Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 05/10/2022 09:29

Lovelyricepudding · 05/10/2022 09:09

Sex not gender

You're right!

I used gender because it had been used by PP, and it also was the word used in the reports I'd seen. I'm also old enough to remember when gender and sex were used interchangeably.

These days? Definitely sex would be the better word!

Lovelyricepudding · 05/10/2022 09:09

Sex not gender

TheBirdintheCave · 05/10/2022 08:40

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 05/10/2022 07:06

@Mumofsend I didn't mean to imply all girls - sorry if that was inaccurate/annoying, but I do think it's "most" rather than just "some". Females have been underdiagnosed for years and many have slipped through the net. It is well known that they - generally - present differently to boys. This, of course, doesn't mean that all girls present the same, just as all boys don't.

The ancient ADOS tests that were still used to diagnose my DD were based on boys' experiences and have let down so many girls. Several studies have shown this. Should the tests be "gendered"? I don't know, but they should be broad enough to identify different presentations in both boys and girls; and they can't do this without recognising that the previous diagnostic criteria were biased towards boys' presentation.

I was diagnosed four years ago at 32. They still used the ADOS on me. I remember being so confused as to why I was being asked to describe a child's story book. I have a degree in creative writing and took acting classes from age ten until 16 so that wasn't hard at all 🤔 They then asked me to describe a holiday island from a cartoon image. Planning holidays is one of my special interests 😂🤦🏻‍♀️

The psychologist said he wasn't going to diagnose me after the first half of the meeting. The second half was about my childhood and once he heard all about that he rapidly changed his mind 😂

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 05/10/2022 07:35

*typical boys' presentation, I probably should have said.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 05/10/2022 07:06

@Mumofsend I didn't mean to imply all girls - sorry if that was inaccurate/annoying, but I do think it's "most" rather than just "some". Females have been underdiagnosed for years and many have slipped through the net. It is well known that they - generally - present differently to boys. This, of course, doesn't mean that all girls present the same, just as all boys don't.

The ancient ADOS tests that were still used to diagnose my DD were based on boys' experiences and have let down so many girls. Several studies have shown this. Should the tests be "gendered"? I don't know, but they should be broad enough to identify different presentations in both boys and girls; and they can't do this without recognising that the previous diagnostic criteria were biased towards boys' presentation.

MinervaTerrathorn · 05/10/2022 06:44

Were any other women on here diagnosed at secondary age in the nineties (or earlier). It feels like I'm the only one who went through what I went through.

H1nger5442678 · 05/10/2022 06:41

No it doesn’t as the gender being kept in stops girls getting diagnosed. Who said all girls with autism mask? They are looked at as individuals and a whole raft of stuff is considered whilst keeping an awareness that tests were designed for males with autism and caused many girls to go undiagnosed.

Mumofsend · 05/10/2022 06:36

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 04/10/2022 19:05

What an awful experience for your DS (and you) @ShootingForTheMoonLandingOnMyArse . I can imagine how angry you must feel with how badly he's been let down, and his school years wasted.

We were also told that my DD wasn't autistic first time around. We didn't accept this, though, and demanded to know what was wrong with her then, as she clearly wasn't normal. They hummed and hawed and realised that our interview detailing all her repetitive and obsessive behaviours hadn't been taken into consideration, so we were then given the diagnosis of atypical autism for her. Interestingly, we were asked whether we "accepted" the diagnosis. We did.

I don't necessarily think she's atypical; girls present differently and their experiences are often overlooked.

After her dx, DD was given regular talking therapy at the CAMHS clinic (like child level CBT) which we were told she could now have due to having a diagnosis. Those without a dx may get some help, but not ongoing help from a psychologist.

The diagnosis certainly opened that, and many other, doors for her.

Like you, I hate when people use the word 'label' it shows their own negative attitude towards autism.

*some girls. The narrative that girls present differently is harmful for those that don't. The amount of people who assume my DD can't be autistic because she can't mask or assume she can do something because "girls can mask" is shocking.

