Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone ever read Malory towers?

558 replies

Orangejelly1 · 02/10/2022 00:04

I used to love the books as a child! I read them cover to cover so many times and my favourite character was Darrell. I recently found my old collection and re read parts of them just for old times sake and I was actually really disappointed to see, as an adult, how awful some of the popular characters were. I know it was a product of its time and a different era, but Darrell, Alicia and some of the most popular girls would be called nasty bullies nowadays. I also felt so sorry for Gwen, which surprised me because as a child rearing the books she was my least favourite character.

just wondered if anyone else re read the books and thought this too!

OP posts:
kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 14:05

Oh and in the new series there’s also an American who says ‘wunnerful’ and ‘twenny’ which of course is a Bad Thing and is kept down a year as American education is apparently inferior. Not sure when that’s happened before…

kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 14:02

The new books are North Tower biased too as Susan, Felicity and Pam seem to take it in turns to be head of form. I think one book has a previously unpopular former pupil as head girl, who is also NT. She then redeems herself and is moved up a year if I recall correctly.

I’m sure one book has some teachers discussing who is to be HG and they rule out some, concluding ‘so that only leaves Felicity and Susan’ seemingly forgetting the 30 or so ET, ST and WT students 😂

(or that could have been in the first series with Darell and Sally being the candidates)

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 13:53

kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 13:50

*Yes - just dug out my 'Second Form' and Isabel says of Mirabel:

'She's bad at lessons - no good at games - hopeless at art - poor at gym.*

Wasn’t that because she wasn’t trying as she wanted to be expelled? So presumably she could have been ok at sports had she tried. I think Gladys was good at sports in the second form and got a go in the team.

But yes, they both forget they were ever great at music/drama when they become the sports captains! 😂

Yes, that could be an explanation, good thought. I suppose EB wanted to explore the idea of the power-crazed sports captain and Mirabel was the most likely candidate.

KatherineofGaunt · 02/10/2022 13:52

CoralBells · 02/10/2022 11:30

I remember when reading it to dd a bit where Gwen was being dropped off at boarding school and crying and the girls were all imitating her by weeping and sobbing to mock her. I remember the stories were modernised a bit in the 80s but I had an old copy from a charity shop.

I think that was the Third Form! The girls all line up along the windows with their hankies ready and start imitating Gwen and her mum. Then Irene snorts and the family look up and Gwen's dad roars with laughter at the assembled girls.

I think it's then that Bill turns up, but I could be wrong.

kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 13:50

*Yes - just dug out my 'Second Form' and Isabel says of Mirabel:

'She's bad at lessons - no good at games - hopeless at art - poor at gym.*

Wasn’t that because she wasn’t trying as she wanted to be expelled? So presumably she could have been ok at sports had she tried. I think Gladys was good at sports in the second form and got a go in the team.

But yes, they both forget they were ever great at music/drama when they become the sports captains! 😂

kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 13:43

Did anyone read the extra 6 Malory Towers books that Pamela Cox wrote

Reading then now 😂 they’re ok. They hammer the EB style of writing a bit using the word ‘for’ as a connecting word eg ‘no I couldn’t have seen her, for I was in the gym’ (I think on one page it’s used about four times) but other than that they’re quite true to the originals

They are a bit samey though - Felicity and Susan are Darrell and Sally again, June gets a best friend who is basically Betty only not in a other tower, Julie gets a friend called Lucy and they’re horse mad in the vein of Bill and Clarissa.

There’s a couple of interesting new ones though, Bonnie, who idolises Felicity at first but turns out to have a lot of character. And her friend Amy who is presumably the new Gwen as she’s pretty and snobbish, but does have sone redeeming features such as loyalty when Bonnie is sent to Coventry for something as she refuses to comply.

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 13:42

There appeared to be about 10 girls in NT so presumably the others were the same. There was no mention of streaming as the ‘duffers’ like Gwen were in the same form as the brilliant ones like Alicia. So were the parents paying all that money so their girls could be in a class of forty?

That does seem to be an inconsistency, as when Darrell joins the school she notes there are about 30 girls in her form - but there are 10 in North Tower, so either the other Towers are smaller or EB's maths is wrong!

And, yes, all the head girls of the forms seem to come from North Tower, and the only two head girls of the school also do. A few girls from other towers are mentioned briefly but AFAIR the only ones who merit more than a line are Betty, Alicia's friend, and Janet who makes the costumes for the panto.

HellaFitzgerald · 02/10/2022 13:42

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 13:37

Do you mean 'The Land of Far Beyond' - EB's version of The Pilgrim's Progress? I'm a huge fan of the original Pilgrim's Progress, and I really liked EB's take on it - it wasn't just a slavish copy with children in the key roles instead, much of it was original while broadly following the theme of Bunyan's masterpiece.

Yes, The Land of Far Beyond! I loved that book. I think that was my first EB book, before any of the school series.

