can cause and they all had to undergo PSHCE similary style sessions.

smileandsing · 02/10/2022 20:40

I wish I knew the answer. My parents set a great example, they still do. But I managed to end up with an alcoholic cocklodger for a husband. No idea how I 'let' that happen.
I try to teach our son how to be a good person, to respect others and so on. We are very close. He isn't as close with his Dad, mainly because his Dad chooses that. But he has seen the bad stuff in our relationship and knows it was not 'normal', but he doesn't know what is so I worry how he'll be when he's older.

Sometimes bad experiences can help shape you into a much better person than your own parent(s). I have a relative who had a very similar father to my son's, he could not be a better Dad, because he knows what it's like to grow up with that.

Lookingforbargains · 02/10/2022 20:24

@Caroffee
I agree - it’s an appalling comment. Not sure you’d get very far reporting it though 🤷‍♀️

It’s so, so obvious that men (as a group) get more out of heterosexual relationships than women it just beggars belief that people (women, no less!) can’t see it. No, it’s not everyone- but it’s a noticeable percentage.

Lunar270 · 02/10/2022 20:22

Hardbackwriter · 02/10/2022 18:58

As much as it saddens me because I'd love to think I can guarantee I'll make brilliant, feminist men, I agree with this. I know lots of people convinced that they'll produce perfect children, but when I look around me at adults I don't see that the connection between how they were parented and how they are now is all that strong, or at least not easily predictable. I have an ex who had a strong, feminist mother who was a dick; DH's parents are mutually respectful but have an extraordinarily gendered marriage, but ours is the most equal one I know. You only have to look at siblings to see that the effect of active choices made by parents is unpredictable. My mum worked; I was really proud of her and wanted to emulate her example, my brother wished she didn't and married someone who wanted to be a SAHM. I'm not saying we shouldn't try, but I do think that lots of people are overoptimistic that if they do things 'right' their children will turn into certain sorts of adults.

Absolutely. We do our best and hope for the best too but part of it is yielding to the fact that there are limits to parenting. From my limited experience, I find the more you try to form children into something, the more they go their own way. A bit like trying to clutch at water.

To be honest I try not to parent too much. I think we promote more critical thinking as opposed to telling them what they should/shouldn't do or how they should think. The basics were necessary when they were younger obviously but nowadays I'd rather have a conversation where we can exchange opinions. Sometimes our opinions align, sometimes not and that's fine. But conversation is a good way for us to establish/compare/develop values. They get an idea of who their dad is and what's important to me. I get to see how they're turning out as adults.

It's a double edged sword really. Ultimately we want strong individuals, who think for themselves but that means finding their own values and morals, that may well oppose or differ greatly from our own. After all, my values are completely different to my mum's and I don't want clones of me either.

DismantledKing · 02/10/2022 20:03

Caroffee · 02/10/2022 20:02

Appalling comment. Somebody should report this.

Go on then.

Caroffee · 02/10/2022 20:02

FiveShelties · 02/10/2022 09:44

The men I know bear no resemblance to posts on here. The women I know would not put up with the behaviour that I read about on here. To be honest I think most of it us made up.

Appalling comment. Somebody should report this.

FirewomanSam · 02/10/2022 19:45

FiveShelties · 02/10/2022 09:44

The men I know bear no resemblance to posts on here. The women I know would not put up with the behaviour that I read about on here. To be honest I think most of it us made up.

I’m sure my friends used to think the same about me. They told me several times that they admired how I didn’t put up with any shit. They had no idea what was going on behind closed doors in my relationship where I was being treated like absolute crap and having my self-esteem gradually worn down over many many years.

Scottishskifun · 02/10/2022 19:45

Definitely agree with the lead by example and pull up behaviour/spoken to from a early age as well as discussing emotion.

My 3 year old DS sets the table each evening for example, he puts clothes into the washing machine and helps get them out, passes pegs to hang them up etc. He has "hoovered" since he was 18 months (it's a toy hoover that he puts on the same time as us). My DH shares childcare responsibilities and chores.

I have friends who DHs are man child's they don't do anything, make excuses all while the wife is exhausted. Turns out their mums did everything for them and made excuses for them!

APlanetFarFarAway · 02/10/2022 19:41

TamzinTotally · 02/10/2022 18:51

@Lookingforbargains

What many women on here can’t seem to stomach is that many women are fine with men not doing as much housework if they have other qualities that make up for it or do more in other areas.

If those women are happy with their husbands who are you to overrule that and say you actually know better, they shouldn’t be happy and their husbands are useless? After all isn’t the point of life to be happy? At least it’s the point of relationships.

No offence but I think you’ve fallen into the trap of thinking just because you wouldn’t want something, that it’s wrong for other people to want/have.

I do a lot more chores than my dh because I work a lot less hours. It suits us and I'm happy to get most of the chores done on my day off so there's less to do on the weekend.
What matters is dh's attitude.
He never expects me to do all the chores and will do a fair share when he's around. He'll also do them all if I'm not able to. We both expect the kids to do chores too.
It's part of being a competent and respectful adult.

dootball · 02/10/2022 19:35

It's hard to really see what's in it for you son though - if he has a pretty good chance of finding a women to do all these things for him why wouldn't he? Will he be happier if he married someone who did all this stuff for him or if he married someone who didn't do it for him?

NeelyOHara1 · 02/10/2022 19:29

It seems to be both the best of times and the worst of times for male and female relations and navigating our way through this is a work in progress that won't happen overnight. There is biology/nature and sociology/nurture plus class/culture clashing beliefs that render these interesting times..

Lookingforbargains · 02/10/2022 19:18

No offence but I think you’ve fallen into the trap of thinking just because you wouldn’t want something, that it’s wrong for other people to want/have.

@TamzinTotally That’s an interesting point of view. But I’m honestly not sure that any woman really wants to be the one responsible for all the domestic drudgery while her husband, who works similar hours, bumbles through life pretending that the kids’ social calendar is some sort of sacred mystery that requires a uterus.

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 02/10/2022 19:17

If I look at how my marriage to STBEXH has ended and why I also place some blame on his upbringing - I'm pretty sure his parents never showed him any physical demonstrations of love like hugging or kissing and it has contributed to him being an emotional black hole, he was also an only child and incredibly spoilt materially so I'll be raising my children and especially my son

  • to give and receive affection freely
  • to talk about emotions, talk about anything really
  • how to manage finances
  • how to look after a house ie ironing, cleaning etc
  • DIY
  • healthy sibling relationships
  • how to manage anger, disappointment etc. all the negative emotions
  • a healthy work ethic
  • discipline when/where/how required
  • if you want something you work hard and earn it
  • how to earn respect and how to respect others
  • how to be happy for others and empathise with others
  • MANNERS! Please and Thankyou goes a long way
LivingMyBestLie · 02/10/2022 19:02

You don't teach children, you show them.
Model the behaviour you want them to learn.

Be a good partner and parent, be responsible. Don't accept poor behaviour. Encourage their critical thinking, empathy and understanding of the world.

Give lots of attention, affection. Create a positive inner voice for them. But also have high expectations of them and discipline where needed.

Cuppasoupmonster · 02/10/2022 19:01

I know this is an unmumsnetty thing to say but the most ‘toxic masculine’ men I know were brought up by their mothers only BUT were also very spoilt.

So the only person they see cooking/cleaning as they grow up is a woman who waits on them hand and foot; and they seem to expect their girlfriends to pick up the baton when they got together.

I think seeing their dad pitch in with household chores is essential, if no dad around then rota them to help around the house as soon as they are able (preferably both!).

i also think mums should be open with their teen sons about harassment/misogyny they’ve faced in their lives, men tend not to see their female family members as ‘potential victims’ because they’re not love interests or ‘random women’ if you see what I mean. it shows all women are somebody’s mum/sister/whatever, and should be treated as such

Hardbackwriter · 02/10/2022 18:58

Lunar270 · 02/10/2022 10:43

Not as much as we'd like to think IMO.

I'd love to say we had a huge impact on our kids but parenting doesn't have a fixed, measurable outcome and sadly there's no formula. It's mostly pot luck. That they've turned out so well is partially down to our values but the credit is mostly theirs as they are ultimately responsible for their behaviour, morals and values. As we all are as adults.

As much as it saddens me because I'd love to think I can guarantee I'll make brilliant, feminist men, I agree with this. I know lots of people convinced that they'll produce perfect children, but when I look around me at adults I don't see that the connection between how they were parented and how they are now is all that strong, or at least not easily predictable. I have an ex who had a strong, feminist mother who was a dick; DH's parents are mutually respectful but have an extraordinarily gendered marriage, but ours is the most equal one I know. You only have to look at siblings to see that the effect of active choices made by parents is unpredictable. My mum worked; I was really proud of her and wanted to emulate her example, my brother wished she didn't and married someone who wanted to be a SAHM. I'm not saying we shouldn't try, but I do think that lots of people are overoptimistic that if they do things 'right' their children will turn into certain sorts of adults.