My boy presents in a more typical "girl" way. The gender needs to be taken out.

H1nger5442678 · 05/10/2022 05:50

I’ve not come across any professionals thinking there is over diagnosis just the reverse. Complete frustration that it takes so long to get a diagnosis.

There are people now who have waited years finally getting the information they should have done years ago.

H1nger5442678 · 05/10/2022 05:12

Mumwithsons

There is no over diagnosis we are simply getting better at diagnosis and the 50% of the population( women and girls ) who were going under the radar now aren’t so much. There is more of an awareness that autism can present differently and be hidden by girls.. It is still incredibly hard to get a diagnosis, nobody is being assessed Willy nilly.🙄

Mumwithsons · 05/10/2022 02:44

someone clueless tries to start drawing a comparison between their non-verbal, autistic boy with learning disabilities and a grown woman with autism and no learning disabilities who is verbal the neurodiversity movement says that there is no severity difference, and that the ‘learning disabilities’ are the difficulty and not the autism.

Mumwithsons · 05/10/2022 02:41

There absolutely is a legitimate debate about whether a lot of conditions are overdiagnosed. As well as what are underdiagnosed and misdiagnosed. To shut down that debate is not healthy. There has been an explosion in diagnoses and there is controversy over why, and whether this is a good thing. The former head of psychiatry felt it was over-diagnosis, others do not. This discussion needs to be ongoing and held out in the open.

I don’t know what is going on, or what is underlying the huge rise. But I do think it is professional to analyse it objectively.

We also do not often debate - what is the point of a diagnosis and is it always a good thing to be diagnosed? Particularly if there are more mild presentations, or there is no real clear support need. What is expected from a diagnosis of a very broad spectrum issue such as autism. Why not look at diagnosing anxiety for example - or the specific need presenting?

There are also some parents of kids who have listed an awful struggle to get diagnosed and assessed when their child is have very clear and obvious difficulties. Sometimes they have been passed off like those with demand avoidance as ‘being naughty’ or it being blamed on the family - which is awful for everyone as years go passed without the right kind of help.

BeserkGiraffe · 05/10/2022 02:12

No professionals who actually specialise in the area and have real knowledge of it think it is "over-diagnosed". It's incredibly hard, still, to get a diagnosis. That leads to the problems you refer to.

There is an argument that it was a mistake to separate to diagnoses of autism and Asperger's. Although because autism isa spectrum, drawing a line between them is almost impossible. Hence that decision. But there are some people whose spectrum is clearly one side of that or the other. That's not really a problem though, unless someone clueless tries to start drawing a comparison between their non-verbal, autistic boy with learning disabilities and a grown woman with autism and no learning disabilities who is verbal. Most of these problems in understanding - ironically - are because of people who are not autistic trying to compare autistic people to each other and not understanding autism, at all, because they think all autistic people should be like the autistic person they happen to know. 🙄

Or even worse, they come out with this debunked nonsense about autistic people not being empathetic, or being hard to be around compared to NT people. Again, just generalisations and not remotely supported by any study. Just prejudice.

One hopes things will change and all of the idiots who spout this stuff will die off fairly soon. I'm sure there will always be some but I hope by the time my children are adults there will be fewer of them to make their lives miserable.

Mumwithsons · 05/10/2022 02:02

I think that the diagnosis of autism is so broad, so unspecific now that it is becoming meaningless imho. There are some professionals who think that there is overdiagnosis - but also some kids who are really struggling with huge lack of support and are underdiagnosed - having to face years of schooling with zero support which doesn’t accommodate them. I honestly think it’s a bit of a mess!

P0MP0M · 05/10/2022 01:41

Sickoffamilydrama · 03/10/2022 23:15

In one way I understand why the military would exclude people with autism. I recall seeing a study that found that over 50% of high functioning teenagers and 20% of adults with high functioning autism exhibited aggressive behavior.

It would make sense to not take on people with more aggressive tendencies but then it does not seem unfair to the 80% that don't.

