Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When people drop massive hints for favours ..

112 replies

domesofpillows · 02/10/2022 00:12

What do you do?
Do you acknowledge it? Answer as if they've asked you? Ignore it?
I have so many people in my life who drop massive hints for favours. I have to say it's mainly my mum who does this.

Such as things like: going to an event a family member has messaged me "Bob won't be able to come tomorrow because he can't get a lift and has no way of getting there".
I KNOW they want me to say "oh I'll pick Bob up".

Or "I was going to come to your house tomorrow. It will take me a while to get there. I'm not sure how many buses I'd need to get or which buses they are. Hopefully I won't get lost and I hope I'll eventually get to yours at some point in the day. I really don't know which bus to get. Do you know which?"

Usually I'll say "it's fine, I'll pick you up". Or something. But it's happened again today where I know it's a massive hint for me to do someone a favour. I'd rather they just ask that all this fannying about.
And half the time it isn't a favour I actually want to do, but feel like I should.

OP posts:
TheHoover · 02/10/2022 07:51

It’s just how some people are. I bet your mum has no idea it infuriates you. How about:
’mum, I’ll pick you up but if you want a lift in future please just ask rather than this hinting which drives me nuts’.
ad infinitum until she gets the messsge.

Daleksatemyshed · 02/10/2022 07:47

Just for balance Op, there's lots of threads on here where people moan about anyone wanting a lift so I generally don't ask anyone. If someone offers lovely but no obvious hints. I'd pick your DM up if I were you, public transport is getting so bad now

Fairyliz · 02/10/2022 07:47

I think you are being a bit harsh, some people have been bought up to think it’s ‘rude’ to ask for things for themselves.
Eg Christmas is coming up, I have a friend who always buys me a present and I know roughly how much she spends.

Should I say ‘hi Friend T I have seen X and I would really like you to buy it for me for Christmas’. Thus getting something I want in her price range.

But what if she is skint this year, or thinking about the environment so no presents? Now I have put her under pressure to buy it or explain she has no money.

It’s a minefield!

Tractorsanddiggers · 02/10/2022 07:46

I have a a friend who does this. It feels like it's so she won't owe me as I have offered. **

Sixsmith · 02/10/2022 07:06

When people do this I ignore them. When people ask outright for the favour, I'll do it. I respect that more so I do it

Anycrispsleft · 02/10/2022 06:51

Meh, I don't know. I think if they're just trying to get you to do it without having to ask, that is annoying. But there are definitely situations where I might think the person might want to help, but if they don't want to help and I ask a direct question they will feel obliged to do it and I don't want that, so if I just mention it once they can take that as their cue and offer if they want, and not if they don't. But the key thing is to mention it once and if they don't bite, let it go!

OLP2019 · 02/10/2022 06:49

Hinting is passive aggressive and annoying! Either acknowledge what they're really saying by saying yes I can take you or sorry she can't make it I'm unable to take h r this time
Or just ignore and play along "oh that's a shame" etc
I do a mix of both

Wilburisagirl · 02/10/2022 06:49

I don't even let my young children get away with this. Ask for what you want politely and be prepared that the answer might not always be yes.

I can not stand hinting and "beating around the bush" or someone expecting me to guess what they want. That's a guaranteed way to have your desire ignored.

Mummyoflittledragon · 02/10/2022 06:42

I have a dh, who too readily says no. Smoothing the way works. I am a direct person and find hinting difficult. I am wondering if some people may hint as they have been brought up by parents, who say no a lot.

Yayyayitsaholiholiday · 02/10/2022 06:39

I was in a women’s social group and one of the major reasons I left was a particular woman posting in every event/activity that was planned:
‘oh I’d so love to do this but it will be very difficult for me to get there as I don’t drive. I’ll try to walk, as I don’t know if there are any buses and I really hope I don’t get lost and arrive really late, although I probably will, as I’m not very good with maps. It will be a very long walk, but I will do my very best to arrive as I want to support the group.’

Then someone would offer a lift and she’d act super surprised that this was an option and that she’d never considered asking as she didn’t want to be a bother.
EVERY FUCKING TIME!!!!!

It used to irritate me so much, seeing this communication around every activity we had planned.

She would also tell everyone within earshot that she didn’t drive, but would never expect lifts from anyone as she could always find alternative means of getting around.

Calphurnia · 02/10/2022 06:19

"Are you asking for a lift Mum, or do you want me to help you work out the buses?"

Shoxfordian · 02/10/2022 06:17

Happily ignore any hints - if someone doesn’t want to be direct then you don’t need to try to understand them or work out what they want

PatchworkElmer · 02/10/2022 06:16

I can’t bear this either. I have a acquaintance who doesn’t drive but will do things like accepting a group invite to an event (which has been forwarded to about 100 people with the same interest as an FYI). The event will be miles from home. She will then say nothing until a week before when she’ll message those of us she knows are going to ask something vague like what our plans are for the day.

We know she’s angling for a lift, she knows she’s angling for a lift. But she doesn’t ask. Which really gets on my nerves! I think it’s partly a defence thing- if we say we have full cars or something then she can pretend she didn’t want a lift- and also partly to avoid owing us in any kind of way (‘I didn’t ask, they just offered’). I’m a bit fed up at the moment as the last trip was some distance away, I went out of my way to collect her and drop her home, and I’m skint so I asked if she could give me a couple of quid for fuel. She still hasn’t.

