Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That it used to be easier to get to Cambridge or Oxford than it is now??

270 replies

countingdownagain · 01/10/2022 17:35

I know a few people that went to Oxbridge in the 70/80s that I struggle to imagine they'd have a hope of getting in today.

It strikes me that it if you were male, fairly well spoken, it was much easier to get in than it would be now??

OP posts:
BlueHeelers · 11/02/2023 07:21

Meeem · 01/10/2022 17:50

Lots more overseas students who bring money with them for the university.

There are different quotas for Home and International students. In general, the number of International students at undergrad level has very little impact on the number of Home students.

And International students subsidise Home students, to an increasingly considerable extent.

Floofyduffypuddy · 11/02/2023 07:15

@Abra1t

SO EE offers are conversely like a real gold standard because it means you have done so well at interviews and their test that they want you regardless of actual a level grades?

GizzyDillespie · 11/02/2023 07:11

I remember back in the day I had to be a bit selective with my application. I went to a “mediocre” state comp (been trashed by OFSTED on a good few occasions, has gone in and out of special measures over the years). At the time, I seem to remember they liked you to do things like either S levels or further maths (neither of which were an option at my school),so I remember looking round for colleges that would go easy on that sort of thing.

I had a great time at Cambridge, though I experienced impostor syndrome the whole time I was there. I had had a comfortable and supportive upbringing, but was painfully aware that most of my peers seemed to have had rather better schooling than I had (or they’d just made better use of what they had :) . If Oxbridge have made inroads into levelling the playing field a bit more - and I hope they’re levelling up not down - then that can only be a good thing.

VestaTilley · 11/02/2023 07:08

YANBU- I think the Miliband’s said they didn’t have straight As in the 80s and they still got in. I think the college admissions tutor was friends with Ralph Miliband or something like that.

ByTheGrace · 11/02/2023 06:55

Swedishmeatball · 02/10/2022 19:08

Absolutely certain that my white, privately educated, DH would not get in now. We’ve told our DC that if they want to attempt to get in they’ll have to move to the local comp for 6th form.

Hilarious.
This happens at DD's school, most of those nice MC parents are horrified at the standard of teaching and have to spend on tuition and some withdraw. The difference between the local private school and ours during Covid was absolutely staggering. That was the first time it was so obvious, the local private school isn't even up there in rhe league with top independents.
Most of the parents of privately educated kids that we know, have no clue about the difference between independent and state.

Greengagesnfennel · 08/10/2022 11:13

TeenDivided · 01/10/2022 18:06

I did maths at Cambridge in the 80s. I don't think I would be good enough to get in now. There is wider participation at university generally these days, and top universities have put effort into outreach to encourage schools/pupils to apply who wouldn't have normally. There is more visibility of the admissions process, e.g. the STEP papers and how to approach them.

So if you were of the right background it was easier in the 80s (and thus the other side of the coin it is harder now). If you were the 'wrong' background it was harder in the 80s, and easier now.

I think standards must be higher now than they were then.

I still read too much on MN though of young people not applying because they think it's 'not for them' which is a shame.

This ^
Easier back then if you were from privileged background. Easier now if you are state educated.

They're still way off being equally open to everyone and privilege still counts but better than they used to be.

It's only harder now if you are an academically average white male public schoolboy who has been handheld through your A levels and helped to get them. I was state educated and saw a lot of these people crash and burn at uni. But daddy still got them the city job afterwards with the right uni on the cv, never mind the grade. The legacy of this is that government and company C-suites are full of these 50 yo underperformers, look at Boris!

Welshwabbit · 08/10/2022 09:00

My Head of Sixth Form tried to do a mock interview with me. He asked me whether I'd had a good journey and what the weather had been like before we both realised it wasn't going to work 😂

fiftiesmum · 08/10/2022 08:44

The elite universities may now be missing out on top students who have quite narrow talents eg stem students who have difficulties with the poetry and fiction needed to get high grades at GCSE, literature and language students who struggle to get the maths GCSE. The older post A level 7th term entry will have been able to by pass this.
I believe you can train for interview - my niece at a private school had interview practice from early year twelve plus help in finding a niche topic as their "love" another niece at a middling comprehensive had a ten minute mock interview with a local businessperson.

Welshwabbit · 08/10/2022 08:12

I applied to Oxford from a comp in the late 90s. Didn't want to do the entrance exam because there was no-one to prepare me for it. I can't remember whether my offer was AAA or AAB, but I got 4 As, so got in. I also had 9 A*s at GCSE. This was not normal at my school (but I was lucky in that I had a primary school teacher mother).

I do remember that, in my college year, there was an unusually high number of state school pupils doing my subject (Law). My law cohort got the best results in the university and the state school kids did better than the independently educated kids. I think 5 or 6 of us got Firsts. Purely anecdotal, but I know, because of my experience at interview, which was very nearly a disaster, that even back then the law tutors at my college put a lot of effort into working out who would do well on the course. It can't have been easy to spot potential in amongst those who had been properly trained for an interview. I don't know whether the standardised tests they use now help with that differentiation or whether they can also be prepared for by schools with more resources.

faffadoodledo · 08/10/2022 07:21

DH did 7th term entry to Oxford from a crap comp and said it made all the difference. Said it was really useful for someone of his background, and in fact says he doubts he'd have gotten in in our children's generation. He describes a tutor who interviewed him and really saw his potential. He did indeed end up with a double First and the overall prize for his subject on graduation. Then a Phd and career in his subject. That tutor got it right!
It's one of the reasons our DS applied post results for Cambridge. He leapt the offer, spent more time reading and thinking about his subject (and earned money and had life experiences). I would encourage all state school applicants to do the same in fact. It helps make up for the lack of prep their schools give them

Yalz · 08/10/2022 01:58

Several people have made points earlier on in this thread that I completely agree with, including there being only 3 colleges in Cambridge before 1972 which took women (I’m not sure about Lucy Cavendish), giving a ratio of about 1:10 female:male students, and that in general there were fewer top A level grades awarded, and no A stars.

Something I haven’t seen mentioned is 7th term entry for Cambridge and probably Oxford. This was where students took the entrance exam in the term after their A levels, and then had 2 terms “out”, doing paid work or having a gap part-year. I think that must have favoured students whose schools were able to continue teaching them for another term, and those whose parents could afford for them neither to be earning in that term nor receiving a grant to be at university - oh, the days when university education was free to students and the government gave them money to live on, if their parents’ income was low enough.

There was 4th term entry, too. I don’t know what the relative merits were of each.

Sleeplessinthesouth71 · 04/10/2022 17:56

Yes @faffadoodledo I think thst is where DD had a disadvantage. She wasn't properly prepared fron early on for the interview but she is happy where she went.

faffadoodledo · 04/10/2022 07:43

The thing is the offers aren't that hard to make for your clever all rounder A level student. Even our crappy comp produced a hatful of sets of full A stars at A level in both DS and DD's years (them included) as well as full compliments of A Stars under the old GCSE system. It's the other hoops - entrance papers and interviews etc - that put them at a disadvantage over their private rivals who'd had proper preparation at school. Bright state pupils don't need contextual consideration for exams; they need it for the extras. Of course they may be getting this; I have no idea if interviewing academics thing 'hmmmm this chap comes from a place focussed on getting kids over the line rather than polishing them from oxbridge, let's dig a bit deeper here..'
Both my children exceeded the offers needed for their subjects (desirable, competitive subjects at that) but only one managed the hoops. In hindsight we should have got DD some help with the MAT. But no matter because she went elsewhere, had fun, did brilliantly and is now zipping ahead of her Arty Cambridge brother!

Sleeplessinthesouth71 · 03/10/2022 23:42

I think DDs Oxford offer for STEM subject would have been A star, A,A. But she only got an interview
Her contextual offer for another RG was BBB and AAB for non contextual offer.
She hit the target for Oxford but went for the University with the BBB offer in the end along with many other Oxbridge applicants.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/10/2022 22:25

bold type fail: you need 1x A star for humanities, 2x A star for STEM for Cambridge. I think Oxford will accept A grades

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/10/2022 22:23

These incredible stories of people getting in with low grades just because they are state school and lower grades being accepted because of parents divorcing etc are indeed incredible.

State or private, you need to get at least one A for humanities, 2A for STEM plus entrance exams, CMAT/BMAT and STEP exams. There are no exceptions or lower offers.

State school education has improved massively since schools have been held accountable for their students' grades. If you have a grade 9 kid, you don't need to go private anymore; state schools are churning out 9s and A*s

As for "feigning enthusiasm"? Yeah right. That's gonna work at an Oxbridge interview.

Sindonym · 03/10/2022 22:12

Agreed Empress. Also there is no neat line ranking students. I’m sure when I got into Oxford there were better all rounders than me but I did genuinely love my subject (ended up doing a PhD in it) and I am sure that is why I got in. I had read extensively around the subject area at 18. Nowadays you probably need to be an all rounder & have read extensively around - but a genuine love of a subject will likely still give an advantage to otherwise equal candidates.

Oxford & Cambridge are stuffed full of academics who are passionate about their areas of research, it’s not just a City or politician’s training ground. They aren’t just interested in the best all rounders, they want people who will love their research as well.

Bovrilly · 03/10/2022 21:56

There are definitely some eye-watering standard offers elsewhere - I would add Manchester and Warwick to those mentioned. (For some subjects, not all.)

EmpressoftheMundane · 03/10/2022 21:42

I think this wouldn’t be such a bun fight if everyone accepted that Oxbridge does not have the best students, but rather, they have some of the best students.

This article mentions that St Andrew’s intake had higher grades this year than Oxbridge. I wouldn’t be surprised if Imperial could say the same, as well as the LSE.

www.theguardian.com/education/2022/sep/24/stoxbridge-st-andrews-overtakes-oxford-cambridge-guardian-university-guide

I appreciate that grades aren’t everything, but they are a relevant measure.

Oxford and Cambridge are harder to get into than ever. And it is harder than ever for Oxford and Cambridge to be sure they are getting the best students.

Hawkins001 · 03/10/2022 20:19

Reading with intrigue

Bovrilly · 03/10/2022 19:04

They can't possibly all be desperately interested in absolutely everything to do with their degree all of the time.

No but showing a bit of that in the PS is pretty basic stuff. I guess people could feign an interest but it's not as if saying "I love geography" is enough. They are looking for evidence of your interest, in the application and at interview. It's a lot of work to provide that evidence if you're actually interested, I can't imagine anyone going to all that trouble if they weren't.

Croque · 03/10/2022 18:52

Young adults can easily feign enthusiasm in some (obviously not all) cases. They can't possibly all be desperately interested in absolutely everything to do with their degree all of the time. I was extremely passionate about my subject but I doubt this would have been detectible to others.

ddl1 · 03/10/2022 18:37

I am sure the incoming/outgoing average attainment is lower than before.

Speaking as someone who has taught at Oxbridge for many years, the reverse seems to me to be true. While most students have always been very good, there was much more of a 'tail' in the past of relatively weak or lazy students and those who were mainly there for 'the Oxbridge experience' rather than out of an enthusiasm for their subject,

Nolongerteaching · 03/10/2022 18:27

I’m not convinced that many students would declare home problems and the school
may not know.

I missed so much school time due to health issues and the school were very unsympathetic. I never thought to mention this at interview or the fact that I had other things going on.

Bovrilly · 03/10/2022 17:52

It's not my system, I am just trying to explain how it works to you.
As far as I know, things like bereavement and divorce would be mentioned in the school reference and I don't think there are many schools which would be prepared to lie. I suppose with a lot of careful preparation a student and their parents / siblings / friends could lie to the school.. but even so the student would still have to impress at interview. I don't think you need to worry about this kind of fraud.