I've often thought the military and police should do some kind of psychometric testing to weed out the aggressive and power hungry people.

Nope. That would be classic discrimination: assuming that because some of X group of people do this, all do.

No, that is not reasonable, and frankly it's shocking that you think that it is. Try adding another word for X in place of autistic.

P0MP0M · 05/10/2022 01:37

BlankTimes · 03/10/2022 21:28

This has already been linked to upthread, but it's worth doing again to illustrate there's no 'scale of severity'
neuroclastic.com/its-a-spectrum-doesnt-mean-what-you-think/

I think this extract explains it very well.
"People who can speak aloud and have reasonable control over their motor processing are often called “high-functioning,” and yet these autistics often struggle with employment, relationships, and executive function.
My doctor recently referred to my autism is “mild.” I gently pointed to my psychologist’s report which stated that my executive dysfunction as being greater than 99th percentile.
“That means I am less functional than 99% of people. Does that seem mild to you?” I asked her.
But, you see, I can speak, and I can look people in the eyes, so they see my autism as “mild.” My autism affects those around me mildly but my autism does affect me severely.
There is no question that those who suffer from severe neuromotor difficulties are extremely disabled, and I am not in any way comparing myself to them.
In fact, I am specifically asking people to stop comparing me to them. It does them a disservice to assume that they have what I have, only worse.
It is this assumption that dehumanizes people like Ido Kedar and Carly Fleischmann. It is this assumption that leads to them and many like them being treated as unthinking, unfeeling, and unhearing. It is this assumption that drives them to beat their heads against the wall in frustration.
If they have what I have, but worse, then they must be so very autistic that they can’t function at all. They must have worse interpersonal skills, worse information processing, worse social awareness.
But that isn’t true at all."

Thank you. Exactly.

P0MP0M · 05/10/2022 01:35

I'm thinking back to when my now 12 year old was in pre school. Doing well. Happy. Healthy. She is now an absolute wreck who barely leaves the house and no longer goes to school. I can't imagine how the past few years would have played out without the diagnosis being in place as soon as we were able to proceed with the assessment.

I think back over my own life experiences and having a firm diagnosis and understanding of myself would have saved me from so much hurt, trauma; rape... Being able to advocate for myself because I understand why I'm different regather than hiding away thinking I am weird has been life changing.

Waiting until support is needed is leaving it far too late

Words. Yes, all of this. Not a single person I know with a diagnosis regrets it, that says it all.

P0MP0M · 05/10/2022 01:33

I am that person, taught themselves to read at age 2, offered a private school scholarship at age 4 (not taken up). Miles ahead throughout primary school, passed 11+ with flying colours etc etc etc
But while my parents always knew there was something different about me (they'd never have said wrong with me even though I would), they never tried to get me a dx.
I struggled all the way through High school, was labeled "naughty" and "disruptive". Always knew I was different, was desperate to fit in, would have loved to be able to walk in to a full classroom and make friends like other people can.
The struggling has carried on throughout adulthood, looking back now I can see how incredibly vulnerable I was/am and how this led to me being in an abusive relationship. Pretty easy to isolate someone who doesn't do socialing anyway.
I finally got my ASD and ADHD dx 5 years ago at age 45. Yes I still have the same issues, but now I don't fight them.

I empathise so much. I am so sorry this happened to you. It happened to me too. And most of my autistic female friends and we are trying to undo the damage but it can never be fully undone - not understanding who you are or why some things are so hard, feeling like an alien for much of life. But with parents who think it's fiiiine because you mask and get good grades.

I really hoped parents now had got past seeing autism as a stigma or "label" 🙄🙄 and would want their kids to have support and be happy and not struggle with mental health issues from years of not being understood and not understanding themselves.

P0MP0M · 05/10/2022 01:27

containsnuts · 03/10/2022 18:10

There is no such thing as "mild autism".

It's "mild" in the sense that day-to-day functioning is effected less than for others with the same diagnosis. Think successful business person, married with children vs someone unable to talk, feed, toilet themselves.