This thread has made me google and I've found a lot of these books available for free in pdf and other formats so I'm going to have a good re-read session soon

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 13:37

HellaFitzgerald · 02/10/2022 13:33

Does anyone remember The Wishing Chair? And the story where three siblings had to overcome obstacles to reach Heaven!?

Do you mean 'The Land of Far Beyond' - EB's version of The Pilgrim's Progress? I'm a huge fan of the original Pilgrim's Progress, and I really liked EB's take on it - it wasn't just a slavish copy with children in the key roles instead, much of it was original while broadly following the theme of Bunyan's masterpiece.

kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 13:34

Also, that panto is ridiculously North Tower heavy. There are four towers - of the 8 speaking parts, four go to North Tower including the principal role; and of a committee of nine, seven are from North Tower. In reality, surely the other towers would have said something

The whole school is ridiculously North Tower top heavy, good luck being head of the form or head girl or games captain or even top of the class if you were in an other tower.

There appeared to be about 10 girls in NT so presumably the others were the same. There was no mention of streaming as the ‘duffers’ like Gwen were in the same form as the brilliant ones like Alicia. So were the parents paying all that money so their girls could be in a class of forty? Miss Grayling must have been minted!

Talking of Gwen and Miss Grayling I can’t help thinking it was a bit rich in the last book where she slags off Gwen to Darrell. She didn’t exactly bust a gut to sort her out did she? Maybe with a bit of support from the staff she could have done better rather than let the girls monitor her behaviour.

Darrell being HG annoyed me too, she wasn’t all that but I guess it was predictable. Packing Hilary off to India in her last year, so the OS twins got to be joint HGs, was harsh though. Poor Hilary! Why would she need to join her parents there full time, isn’t that sort of the point of boarding schools? They could have easily said they just wanted to give someone else a chance.

HellaFitzgerald · 02/10/2022 13:33

Does anyone remember The Wishing Chair? And the story where three siblings had to overcome obstacles to reach Heaven!?

HellaFitzgerald · 02/10/2022 13:32

Pineappleflowers · 02/10/2022 13:18

The characters are flawed but the reader was supposed to see that. Alica’s bullying of Gwen in particular was clearly highlighted and supposed to be thought provoking.

The snowflake generation can only cope with “goodie” and “baddie” characters but fiction used to be more interesting and complex than that.

Was it? I remember Gwen publicly putting Alicia in her place once when she was particularly horrible to someone and Darrell(?) joining in, and Alicia not liking it because she wasn't used to being on the other end, but I mostly remember it as being simplistic: Sporty, loud, confident girls were popular and quiet, non-sporty, shy girls mere mocked and derided. I don't remember any nuances that deviated from this path.

Earthrocknroll · 02/10/2022 13:29

KimberleyClark · 02/10/2022 09:03

I do wonder where she got the idea that French girls didn't like playing sport?

Or that they were all brilliant at sewing and embroidery!

she probably thought they all went to convent schools.

Or had no ‘sense of honour’!
That book with ‘little Claudine’ was always banging on about teaching her ‘the English sense of honour’ as if no other nationality had any!

These were some of my favourite books as a child, despite the issues. Naughtiest girl, Adventure Series, Adventurous Four and St Clare’s too.

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 13:23

HellaFitzgerald · 02/10/2022 13:11

How strange! I've just googled it and you're right. This part:

Margery is playing in a school match, but is not cheered either time she scores a goal, all because Pat O'Sullivan reminds everyone that Margery is in Coventry.

Until I just read it, I thought that was Mirabel!

Yes - just dug out my 'Second Form' and Isabel says of Mirabel:

'She's bad at lessons - no good at games - hopeless at art - poor at gym.'

Mirabel is only mentioned playing lacrosse at a practice, where she turns up late because the others have put stones in her shoes and sewn her sleeves up.

It's the girl she befriends, Gladys, who is marvellous at lacrosse - in 'Fifth' she is vice captain to Mirabel as sports captain.

TheLostNights · 02/10/2022 13:23

Loved these books as a child. Now enjoying the Iplayer series

Pineappleflowers · 02/10/2022 13:18

The characters are flawed but the reader was supposed to see that. Alica’s bullying of Gwen in particular was clearly highlighted and supposed to be thought provoking.

The snowflake generation can only cope with “goodie” and “baddie” characters but fiction used to be more interesting and complex than that.

Ozgirl75 · 02/10/2022 13:17

It’s awful but the name Alma will always be a fat girl name to me because of Enid Blyton.
In fact when I think of it, I always picture Gwendolines as blonde, lazy and mean and Sally as a good sort.
Clearly more influenced than I realised 😄

HellaFitzgerald · 02/10/2022 13:11

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 13:04

An interesting thing about that book is Mirabel suddenly becoming sports mad. When she's introduced in 'Second Form' her passion is music, specifically the violin and it's mentioned in passing that she's no good at lacrosse.

In 'Fifth' we meet Felicity, the violin-playing genius, and Mirabel doesn't seem to feel any sympathy for her.

It's almost as if EB has conflated Mirabel with Margery, who is brilliant at games but a similar pain in the neck when she first arrives at the school.

How strange! I've just googled it and you're right. This part:

Margery is playing in a school match, but is not cheered either time she scores a goal, all because Pat O'Sullivan reminds everyone that Margery is in Coventry.

Until I just read it, I thought that was Mirabel!

Silvernecklace · 02/10/2022 13:08

I loved numbers 1, 2 and 4 but not the others.

I identified most with Violet. She is the quiet, shy child in the form and is pretty much invisible. She is only mentioned twice in the first book. Also Emily, the studious one who does embroidery. I always felt like Enid Blyton really despised those characters though. And I thought Darrell was mean to invite Emily out at half term then ignore her again because she was boring.

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 13:04

HellaFitzgerald · 02/10/2022 12:57

The best story out of Malory Towers and St Clares was Fifth Formers at St Clares - that book was hilarious and entertaining from start to finish:

Angela going power mad at having 'servants' in the form of the lower formers and her ongoing battle with Claudine's cousin Antoinette who made her eat shoe polish sandwiches

Mirabel also going power mad and the whole school turning against her

Anne-Marie setting up that teacher who openly despised her with the fake poem and exposing her in front of the whole class

The night with the midnight feast and Mamzelle on the prowl locking up girls she thought were burglars, including Alma who was stealing food because she was jealous that she wasn't invited to the feast, and Jane who was ill to the point of collapse after being bullied by Mirabel. Also the aforementioned Anne Marie who pretended she was sleepwalking because that's what Felicity "the musical genius" did and she was jealous of the attention it got her.

That is one I will always reread.

An interesting thing about that book is Mirabel suddenly becoming sports mad. When she's introduced in 'Second Form' her passion is music, specifically the violin and it's mentioned in passing that she's no good at lacrosse.

In 'Fifth' we meet Felicity, the violin-playing genius, and Mirabel doesn't seem to feel any sympathy for her.

It's almost as if EB has conflated Mirabel with Margery, who is brilliant at games but a similar pain in the neck when she first arrives at the school.

UpendedPineapple · 02/10/2022 13:03

eddiemairswife · 02/10/2022 09:57

The first Enid Blyton I read was The Mystery of the Burnt Cottage, It must have been a birthday or Christmas present, and it was newly published, and I had newly learnt to read. After that I read as many of her books as I could until I was about 10 or 11, when I realised I becoming less addicted. At that time there were very few paper-backs for children (paper shortage) so the library was the main place to go for reading material.

That was my first book and I loved them! The Mystery of the Siamese Cats with Fatty and Busted 🤣

Skelligsfeathers · 02/10/2022 13:01

KimberleyClark · 02/10/2022 12:32

Pudding was her surname. They called her pudding.

All EB’s children are extremely greedy, but fat people get a very hard time in her books.

Her name WAS Alma Pudden.
At the end itvturned out ut was glandular and she had an operation. :0

KimberleyClark · 02/10/2022 12:59

Angela going power mad at having 'servants' in the form of the lower formers and her ongoing battle with Claudine's cousin Antoinette who made her eat shoe polish sandwiches

And used up all of Angela’s incredibly expensive face cream to polish Angela’s shoes.

UpendedPineapple · 02/10/2022 12:57

Ozgirl75 · 02/10/2022 04:45

I also really liked the Trebizon books and there was another series where they did a play about the two princes (I think?) and I vaguely remember they were in like a girl guides group? Very hazy memories but I really liked them at the time!

Was coming to see if anyone else read Trebizon. I loved them, Rebecca the amazing tennis player and her crush on Robbie, Trish's brother. Sue who wore glasses.

They seemed so modern compared to MT and St C. Loved those too - Claudine seemed so exotic a name to me. And Carlotta!

HellaFitzgerald · 02/10/2022 12:57

The best story out of Malory Towers and St Clares was Fifth Formers at St Clares - that book was hilarious and entertaining from start to finish:

Angela going power mad at having 'servants' in the form of the lower formers and her ongoing battle with Claudine's cousin Antoinette who made her eat shoe polish sandwiches

Mirabel also going power mad and the whole school turning against her

Anne-Marie setting up that teacher who openly despised her with the fake poem and exposing her in front of the whole class

The night with the midnight feast and Mamzelle on the prowl locking up girls she thought were burglars, including Alma who was stealing food because she was jealous that she wasn't invited to the feast, and Jane who was ill to the point of collapse after being bullied by Mirabel. Also the aforementioned Anne Marie who pretended she was sleepwalking because that's what Felicity "the musical genius" did and she was jealous of the attention it got her.

That is one I will always reread.