Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That it used to be easier to get to Cambridge or Oxford than it is now??

270 replies

countingdownagain · 01/10/2022 17:35

I know a few people that went to Oxbridge in the 70/80s that I struggle to imagine they'd have a hope of getting in today.

It strikes me that it if you were male, fairly well spoken, it was much easier to get in than it would be now??

OP posts:
Croque · 02/10/2022 19:34

The only think I can think of would be that they mentioned being related to me. I may have been on a secret naughty list on account of one or two small incidents!

Croque · 02/10/2022 19:30

nightwakingmoon · 02/10/2022 18:55

Someone in your relatives isn’t telling you quite the truth here, because a candidate would only not be invited to interview under limited conditions, such as:

  1. they fell below the minimum acceptable standard in a standardised test pre-interview, eg mark was in the lowest quartile of applicants (Oxford)
  2. their school-predicted A-level grades did not meet the standard offer (Ox and Cam)

Neither of these was the case. They also did the DOE. That is why we were surprised, I do not know what was in their statements but it is hardly likely to have been outrageous as they are quite shy and sheltered. School provided great references. They scored over 100% in two exams each (I think they are marked out of >100%
Their abilities were never in doubt.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 02/10/2022 19:25

In terms of grades, the ask is higher pretty much across the board.

H went from a comprehensive school to sixth form college and got into Cambridge with AAAB. My best mate got into a London medical school with BBB, and this wasn't uncommon then (1990s). My offer for a popular course at a Russell group university was BCC and no specific subject requirements. I've just checked and that's risen to AAA with some subject requirements. I'd have missed that offer as I got AAC.

It's a bit scary looking now at prospective universities with DC1, who's in Year 11. Half the places she's looked at want at A* A A for the subject she'd most like to apply for, which feels like a lot of pressure.

Ruthietuthie · 02/10/2022 19:23

@user29, something shit like anthropology?
Cambridge anthropology graduate here. I became a professor and a best selling author. Also in my cohort, a diplomat, an incredibly successful film director, the director of a museum, the head of an international NGO... so perhaps not such a "shitty" choice after all?
(Beyond our career paths, how learning about humanity could be regarded as a shitty choice, as you state, is beyond me...).
On the "how competitive" question, each college only has a small number of places to offer on such courses. And the vast majority of those who put themselves forward at the interview stage have amazing grades predicted. So perhaps it wasn't quite as easy as you imagine for your child's friend to score his "shitty" anthropology offer.

Pedallleur · 02/10/2022 19:18

Toby Young that should read. Winchester always has a guaranteed number of places at Oxford but the pupils still have to get in

Pedallleur · 02/10/2022 19:16

Former cabinet minister got in when his father Lord Young made a phone call to the Bursar.

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 19:15

PhotoDad · 02/10/2022 19:10

@Sindonym Same here. We both have multiple Oxbridge degrees.

DD is at art-school. And, I venture to guess, will be happier about her education than either of us.

Ha, ds2 is off to drama school. Can't see the youngest going to university, he certainly doesn't want to at the moment and no point paying a fortune if you are not keen.

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 19:13

Which bit isn't true? I didn't mean people were offered places at Oxford or Cambridge with a C - just that generally it was seen as a perfectly acceptable grade whereas half of mums net seems to be think it is a disastrous grade now.

For Oxford thirty odd years ago you had the choice of the entrance exam, which could result in a 2 E offer, or A levels which tended to be 3As or 2As and a B. I went for the entrance exam.

At the time there was a bit of a hoo hah that private school candidates had better chances (they did) because they were supported to prepare for the entrance exam. I had some support from my state school, but it largely involved reading around and beyond the A level syllabus.

PhotoDad · 02/10/2022 19:10

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 19:01

Just to add some balance. Both dh and I attended Oxford (met there) and none of our children will be attending Oxford/Cambridge or any Russell Group uni.

@Sindonym Same here. We both have multiple Oxbridge degrees.