It affects other people less because the autistic person is able to mask it. It does not mean that the autism is "less severe" or "mild" for the autistic person. In fact, the masking that those who you class as being "high functioning" or with "mild autism" (what a joke to anybody autistic!) often causes additional mental health issues on top of the problems with autism itself. Studies show this clearly. Please stop making damaging comments. Someone's autism isn't categorised by how much they're able to mask it (with repercussions for them) and shield YOU from it. This whole perspective is about how the autistic person can "fit in" to your moulds or not, not about their experience of life. Please stop it.

TinaTeaspoons · 04/10/2022 22:21

Pretty sure my best friends sister is.
Always struggled from a very young age with social events, friends etc. Teacher at school noted concerns and said that they thought there may be an issue. Friends parents ignored it. Now she's 35, never visited a hairdresser or dentist and always struggles with work and has severe anxiety and OCD.
Makes me sad for her as with the right support, things could have been different for her.

BlankTimes · 04/10/2022 22:15

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 18:24

@ParrotPoppy Yes, he's going to be assessed for ADHD.

I also think that a lot of these conditions are one in the same, to milder or different degrees. I've met many children and adults who are solely diagnosed with ADHD, Dyslexia, Dyscalculia, Dyspraxia etc. and so many also have ASD traits (perhaps not enough though for a diagnosis) or vice versa, the ASD diagnosed person also has traits of the other co-morbidities.

It wouldn't surprise me in coming years if all of these diagnosis become amalgamated in some form.

Thanks for clarifying about the assessment @AutiMum
It sounds as though it was comprehensive.

Definitely a good idea to go for an ADHD assessment too. There is a vast overlap of traits between many conditions and sometimes it's hard even for the experts to pick which one is the most relevant. In one of DD's assessments, it states that her dyspraxia was so much to the forefront, her other presentations were missed and further testing was recommended as ASD seemed a very likely conclusion.

The thing is with very many people, the initial diagnosis is not necessarily the one that affects someone's life the most, sensitivities and coping mechanisms and other factors change a lot through childhood and into adulthood. When co-morbids are present, sometimes one becomes more apt and if that's the case, it's referred to in medical records as the Primary Diagnosis.

lennonj · 04/10/2022 19:50

My son was diagnosed at 6 years old, he needed very little support at school but since leaving school, well I’m so glad he had a diagnosis! It would have been incredibly difficult to get the support he needed.
I worked in a school where many teachers could not see the benefit of children who were seen to have ‘mild symptoms’ (not my words) being diagnosed or encouraging parents to look into diagnosis. It’s very short sighted as no one knows when support may be needed, others seeing the autism as being mild is so wrong, it’s not a linear spectrum! My son finds life much more difficult now as an adult!

AutiMum · 04/10/2022 19:47

@EndlessTea I don't struggle with any of the things listed, nor do I need to adapt his or my life, nor do I see my DS as impaired (though he does admittedly struggles with some social interactions).

@Summerlaundry To be honest, the main reason was the suggestion from school who said they saw traits of ASD. I went into panic mode and felt like I needed to proactively do something. Would I make the same decision now it has been a few months and I've had time to process, research etc.? I'm not so sure.

My DS does have some social differences and difficulties. He is different from his peers in that respect. He does not get some social nuances, he misses social cues and some children (and adults) find him overwhelming and annoying. He is very hyperactive.

Has a diagnosis helped him or got him extra support in the immediate? No. It may help in the future though.

Has it hindered him in the immediate? Perhaps, as school has prescribed characteristics to him that don't exist and I feel there's an element of him being limited from his potential, with 'he's autistic' used as the reasoning.

EndlessTea · 04/10/2022 19:11

”People on this thread seem quite certain about what they've notice, but IRL everyone is secong guessing themselves. People want evidence that their children are neurotypical, but what would that be.”

