Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone ever read Malory towers?

558 replies

Orangejelly1 · 02/10/2022 00:04

I used to love the books as a child! I read them cover to cover so many times and my favourite character was Darrell. I recently found my old collection and re read parts of them just for old times sake and I was actually really disappointed to see, as an adult, how awful some of the popular characters were. I know it was a product of its time and a different era, but Darrell, Alicia and some of the most popular girls would be called nasty bullies nowadays. I also felt so sorry for Gwen, which surprised me because as a child rearing the books she was my least favourite character.

just wondered if anyone else re read the books and thought this too!

OP posts:
gaymeanshappy · 09/10/2022 18:32

That is true. What are the main differences between MT and St Cs' would we say?

I can't put my finger on it.

AsAnyFuleKno · 09/10/2022 18:27

It occurred to me that if EB had structured St Clare's the same as MT, we'd probably have the same stories and characters, just set in different years with minor alterations to reflect that. So it would be -
The Twins at St Clare's - first form
The O'Sullivan Twins - second form
Summer Term at St Clare's - third form
Second Form at St Clare's - Fourth form
Claudine at St Clare's - Fifth form (the first or second term, before studies were allocated)
Fifth Formers at St Clare's - Sixth form (Hilary might have been head for this book, but left for India at the end, so it could end with the twins being chosen as originally written for the fifth).

gaymeanshappy · 09/10/2022 18:00

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 07/10/2022 00:06

They're a lot rougher round the edges, but somehow I find them fresher, livelier and all the sincerer for it. The series as a whole is poorly-plotted and very bottom-heavy, with three whole instalments before they even make it out of the first form. Although Enid herself is in top-brass character, and is just as xenophobic toward the Americans and French as she is in MT, at SC's Old Money as opposed to the nouveau riche comes in for quite a bit of ribbing. The aristocratic Angela Favourleigh is an unmitigated horror, and unlike some of the nastier characters of MT readers are really not encouraged to like her.

Even so, stark no nonsense St Clare's is still just as much as correctional facility as castle-like MT, with the girls indoctrinated into models of the good wives and mothers of the future. I liked the fact that we follow MT from forms 1 through 6 - especially the instalment with the school cert year - but by this time the plots have become pretty formulaic. Most of the key characters of MT can find an equivalent in the series' predecessor, and a number of storylines are rehashed. The introduction of Felicity et al toward the end of the series is also an annoying distraction. It's as if Enid has run out of things to say about our girls once they [hit adolescence] turn into boring/staid 6th formers, so the younger girls get prominence as cardboard cutouts of their elders but are even more awful than they are, if that's possible!

The best part of St Clare's is that through not following the boring twins through to Year 6, we are spared the nauseating Fond Farewells at the end of MT which put even Gwen to shame! 'Carry the Standard high!' Bleurgh. UGH!

I'm loving this thread. 100% Nostalgia!

I love this thread too. There's so much that is discussion-worthy about the books.
I don't know why I preferred Malory Towers to St C's. And we know what Mal Towers were based on-do we know if EB was inspired by any school/building for St Cs'?

I remember the story of the twins using boot polish instead of Anchovy Paste (I hadn't ever heard of Anchovy Toast before I read the books)!
And Carlotta the 'jumped up' circus girl-but I don't remember much else really?

I remember a lot more about Malory towers although it could be just me, I had the books as a present and I loved them and read them cover to cover-I was irked as an 11 year old when I reached the end, I wanted a sequel. Perhaps my love of reading stemmed from them although I am not sure, I've always been a reader.
I remember being so scared of boarding schools though, I would have personally hated to be educated at one, school was bad enough mind you so was home when I didn't have to be there all the time. I am trying to think of what girl I would have been most like. (Goes off to see if there's an online quiz...).. :)

Phos · 09/10/2022 16:49

Although I agree the new books aren't quite the same, I quite appreciated it last year when I re-read SC and the gaps were filled in. I found it very frustrating that certain forms were missing and I did really want to hear about the twins et al's final year.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 07/10/2022 00:06

KimberleyClark · 05/10/2022 12:04

And it is mentioned in Claudine At St Claire’s that Alison had lost her heart to the head girl of the third. Who can’t have been Hilary.

The St Claire’s books feel slapdash compared to MT.

They're a lot rougher round the edges, but somehow I find them fresher, livelier and all the sincerer for it. The series as a whole is poorly-plotted and very bottom-heavy, with three whole instalments before they even make it out of the first form. Although Enid herself is in top-brass character, and is just as xenophobic toward the Americans and French as she is in MT, at SC's Old Money as opposed to the nouveau riche comes in for quite a bit of ribbing. The aristocratic Angela Favourleigh is an unmitigated horror, and unlike some of the nastier characters of MT readers are really not encouraged to like her.

Even so, stark no nonsense St Clare's is still just as much as correctional facility as castle-like MT, with the girls indoctrinated into models of the good wives and mothers of the future. I liked the fact that we follow MT from forms 1 through 6 - especially the instalment with the school cert year - but by this time the plots have become pretty formulaic. Most of the key characters of MT can find an equivalent in the series' predecessor, and a number of storylines are rehashed. The introduction of Felicity et al toward the end of the series is also an annoying distraction. It's as if Enid has run out of things to say about our girls once they [hit adolescence] turn into boring/staid 6th formers, so the younger girls get prominence as cardboard cutouts of their elders but are even more awful than they are, if that's possible!

The best part of St Clare's is that through not following the boring twins through to Year 6, we are spared the nauseating Fond Farewells at the end of MT which put even Gwen to shame! 'Carry the Standard high!' Bleurgh. UGH!

I'm loving this thread. 100% Nostalgia!

ReneBumsWombats · 06/10/2022 21:32

ReformedWaywardTeen · 06/10/2022 21:03

Ooh that looks fun

If you like that, there's another site you'll love. I'll take you straight to the Sweet Valley/Hunger Games fanfic crossover.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 06/10/2022 21:03

Keyansier · 03/10/2022 19:42

Ooh that looks fun

AsAnyFuleKno · 06/10/2022 19:48

KillingMeDeftly · 06/10/2022 19:38

I read some of the extra books by new authors but it just didn't feel the same. It was odd having the girls greeting each other with "Hi guys" etc

Oh, that would really grate Sad

ReneBumsWombats · 06/10/2022 19:47

Yes, I've just tried one of the Pamela Cox ones and it's a valiant effort but it just jars. The TV adaptation is fine because they've just recreated the whole universe and it's internally consistent. Enough of the original to feel like Malory Towers, updated enough so that you don't have to worry about all the problematic elements.

Blyton was quite prolific enough. We don't need any more.

KillingMeDeftly · 06/10/2022 19:38

I read some of the extra books by new authors but it just didn't feel the same. It was odd having the girls greeting each other with "Hi guys" etc

ElizabethBest · 06/10/2022 19:19

Re the tv series - Clarissa joined the year after Bill so if they do have her in it, it’ll be next series.

AsAnyFuleKno · 06/10/2022 18:40

kierenthecommunity · 06/10/2022 18:28

And what's with other authors writing additional books- sort of randomly for St Clares- but a whole series about Felciity for MT- where her class are all just clones of Darrells

It was handy how the new girls in the St Clare’s third and fourth form books were only ever going to be there for one term…

The sixth form at SC one is a bit puke worthy with all the reverence towards the twins. I mean, Miss T only picked them as there was no other candidate, with the worthy Hilary inconsiderately buggering off to India

I wish someone would write one about Darrell and co. at St Andrews. Is there any decent fan fic about this, does anyone know?

kierenthecommunity · 06/10/2022 18:28

And what's with other authors writing additional books- sort of randomly for St Clares- but a whole series about Felciity for MT- where her class are all just clones of Darrells

It was handy how the new girls in the St Clare’s third and fourth form books were only ever going to be there for one term…

The sixth form at SC one is a bit puke worthy with all the reverence towards the twins. I mean, Miss T only picked them as there was no other candidate, with the worthy Hilary inconsiderately buggering off to India

MrsFionaCharming · 06/10/2022 16:18

I’ve just finished Beswitched as recommended up thread, really enjoyed it thank you!

Notcreativeatall · 06/10/2022 09:13

I read them with my son.They are really dated but still fun to read and its actually interesting to talk about the bullying etc- He's a lot more clear-sighted on how unacceptable its is and how mean some of the girls are. he does find it really baffling how paired up the girls are- they are only allowed one friend really.
Theres some odd amendments though- the replacing of the word smack/slap with scold makes no sense a lot of the time, And what's with other authors writing additional books- sort of randomly for St Clares- but a whole series about Felciity for MT- where her class are all just clones of Darrells

AsAnyFuleKno · 05/10/2022 19:33

lessthanathirdofanacre · 05/10/2022 19:15

I love Tim. Her sceptical attitude toward school life is perfectly drawn. I always had the sense that she would be hugely successful as an adult, whereas she just had to endure childhood and adolescence. She wasn't always "nice," but that's true of all the interesting characters. They are all flawed in one way or another.

Tim is so refreshing after all the other writers' cardboard cut out sports-haters being fat, lazy, unpopular Gwendoline types.

I very much doubt I'd have been friends with her - I suspect I'd have been a Marie Dobson type at Kingscote - but she is a brilliant creation.

lessthanathirdofanacre · 05/10/2022 19:15

Novum · 04/10/2022 23:44

You'd love Tim in the Antonia Forest Kingscote books, then.

I love Tim. Her sceptical attitude toward school life is perfectly drawn. I always had the sense that she would be hugely successful as an adult, whereas she just had to endure childhood and adolescence. She wasn't always "nice," but that's true of all the interesting characters. They are all flawed in one way or another.

AlexCabot · 05/10/2022 15:54

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 05/10/2022 15:28

just popped on the first episode of Malory Towers and am tickled to see Matron is played by same woman who plays Big Mandy in This Country Grin

Wonder if she'll have cause to use her nunchucks on gwendoline Mary.

Will she be giving the first years MASSIVE tattoos?

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 05/10/2022 15:28

just popped on the first episode of Malory Towers and am tickled to see Matron is played by same woman who plays Big Mandy in This Country Grin

Wonder if she'll have cause to use her nunchucks on gwendoline Mary.

Has anyone ever read Malory towers?
worriedniece · 05/10/2022 13:21

The bbc TV series is fab. My daughter has the books as bedtime stories read to her. She is Darrell through and through. Kind hearted and wants the best with a strong sense of integrity but also a temper when things are unjust!

KimberleyClark · 05/10/2022 12:04

And it is mentioned in Claudine At St Claire’s that Alison had lost her heart to the head girl of the third. Who can’t have been Hilary.

The St Claire’s books feel slapdash compared to MT.

KimberleyClark · 05/10/2022 12:01

Hilary was always head girl of the form, except in Second Form,

Wasn't there someone called Susan who was head in the fourth form (but had vanished by the fifth form)?

oh yes there was, I’d forgotten all about her. Another one who was “left down”.

AsAnyFuleKno · 05/10/2022 11:57

think there was deliberately no corporal punishment at Whyteleafe as it was a progressive school with the children governing wrong doing.

A nice thought, but the corporal punishment has been edited out in modern editions. In the older editions, there is 'spanking' with a hairbrush.

Hilary was always head girl of the form, except in Second Form,

Wasn't there someone called Susan who was head in the fourth form (but had vanished by the fifth form)?

ReneBumsWombats · 05/10/2022 11:31

NumberTheory · 05/10/2022 10:25

I used to love Mallory Towers and the Twins at St Clares.

But I’m under no illusions they’re a product of their time. It’s been the same with a lot of favourites from my childhood. We started reading Thomas the Tank Engine to our kids when they were three or four and had to stop because it is absolutely horrendous. Since that I’ve shared favourites but mainly gone with more contemporary books. Now my kids are teens and we’ve been doing movie nights and I’m finding all my favourite movies from my teen years are pretty horrendous, full of date rape and atrocious attitudes to women and sex. But I keep reminding myself that I grew up okay despite them, so maybe they will too.

What was wrong with Thomas the Tank Engine?

KimberleyClark · 05/10/2022 10:58

Thinking about St Claire’s. Hilary was always head girl of the form, except in Second Form, and that was because two girls from the previous second form had been left down - Anna and Elsie. They were made joint heads because Miss Theobald didn't think it fair that a “new” second form girl should be put in charge of them, even though neither was head girl material, Anna being lazy and Elsie being spiteful. I think Anna did get her act together eventually but the girls eventually “sacked” Elsie.

The OS twins had no experience of being heads of form at all, but then in Fifth Form Miss T decided they were suitable to be heads of the whole school.