DD is at art-school. And, I venture to guess, will be happier about her education than either of us.

nightwakingmoon · 02/10/2022 19:10

TheRubyRedshoes · 02/10/2022 19:03

@DelurkingAJ

Did he ever mention duke of Edinburgh?.
Does that count on admissions form? .
We can't afford for DD to.do it and two other trips this year'?

@TheRubyRedshoes No — DoE is never taken into account, never. Because we know it’s all about what school you go to and how wealthy your parents are. So please do not worry at all!

Swedishmeatball · 02/10/2022 19:08

Absolutely certain that my white, privately educated, DH would not get in now. We’ve told our DC that if they want to attempt to get in they’ll have to move to the local comp for 6th form.

nightwakingmoon · 02/10/2022 19:07

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 18:55

You can't compare A level grades from thirty years ago. C was seen as a perfectly good A level grade then and there were very few A's awarded. Now people pass out at a B.

I went to Oxford from a state school. I took the entrance exam so had a 2 E offer. The entrance exam was a lot more interesting than A levels tbh. It provided the opportunity to show what you knew rather than highlight what you didn't know. Finals were like that as well thinking about it. Don't know whether that has changed.

I do think it seems like a much more pressurised place now - not sure I'd enjoy it as much.

I’m not sure that’s completely true. I went to Cambridge thirty years ago this autumn (where has the time gone?!?) and my offer was AAA (the A* didn’t exist then).

My closest friend missed her offer for Natural Sciences at one of the big “Backs” colleges — her offer was AAA and two 1s in STEP. She got AAA, a 1 and a 2 and was bumped — went to Durham instead. Now is HoD of a major science department in the US so it didn’t exactly harm her career in science. But it’s a total myth that everyone got in with two Es and a wink and a nod in the past. Standards have been very high for a long time.

Cambridge still interview most candidates, but Oxford nowadays are quite ferocious with desummonsing any candidate who doesn’t score well enough in their pre-interview tests. If anyone knows of candidates from top public schools with great grades who didn’t even get asked to interview (as posters have been suggesting), they most probably scored really badly in an Oxford pre-interview test.

No-one is interested in an Etonian trailing streams of A*s, if they are scoring three quartiles below the top state comp candidates in a standardised test. No matter how naicely they converse. Sorry.

Cheeselog · 02/10/2022 19:06

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 18:55

You can't compare A level grades from thirty years ago. C was seen as a perfectly good A level grade then and there were very few A's awarded. Now people pass out at a B.

I went to Oxford from a state school. I took the entrance exam so had a 2 E offer. The entrance exam was a lot more interesting than A levels tbh. It provided the opportunity to show what you knew rather than highlight what you didn't know. Finals were like that as well thinking about it. Don't know whether that has changed.

I do think it seems like a much more pressurised place now - not sure I'd enjoy it as much.

It is very pressurised. I had a great time nonetheless, but DP (we met there) says he would discourage our DC from going.

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 19:05

Late teens and early twenties. They're not remotely interested.

TheRubyRedshoes · 02/10/2022 19:04

@Sindonym

Why?? How old are they

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 19:03

badbaduncle · 02/10/2022 15:50

They are higher, not lower. It used to be EE, DS got 4x A and an A at EPQ as did his peers.

Only EE if you took the entrance exam.

TheRubyRedshoes · 02/10/2022 19:03

@DelurkingAJ

Did he ever mention duke of Edinburgh?.
Does that count on admissions form? .
We can't afford for DD to.do it and two other trips this year'?

Sindonym · 02/10/2022 19:01

Signeduptosimplyreplytothis · 02/10/2022 17:04

It's more smart educated people who work professional careers tend to role model and produce smart educated children who want professional careers

Just to add some balance. Both dh and I attended Oxford (met there) and none of our children will be attending Oxford/Cambridge or any Russell Group uni.

