Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When people drop massive hints for favours ..

112 replies

domesofpillows · 02/10/2022 00:12

What do you do?
Do you acknowledge it? Answer as if they've asked you? Ignore it?
I have so many people in my life who drop massive hints for favours. I have to say it's mainly my mum who does this.

Such as things like: going to an event a family member has messaged me "Bob won't be able to come tomorrow because he can't get a lift and has no way of getting there".
I KNOW they want me to say "oh I'll pick Bob up".

Or "I was going to come to your house tomorrow. It will take me a while to get there. I'm not sure how many buses I'd need to get or which buses they are. Hopefully I won't get lost and I hope I'll eventually get to yours at some point in the day. I really don't know which bus to get. Do you know which?"

Usually I'll say "it's fine, I'll pick you up". Or something. But it's happened again today where I know it's a massive hint for me to do someone a favour. I'd rather they just ask that all this fannying about.
And half the time it isn't a favour I actually want to do, but feel like I should.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 02/10/2022 12:24

I happily ignore hints-I think they are really rude. Nobody I am friends/family with would hint to me-they would ask and I would agree or not, depending on what it was!

If people do this to you a lot, you need to reconsider your responses.

Island77 · 02/10/2022 12:23

Don’t feel like you have to justify why you cannot.
Just say, i am not available, or have other engagements.
Or win time by learning to say you’ll think about it.

it will get easier over time if you keep being consistent, people will learn.

KettrickenSmiled · 02/10/2022 12:20

Isaidnoalready · 02/10/2022 00:26

I'm pondering this at the moment the message received was are you walking to school on x day I literally walk every day they know this what they want to say is can you take my kid to school because I'm sick and the unemployed love of my life doesn't want to take our kid to school and I can't cope with them both home because I'm ill

Thing is they have burned many many bridges lately with many many people me included 😕 I'm just not sure I want to open myself up to being used and dropped again

I think I might have an "appointment"

Don't invent things to get out of being imposed on.
Just tell it like it is.

"Surely your partner can take your child to school?"

Luredbyapomegranate · 02/10/2022 12:18

The reason it keeps happening to you is because you keep saying you’ll do it.

Don’t. Just say ‘oh that’s a shame.’

Do an assertiveness course perhaps. You are being a doormat and people will take advantage of that.

Island77 · 02/10/2022 12:12

It’s okay to do y0ur mum a favour. But what is going too far (for me) is people who promise others favours, that they expect you to do for them.
its hard but learn to be assertive and decide on what you’re willing to do.
And from ‘their’ side ; it doesnt hurt to ask ..?
people usually remember very well which people are helpful, and come back, if you seemed to not mind last time?
You have to ‘train’ people.

MissingNashville · 02/10/2022 12:07

I ignore hinting. Just ask me, if I can help and I want to, I will. I like straightforward people. All my friends are like me, it keeps things simple.

We have a family member that would hint and use guilt to try to get what they want. It just doesn’t work on me and makes me dislike the person, it’s manipulation and I have no time for it.

ShinyS1 · 02/10/2022 11:57

Someone I know is a serial hinter. I ignore it, or would respond 'I think it would be a useful experience to work out bus routes, it's good to get out of your comfort zone now and then'. If the bus prices come up I would say 'Yes, petrol is really expensive for everyone right now'.

My serial hinter has missed out on my usual generosity because she just won't ask me outright, and I don't think she ever will.

JustBetween · 02/10/2022 11:56

Thelnebriati · 02/10/2022 11:32

Thanks JustBetween - yes it was tough (and pre Google) - but I learned how to decorate, and now my kids know how to do it as well. When they got older we did their rooms together. There's no way I'd expect someone to decorate my house for free, I know what a faff it all is!

Great way to bond, and the tremendous sense of achievement and pride that follows… brilliant way to raise teenagers.

YellowTreeHouse · 02/10/2022 11:55

Ignore it. I can’t stand hints. Just say what you bloody well mean!

JustBetween · 02/10/2022 11:54

PorridgewithQuark · 02/10/2022 11:30

Obviously say no, spell out that it's a huge amount of work and not an enjoyable activity and tell her to pay for a professional to do it.

My mother used to be terrible for asking for this kind of favour through hints (not specifically painting but huge multi-day manual or volunteering type tasks). She always played down the magnitude of the tasks and implied that they were no bother for younger people and really quite "fun" 🙄 She could also afford to pay someone but liked to have family do things for her. Tbh she loved more than anything telling her friends how many people helped her.

She once had the audacity to admit, after one more glass of wine than she'd usually have, that she "knew" we loved to feel needed! At that time I had a baby and a toddler and I really did not need to feel needed by anyone else! 🤬 That's when I became completely direct with her (which caused a lot of drama tbh but eventually she stopped the hinting mostly - and not just with me but everyone).

When she used to do that she was still working age and then early retired and fairly healthy and able.

Interestingly now she actually genuinely needs help she just pays for it (luckily she can afford to).

I think you’re onto something about loving to tell people how you were helped. I am now thinking these are acts of service people, mixed with a little bit (quite a lot) of tightness.

Curious about what exactly you said to your mum that made her turn over a new leaf, that’s quite a turn-around. Admirable. We can all make mistakes but seeing drastic change for the better is a beautiful thing to witness.

Echoecho35 · 02/10/2022 11:34

I've had a recent experience of this. Made a massive effort to see my aunt, took a flight to see her, took her out for lunch, bought her a nice expensive gift felt happy / good about doing all of that and then when I was on holiday with my family shortly after that she kept dropping hints about asking me to contribute to her charity run. When I was on holiday. Twice in quite an assertive way. It was the tone that has bothered me so much tbh. So I paypaled her a tenner but I will be taking a step back as I feel she has taken the mick and asked me for more than I was happy to give if that makes sense. I'm listening more to my gut and how relationships feel iyswim.

Thelnebriati · 02/10/2022 11:32

Thanks JustBetween - yes it was tough (and pre Google) - but I learned how to decorate, and now my kids know how to do it as well. When they got older we did their rooms together. There's no way I'd expect someone to decorate my house for free, I know what a faff it all is!

PorridgewithQuark · 02/10/2022 11:30

JustBetween · 02/10/2022 11:16

That sounds so difficult! You must have been bone tired getting through the days! See, that makes me want to do it. It sounds like a really hard time, it must feel sad to think there is no support and you have to survive on your own with kids. I hope things are a lot easier for you now, are you children now grown if we’re talking pre-Google?

However, in this situation, my sister has the funds for hired help, she just doesn’t want to part with cash if it can be done free. We all want free, I would just not be able to bring myself to ask someone to take on such an arduous undertaking if it were not necessary. I would happily dip into my pocket, or do it myself if I were able to get childcare.

Obviously say no, spell out that it's a huge amount of work and not an enjoyable activity and tell her to pay for a professional to do it.

My mother used to be terrible for asking for this kind of favour through hints (not specifically painting but huge multi-day manual or volunteering type tasks). She always played down the magnitude of the tasks and implied that they were no bother for younger people and really quite "fun" 🙄 She could also afford to pay someone but liked to have family do things for her. Tbh she loved more than anything telling her friends how many people helped her.

She once had the audacity to admit, after one more glass of wine than she'd usually have, that she "knew" we loved to feel needed! At that time I had a baby and a toddler and I really did not need to feel needed by anyone else! 🤬 That's when I became completely direct with her (which caused a lot of drama tbh but eventually she stopped the hinting mostly - and not just with me but everyone).

When she used to do that she was still working age and then early retired and fairly healthy and able.

Interestingly now she actually genuinely needs help she just pays for it (luckily she can afford to).

JustBetween · 02/10/2022 11:16

Thelnebriati · 02/10/2022 10:51

Sister is now unhappy because she said I have more time and energy to do it because I have no children. What would others here do?

I was a single parent and did the decorating myself at night into the early hours. It was gruelling, I had to go to the library and learn how to do it so I didn't waste any effort, time or money. It took several months.
I hate being dependant on others and it wouldn't occur to me to drop hints. If I need help I ask for it and offer to barter something in return. If the person doesn't want to, that's fine.

That sounds so difficult! You must have been bone tired getting through the days! See, that makes me want to do it. It sounds like a really hard time, it must feel sad to think there is no support and you have to survive on your own with kids. I hope things are a lot easier for you now, are you children now grown if we’re talking pre-Google?

However, in this situation, my sister has the funds for hired help, she just doesn’t want to part with cash if it can be done free. We all want free, I would just not be able to bring myself to ask someone to take on such an arduous undertaking if it were not necessary. I would happily dip into my pocket, or do it myself if I were able to get childcare.

PorridgewithQuark · 02/10/2022 11:11

I'd tell my mother straight out to ask directly.

People do this because they want to be able to say "I didn't ask, you offered!" if you dare mention that doing the favour has had a knock on effect on other things planned for the day.

It's nothing to do with politeness and everything to do with making sure that they don't owe you anything because you wanted to do whatever it is.

TheHoover · 02/10/2022 11:04

There is a difference between
a) concealing an ask into a hint hoping someone will offer; and
b) what they are asking for/hinting at being complete cheeky fuckery.

a) is what this thread is about I think?

urgen · 02/10/2022 11:04

The lift hints are the worst. On MN people claim they don’t drive but would never impose on others.

But it’s rife in real life and I suspect these hinters want someone to ‘offer’ so that they can claim they never asked - someone offered.

JustBetween · 02/10/2022 10:59

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 02/10/2022 10:43

@JustBetween no way would I paint her house! I painted mine we moved in and it was hard work, the only thing that got me through it was thinking how much I would enjoy my own home.

Your sister seems to be using you.

I have to say she has form for this.

I remember how tough painting was, that’s why professional painter decorators are not cheap. My sister comes from another country where household servants were the norm, her and her father (different dads), seem to mistake family and random people as free labour.

Her dad once offered to treat me to a coffee, and then asked me to tidy up his garden, on the strength of a coffee! 😂 That’s how they think and operate. I know it sounds far fetched, but it’s absolutely true.

If you are asking for help, with paint or a garden, or whatever else it is, it’s best you muck in for your own stuff as well, rather than sit around like Lord or Lady of the manor whist others do non essential large favours for you. It’s astonishing.

Many people want little to do with them as a result of this. My poor sister then is a bit isolated. I do feel genuinely sorry for her on that front. It’s not her fault she was raised that way. It’s hard to learn new ways in the world.

IncompleteSenten · 02/10/2022 10:55

JustBetween · 02/10/2022 10:41

I’ve got a situation with my sister right now… she has been hinting extremely heavily and frequently for weeks - she wants me to paint her house. She is fit and healthy, although she has two very young children. I think the idea is that she has her hands full with the children and doesn’t know how to paint.

If she were disabled, or couldn’t afford to hire a painter decorator, I would possibly do it. I am feeling rather guilty having said “no” finally.
Is fresh paint an essential need? It’s not like I’m leaving her to starve.
It would never occur to me to ask anyone to paint my home.
I’ve learned how to do it over the years out of necessity and it’s not rocket science. And if I’m not in the right place to do it just then, I wait until I am. I haven’t painted my own home for more than a decade!

Sister is now unhappy because she said I have more time and energy to do it because I have no children. What would others here do?

Perhaps if I were a man, and very handy, I might see how she might have that expectation, but I’m neither of those things.

I'd say I don't want to do it.

If she sulks that's up to her.

Worthyornot · 02/10/2022 10:55

BMW6 · 02/10/2022 00:17

Just play along and keep a straight face 😆

This. I would just say oh it's such a shame that Bob will miss it. If it's no effort for me I would offer but if it's an inconvenience then I would just pretend not to get the hint and change the subject .

Bearsporridge · 02/10/2022 10:52

I don’t pick up on hints - that’s not deliberate; I just don’t make that connection.

people who know me, know they need to ask directly. I’m more than happy to help but having to ask seems to be a huge hurdle for some people. I don’t understand why.

Thelnebriati · 02/10/2022 10:51

Sister is now unhappy because she said I have more time and energy to do it because I have no children. What would others here do?

I was a single parent and did the decorating myself at night into the early hours. It was gruelling, I had to go to the library and learn how to do it so I didn't waste any effort, time or money. It took several months.
I hate being dependant on others and it wouldn't occur to me to drop hints. If I need help I ask for it and offer to barter something in return. If the person doesn't want to, that's fine.

Rocketclub · 02/10/2022 10:46

Having invited someone to dinner I would not expect to pick them up and entertain them and then drop them home - two hour dinner fine - two hour dinner and four hours picking them up and then home etc just no

bloodyplanes · 02/10/2022 10:46

Defaultsettings · 02/10/2022 00:17

I have a personal policy of ignoring hinting. I find it embarrassing for the person hinting.

Either ask me outright or don’t bother at all. Again my mum is the worst culprit. If I call her out on a hint, she says that she didn’t want to be rude by asking, as if hinting for what you want is better.

This

Rocketclub · 02/10/2022 10:45

k1233 · 02/10/2022 00:34

The first one I'd respond "that's a shame". The second I'd direct them to the online public transport site that allows people to plan their trips.

I don't "get" hints and I tell people that. If you want to ask / tell me something, then say it directly. Otherwise it will take more than three repeated comments for me to get that you are actually hinting at something.

This

second example - try the internet I’m sure they have an online route tracker etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread