Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 04/10/2022 11:55

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 11:41

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow

My DS was diagnosed because he has persistent social communication difficulties. That trait is very clear.

What isn't clear is Criteria 2. The psychologist states in her report that he does not have 'restricted, repetitive patterns of behaviour.' He does have some sensory seeking behaviours, which I question could be down to ADHD. I'm very interested to have him assessed for ADHD (which will also be private) and also trial medication, to see what difference that makes.

Despite his social differences, he is a very independent boy. If I was ill for the day, he could easily take care of himself without my input. He can get himself dressed, do his own breakfast, lunch, entertain himself, tidy up after himself, use the bathroom and shower independently, brush his teeth, put himself to bed if required. To categorise him as disabled feels strange, if I am honest.

That’s interesting. He sounds fantastic and extremely independent for a 7 year old! Did they not consider the social/communication disorder diagnosis instead?

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 04/10/2022 11:46

No I think it is people don't understand what a spectrum is - they can only see the word in relation to the 'autism spectrum' despite illustrating this with a completely different spectrum - the light spectrum. So when I say there is a spectrum of behaviour they cannot see beyond autism and take offense

Anyone with the briefest exposure to high school science knows what a spectrum is; but bandying the word about in relation to autism, in a discussion about autism - AKA Autistic Spectrum Disorder - and saying "oh I didn't mean that spectrum is inviting misunderstanding.

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 11:41

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow

My DS was diagnosed because he has persistent social communication difficulties. That trait is very clear.

What isn't clear is Criteria 2. The psychologist states in her report that he does not have 'restricted, repetitive patterns of behaviour.' He does have some sensory seeking behaviours, which I question could be down to ADHD. I'm very interested to have him assessed for ADHD (which will also be private) and also trial medication, to see what difference that makes.

Despite his social differences, he is a very independent boy. If I was ill for the day, he could easily take care of himself without my input. He can get himself dressed, do his own breakfast, lunch, entertain himself, tidy up after himself, use the bathroom and shower independently, brush his teeth, put himself to bed if required. To categorise him as disabled feels strange, if I am honest.

eyeteevee · 04/10/2022 11:26

If it the criteria were so black and white then why are autistic children not picked up immediately at birth or shortly after?

Because it would be a bit like trying to assess a goldfish. Useless. The criteria are black and white. They are definite. But if you take note of any of the criteria, they don't apply to babies any more then they do goldfish.

Winecrispschocolatecats · 04/10/2022 11:21

eyeteevee · 03/10/2022 12:58

Genuine question to those who don't want their child 'labelled' because they are doing well in school

What do you think would happen to your child if they were labelled (diagnosed)?

I for one (admittedly clueless at that time!) didn't think that labelling a kid as 'different' would be helpful to them. Happy to admit I was totally wrong. My friend told me to think about the diagnostic process as a safety net - whilst my son didn't (seem to) require any particular additional support or accommodations initially, a diagnosis would ensure he could receive them if he ever required them. As my DS has got older (now nearly 14) and more comfortable not 'masking' his condition, it's become increasingly obvious that a) he spent a huge amount of time and energy as a child just trying to fit in and b) he's much happier, more secure and confident now.

ParrotPoppy · 04/10/2022 11:18

If it the criteria were so black and white then why are autistic children not picked up immediately at birth or shortly after?

Not receiving a diagnosis at birth/shortly afterwards doesn’t mean the criteria aren’t black and white. Unless you also think the criteria to diagnose e.g. chromosome abnormalities aren’t clear cut. Many people with chromosome abnormalities aren’t diagnosed until later in childhood or adulthood or even at all. That doesn’t mean the criteria aren’t clear cut.

Treebranch · 04/10/2022 11:07

What is your point here? That autism is a contrived and meaningless diagnosis? That autism doesn't exist?

People's experiences of autism obviously exist. As I'm sure you know, though, autism has no biomarkers. In the future, when more is known about causes, the category of autism may break up into several conditions, or not. In the meantime, the question is, how useful is this diagnostic category, how fair is it? From the comments here, it sounds as though its useful in several ways but not perfect.

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 11:06

eyeteevee · 04/10/2022 10:42

Do you think every non autistic person has the same degree of social skills regardless of any other neuro diversity they may have? Do you understand the meaning of the word 'spectrum'?

Your not serious?

