Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone ever read Malory towers?

558 replies

Orangejelly1 · 02/10/2022 00:04

I used to love the books as a child! I read them cover to cover so many times and my favourite character was Darrell. I recently found my old collection and re read parts of them just for old times sake and I was actually really disappointed to see, as an adult, how awful some of the popular characters were. I know it was a product of its time and a different era, but Darrell, Alicia and some of the most popular girls would be called nasty bullies nowadays. I also felt so sorry for Gwen, which surprised me because as a child rearing the books she was my least favourite character.

just wondered if anyone else re read the books and thought this too!

OP posts:
Flapjacker48 · 02/10/2022 16:52

@HuntingoftheSnark Yes - "Mystery of the missing necklace" - disguises himself as a waxwork of Napoleon (is caught by the criminals as Goon who is also hiding at the waxwork display coughs!)

Flapjacker48 · 02/10/2022 16:50

@MurderAtTheBeautyPageant Goon does indeed thrash his nephew Ern but of course would never touch the upper middle class children of Peterswood! (Good is "in awe" of Mrs Trottersville) However this unfair corporal punishment of Ern is criticised in the story...

HuntingoftheSnark · 02/10/2022 16:49

@Flapjacker48 true, and at least Fatty was revered by all and highly intelligent despite his size (that's in the context of EB's other plus size characters).

Did he once disguise himself as a waxwork?!!! I have a vague recollection of him putting a thin layer of wax all over his face. Now that was a bit hard to believe ....

lessthanathirdofanacre · 02/10/2022 16:49

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 16:09

When I first read her books I was a bit thrown by the odd timescale

I didn't read them in order - before the internet they were very hard to get hold of - I read Autumn Term first and then The Cricket Term - and I was totally baffled by TOTP references in the latter, coupled with Karen having acquired a husband and two step children; when in Autumn Term they'd been travelling on steam trains and Karen was heading for Oxford. I kept trying to make sense of the timeline and failing, obviously. It was only when I'd got hold of more of them that I realised there were two completely independent timelines.

I echo everything you say about the quality of the books - they really are in a different league from other school stories (not that they can truly be pigeonholed under 'school' as there are more holiday books than school books). The only failing (in my opinion) is that I didn't think the two historicals were anywhere near as good - they're OK but not special - and it annoys me that she spent time writing them that she could have spent writing two more contemporary Marlow books.

I had a similar experience of reading them out of order. I read all the Kingscote books before ever getting my hands on the others. On the first page of End of Term, Nicola thinks, "Lucky Patrick." I remember thinking lucky who? I now have a full set of all the books, some Girls Gone By reprints and others that I found by scouring Amazon for used copies.

I agree about the historical books. Though I think some of the contemporary books are also weaker than others. The Thuggery Affair is one that I don't much care for. My favourites are all four school stories, Peter's Room, and Falconer's Lure.

Flapjacker48 · 02/10/2022 16:47

@Silvernecklace I don't think it was as stark as "no anesthetic" - all was stated was that Mr Rivers did the operation with the schools matron (who was a qualified nurse too) assisting. Presumably in the "san" (school hospital)

Flapjacker48 · 02/10/2022 16:44

@HuntingoftheSnark I think as a child though, the find-outers books were clever as Fatty "revealed" how he solved the cases and what his thinking was (done in some of the books of the series better than others) - of course EB was probably inspired by Conan Doyle as Holmes also sets out HOW he worked it out towards the end!

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 02/10/2022 16:42

I wasn't as keen on those due to the unlikelihood of an 11 year old boy being such a master of disguise that he could transform himself into a gypsy woman or an old tramp in the blink of an eye.

I had forgotten that. So funny Grin

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 02/10/2022 16:41

That poor policeman Mr Goon really must have been itching to wallop Fatty and chums.

HuntingoftheSnark · 02/10/2022 16:39

Flapjacker48 · 02/10/2022 15:40

I used to love the "Five find outers" (mystery) series, but the way their "lower class" friend Ern, is treated is stark (eats in kitchen with cook at Fatty's place for example, whereas the other would each with his parents etc)

Ern Goon - wasn't he the local policeman's nephew? And another example of awful degradation of Frederick Algernon Trotteville, giving him those initials and calling him Fatty!!! I wasn't as keen on those due to the unlikelihood of an 11 year old boy being such a master of disguise that he could transform himself into a gypsy woman or an old tramp in the blink of an eye. Although at least Bets had a starring role, unlike poor old Anne whose destiny was always to make the cave look homely.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 02/10/2022 16:35

Arbesque · 02/10/2022 16:33

They went into business together running a riding school.

Yes but it is clear that they are living together as part of that

Arbesque · 02/10/2022 16:33

Tomorrowisalatterday · 02/10/2022 15:36

Bill and Clarissa are basically canon aren't they? They set up home together after school!

