Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my mother is a disgraceful excuse for a human being?

107 replies

AutumnalAgedWoman · 02/10/2022 02:09

My mother and I have not kept in touch for 10 years due to a serious fallout. She last saw DS when he was 18 months old.

We have recently been in touch due to DS being diagnosed with a serious health condition (family medical history check). DS has been asking occasionally if he could meet her to see what she's like for some years. I have always brushed it off.

Since the Queens death being everywhere, he asked a few more times (suppose he connected elderly woman dying etc) and as we'd recently texted a few times. I put the idea for a meet up with him and adult DC (I don't want to see her) to her.

She responded that she would meet him and she'd come back with date and time. That was two weeks ago and knowing her. she won't respond again. She is not a busy woman with no time to organise an afternoon drink in a pub with a grandchild she's never had a relationship with. Not ill, faculties still there.

He asked me earlier when it had been arranged for.

I just want to tell her to fuck off and die quite frankly. She is not a nice person (but no risk to DC) and she should be honoured he even wants to meet her just once.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DavidLostBoysMullet · 03/10/2022 12:29

If my mum was this way,no way would I let her have ANY contact with my child. If she's cut you out of her life,then that goes for any grandchildren too.

Doingprettywellthanks · 03/10/2022 12:24

AutumnalAgedWoman · 02/10/2022 12:19

Definitely do this. It would be unkind to go along with his fantasy of a nice grandma when he’ll never have that. He’s old enough to understand, and it’s better for him to be disappointed now than keep hoping for what could be years
*
There is no fantasy of her like I had of my Dad. He knows she's under 'Evil Old Hag' in my phone. He knows what went on.* It's curiosity and to see what's she's like as his siblings have. He did once say to me he wanted to meet her to see similarities to me as how could she be like that and me like I was!

Your DD has a morbid desire to see his evil granny. I think my teen boy may too!

Don’t indulge it
Don’t actively go seeking to facilitate.

Just shrug and say, as expected, no word from her.

end of

BobbysGirly · 03/10/2022 12:06

DD and DS1 said have said they'll go with him for support but don't want to get involved with arranging as they don't want to contact her

TBH I’m not surprised your mum hasn’t replied. You have put her in a very uncomfortable position. You have been estranged for 10 years. You obviously don’t like your mother and haven’t hidden your feelings from your DC. You expect her to meet a 13 year old “stranger” in a very hostile environment.

How do you think your mum feels when she has to meet up with not only a child she has never met so has no bond with, who will be escorted by two people who have made it clear they have no wish to make contact with her?

i don’t think anyone can support your stance that your mum is a terrible person without her side of what happened 10 years ago.

Yupsuuuure · 03/10/2022 07:56

Tell your son you have contacted her and she's not replied. That will surely satisfy his curiosity about what she's like. That's a golden example right there.

He doesn't need to meet her so just let sleeping dogs lie. You've tried, and she's not up for it. Nothing more you need to do.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/10/2022 07:54

TBH OP if she’s so awful why are you allowing your DS to meet her?

The woman hasn’t heard from you for 10 years, I don’t think she’s obliged to jump up and down with joy because you now need something from her

LovelyDaaling · 03/10/2022 07:48

Your comment disturbs me, Autumnal AgedWoman.
"There is no fantasy of her like I had of my Dad. He knows she's under 'Evil Old Hag' in my phone. He knows what went on. It's curiosity and to see what's she's like as his siblings have. He did once say to me he wanted to meet her to see similarities to me as how could she be like that and me like I was!"

From your mother's perspective, she is probably right maintaining no contact. That's not a healthy reason to want to meet her.

Aubree17 · 02/10/2022 17:50

What was the serious fallout about?

LemonDrop22 · 02/10/2022 12:27

Do you think she's a psychopath/sociopath/narc/disordered etc op?

He'd really be better not subjected to her.

AutumnalAgedWoman · 02/10/2022 12:19

Definitely do this. It would be unkind to go along with his fantasy of a nice grandma when he’ll never have that. He’s old enough to understand, and it’s better for him to be disappointed now than keep hoping for what could be years
*
There is no fantasy of her like I had of my Dad. He knows she's under 'Evil Old Hag' in my phone. He knows what went on.* It's curiosity and to see what's she's like as his siblings have. He did once say to me he wanted to meet her to see similarities to me as how could she be like that and me like I was!