  1. You simply are misunderstanding
  1. You were wrong but don't want to back down so are continuing to try and prove something
  1. You are being goady

So, which is it? Because the more you post, the worse it gets Sad

No I think it is people don't understand what a spectrum is - they can only see the word in relation to the 'autism spectrum' despite illustrating this with a completely different spectrum - the light spectrum. So when I say there is a spectrum of behaviour they cannot see beyond autism and take offense. If it the criteria were so black and white then why are autistic children not picked up immediately at birth or shortly after? Why watch and wait for preschoolers or primary kids get turned down for a diagnosis only to be picked up as things fall apart at secondary? What are doctors doing if not trying to determine which side of a cut off point a continuous variable lands? Why are so many more people now diagnosed if those cutoff points/criteria had not changed in the last 40 years? May be this is a flaw with the diagnostic criteria -maybe MRI scans or eye tracking software in babies could give a more black and white diagnosis but currently the criteria used are continuous variables (a spectrum) not discreet variables.

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 11:04

@Lovelyricepudding

I agree, a diagnosis is ultimately subjective and based on the opinion of the psychologist, on a test that attempts to invoke objectivity. That is the same with most psychology, where a physical test cannot be done, like it could be for high blood pressure or diabetes for instance.

They are also widening the criteria, as I said previously, my son would not have been diagnosed a few years ago had it not been for the recent addition of 'sensory differences.' That's not to say I believe there is anything wrong with autism, there absolutely isn't and it is a neurological difference which should be celebrated and nurtured, but when so much is based on subjectivity of a psychologist and not the individual characteristics of the person, it's very difficult.

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 04/10/2022 11:03

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 10:07

I feel very split on this.

My DS has a diagnosis, he is aged 7, and this was as a result of the school pointing out his differences. We paid privately for his diagnosis, but the psychologist pointed out that whilst he met the criteria from the home screener questionnaire, he didn't actually meet the criteria from the school questionnaire. Had his diagnosis been through the NHS or CAHMS, he would have been dismissed at that point. He also doesn't meet any of Criteria 2 of the DSM-5, but because he has 'sensory seeking behaviour', he got the diagnosis. A few years ago he would not have been diagnosed. He also has suspected ADHD, which could account for the sensory seeking behaviour.

I got the diagnosis mainly for the future, just in case. He is doing really well. Very clever, well liked, we support him as a family.

School, despite being the ones who suggested getting a diagnosis, haven't offered any extra support or funding. They've said that he isn't eligible because he is happy and doing well in school. They won't support an application for an EHCP, as they claim he doesn't need it. Interestingly, they also started attaching autistic characteristics to my son which he doesn't have, such as writing in a report that he 'has troubles with transitions' and it took us pointing out that he doesn't, for them to acknowledge this. One of my DS's strengths is his flexibility and spontaneity. People do tend to stereotype autism, and because my son does not fit a lot of the classic autistic characteristics, I really fear he will be stereotyped, which has already started happening.

Diagnosis doesn't = support. Being the type of parent who is constantly in contact with the school, LA and has the money and resources required does. Having worked in a school, those parents are also the ones that get criticised and disliked by all the teachers!

@AutiMum how did he meet the criteria for diagnosis? It doesn’t sound very clear cut to me in his case.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 04/10/2022 10:49

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 10:32

A diagnosis of autism seeks to determine whether or not someone has a neurological difference.

No it doesn't. It seeks to determine whether or not someone meets the diagnostic criteria for autism. There are a whole range of neurological differences that are not autism and many have features that overlap with autism.

OK then, it seeks to determine if someone has the particular neurological difference known as autism, which I think was pretty clear from what I said.

The other neurological differences are not diagnosed with the same criteria.

What is your point here? That autism is a contrived and meaningless diagnosis? That autism doesn't exist?
PPs are right: you are bordering on offensive.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 10:48

eyeteevee agreed. Goady would be the nicest intention I could infer from these terrible posts.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 10:47

Do you??

eyeteevee · 04/10/2022 10:42

Do you think every non autistic person has the same degree of social skills regardless of any other neuro diversity they may have? Do you understand the meaning of the word 'spectrum'?

Your not serious?

  1. You simply are misunderstanding
  1. You were wrong but don't want to back down so are continuing to try and prove something
  1. You are being goady

So, which is it? Because the more you post, the worse it gets Sad

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 10:36

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 10:28

You don’t know what you’re talking about. It’s your own little theory that has no validity IMO and is offensive.

Do you think every non autistic person has the same degree of social skills regardless of any other neuro diversity they may have? Do you understand the meaning of the word 'spectrum'?

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 10:32

A diagnosis of autism seeks to determine whether or not someone has a neurological difference.

No it doesn't. It seeks to determine whether or not someone meets the diagnostic criteria for autism. There are a whole range of neurological differences that are not autism and many have features that overlap with autism.

SleeplessInEngland · 04/10/2022 10:30

Some odd assumptions on this thread. If anyone's cruel enough to bully an autistic child then they'll do it with or without an official diagnosis.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 10:28

You don’t know what you’re talking about. It’s your own little theory that has no validity IMO and is offensive.

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 10:26

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 09:51

I’m almost too scared to catch up on this thread enough to understand why anyone would actually write we are all on the autism spectrum. What rot.

I didn't say everyone was autistic or refer to THE SPECTRUM. I said the diagnosis is based on attributes that are spectrums we all sit on - just like we all sit on a spectrum for blood pressure. But that doesn't mean we all have high blood pressure, only those above a cut off point are diagnosed with high blood pressure. Though the cut off point moves depending on age and location of testing. So it is with autism - only those 'above' a certain point on the spectrum of social skills and repetitive interests are diagnosed as autistic. But that cut off point has moved over time. The cut off point also changes with LD or GDD. Diagnosis isn't as clear cut as people suggest and not autistic people are also neurodiverse.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 04/10/2022 10:09

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 09:48

Not everyone has high blood pressure. Everyone has some degree of social skills and interests which are the criteria for the diagnosis of autism.

Not everyone has high blood pressure, but they could develop it. And if they do they can have help to lower it.
You can't develop autism; nor can you cure it.

A diagnosis of autism seeks to determine whether or not someone has a neurological difference. This, unlike high blood pressure, is congenital and permanent. The associated problems (anxiety, OCD etc.) are lifelong and, though fluctuating, are permanent. Others with e.g. OCD may recover with treatment.

The diagnosis is not easy or perfect, but seeks to describe a congenital neurological condition, not a personality type. Alzheimer's is similar in that it can only truly be diagnosed post mortem, yet is diagnosed in life.

Tootels · 04/10/2022 10:08

@TheFormidableMrsC Sorry yes it was.

The only help they offered me was to join an autistic discussion group. I hate going out / chatting / don't drive.

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 10:07

I feel very split on this.

My DS has a diagnosis, he is aged 7, and this was as a result of the school pointing out his differences. We paid privately for his diagnosis, but the psychologist pointed out that whilst he met the criteria from the home screener questionnaire, he didn't actually meet the criteria from the school questionnaire. Had his diagnosis been through the NHS or CAHMS, he would have been dismissed at that point. He also doesn't meet any of Criteria 2 of the DSM-5, but because he has 'sensory seeking behaviour', he got the diagnosis. A few years ago he would not have been diagnosed. He also has suspected ADHD, which could account for the sensory seeking behaviour.

I got the diagnosis mainly for the future, just in case. He is doing really well. Very clever, well liked, we support him as a family.

School, despite being the ones who suggested getting a diagnosis, haven't offered any extra support or funding. They've said that he isn't eligible because he is happy and doing well in school. They won't support an application for an EHCP, as they claim he doesn't need it. Interestingly, they also started attaching autistic characteristics to my son which he doesn't have, such as writing in a report that he 'has troubles with transitions' and it took us pointing out that he doesn't, for them to acknowledge this. One of my DS's strengths is his flexibility and spontaneity. People do tend to stereotype autism, and because my son does not fit a lot of the classic autistic characteristics, I really fear he will be stereotyped, which has already started happening.

Diagnosis doesn't = support. Being the type of parent who is constantly in contact with the school, LA and has the money and resources required does. Having worked in a school, those parents are also the ones that get criticised and disliked by all the teachers!

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 04/10/2022 10:05

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 09:56

Persistent deficits in social communication and social interaction across multiple contexts.
And
Restricted, repetitive patterns of behaviour, interests or activities

Symptoms must present in early developmental period (but may not become fully manifest until social demands exceed limited capacities).
Symptoms cause clinically significant impairment.
Not better explained by LD or GDD.

From DSM-5.

You said "those are the criteria" in reference to my previous message, wherein I hadn't mentioned the diagnostic criteria at all. That was my confusion.

I'm aware of the broader description of diagnostic criteria.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 10:02

It’s super offensive as are lots of the comments on this thread. People having in-depth discussions on autism at the very least should know what a spectrum is!!! Jfc and no, we are NOT all ‘on it’

TheFormidableMrsC · 04/10/2022 10:01

Tootels · 04/10/2022 09:15

What support was he after? I didn't think there was any?

Was that in response to my post? He needed support at school particularly, was isolated, unable to make friends, struggled with noise, concentrating etc. When I compare his experiences with that of my own child, it's desperately sad. My son has been so heavily supported that it has made a huge difference to him and he has been able to stay in mainstream school.

That said, there is a woeful lack of support for autistic adults sadly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread