Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
Beefstew · 04/10/2022 16:50

In my region of Ireland the diagnostic process is very indepth, parent interview, SLT, o/t and psychology each assess the child, school /creche visit by psychology, contributions from teacher and then results from the team are collated to form a diagnosis or not.
Its very difficult to access services or help at school with a private psychological assessment.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 16:49

It would be highly unusual for autism to be diagnosed by a psychiatrist

it’s really not. Quite a lot of parents I’ve spoken to have had psychiatrists diagnose their kids too and some schools insist on it. We had a private well respected clinic do it, our school paid for it.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 16:47

My DD knows the entire dialogue including sound effects of Coraline the movie, and episodes of certain comedy shows she likes. I’ve never seen anything like it, despite being around lots of different children who have the usual childhood TV or film obsessions. Even in her 20’s she still watches these things too, we ‘have’ to watch Coraline every birthday and often repeats the script word for word at the same time. It’s the intensity and knowledge of whatever the interest or obsession is that is really just, different. Noticeably.

Something for those with diagnosed children who they think don’t appear too challenged or affected at a young age, remember young children are often keen to please the adults and will ‘mask’ a lot, this takes enormous energy and concentration to do. A diagnosis early can stop this and allow them the freedom to be themselves and not feel like they need to keep masking. My DH calls it ‘assimilating’ and he and our DD laugh about it, but it’s quite sad when I think about it. That’s why I got cross at her teachers who would say ‘ oh but we see she can communicate properly so we are trying to get her to do that all the time’!!! No!! Don’t do this!! It’s exhausting and confusing!

NoYouSirName · 04/10/2022 16:47

It would be highly unusual for autism to be diagnosed by a psychiatrist. That is usual for ADHD.

Yes, two of my dc showed signs later but then looking back at their early development the signs were there.

autimum, I’m really interested, do you think a child with adhd would have those independence and organisational skills? The two I have couldn’t organise the proverbial. But I’m aware that they’re not all the same.

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 16:46

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow The psychologist specifically stated there was no evidence of 'obsessions'. The only early indication was high intelligence and that is literally all that his report states, plus all that was fed back to us in the feedback session. She said that being able to count to 100 before 2 is 'abnormally intelligent' plus the other ways he was clever.

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 16:44

@ParrotPoppy

My DS doesn't have echolalia and doesn't have special interests. He has a wide range of interests, of which Thomas was one of them. Yes he intensely likes Minecraft, Roblox, Pokemon and would love to sit on his iPad all day, but he enjoys a wide range of topics and hobbies. His psychologist report also states he does not have repetitive or restrictive interests, she tried to ask him about one of his interests as part of the assessment and he wasn't interested in discussing it 😂

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 04/10/2022 16:44

ParrotPoppy · 04/10/2022 16:38

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow I think the difference is the intensity, repetitiveness and restrictiveness of the special interest. The same with things like numbers, advanced speech, echolalia and hyperlexia. You have to take the specifics of the individual’s situation.

Yes, that’s why I said context is everything.

But @AutiMum didnt say the psychologist noted her son’s obsession with Thomas, but rather picked up on the fact that he knew all the character names. If that is all then it seems a bit of a stretch to me. Perhaps there was more to it than that though.

ParrotPoppy · 04/10/2022 16:38

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow I think the difference is the intensity, repetitiveness and restrictiveness of the special interest. The same with things like numbers, advanced speech, echolalia and hyperlexia. You have to take the specifics of the individual’s situation.

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 04/10/2022 16:35

But loads of kids love Thomas and could tell you all the character names! Hardly unusual.

Obviously context is everything here but it sounds very odd to me.

ParrotPoppy · 04/10/2022 16:33

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 16:16

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow DS's psychologist said that being 'abnormally intelligent' e.g. his ability to know numbers to 100, name all the Thomas characters, be speaking in fluent sentences before 2, are all signs from early developmental period. It also says throughout that this is all 'her professional opinion.'

It wouldn't surprise me if his diagnosis got changed to ADHD, I was very sceptical about ASD from the beginning. I also question, if ADHD medication 'solved' his sensory seeking behaviour (hyperactivity) does that mean his ASD diagnosis is no longer applicable?

That's why I would rather look at DS's collective strengths and weaknesses rather than all these diagnosis.

@AutiMum my 2 autistic DC were the same with Thomas. I am also autistic and as a result happen to have a very good long term memory, so I can still recite all the characters. Blush

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 04/10/2022 16:33

@AutiMum that all sounds bizarre. Both of my NT kids were/are speaking in fluent sentences before 2 - it’s not the norm but also not that uncommon. Just because some autistic people are intelligent does not mean that intelligence is a sign of autism 🤯

ParrotPoppy · 04/10/2022 16:31

TheBirdintheCave · 04/10/2022 15:10

@AutiMum

So many of the traits don't fit for my DS, and whenever I hear 'significantly impairs everyday functioning' I really, really cannot relate that to my son.

I honestly think that bit depends on so many factors. Currently, I work from home and have no issue functioning whatsoever. However, if you were to make me commute to work every day, my daily functioning would be very much classed as impaired. I would be far more anxious, I would have meltdowns on crowded trains, I would struggle to remember social niceties, panic when I can't remember people's faces etc etc.

It sounds like, right now, your son is in an environment perfectly suited to him and his needs :)

You see, I think in your current situation your ASD does “limit and impair everyday functioning”. If it didn’t you wouldn’t have to think about being limited to WFH because of your ASD. I think just because someone is functioning well in an environment they have found meets their needs well doesn’t mean their everyday functioning isn’t limited and impaired.

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 16:25

@WahineToa Interesting. My DS's diagnosis is from a clinical psychologist and SALT.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 16:22

My DD’s school insisted on a psychiatrists diagnosis, not psychologists.

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 16:16

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow DS's psychologist said that being 'abnormally intelligent' e.g. his ability to know numbers to 100, name all the Thomas characters, be speaking in fluent sentences before 2, are all signs from early developmental period. It also says throughout that this is all 'her professional opinion.'

It wouldn't surprise me if his diagnosis got changed to ADHD, I was very sceptical about ASD from the beginning. I also question, if ADHD medication 'solved' his sensory seeking behaviour (hyperactivity) does that mean his ASD diagnosis is no longer applicable?

That's why I would rather look at DS's collective strengths and weaknesses rather than all these diagnosis.

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 04/10/2022 15:58

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 14:59

My DS showed no signs, really, before about the age of 6. I have gone back through his developmental history, I have tons of videos and photos from that time period, and there were really zero signs or indications of autism. It was never mentioned at nursery. It has only really been since he has got older, his social skills seem to have worsened or stopped developing in line with his peers. The only thing I can possibly say may be an indication of autism was being very clever from a young age e.g. knowing numbers to 100 before the age of 2. But I also was/am very intelligent, and I am not autistic.

I got his ASD diagnosis as a knee jerk reaction. School suggested they saw traits of autism, I was probably in a state of shock looking back, and felt like I needed to 'do' something. I'm not sure I would get the diagnosis now, only time will tell if it actually helps or is useful. I would also explore other options, like social communication disorder and ADHD, before automatically jumping to autism. So many of the traits don't fit for my DS, and whenever I hear 'significantly impairs everyday functioning' I really, really cannot relate that to my son.

I thought that the signs had to be there from the early developmental period? It sounds quite unusual to me.

Definitely worth keeping it all under review. Fwiw my niece was initially diagnosed with sensory processing disorder but my sister never felt it was right and she’s recently had her diagnosis changed to ADHD.

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 15:49

@TheBirdintheCave Yes, that's exactly it. I think we are framing diagnosis the wrong way. I think we should be teaching people about their strengths and weaknesses, and helping them from there, rather than an all encompassing label/diagnosis. ASD may describe some of my DS's characteristics, but it doesn't define him, and due to there being so many assumptions and misinformation about ASD, people assume he must have 'x' trait e.g. his school assuming he must struggle with transitions, or meltdowns, or have limited interests, none of which are true for my DS.

I've always struggled with authority and being told what to do, this stretches back to being a child. I'm sure I could probably be diagnosed with some form of PDA if I was at school now. However, I just formed my life around my strengths - my independence and determination. I have a very successful business. I have had periods of employment before, but these have been short-lived, as I have struggled with regimentation and 'criticism' from bosses etc. I think we need to take a more holistic, individualistic approach.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 15:39

Yes, things can definitely change as your child ages. Mine is now an adult and her needs are so different, as is the way she copes. Primary was not much of an issue but secondary the challenges were far greater and I deeply regret not noticing and getting a diagnosis in her primary years. My DH is autistic so I feel like I should have known and seen and she suffered later on because I didn’t. I would never delay diagnosis knowing what I know now.

TheBirdintheCave · 04/10/2022 15:10

@AutiMum

So many of the traits don't fit for my DS, and whenever I hear 'significantly impairs everyday functioning' I really, really cannot relate that to my son.

I honestly think that bit depends on so many factors. Currently, I work from home and have no issue functioning whatsoever. However, if you were to make me commute to work every day, my daily functioning would be very much classed as impaired. I would be far more anxious, I would have meltdowns on crowded trains, I would struggle to remember social niceties, panic when I can't remember people's faces etc etc.

It sounds like, right now, your son is in an environment perfectly suited to him and his needs :)

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 14:59

My DS showed no signs, really, before about the age of 6. I have gone back through his developmental history, I have tons of videos and photos from that time period, and there were really zero signs or indications of autism. It was never mentioned at nursery. It has only really been since he has got older, his social skills seem to have worsened or stopped developing in line with his peers. The only thing I can possibly say may be an indication of autism was being very clever from a young age e.g. knowing numbers to 100 before the age of 2. But I also was/am very intelligent, and I am not autistic.

I got his ASD diagnosis as a knee jerk reaction. School suggested they saw traits of autism, I was probably in a state of shock looking back, and felt like I needed to 'do' something. I'm not sure I would get the diagnosis now, only time will tell if it actually helps or is useful. I would also explore other options, like social communication disorder and ADHD, before automatically jumping to autism. So many of the traits don't fit for my DS, and whenever I hear 'significantly impairs everyday functioning' I really, really cannot relate that to my son.

firef1y · 04/10/2022 13:59

If it the criteria were so black and white then why are autistic children not picked up immediately at birth or shortly after?

In my case it probably could have been picked up from near birth. I've been told I was a very difficult baby from a very young age. I barely slept and it was a real struggle to get me to take milk, as in my mother would literally drip milk in to my mouth in the hope that I'd swallow it. I was then what would probably be called precocious, I toilet trained early, didn't like the feel of a nappy on my skin. I spoke early, I read early, etc etc. I have always struggled in social situations from a very young age. But I also have a very high IQ which has helped me mask many of my difficulties.
Of my 6 children, 5 (possibly all 6) are on the spectrum. 1 of them was just over a year when we first got the PDD-NOS (also known at the time as atypical autism) dx and this was over 20years ago. My 12yo got a PDD dx before he was 2, but due to his other difficulties (ADHD/GDD) he only got his ASD dx this year, I've known since before his first birthday that he was autistic.

PDD= Pervasive Developmental Disorder (and IME is generally a precursor to an ASD diagnosis unless it's paired up with something such as Retts)
PDD-NOS = Pervasive Developmental Disorder-Not Otherwise Specified (this used to be interchangeable with Atypical autism or aspergers, it was a way of saying autistic without saying it)

I remember when my now 23yo got the PDD-NOS dx, searching on the rather limited Internet we had back then to find out what it meant.

TheBirdintheCave · 04/10/2022 13:57

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 04/10/2022 13:03

If it the criteria were so black and white then why are autistic children not picked up immediately at birth or shortly after?

It can be clear from a very young age. When I look back I can see signs from birth, such as didn't communicate when he wanted a feed, didn't copy sounds or actions as a young baby. But most people don't know what to look for. When I raised concerns about my son's developmental milestones at 18m I was sent to the BBC website to learn how to communicate better. It was only because we pushed that my son was diagnosed at 2. By that point he had many of the criteria they look for. But lots of these were obvious from early days if you know what to look for.

My mum says that I showed no signs whatsoever to cause concern as a baby or toddler (she used her experience with my cousin who is also autistic as a guide). If anything I was ahead in my development. So whilst yes, it can be obvious if infants follow the stereotypical signs of autism like my cousin did, a lot of us - chiefly girls - don't present that way.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 04/10/2022 13:03

If it the criteria were so black and white then why are autistic children not picked up immediately at birth or shortly after?

It can be clear from a very young age. When I look back I can see signs from birth, such as didn't communicate when he wanted a feed, didn't copy sounds or actions as a young baby. But most people don't know what to look for. When I raised concerns about my son's developmental milestones at 18m I was sent to the BBC website to learn how to communicate better. It was only because we pushed that my son was diagnosed at 2. By that point he had many of the criteria they look for. But lots of these were obvious from early days if you know what to look for.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 13:01

Winecrispschocolatecats

That post was worded horribly. Absolutely. But the Cass report identified some issues with autistic girls not being adequately supported and a massive unexplained increase in numbers thinking that way and going to clinics and they haven’t identified why that is. It’s concerning if they’re being misdiagnosed due to their autism not being adequately identified or supported somehow.

Winecrispschocolatecats · 04/10/2022 12:52

@ROBYN did you just type "get an ASD diagnosis in case your kid decides they're trans instead" ?? What kind of screwed up, utterly transphobic, ignorant and hateful pile of horse manure is that?