I think it is more as a parent, your own functioning is impaired by them, which makes you seek a diagnosis. For example - Do you find yourself getting anxious on public transport in case your child makes an embarrassing scene about not sitting next to a stranger? Does it seem out of the question to ask your child to run basic age-appropriate errands like popping to the shops for you, because you know they’ll become overwhelmed? Do you need to avoid anything or excessively plan everything-eg- going to the cinema, to avoid your child having a meltdown? Is it an extraordinary nightmare trying to buy them shoes and socks they’ll actually wear?

If you aren’t, as a parent, struggling and the child isn’t struggling with everyday things either, then I don’t think there is an impairment there.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 04/10/2022 19:05

ShootingForTheMoonLandingOnMyArse · 04/10/2022 18:41

Nobody knows my child is autistic unless they need to know or they choose to tell them. I mean what’s the alternative? School tried to force them into an environment that was traumatic and punished them when they couldn’t manage it. As others have said.

This was a happy, confident child at primary and then the bomb exploded when they transitioned to secondary. Nobody even suspected autism because they are highly social and an expert masker. It has taken them years to accept their diagnosis but hopefully that will mean a better outcome in the long run. It has definitely opened doors to support we’ve needed that would otherwise remain firmly closed.

This was exactly my experience with DC3. He was extremely social, popular and gregarious at Primary but not at all bothered about academic work. Then at Secondary school his social interactions became difficult as they were often inappropriate and perceived as 'weird' which led to him being isolated and laughed at. He changed into a very anxious and depressed (leading to self harming) teen and his school were absolutely horrendous in the way they dealt with him.

We were told via a full NHS ADOS assessment which included observation at school, paediatrician. clinical psychologist, SALT and OT that he did not fit the criteria for ASD at age 11 so no support at school and I had to remove him at age 15 due to the school's behaviour. He was diagnosed with learning difficulties at that time though, still no support or EHCP. He actually decided to learn to read at age 8 (long after the rest of his peers) as there was a specific of his that he wanted to read about. His reading age came out at age 16 in his assessment at age 11.

He was finally reassessed at age 17 again via a full ADOS assessment and I was told it was so obvious it certainly should have been diagnosed at age 11. His entire statutory school years were completed fucked up and I'm still trying to fight for support to correct the damage. Must more difficult now he's an adult.

I knew from about 18 months. He lined his Thomas Engines up and got distressed if anyone moved them. Used to spin around and around, sensory stuff like certain clothes and wanting to be stroked. Would refuse outright to do anything he didn't want to do. Never has ''meltdowns' though.

It took 2.5 years for the initial assessment and 2 years for the reassessment.

It would be foolish. and a lack of duty of care, not to try to get an assessment if you suspect it IMO.

It annoys me that people see it as a 'label'. The paediatrician which misdiagnosed him said that to me 'why do you want him to have a label'. I don't and it's not. It's a diagnosis and an understanding of why he is like he is and means he can get support for a condition that has had a massive detrimental effect on his life!

DS currently gets enhanced rate PIP and LCWRA as at the moment there's no way he can hold down a job. He also has an Adult Disability Social Worker and is eligible for Supported Living when he's ready for it. He wouldn't have got it otherwise.

What an awful experience for your DS (and you) @ShootingForTheMoonLandingOnMyArse . I can imagine how angry you must feel with how badly he's been let down, and his school years wasted.

We were also told that my DD wasn't autistic first time around. We didn't accept this, though, and demanded to know what was wrong with her then, as she clearly wasn't normal. They hummed and hawed and realised that our interview detailing all her repetitive and obsessive behaviours hadn't been taken into consideration, so we were then given the diagnosis of atypical autism for her. Interestingly, we were asked whether we "accepted" the diagnosis. We did.

I don't necessarily think she's atypical; girls present differently and their experiences are often overlooked.

After her dx, DD was given regular talking therapy at the CAMHS clinic (like child level CBT) which we were told she could now have due to having a diagnosis. Those without a dx may get some help, but not ongoing help from a psychologist.

The diagnosis certainly opened that, and many other, doors for her.

Like you, I hate when people use the word 'label' it shows their own negative attitude towards autism.