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 02/10/2022 11:58

BadNomad · 02/10/2022 04:27

The kid obviously has some fantasy in his head of what a grandmother is. Just tell him the truth.Tell him, "I tried to arrange it, but your grandma won't respond. She knows you want to meet her, but she doesn't care because she isn't nice. That is just the way she is."

I do NOT think she should say this. It is unnecessarily hurtful to a child.
His expectations and hopes need to be managed, but not like this!

(I speak from experience, that's all i will say.)

victoriacrosshairs · 02/10/2022 11:55

I don't want or need to start a thread. I'm just giving an alternative perspective. I've no issue with where I am in my life and wrt my bro DS and nephews. My door is open. If they find me as adults, I'll take it from there.

I think it would help the op to examine her motivations for pushing this contact.

Goosygandy · 02/10/2022 11:54

victoriacrosshairs · 02/10/2022 11:40

To answer your question.

Someone who is evil.

Or

Someone who is protecting themselves emotionally and doesn't want to have to see someone they want to be close to but know they'll never see again.

It could be either.

If one of my nieces or nephews wanted to meet me but I knew it was likely due to their mother that I'd never see them again, I might agree when put on the spot, but on reflection decide against it. I'd let you know though.

But this is the opposite situation. The OP didn't cut her mother off, she was cut off. It would be like in your situation you had cut off your nieces and nephews. The question then would be, would they want to see you again, via your adult children in case you messed them around again?

Maybe you need to start your own thread with your particular situation because I do understand why it was hurtful for you to be cut off by everyone because your relationship broke down. * *

victoriacrosshairs · 02/10/2022 11:53

You clearly have massive issues with her.

What will he gain by having contact with her and why are you so keen for it to happen?

AutumnalAgedWoman · 02/10/2022 11:52

'Someone who is protecting themselves emotionally and doesn't want to have to see someone they want to be close to but know they'll never see again.'
*
That made me snort. TBH she was never bothered about DS3. She had her favourite in my DC and it wasn't him. She wasn't bothered when her favourite was diagnosed with ASD and a learning disability either. I could have done with some family support then but she took them all with her to ensure I was punished by being alone and ostracised. She 'forgot' DS3s first birthday as didn't like his name. Sounds unbelievable but true! Doubt she'd understand the concept of 'protecting herself emotionally'.*

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 02/10/2022 11:49

BadNomad · 02/10/2022 04:27

The kid obviously has some fantasy in his head of what a grandmother is. Just tell him the truth.Tell him, "I tried to arrange it, but your grandma won't respond. She knows you want to meet her, but she doesn't care because she isn't nice. That is just the way she is."

Definitely do this. It would be unkind to go along with his fantasy of a nice grandma when he’ll never have that. He’s old enough to understand, and it’s better for him to be disappointed now than keep hoping for what could be years.

Derbee · 02/10/2022 11:48

Those saying why let DS meet her if she's a bad person, he's at no risk, psychological or otherwise.

Sorry, but this isn’t true. You are letting him meet her, only to put him in a position where she doesn’t see him again (which is personal) or they start some sort of relationship which he as a 12 year old has to navigate when his mum is NC a with the grandparent he’s starting a relationship with.

It has PSYCHOLOGICAL RISK written all over it, in a flashing neon sign. It’s concerning that you can’t see that.

victoriacrosshairs · 02/10/2022 11:40

To answer your question.

Someone who is evil.

Or

Someone who is protecting themselves emotionally and doesn't want to have to see someone they want to be close to but know they'll never see again.

It could be either.

If one of my nieces or nephews wanted to meet me but I knew it was likely due to their mother that I'd never see them again, I might agree when put on the spot, but on reflection decide against it. I'd let you know though.

BadNomad · 02/10/2022 11:39

You're letting your own childhood experiences cloud your judgement with this. This is not the same thing. Letting your son see this toxic woman is not the opposite of that toxic woman not letting you see your father. This is you knowingly letting a toxic woman into your son's life. That is not good.

Ok to reframe what kind of person doesn't want to meet their newly disabled 12 year old grandchild, with a life threatening condition, for an hour after they've asked for many years to meet them?

A toxic one.

AutumnalAgedWoman · 02/10/2022 11:33

HoppingPavlova · 02/10/2022 10:34

@Herejustforthisone seriously? I understand she hates her mother, and likely for just reason but to state that all 70yo’s don’t do anything - do I need to cut and paste that again? - is beyond the pale and does so many of them a disservice. Very unpalatable.

Oh for gods sake. MN nitpicking at its finest. Pathetic! Let me spell it out for you what I meant - the vast majority of over 70's of my mother's generation do not work all the hours god sends, are not raising DC etc and would have time to arrange a time to meet up with a long lost grandchild. My mother has never worked, had any hobbies, did anything charitable, had no friends and I highly doubt she'd have changed.

I only put in that comment before someone jumped in to say she was probably busy and over two weeks was a reasonable timeframe to not follow up on giving a date!

She agreed to meet him. She could have not responded as I expected her not to.

The reason I'm OK with DS meeting her is that I was prevented (by her) from seeing my father after she remarried a year after their divorce when I was 7. Meeting him again in my 40's was what led up to her cutting me off as she was furious I had the audacity to want to know my own father. I have vowed never to be like her. I only met my Dad twice as I couldn't keep a relationship with him after all that had happened but I'm glad I did see him.

Those saying why let DS meet her if she's a bad person, he's at no risk, psychological or otherwise. My adult DC will be with him, know very well what's she like so will leave immediately. Anyway she will not be nasty in public, she's all about what others think. I highly doubt a relationship would go any further.

Since DS's diagnosis, I want to give him the bloody moon so can put my own feelings aside for him. He's not an average 12 year old I have to say. Extremely intelligent, emotionally and academically. He's been asking about her since he was about 5. My other DC have memories of her as they were very close to her and she still is mentioned occasionally so yes, he is aware of her and that he's the only know who doesn't know who she is.

Ok to reframe what kind of person doesn't want to meet their newly disabled 12 year old grandchild, with a life threatening condition, for an hour after they've asked for many years to meet them?

OP posts:
HoppingPavlova · 02/10/2022 10:34

@Herejustforthisone seriously? I understand she hates her mother, and likely for just reason but to state that all 70yo’s don’t do anything - do I need to cut and paste that again? - is beyond the pale and does so many of them a disservice. Very unpalatable.

Doingprettywellthanks · 02/10/2022 10:21

mam0918 · 02/10/2022 09:49

This is how I read it too.

Family/blood means NOTHING in reality, what makes up close is our bond and relationships... you refused to let her have one so really you DS is not her grandchild in anything other DNA. He is just a strange child to her with a rude unlikable mother.

You want to pick her up and drop her when ever it suits you... you sound quite entitled on your part to be honest.

I do feel for your DS who is the innocent here however it is who YOU have used him a weapon though against his own wishes and this is the consiquence of your choice.

She cut us out. We didn't cut her out. She said she never wanted to see me again

guessing you missed this @Porcupineintherough

mam0918 · 02/10/2022 09:49

Porcupineintherough · 02/10/2022 02:52

Actually yes, you are being a little unreasonable. You cut her out of your lives for 10 years now you expect her to show up on demand. And then what? She meets her grandson to satisfy his curiosity then you drop her again.

I don't doubt she's dreadful if you had to cut her out but she's still human, with feelings. Not a toy to be picked up and put down at will. If you were nc for good reason then best keep it like that.

This is how I read it too.

Family/blood means NOTHING in reality, what makes up close is our bond and relationships... you refused to let her have one so really you DS is not her grandchild in anything other DNA. He is just a strange child to her with a rude unlikable mother.

You want to pick her up and drop her when ever it suits you... you sound quite entitled on your part to be honest.

I do feel for your DS who is the innocent here however it is who YOU have used him a weapon though against his own wishes and this is the consiquence of your choice.

PuppyMonkey · 02/10/2022 09:35

“Sorry son, she still hasn’t got back to me with a date, I doubt it will happen so don’t get your hopes up.”

Noteverybodylives · 02/10/2022 09:30

You’ve been honest with your child up til now so I would carry on being honest.

Tbh at a mature 12 then he could just reach out to her himself and then he can see for himself and you won’t need to worry about being involved.

Ifulikepinacoladas · 02/10/2022 09:30

Goosygandy · 02/10/2022 03:37

By the way, people who haven't had manipulative, abusive family members will never get it and will always accuse you of not trying hard enough. Resist them!

Agree. Impossible to imagine. They think they can, but they can't.