TheRubyRedshoes · 02/10/2022 19:00

@HideousKinky

3 DDS!! That's incredible how did they all get in

nightwakingmoon · 02/10/2022 18:55

Croque · 02/10/2022 18:26

The weaker applicants were given the chance, the stronger ones were not even given the chance to demonstrate what they know. It was as though the name of their school was enough to rule them out. The few who got in were scholarship kids from disadvantaged backgrounds with weaker academics.

Someone in your relatives isn’t telling you quite the truth here, because a candidate would only not be invited to interview under limited conditions, such as:

  1. they fell below the minimum acceptable standard in a standardised test pre-interview, eg mark was in the lowest quartile of applicants (Oxford)
  2. their school-predicted A-level grades did not meet the standard offer (Ox and Cam)
Sindonym · 02/10/2022 18:55

You can't compare A level grades from thirty years ago. C was seen as a perfectly good A level grade then and there were very few A's awarded. Now people pass out at a B.

I went to Oxford from a state school. I took the entrance exam so had a 2 E offer. The entrance exam was a lot more interesting than A levels tbh. It provided the opportunity to show what you knew rather than highlight what you didn't know. Finals were like that as well thinking about it. Don't know whether that has changed.

I do think it seems like a much more pressurised place now - not sure I'd enjoy it as much.

nightwakingmoon · 02/10/2022 18:51

No idea why my italics went rogue there! 😂

nightwakingmoon · 02/10/2022 18:50

Croque · 02/10/2022 18:23

I could cite other examples but it is pointless if you are specifically here to defend the inclusion policies.

We don’t get a choice. Why not take your grievances up with government instead, and specifically the OfS, which regulates the targets for the sector, not us?

As an interviewer, I can say that it’s undoubtedly the case that independent schools have some excellent candidates who are fully deserving of a place.

They also put forward to us a fair number of mediocre students who have good results, and are clearly lovely well brought up young people, but can’t demonstrate much evidence of independent thought or ability/potential/talent beyond their school teaching.

It’s our job to sort the first from the second category. We still want the first category; but these days, we’re a lot tighter on the second than we used to be.

Sure, some of that second category could probably do fine here and enjoy themselves and come out with a mediocre okay degree. But why should that second category get preference over state applicants who have exactly the same grades without all the advantages of nice schools and wealthy families?

We now get a huge amount of contextual data about applicants’ schools and backgrounds. It’s not unfair to look at someone getting 8 8s or A*s from Westminster, and compare them with someone who got the same from Bog Standard Comp, Northern City.

There is no law that says that naice people really must get in. And sone independent schools teach to the test so much that they can churn out A*s from students who are in fact quite intellectually mediocre when it comes to independent thought.

londonmummy1966 · 02/10/2022 18:49

What I think was easier was the admissions process - sit the exam, have an interview and if you were sucessful you got a 2E or unconditional offer. Now its sit the exam, have the interview and stress all year about getting AAA or more as you need to meet your offer. Not having that pressure was hugely beneficial to my mental health compared with my classmates with offers from Durham/Bristol/London etc.

Bovrilly · 02/10/2022 18:45

I am not here to defend the inclusion policies but just asking on what basis you think standards are declining and what you mean by that. It makes sense to me that candidates who can achieve without the advantages of a private education are seen as more desirable, and I believe there is evidence that on the whole they do better as undergraduates, so no wonder the universities want them. Tbh with a wider pool and more competition, I would expect standards to rise, not fall. Of course there are thousands of clever people who don't get in every year, but I don't think individual examples are particularly meaningful. Could it not be that even though they had all 9s at GCSE, something else about their application - entry test / interview / PS - was weaker than the next person? Or the tutors felt that they didn't suit the teaching environment? Or that a state school student was more impressive when educational backgrounds were taken into consideration? For some schools all 9s at GCSE is not that remarkable, for others a mix of 7/8/9 is very good going.

I understand it must be difficult for high achieving students to be rejected by Oxbridge and I guess if believing in a decline in standards helps then that's fair enough if a bit bizarre - "I didn't get into Oxbridge because I'm too good" - but the bottom line is always, the university has a very limited number of places and they wanted someone else more.