Hearthnhome · 02/10/2022 06:03

I hate when people hint at things. maybe it that I was married to someone who hinted all the time and I never got the offer right. But when people hint, I have found in the past that when I then pick up on the hint and offer, my help hasn’t been quite what they were looking for. Or I end up overthinking later and convince myself what I offered wasn’t right. It causes me a lot of stress.

I remember exh once saying ‘oh we could have gone seen my parents today’ it was 11am and they lived 2 hours away. I took the hint that he wanted to arrange to see them so said ‘oh why don’t we go next weekend’. Never entered my head he wanted to go that day. I presumed he meant ‘if we had planned earlier we could have gone today’, didn’t occur to me that at 11am he would want to start packing the kids up to drive 2 hours there and 2 hours back to spend a couple of hours there. Then the next he was annoyed and said I never do anything he wants to do. I was genuinely shocked because I thought he was hunting to arrange a visit. But not that day. Thought I had picked up in the hint, but turns out I hadn’t

Now, to avoid the stress and overthinking it causes me, I completely ignore hints.

Depending on who it is, I may just say ‘if you need me to do something m, let me know what it is’. To dp I use to say ‘I get the impression you are hinting, I don’t mind helping but can you tell me what it is you want’. He understood why and started just asking instead of hinting and it works.

Also these things make life difficult for ds who is ND. If you tell ds ‘Bob can’t come because he can’t get there’ he wouldn’t pick up on the hint as was being told ‘Bob can’t get here’. That’s it. It makes him frustrated when he finds out that there’s a subtext, he has missed. Social interactions are hard enough for him without people trying hide a meaning in it.

FangsForTheMemory · 02/10/2022 05:42

I ignore hints. My mother was a serial hinter and it drove me mad.

Eviebeans · 02/10/2022 05:35

Sounds like Bob stays home this time.
Presumably you’d have known that someone was going to be coming to your house tomorrow as you’d have invited them. In that situation I’d say “so glad you let me know - would hate for you to have a wasted journey- we’ll arrange something another time”

Olivetreebutter · 02/10/2022 05:28

I hate this.
For Uncle Bob I would say "then perhaps he should ask if he wants or needs a lift".
For your mom I'd say "mom, if you want something like a lift in future please just ask for it, I can't guarantee I'll say yes when you ask but I will help if circumstances allow, but being hinted at isn't going to work."
She might say she thinks it's more polite or whatever so I'd just say "well i prefer a direct question, so please just ask in future".

If you think about it, any other response is 'hinting' that you don't like hinting. It's quite hypocritical. Better to be up front.

petridishmystery · 02/10/2022 05:28

I was awful for this as a teen/young adult, makes me cringe now. I get overly embarrassed/upset when someone refuses me something (I’ve read it can be an ADHD thing) so if I didn’t ask outright, I didn’t run the risk of being told no. But like I say, I was young! I am 35 now. I still have the same reaction to being told no, but now I’ll either make myself ask, or just get on with whatever it is without asking for help.

it is so obvious when someone else is doing it, which like I say makes me cringe as I must have been so annoying back in the day!

ChagSameachDoreen · 02/10/2022 05:20

Ignore.

If someone wants something, they can use their words ask. I can't bear hinting.

StClare101 · 02/10/2022 05:18

I’m much better at ignoring hints these days. And if people try to create more work for me in a roundabout way I call them out on it. One of the benefits of giving less fucks as I get older!

Mummybear888 · 02/10/2022 05:10

Like others have said, play along or say 'oh that's a shame :('

Good luck though. I know how you feel, it is soooo irritating!

blubberball · 02/10/2022 05:04

I can't stand this. Just ask directly. Hints are usually ignored, but occasionally I'll bite unfortunately, because I can be a push over

melj1213 · 02/10/2022 01:08

If anyone hints, subtly or otherwise, then I will usually ignore it or will match their hinting with feigned ignorance or just "hint" back at them to put the ball in their court again.

Bob won't be able to come tomorrow because he can't get a lift and has no way of getting there" Oh no what a shame! Has he asked anyone for a lift? I'm sure people would be happy to give him a lift if he just asked them directly but if nobody can do it then I guess we'll see him next time"

Depending on the person, or how much patience I have at the time, I will sometimes just be really blunt.

"I was going to come to your house tomorrow. It will take me a while to get there. I'm not sure how many buses I'd need to get or which buses they are. Hopefully I won't get lost and I hope I'll eventually get to yours at some point in the day. I really don't know which bus to get. Do you know which?" "If you want a lift then just ask me, but if it's too much hassle with the buses then you don't have to come over."

Vecna · 02/10/2022 00:50

It's precisely because you don't have to answer as though they've asked that it's polite. It doesn't put you on the spot. Also saves them the embarrassment of rejection and gives them the ability to pretend they weren't asking.

Obviously when it's very transparent that they want you to offer it can be embarrassing. But still totally ignorable.

RainbowSlide · 02/10/2022 00:41

Agree with the "that's a shame" for uncle Bob, why on earth should you feel responsible for collecting him?

With your mum, it's a tricky one. You might just be direct with her and say "mum are you asking for a lift? Or shall I show you the way on google maps?". Call her out on it but just to acknowledge it and then to find a solution. She might have the sense that asking directly is rude, but that's not your feeling, so either you ignore it or call it out and find a way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread