Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone ever read Malory towers?

558 replies

Orangejelly1 · 02/10/2022 00:04

I used to love the books as a child! I read them cover to cover so many times and my favourite character was Darrell. I recently found my old collection and re read parts of them just for old times sake and I was actually really disappointed to see, as an adult, how awful some of the popular characters were. I know it was a product of its time and a different era, but Darrell, Alicia and some of the most popular girls would be called nasty bullies nowadays. I also felt so sorry for Gwen, which surprised me because as a child rearing the books she was my least favourite character.

just wondered if anyone else re read the books and thought this too!

OP posts:
zingally · 02/10/2022 12:52

I read them as a child and loved them! I also read the St Clares series a year or so later!

But no, looking back, they don't stand the test of time. Darrell is unpleasant and violent (she hit a couple of people hard enough to leave marks, I seem to recall) and Alicia is a bully.

KimberleyClark · 02/10/2022 12:51

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 12:48

A random musing - I've always wondered why Darrell didn't go to Miss Potts and admit the Fourth had had a midnight feast, as soon as Felicity told her the First form were under suspicion. It would have been the decent thing to do; and especially once Felicity told her June was going to 'own up' - at that point it would have been common sense - rather than going off to have a go at June.

Good point. If she had gone to Miss Potts, quite possibly the very serious matter of girls from another tower being there might not have come up.

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 12:48

A random musing - I've always wondered why Darrell didn't go to Miss Potts and admit the Fourth had had a midnight feast, as soon as Felicity told her the First form were under suspicion. It would have been the decent thing to do; and especially once Felicity told her June was going to 'own up' - at that point it would have been common sense - rather than going off to have a go at June.

gnilliwdog · 02/10/2022 12:46

I am not going to forgive EB for her xenophobia and racism, which is a thread throughout her fiction. She isn't alone in that - lots of writers from the past had those attitudes. But I don't know what sort of children's writer she was if she wasn't for all children, regardless of class, ethnicity and nationality. I suppose she is interesting from a historical perspective.

goldenbag · 02/10/2022 12:39

@lurker2003 I think I read a couple. They weren't bad but there were some language errors

lurker2003 · 02/10/2022 12:36

Did anyone read the extra 6 Malory Towers books that Pamela Cox wrote?

Chickychoccyegg · 02/10/2022 12:35

I read them all again a while back with my daughter, and I still love them, fair enough, none of them were perfect and some words used, wouldn't be acceptable now, but still good books, written for their time.
Gwen is still awful, a liar, a snob, bossy and mean spiritted , though Darryl is short tempered, she's also honest and kind, and apologies when she's wrong, so good things to learn for anyone 🙂 I don't think there's any book where all characters are lovely to kind of irrelevant really.

Maireas · 02/10/2022 12:33

@Helgadaley - I bet you've never forgotten it. Unfortunately that kind of attitude persisted.
As recently as 1992 (yes, I remember the year, and the teacher) a colleague referred to me as Sambo because I'd returned from holiday with a tan.
I'm white, so goodness knows what you've experienced 🌺

KimberleyClark · 02/10/2022 12:32

HuntingoftheSnark · 02/10/2022 12:26

@HumphreyCobblers yes, poor Alma! Didn't EB even give her the surname "Pudden" or have I made that up?!

Pudding was her surname. They called her pudding.

All EB’s children are extremely greedy, but fat people get a very hard time in her books.

Helgadaley · 02/10/2022 12:31

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 02/10/2022 08:29

So curiosity got the better of me and I just looked up that book. Apparently it wasn’t by EB, but she wrote another book about a black character, called Sambo, whose face was washed ‘clean’ in the rain… 🤯 Not sure if that’s me misremembering or whether our teacher at the time conflated the two. Either way - appalling message.

This was one of my first (sadly not my last) experiences of racism. I was one of only two mixed race children in the late1950s and the teacher read aloud 'Little Black Sambo.' How on earth a teacher thought this was ok when there was a mixed race child in the class, I've never understood. Other children were looking at me when she was reading it, I've never forgotten it even now I'm approaching 70.

KimberleyClark · 02/10/2022 12:30

Comedycook · 02/10/2022 12:19

I read the books avidly as a child and again with my own DD.

I couldn't stand Alicia, even as a child when I read the books, an an adult, I disliked her even more. She was horrible. I was definitely more of a Gwen type! I hated PE. I'd have got on terribly at Malory towers! They were vile to Gwen.

Gwen wasn’t a nice person though. She played horrible tricks on Mary Lou, including smashing her pen which was of sentimental value to her, and tried to make it look like Darrell was responsible. She pretended to have a weak heart (inspired by Clarissa who actually did have one and couldn’t do games etc because of it), causing immense worry to her parents. She bullied her father into letting g her go to an expensive Swiss finishing school he couldn’t afford and by her own account said some pretty horrible things to him.

I didn’t feel sorry for her.

goldenbag · 02/10/2022 12:29

@AsAnyFuleKno what an utterly brilliant stress-relief idea. I'm going through a tough time so I'm going to do something similar. Thanks for the inspiration. I think I would say:

Last (too focused on the next generation - Felicity etc - which is a bit boring)

Fifth - Panto domination is weird, as you say

First - slow-moving opener

Third - too many horses Grin

Fourth - great characters and dramas

Second - huge fun, mysterious Daphne

HuntingoftheSnark · 02/10/2022 12:26

@HumphreyCobblers yes, poor Alma! Didn't EB even give her the surname "Pudden" or have I made that up?!

Maireas · 02/10/2022 12:26

TheMoth · 02/10/2022 12:24

I'm now a teacher. I have no idea how to pronounce any name anymore. Parents need to provide a phonetic spelling of every name these days. Eg. If your child is called niamh, I will pronounce it 'neve'.
"No miss, it's 'ni-am'"

Oh lord, I'm forever getting Alicia wrong, and Elisha, and Aoife (depending on the girl, Eefy, Oife, Ayfey....)

TheMoth · 02/10/2022 12:24

KillingMeDeftly · 02/10/2022 10:50

I went to school with an Alicia who pronounced it Aleesha so it seems there's no end of confusion!

I'm now a teacher. I have no idea how to pronounce any name anymore. Parents need to provide a phonetic spelling of every name these days. Eg. If your child is called niamh, I will pronounce it 'neve'.
"No miss, it's 'ni-am'"

Comedycook · 02/10/2022 12:19

I read the books avidly as a child and again with my own DD.

I couldn't stand Alicia, even as a child when I read the books, an an adult, I disliked her even more. She was horrible. I was definitely more of a Gwen type! I hated PE. I'd have got on terribly at Malory towers! They were vile to Gwen.

HumphreyCobblers · 02/10/2022 12:17

Whilst I agree there is an awful lot of negative stereotyping in MT I think it is being slightly unfairly portrayed as wholly bad on this thread. Virtues such as kindness, honestly, forgiveness and understanding are core themes also. Gwen IS a schemer who tries to get other girls into trouble by playing mean tricks on them and is slapped by Darrell because she held poor Mary -Lou under the water and practically drowned her.

Having said all that, sometimes the casual cruelty is so shocking. There is a character called Alma in the St Clare's books who is portrayed as loathesome in her 'fatness' and when it is revealed to be a product of a glandular 'imbalance'. the girls continue to mock her by making gobbling noises and imitating the way she eats! Confused

Antonia Forest writes school stories of total literary merit. They are superb.

Sonineties · 02/10/2022 12:17

I loved reading MT. Descriptions of midnight feasts were the best! It was the Harry Potter of the 1970s and 1980s IMO.

DC and I have watched the CBBC adaptation and I was a bit disappointed. In order to make it “right on” the plots have been mangled out of all recognition - it is now just a blank canvas for teaching 2020s PSHE. Matron’s infatuation with the male teacher was bizarre enough but the period one really jumped the shark for me.

Maireas · 02/10/2022 12:17

murasaki · 02/10/2022 00:10

I wanted to go to a boarding school with a sea water pool. Sadly it never happened for me...

Same here. I fantasised about going to boarding school and having that life!

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 12:15

Novum · 02/10/2022 12:10

I could never work out the way year groups worked, especially with children being bumped up a year if they were extra bright. Surely it would play havoc with their School Certificate exams if they'd effectively missed a year of education?

EB's seem a bit whimsical. MT and SC don't seem to have any kind of streaming. Also, though there is an 'Upper Fourth' at MT, no mention is ever made of a Lower Fourth.

If you compare Antonia Forest's Kingscote school, that had A forms and B forms and also 'Removes' for people who needed extra coaching, which would allow more flexibility for people being taught outside their age group.

KimberleyClark · 02/10/2022 12:15

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 12:02

As were the O’Sullivan twins in the St Claire’s books.

The O'Sullivan twins really fade into the background after 'Second Form at St Clare's' so it's hard to say whether they'd have been any good as head girls.

I found it odd that EB, with St Clare's, set three books in the first year and one in the second, fourth and fifth, so we were cheated out of the third year and sixth form. I know someone has written fill-ins, but they're not the same.

And when the twins arrived St Clare’s the girls in the first form had been there several terms already, yet they all went up into the second form at the same time! As did the new girls in the previous book, other than Prudence who was expelled, and Pam who was considered too young, but she had caught up with them by the fifth form. Made no sense.

KillingMeDeftly · 02/10/2022 12:14

Novum · 02/10/2022 12:10

I could never work out the way year groups worked, especially with children being bumped up a year if they were extra bright. Surely it would play havoc with their School Certificate exams if they'd effectively missed a year of education?

Yes! Ellen is a new girl in the second form book but by third year she's gone up to the fourth.

Likewise clever Pamela in St Clare's is not made head girl because the teachers consider her too young, but it's then mentioned that she's staying on an extra year so could be head in the future. Surely if she was so clever she'd be off to university rather than spend two years in sixth form?

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 12:12

KillingMeDeftly · 02/10/2022 12:09

I think Ann Digby (Trebizon author?) wrote the fill-in St Clare's books and the Malory Towers sequels.

It was Pamela Cox who did St Clare's and Malory Towers, and Anne Digby wrote the 'Naughtiest Girl' sequels.

Novum · 02/10/2022 12:10

I could never work out the way year groups worked, especially with children being bumped up a year if they were extra bright. Surely it would play havoc with their School Certificate exams if they'd effectively missed a year of education?

KillingMeDeftly · 02/10/2022 12:09

I think Ann Digby (Trebizon author?) wrote the fill-in St Clare's books and the Malory Towers sequels.