They went into business together running a riding school.

Silvernecklace · 02/10/2022 16:26

FlosCampi · 02/10/2022 10:30

And doesn't someone have their appendix removed without anaesthetic in the sanatorium?

So glad someone mentioned this!!

As I child I didn't question it. Reading it as an experienced Theatre nurse is something else!!

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 02/10/2022 16:10

Yes. Read every single one as a kid and loved them 💕

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 16:09

When I first read her books I was a bit thrown by the odd timescale

I didn't read them in order - before the internet they were very hard to get hold of - I read Autumn Term first and then The Cricket Term - and I was totally baffled by TOTP references in the latter, coupled with Karen having acquired a husband and two step children; when in Autumn Term they'd been travelling on steam trains and Karen was heading for Oxford. I kept trying to make sense of the timeline and failing, obviously. It was only when I'd got hold of more of them that I realised there were two completely independent timelines.

I echo everything you say about the quality of the books - they really are in a different league from other school stories (not that they can truly be pigeonholed under 'school' as there are more holiday books than school books). The only failing (in my opinion) is that I didn't think the two historicals were anywhere near as good - they're OK but not special - and it annoys me that she spent time writing them that she could have spent writing two more contemporary Marlow books.

Flapjacker48 · 02/10/2022 15:57

@HumphreyCobblers No, it is revealed towards the end by Miss Theobold that Alma has the condition making her overweight and unhealthy and the girls so then feel ashamed about their behaviour.

Flapjacker48 · 02/10/2022 15:40

I used to love the "Five find outers" (mystery) series, but the way their "lower class" friend Ern, is treated is stark (eats in kitchen with cook at Fatty's place for example, whereas the other would each with his parents etc)

lessthanathirdofanacre · 02/10/2022 15:39

Someone above referred to EB's books as "iconoclastic." I would say they are rather the opposite, repeating and reinforcing the worst beliefs and values and prejudices of their time without challenging them at all. EB can tell a good story sometimes, but all her characters are one-dimensional.

I'm so glad to see other fans of Antonia Forest on this thread. She was a truly brilliant writer, leagues above EB and her ilk. AF's characters are so subtly drawn and I love the way she subverts the usual school story tropes. When I first read her books I was a bit thrown by the odd timescale (in the earlier books the characters can remember the war while in the later books they watch Top of the Pops and discuss Vatican II) but before long it didn't bother me. I still reread my favourites regularly. I used to reread End of Term in the run up to Christmas every year. Maybe I'll do that again this year.

jane1956 · 02/10/2022 15:37

Pam Cox has done some wonderful add on to the original books

Tomorrowisalatterday · 02/10/2022 15:36

Bill and Clarissa are basically canon aren't they? They set up home together after school!

KillingMeDeftly · 02/10/2022 15:35

@kierenthecommunity as long as it didn't involve Timmy the dog...

kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 15:21

There’s some very interesting fanfic featuring Bill and Clarissa if anyone’s in the market for that. Similarly Miss Peters and Miss Linnie/Mam’zelle Rougier.

There’s also a very colourful one featuring Sally Hope who’s married to Julian Kirrin having a threesome with Felicity.

Apparently.

PonyPatter44 · 02/10/2022 15:04

I loved Bill. Turning up on horseback with all seven brothers was absolutely my dream way to arrive at school!

I can only assume that her parents sent the driver with her trunk and tuckbox and all her horse things separately.

kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 14:28

I actually thought Zerelda was a great character and thought it was a shame EB wrote her out, especially as they’d palled her up with Mavis.

I really related to the bit where she was sent down a form and acted like she was unconcerned

I also loved the bit where Miss Hibbert realised she was a bit hard on her and has a private chat after the doomed play rehearsal - and how Zerelda totally takes on board what is said to her

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 14:08

kierenthecommunity · 02/10/2022 14:05

Oh and in the new series there’s also an American who says ‘wunnerful’ and ‘twenny’ which of course is a Bad Thing and is kept down a year as American education is apparently inferior. Not sure when that’s happened before…

It totally pissed me off when Zeralda was criticised for reciting Shakespeare in an American accent. Shakespeare wrote his plays before the English language migrated to America, so her pronunciation would be no further from originally intended than the UK girls' pronunciation

AsAnyFuleKno · 02/10/2022 14:06

or that could have been in the first series with Darell and Sally being the candidates

In 'Second Form* when Sally is made head of form, Miss Parker tells the girls who was in the running - Darrell, Jean (also NT and is HG of 3rd form and for two terms in Upper 4th before she moves up a form and Darrel becomes head) and 'Winnie Toms' - Winnie isn't NT. She may be the Winnie who Betty takes along to the feast in book 4, in which case she is East Tower.