Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school shouldn’t have left out 8 kids?

67 replies

CoffeeHousePot · 01/10/2022 18:02

My DS goes to an independent primary school (all boys). He’s in Y 4. Rugby is a big thing at the school. My DS’s year is small 26 kids in 2 classes. They are split into three teams A, B and C based on ability. There are 8 kids in Team C. Ds is one of them. I’ve no issue with that.

Today on WhatsApp/Instagram are pictures of a rugby tournament run by the school (7 a side). They’ve invited other schools. Only Teams A and B were invited. So 8 children out of the year were not.

I just don’t think this is on. Given it was a weekend I imagine some children would not have been able to come, surely they could have rejigged the teams with a few subs on each team and everyone could have been invited? I just think they are 8/9 and to leave less then a 1/3 of the year out is mean. Fair enough if the year was bigger, but surely when you get to the point less then 1/2 kids won’t be invited you look to try and include everyone?

There’s plenty of time for the less sporty kids not to be selected why do it so early? My son is not as good as the most able kids, but it’s not the stage where it’s obvious. .

My DH however thinks it’s fine (he was good at rugby). You can’t be expected to be selected for everything. His view is if the kids aren’t good enough then they will be demoralised playing against more able kids.

So:

YABU - school should not have left out the C Team/should have rejigged to include everyone.
YANBU - it was fine. You can’t expect kids to be selected for everything/would be unfair to make C team players be subs for B team.

OP posts:
GeorgeorRuth · 01/10/2022 19:03

I can see both sides. Sport is competitive and it shouldnt be prizes for all but they should be encouraging a love of activity and sports.
In this tournament was the standard the same as A & B team so even matches? Or, was school trophy hunting to look good and would C team have had a good run out given the opportunity? I often found it was the former.
It also usually included kids belonging to clubs out of school.
My DC were in this position years ago at their indie schools.
I ended up in an engineered informal conversation with Head Teachers pointing out a schools results only were impressive when progress of the weakest improves. Therefore a DC going from C to B to A without additional coaching is an impressive school PE dept.
DS2 who was completely uncoordinated and couldn't catch if his life depended on it went from 'D' to 'A' reserve player in 2 years once at a school that coached all levels not just the 'chosen' few.

SophieIsHereToday · 01/10/2022 18:55

I remember auditioning for the school choir and I tried really hard. 5 out of 30 kids weren't selected. Whilst all the other kids were singing we had to do extra work. Choir practice was once or twice a week for a year. It was embarrassing and made me feel left out.

But actually it was a good experience, I'm sure resilient and being different bothers me less than most people. After all I'm an awful singer that were right

LIZS · 01/10/2022 18:48

Sorry but this happens all over. Dd was regularly one of a handful omitted, even in school time matches as their school had more pupils than the conpetition. I did complain when she was one of two excluded, was told it was an obvious mistake and my shy demotivated 9 yo should have approached the arrogant shouty staff member to speak up.

mantequilla · 01/10/2022 18:48

I think what the school are doing is fine, it's not like they're 3-4 year olds.

What's the point in taking along the kids that definitely won't play, and if they did play would likely be injured or unable to play to the needed level? This is how all sports are. Your DH is right, and it's a realistic age to start learning this.

Maybe find a fun/non competitive activity for your DC?

RandomUsernameHere · 01/10/2022 18:45

I think that is a downside of very small schools. Probably not all the DCs wanted to go anyway though. DS is the same age and hates rugby (he's absolutely football obsessed however).

luckylavender · 01/10/2022 18:41

That's sport. It's not always easy to have the whole spread of teams. I actually think it's a better lesson for life than always trying to accommodate everyone.

CoffeeHousePot · 01/10/2022 18:40

@SerenaTee I’m not upset. I was genuinely interested in peoples’s views. My DH usually have very similar views on schools and kids.

You (and various other posters) have all raised very good reasons on why they maybe could only have an A and B team, but none of that communicated.

OP posts:
AloysiusBear · 01/10/2022 18:39

By 8/9 they kinda have to start getting used to things like this. They arent tiny children any more, they know not everyone is good at everything.

Cornisharchitect8 · 01/10/2022 18:37

It's crappy but that's how it is :(

Whoever compared kids to Olympians upthread though 🤣 what an odd comparison

That's like comparing the school nativity to Lord of The Rings 😆

lannistunut · 01/10/2022 18:37

I just wouldn't give this head space. Team sports don't matter, just help him not to worry about rugby. Team C are the lucky ones, don't have to waste a Saturday!

itsgettingweird · 01/10/2022 18:36

CoffeeHousePot · 01/10/2022 18:29

@itsgettingweird it’s not the selection part per se. If the A team had gone off to a tournament fine. As I’ve mentioned my eldest is also in the C team, but in a much bigger year. So if A and B go off somewhere there is still a big group left.

So I would have an issue if the school did a maths challenge and said 18 kids were good enough to go and 8 weren’t. I would be really concerned the 8 would (at Agee 8) would go “I’m rubbish at maths”. If they took 6 or so no issue.

Except that does happen.

My ds is crap at some sports he knows it.

He's crap at English and knows it.

He's a brilliant para swimmer (British champ) and amazing at maths, science and computers and has a great job with a start up company with a great career ahead of him in software development.

Recognising your weaknesses and being resilient to them and using your strengths to your advantage are great skills to learn.

It doesn't work to pretend to children they are brilliant at everything and will get to do everything. The longer in life you believe it the harder the fall is when the truth dawns on you.

You can develop a child's self worth without lying to them about their abilities.

spiderontheceiling · 01/10/2022 18:36

My experience of tournaments is that there is usually a limit on the number of teams a school can enter and a limit on the number of players per team. It may well be that the school didn't actually have a choice about the numbers involved (well, unless they chose not to participate in the tournament at all).

Simonjt · 01/10/2022 18:36

The whole point of sport is that it is competitive, if you’re going to a tournament you take your best team/players, not your 3rd, 4th or 5th team.

We played today, we won, if we’d sent our 3rd team we would have lost. We recently won an international competition, we wouldn’t have won if we’d sent the second team.

My son plays rugby (will be playing the same age range as your son), he knows that some people are better than others, he knows that better teams sometimes get played more as he knows league tables are important. Being able to lose or happily sit out is an important part of life.

CheezePleeze · 01/10/2022 18:35

They've left out 1/3 of the year - not 'a few kids'.

I'm with your DH on this.

There's plenty of time for your DS to improve and join the A or B team.

scrufffy · 01/10/2022 18:34

That's just competitive sport I'm afraid.

SerenaTee · 01/10/2022 18:33

I’d be asking why the C team weren’t included before I got upset about it, particularly if the tournament was run by the school themselves. Maybe there weren’t enough other teams to allow C to play, maybe the standard of other teams was significantly better and C would struggle, maybe they didn’t have enough staff available to run 3 teams. But overall I do agree with your DH that it’s part and parcel of life (and sport).

decayingmatter · 01/10/2022 18:33

For gods sake, why not just eliminate all competitive sport and all categories and make every match that anyone ever has a draw in case anyone feels left out.

Get a grip, OP. From a parent whose DC is never in the first or second team but is being brought up with some resilience. Do you want to raise an entitled adult?

Curta · 01/10/2022 18:33

CoffeeHousePot · 01/10/2022 18:30

@Curta theres 9 on the A and B teams. Depending on other teams size they play 7/8/9 a side and they swap kids in.

Ahh, so 18 children went along and they picked 7 at a time for the matches. Seems like they easily could have taken them all and picked from the whole cohort.

TeenDivided · 01/10/2022 18:31

I suspect the school was limited as to how many teams it could enter due to the rules of the tournament. If schools can enter 3 teams then that massively increases the number of teams. There were probably also rules on what made up a 'team' e.g. 9 max.

CoffeeHousePot · 01/10/2022 18:30

@Curta theres 9 on the A and B teams. Depending on other teams size they play 7/8/9 a side and they swap kids in.

OP posts:
CoffeeHousePot · 01/10/2022 18:29

@itsgettingweird it’s not the selection part per se. If the A team had gone off to a tournament fine. As I’ve mentioned my eldest is also in the C team, but in a much bigger year. So if A and B go off somewhere there is still a big group left.

So I would have an issue if the school did a maths challenge and said 18 kids were good enough to go and 8 weren’t. I would be really concerned the 8 would (at Agee 8) would go “I’m rubbish at maths”. If they took 6 or so no issue.

OP posts:
Curta · 01/10/2022 18:28

How does three groups of eight actually even include all 26 children in the year?

CoffeeHousePot · 01/10/2022 18:26

@Madamecastafiore i appreciate that, but he’s not “crap” at rugby.
I’ve no issue with him being in the C team. But in training they are all together. House rugby they mix them up so they clearly don’t have safety concerns z

@TeenDivided I will. My DS is a summer born baby.

@arethereanyleftatall i think that’s what surprised me a bit. The school is very inclusive normally. There’s a couple of local schools which are much more pushy and I didn’t choose them for that reason.

@OhBeAFineGuyKissMe i think that’s my concern. I just don’t think it’s sending out the right message at this age. I have no issue with selection. My eldest is in the C team but in a much bigger year. So if A and B go somewhere there are still the C, D, E and F teams not going. It just feels like this small group are already being set up as “crap” at rugby - as one poster has already commented.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 01/10/2022 18:19

Would you say the same if it was a maths challenge or spelling bee?

Would you expect all pupils in the year to attend despite some really not being of a good standard and it'll show?

Sports work the same.

My ds is a swimmer.

I laughed really hard at a parent one day who commented "they always pick the same fastest swimmers for the competitions"

Me "well yes - they pay to enter and want to at least try and win!"

My ds was never chosen. He'll never be chosen (he has a disability so competes parasport).

I'd only have concerns if they pick the teams and they remain static despite pupils ebbing and flowing in who's the best 8 and next 8 etc.

arethereanyleftatall · 01/10/2022 18:16

I loved my dds state primary school because they did exactly what you want - which was great for my non sporty daughter. It was 'hands up who wants to be in the netball match' for example. Everyone who wanted to, got picked, simple as that.
Whereas, my friends children at private school, they do exactly as yours did, as they have a reputation to protect - of being a sporty school. You tend to get the choice when you pick a private school - pick a school that has the best results and of course this is the consequence; or pick a private school that doesn't but is renowned for inclusion.,