Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Possible benefit fraud and cms

89 replies

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:02

Posted here for traffic!

I know benefit fraud threads have been done quite frequently some think report some say mind your own business anyway

I'm unsure wether to report this or not as don't know for certain just wanted others views

So not to drip feed this is about my children's father and wife it's not about me being bitter more the principle so ex doesn't see kids at all his choice but contacts me sporadically I went through cms even though I knew he was on universal credit and it would be £7 a week like I said principle he still didn't pay or waited till I txt him and then pay late so he was put on collect and pay it got took from his UC so one month a payment never came so I contacted cms to be told he's not on UC anymore they will investigate to find out why and if he's working that was fine. He then contacted me and I mentioned payments stopped he said aw he messed up told up he was working self employed when he wasn't to get them off his back with interviews and it backfired so his UC claim was stopped Idiot! Anyway I'm confused as far as I'm aware it should have been a joint claim(I'm not interested in her finances) so my question is if it's a joint claim his if wouldn't have been stopped? which now makes me think they were both claiming separately what do people think? He's definitely not claiming anymore and definitely not working so as far as cms are concerned he's got no income yet rents, drives a car as another child living with them so can a married couple claim separately or can he be kicked off the claim alone? Hope that makes sense

I have no worries reporting him for benefit fraud but only if I'm 100% sure

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/10/2022 23:43

If she's supporting him (for example, because she's increased her hours and now isn't eligible for anything or because he dropped his claim for any reason), it's not her job to support your children.

Even if she is claiming for both of them, you reporting a possible historical fraud would only have the effect of penalising their toddler, it wouldn't get you any money.

Is hurting a toddler worth it for a feeling of revenge?

Sugarplumfairy65 · 01/10/2022 23:32

Isn't paying

Sugarplumfairy65 · 01/10/2022 23:32

BambinaJAS · 01/10/2022 21:09

Mind your own business.

It is her business. He installing support for his children

Gingerkittykat · 01/10/2022 22:24

If he reported paid employment through UC they would base the payment on what HMRC reports to them, if HMRC report 0 earnings then his UC claim could continue.

Gingerkittykat · 01/10/2022 22:22

Banana2079 · 01/10/2022 22:01

This is incorrect universal credit require all claimants to look for work regardless of how old the child is
There is no such thing as income support anymore that is an old system
There also is no such thing as One person being put down as the main carer for the child so not required to look for work - no such thing OP
seeing as his benefits stopped it is obvious that she is the one who has been put down as the main carer not him so universal credit will have been asking him to look for work . Why did his benefit stop then? Either she earns too much for him to be able to receive it or he Has declared that he is working and in that case CMS can investigate

I'm sorry but that is inaccurate.

In a couple one person is named main carer for children, someone who is the main carer is not expected to work at all if the child is under 3 and then it is limited hours until the child is 12.

In addition, if one partner earns the equivalent of 35 times the minimum wage per week then the other partner will not be expected to work at all even when the kids are older.

It would make no financial sense for him to come off a joint claim. They would get approx an extra £200 a month so even taking out £28 for maintenance they would be better off.

A healthy single man wouldn't have been able to stay on UC for two years without having to do very intensive work search and would face being sanctioned if he didn't comply.

It is possible that he is a cocklodger who does not work and lives off his new partner. My ex did this while working cash in hand so he didn't have to pay me anything.

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 22:14

@Banana2079

That's not true both parents dont need to be working or look for work 1 of them is classed as caregiver for child and when child turns 3 they are put on light touch to prepare for looking for work.

She works definitely and his UC claim stopped not because her income was too high his claim stopped because he reported him working when he wasn't because he thought it would make them stop making him look for work I know this because he told me and also because cms told me he reported paid employment to UC therefore his claim stopped but he only done it thinking they would stop making him look for work and continue to pay him some UC

OP posts:
ironingboredrefusal · 01/10/2022 22:11

BambinaJAS · 01/10/2022 21:09

Mind your own business.

It is her business - the father should be paying towards his children - and not just what the CMS says he should either!

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 22:06

Banana2079 · 01/10/2022 21:55

If she is working depending on how much she earns he may not be entitled to any benefits because UC will see him as a joint couple
If he is no longer claiming universal credit then there’s nothing That CMS can do
If you think he’s self-employed and Getting cash in hand then it will be really hard to prove.
You can call the fraud hotline or report benefit fraud online Stating that you think that he is working cash in hand And she hasn’t declared it on her universal credit
If he is self-employed and NOT getting cash in hand CMS can still ask him to pay based on his tax returns but Your post seemed to imply that he is self-employed and not declaring it to anyone.
regardless though he must be getting some sort of income for himself there is no way that he will be living without a penny going to him and as a good father he should continue paying £7 a week even if it comes from his ex partner who should be giving him some sort of allowance if he’s not working and not entitled to universal credit because she works.. My friend and his wife ( who earns good money ) were claiming universal credit and he did get some for him In his account

She's definitely working and in a good profession that's why I am now thinking his claim is fraudulent as he's been on ice and been paying cms through collect and pay from his in since before he met her.

Thanks for the info but I know he's not working at all not even cash in hand he's quite literally not receiving any money now unless from her which is fine I'm not expecting or even wanting anything from her obviously but it's the fact they will have been better of for the past two years as claiming fraudulently and because of that he's not had to bother making any effort to get a job to provide for our 2 kids. In my mind if they hadn't been claiming separately they financially wouldn't be in the position of him needing to work and/or they would be claiming together and her working and him still receiving uc while caring for their child .

In a nutshell really he's got away with staying on IC for 2 years because they have been claiming separately

OP posts:
Banana2079 · 01/10/2022 22:01

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:40

@Babyroobs

See I thought about that but it doesn't explain him being made to job search 35 hours and attend appointments as he wouldn't need to with her working and then having a 2 year oldHmm I know for certain not an assumption about the jobcentre appointments as he sent me screenshots previously of his journal work search notes to prove he was looking for work to provide for our kids as he told me he wanted to "step up" and I told him I didn't believe him so he sent them

This is incorrect universal credit require all claimants to look for work regardless of how old the child is
There is no such thing as income support anymore that is an old system
There also is no such thing as One person being put down as the main carer for the child so not required to look for work - no such thing OP
seeing as his benefits stopped it is obvious that she is the one who has been put down as the main carer not him so universal credit will have been asking him to look for work . Why did his benefit stop then? Either she earns too much for him to be able to receive it or he Has declared that he is working and in that case CMS can investigate

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:59

@Isaidnoalready

Posted too soon!

So he's was on UC before he met her a honestly believe they haven't then changed to a joint claim and he's since getting married continued to claim as a single person

OP posts:
Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:57

@Isaidnoalready

No I never even though about that till your post

Me and him both worked full time when together he stopped work a while after we separated always provided for kids up till then he then went on to UC and our cms changed accordingly then he met her got married within a year and the cms amount has always stayed at the £7

OP posts:
Banana2079 · 01/10/2022 21:56

Sorry Gettin the £7 from his new partner not X

Banana2079 · 01/10/2022 21:55

If she is working depending on how much she earns he may not be entitled to any benefits because UC will see him as a joint couple
If he is no longer claiming universal credit then there’s nothing That CMS can do
If you think he’s self-employed and Getting cash in hand then it will be really hard to prove.
You can call the fraud hotline or report benefit fraud online Stating that you think that he is working cash in hand And she hasn’t declared it on her universal credit
If he is self-employed and NOT getting cash in hand CMS can still ask him to pay based on his tax returns but Your post seemed to imply that he is self-employed and not declaring it to anyone.
regardless though he must be getting some sort of income for himself there is no way that he will be living without a penny going to him and as a good father he should continue paying £7 a week even if it comes from his ex partner who should be giving him some sort of allowance if he’s not working and not entitled to universal credit because she works.. My friend and his wife ( who earns good money ) were claiming universal credit and he did get some for him In his account

Isaidnoalready · 01/10/2022 21:53

Honestly some people don't know about the carer thing it cropped up in one of my groups and took us awhile to work out why

PicaK · 01/10/2022 21:50

He's obviously claimed fraudulently. I would report them.
The rules around LTAAMC* are really clear. And if you are you have to do a joint claim.
*living together as a married couple

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:48

@Isaidnoalready

That's why I'm suspicious that he was claiming as a single person

OP posts:
Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:47

@Isaidnoalready

The way it works on UC if you do a joint claim one person has to put themselves down as the main carer for the child if she was the main carer he would have been expected to work/look for work (even if she was working unless you change the person registered as the carer)

Thank you that makes sense although don't understand if that's the case why he wouldn't have put him as main carer for child as she definitely works his issue was they "were on his case to look for work" his words and that's why he told them he was now working but it backfired

OP posts:
Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:44

Paparazzicrap · 01/10/2022 21:38

His wife's income has absolutely nothing to do with your claim. He could give up work completely, live the millionaire lifestyle on her money and you would be entitled to absolutely nothing

I couldn't care less about his wife's income! So your comment is pointless the only reason I've mention his wife working is because on a joint claim I thought one parent would be exempt from looking for work to care for child and if she was working then that would be him so therefore he would still be receiving UC and our children would still be receiving their measly £7 a week

OP posts:
Isaidnoalready · 01/10/2022 21:42

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:40

@Babyroobs

See I thought about that but it doesn't explain him being made to job search 35 hours and attend appointments as he wouldn't need to with her working and then having a 2 year oldHmm I know for certain not an assumption about the jobcentre appointments as he sent me screenshots previously of his journal work search notes to prove he was looking for work to provide for our kids as he told me he wanted to "step up" and I told him I didn't believe him so he sent them

If he has claimed to be living as a single person it makes sense he cant be the carer for the two year old if he isnt living in the family home

Isaidnoalready · 01/10/2022 21:40

Paparazzicrap · 01/10/2022 21:38

His wife's income has absolutely nothing to do with your claim. He could give up work completely, live the millionaire lifestyle on her money and you would be entitled to absolutely nothing

But it does have to do with universal credit you can be married live seperate and claim as a single person or you can live together and not be entitled due to her earnings if that's the case she won't get anything from him because they were taking it from his UC as he wouldn't pay

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:40

@Babyroobs

See I thought about that but it doesn't explain him being made to job search 35 hours and attend appointments as he wouldn't need to with her working and then having a 2 year oldHmm I know for certain not an assumption about the jobcentre appointments as he sent me screenshots previously of his journal work search notes to prove he was looking for work to provide for our kids as he told me he wanted to "step up" and I told him I didn't believe him so he sent them

OP posts:
Paparazzicrap · 01/10/2022 21:38

His wife's income has absolutely nothing to do with your claim. He could give up work completely, live the millionaire lifestyle on her money and you would be entitled to absolutely nothing

Isaidnoalready · 01/10/2022 21:37

Does she work?

The way it works on UC if you do a joint claim one person has to put themselves down as the main carer for the child if she was the main carer he would have been expected to work/look for work (even if she was working unless you change the person registered as the carer)

It's slightly complex

My ex was falsely claiming to live on the streets in reality he was living with his girlfriend and working cash in hand its frustrating he was paying me the £7 a week then he got a real job and refused to update CMO they refused to investigate him working so he got to keep his wages to himself for a year just continuing to pay me the £7 a week now they decide to look at it gave him a new amount he has suddenly had a serious accident at work and might lose his job

My point is you can't make a parent pay if they are enabled by others and unwilling to pay as long as his mom and girlfriend keep bankrolling him he will always be able to dodge payments

Babyroobs · 01/10/2022 21:34

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:32

@Babyroobs

Thanks it's a pathetic amount n to be honest obviously I didn't rely on it but it's the pure principle.

I honestly don't think it's been a joint claim she works in a decent job( don't want to put here incase outing) but she went to uni for it they have a toddler he was in UC before they got together as he's always paid £7 but he's been going to jobcentre for work appointments I know that for sure and he has even admitted to me that he's shot himself in the foot as he only told uc he was now working(even though he wasn't) and now he gets no uc money.

What I'm annoyed about is the only reason he's not been looking for a job to provide for his kids is financially he didn't have to if he was receiving single persons UC amount and she was working and receiving UC for their child then financially they were sorted but now he's not even being made to provide the measly £7 for 2 kids it's a joke

Could it be that they do have a joint claim and she earns too much for them to get any UC any more though because of her wages?

Lalala1 · 01/10/2022 21:34

@Diegofrompennyburn

Yes our children's cms claim is now nil award as Mr xxx has stopped receiving benefits

What assumptions? And I'll explain why I'm suspicious

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread