Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have asked them to find their own place to live?

222 replies

diddymu · 01/10/2022 22:19

I've name changed as this could possibly be outing.

DS (20) has been in a relationship with a woman for about a year and half, she's slightly older and has a 5 year old from a previous relationship, they've been living with me for about a year as the child's dad found out where she was living, it's all been fine, they contribute a little financially and they do their fair share of cleaning and cooking. The only issue is holidays as the 5yo is sleeping in what was the spare room/ previously DS1s room and DS1 is at uni but when he comes home from uni, the 5 yo has to sleep in with DS and his mum which isn't ideal but they don't seem to mind.

They recently announced that the girlfriend is pregnant (about 10/11 weeks) which was a bit of a shock but they seem happy with the news, I've told them they have to find their own place to live before the baby arrives and DS has said I'm selfish as it's my grandchild, they won't be able to afford it as he's just started uni, they'll make the lack of space work and has tried blaming DS1 for coming home during holidays as he said if he didn't I wouldn't be asking them to move out.

It's probably my fault as he is my youngest so I probably have made the wrong decision to allow them all to stay etc as I didn't want him to move out yet, so feel free to judge but AIBU?

OP posts:
diddymu · 02/10/2022 11:30

I've read through the replies and ill try and answer some questions, and some again as they seemed to have been missed.

DS previously quit uni back in 2020 as he didn't like it as most the lectures were online and he wasn't enjoying the course etc. He got a job and worked there for about 2 years until he had an argument of some sort with his manager a few months ago and quit, he never told me what it was about as he said it didn't matter. When they were both working they'd both contribute a small amount but now it's just his girlfriend, she is lovely and does cook and clean etc and she buys everything her child needs, DS does also clean.

His girlfriend was previously in a council house, her parents aren't involved as they wasn't happy about the first pregnancy.

OP posts:
CherryGenoa · 02/10/2022 11:26

@Mamansparkles also made a good post, plenty of positive suggestions. You want to be treading that line where you are supportively launching them into independence but not burning bridges. A new grandchild is a lovely thing and I imagine you will want to be an involved granny on your terms of course.

MeridianB · 02/10/2022 11:24

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 01/10/2022 22:30

Get them out before baby arrives, or they will never leave!

This.

You’ve been hugely supportive for a year. It’s a slap in the face that your son has called you selfish for not accommodating their reproductive choices. They’ve clearly given zero thought to supporting a family before they created one. if you let them stay it will be many more years before anything changes.

AloysiusBear · 02/10/2022 11:24

If he is at uni so doesn't have any income, doesnt seem like they were in a position to have a baby. Not a good choice, have they thought this through?

CherryGenoa · 02/10/2022 11:22

Your DS is still young at 20 and probably feels intimidated by the idea of living in his own place with all the adult responsibilities that go with keeping a roof over the head of them both and two children. Who wouldn’t be sympathetic, but he has grown up responsibilities that he needs to face. What your other son does is irrelevant, it is your home and your wishes that matter. I can envisage a scenario where if they stay, you may be pressured into providing free childcare and sidelining your own needs once the baby arrives. You must establish firm boundaries now.

Tell them that they must move out before the baby is born. You can be supportive with helping them by providing information and advice, building their confidence that they can manage ok as a couple.

Your DS and partner need to budget for different scenarios (that don’t include continuing to stay with you!) to work out what they can afford. Tell DS that he possibly needs to defer university to get a full time job, but that they need to check how much they would have to live on in each scenario, factoring in expenses such as housing, childcare, commuting and utilities. Tell them about the Entitled to calculator, or how to contact local citizens advice if they are struggling to pull the figures together. Good luck, and if you need any info to help you support them, let us know and the Mumsnet hivemind can probably help.

Lampzade · 02/10/2022 11:21

Mamansparkles · 02/10/2022 11:19

Why do people keep saying the gf is 5 years older? OP has said she is 'slightly' older and has a 5 year old. She could be 21, 22, 23...
OP I think tough love, they need to move out. It sounds like the gf is very vulnerable but also much more sensible than DS. She's had a child in her teens, presumably in the abusive relationship, managed to get out and is working part time around looking after this 5 year old and seems to have no support from her own family. Given DS doesnt work, she must be the one who is making the financial contributions to the household that you mentioned?

She is clearly vulnerable and young herself and will need your help with the practical things but sounds far more open to it than your son. Sit down with her, talk through how you and she both know this is not a good set up for the children and they need their own home. Think beforehand about what help you can offer (ie help with baby costs e.g. pram so she can save for household, babysitting 2x a week etc). Make clear you arent cutting them out.
Then work through the options together, realistically:

  • uni accommodation, with DS still studying. Think about budgets and availability.
  • council; what's availability like in your area? Could they cope with DS studying or would he need to work? or half and half? Do you need to write a letter of eviction to get them on the list?
  • private rented. Are there deposit schemes? DS will certainly need to work. What is her maternity pay like? Etc.

Your DS sounds like he will be of no use in these discussions. When you and gf have worked out the fine details and what is the best/most possible option without his manipulative whinging, he can join you.

Great ideas

Mamansparkles · 02/10/2022 11:19

Why do people keep saying the gf is 5 years older? OP has said she is 'slightly' older and has a 5 year old. She could be 21, 22, 23...
OP I think tough love, they need to move out. It sounds like the gf is very vulnerable but also much more sensible than DS. She's had a child in her teens, presumably in the abusive relationship, managed to get out and is working part time around looking after this 5 year old and seems to have no support from her own family. Given DS doesnt work, she must be the one who is making the financial contributions to the household that you mentioned?

She is clearly vulnerable and young herself and will need your help with the practical things but sounds far more open to it than your son. Sit down with her, talk through how you and she both know this is not a good set up for the children and they need their own home. Think beforehand about what help you can offer (ie help with baby costs e.g. pram so she can save for household, babysitting 2x a week etc). Make clear you arent cutting them out.
Then work through the options together, realistically:

  • uni accommodation, with DS still studying. Think about budgets and availability.
  • council; what's availability like in your area? Could they cope with DS studying or would he need to work? or half and half? Do you need to write a letter of eviction to get them on the list?
  • private rented. Are there deposit schemes? DS will certainly need to work. What is her maternity pay like? Etc.

Your DS sounds like he will be of no use in these discussions. When you and gf have worked out the fine details and what is the best/most possible option without his manipulative whinging, he can join you.

Smineusername · 02/10/2022 11:14

Depending on the degree it might make a lot more financial sense to drop out now and work full +over time. I teach Higher education and most degrees do not increase your earning potential these days

Smineusername · 02/10/2022 11:12

The gf needs to get her own place with her kid. Universal credit would then cover most of her rent and give her a bit extra to live on if she is working part time. He should (technically) stay at yours, get a part time job working 30 odd hours a week, you give him a pass on the rent and bills and he saves like fuck for the next 6 months. This could give a nest egg of at least a few thousand. That way you are helping and supporting them working toward independence. I wouldn't have them in the house but equally it's not a good time to cut them off they will need support

Lampzade · 02/10/2022 11:06

Social housing is difficult to get. As another poster said it depends on the area. They may be housed in temporary accommodation which is usually grim.
Op may find that her son punishes her by going no contact.
It is a really difficult situation to be in Op. However, this is a situation where the notion of ‘tough love’ comes into play.
He is basically a father of two and has to sort himself out. He needs to study part time and work. It will take him slightly longer to complete his degree but he will only be about twenty five when he completes his degree
It will not be easy but he made his own bed..,,

MarigoldMoonStone · 02/10/2022 11:01

I got a flat in Glasgow 3 years ago and a flat in Devon 18 months ago so it is totally possible. You are not expected to share a bedroom with your baby and while it doesn’t make you the highest priority it does still give you a chance of getting somewhere. They need to register asap because the longer you are on it also increases your chance of getting somewhere. Different areas have different criteria.

katepilar · 02/10/2022 11:01

knittingaddict · 02/10/2022 10:03

That's fine for you in your culture, but nothing in the op says that this is their culture, so no reason for the op to try to make it work. Overcrowding is overcrowding what ever your culture.

Whether you feel two parents and two children sleeping in one room is overcrowding or not IS cultural.
That a lot of UK (bed)rooms are too small to put four beds in is another issue.

YumYummy · 02/10/2022 10:59

Years ago it used to be the case that if the OP evicts then then the local authority will place them in temporary accommodation (B&B accommodation perhaps). I don’t know if this is still the procedure.

MarigoldMoonStone · 02/10/2022 10:57

My experience was 18 months ago, it’s most certainly worth a try - it totally depends on the area.

Branleuse · 02/10/2022 10:57

Could they apply for social housing as overcrowded

PorridgewithQuark · 02/10/2022 10:54

lapasion · 02/10/2022 10:44

What? Where? I’m stuck in private rented and would love this.

I thought that - I don't thinkMarigoldMoonStone was speaking from recent experience!

Even 20 years ago I remember 16,17 and 18 year old girls at the school where I worked half seriously claiming that they were going to get pregnant "to get a flat" and having to be convinced of the reality of the situation (and every couple of years one actually being pregnant and not having a snowball in hell's chance of getting accommodation and remaining in the overcrowded family homes sharing their childhood bedroom with the baby, or once moving to a mother and baby foster placement).

MadMadMadamMim · 02/10/2022 10:53

What a silly pair. They are currently unable to house themselves or the 5 year old that the GF already has. They both sound utterly immature - although there is some excuse for your barely-out-of-his-teens son. Little excuse for an adult woman who already has a 5 yo child and is relying on others to put a roof over their heads.

They need to move out. And behave like grown ups if they actually want to be parents.

MarigoldMoonStone · 02/10/2022 10:53

@lapasion because they are living in overcrowded conditions, you can’t count the others sons bedroom so it’s 3 going to be 4 in one room plus shared kitchen and bathroom, also they can say OP needs them out, so they would be a high priority on the housing list. Unfortunately being stuck in private rented doesn’t make you a priority :( obviously depends on the area how quickly they would get somewhere but when this was my situation I got somewhere in a few months.

lapasion · 02/10/2022 10:44

MarigoldMoonStone · 02/10/2022 10:04

They would be able to get a house through the local housing authority easily and get help paying rent

What? Where? I’m stuck in private rented and would love this.

TiaraBoo · 02/10/2022 10:38

YANBU!
I’d want to have a vote in their family planning if they’re planning to extend their family in my house!

Also, if they’re stealthily taking over your house by saying you’re selfish (which is rude), when do you get to invite friends over including make friends - unless that’s been benched on your behalf!

Qwerkie · 02/10/2022 10:36

It’s their choice to have this baby. If they are going to have it then your DS needs to forget about uni for now, stop dicking around and get a job to support them all.

definitely not unreasonable to ask them to leave especially since he’s now eyeing up other rooms in your house for them to use instead of getting his act together

Bearsporridge · 02/10/2022 10:32

I’m not disagreeing with you, or with the advice you’ve been given here, but one of the things that’s jumping out from your posts is that your decisions so far have been reactive.

First you invited them in because you had too much space/you were lonely; then you’re asking them to leave because it’s overcrowded. So I can understand (to an extent) your ds’ rational that the problem is his extra sibling. He’s not correct, but he might be partially right in intuiting that if your other ds hadn’t come home you might have reacted differently.

Dc, and particularly youngest ones are bloody expert psychologists when it comes to ferreting out the weak points in their dp’s thinking.

I think you need to figure out what’s important to you and then the decisions you take will be much more certain.

Write down everything that could be important, and that is important, and after a while come back to the list and you’ll see the 1 or 2 things that are most important to you.

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 10:31

The notice to move out isn’t going to magic up a place for them to live. And the OP is going to probably end up being asked to be guarantor which I would be very unhappy about given son’s displayed level of maturity.

Housing is really really difficult at the moment. I would support them to talk to charities, CAB, uni accommodation about their options. Uni family accommodation is usually in short supply and unlikely to be an option.

SacredDeer · 02/10/2022 10:31

In the words of Jeremy Kyle

'he should've out something on the end of it'

Your son and his girlfriend are taking the piss unfortunately, if they are paying a small amount of money to stay with you then they should have been saving the rest.

This isn't your fault that they are in this position and it's not your responsibility. He needs to grow up and accept responsibility. A lot of people are at uni and still work, he should've thought about accommodation/finances etc before knocking up his girlfriend.

Cantthinkofanewnameatm · 02/10/2022 10:27

Yes, this year is his first year of uni, he's refused to defer as he left a few years ago as he didn't like it but he's said he wants to stick at it this time. He did get a job but he quit a few months ago after an argument with his boss (no idea what about) and me and his girlfriend both agreed it was a stupid thing to do but he didn't seem to care and he spent the summer looking after the 5 year old when his gf was working or playing on the Xbox

This doesn’t bode well. He’s immature and selfish, no reflection on you, he probably just won’t grow up up until he’s mid 20s-30.
He can’t play in an X-box when he’s responsible for children, he’s not 12.
He needs to crack on and find a home and get a p/t job if he’s going to be at Uni.
3 months notice to move out.